gregaaron

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 101 through 150 (of 185 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Eating in Sukkah on Shemini Atzeres #899033
    gregaaron
    Member

    @HaLeivi:

    That’s always intrigued me as well; I’ve been told that the answer is simply ?? ???? – once there are two days for some Yomim Tovim, we do it for all of them (except Yom Kippur).

    @Stuck:

    Because in Eretz Yisroel they never had to keep two days (because they knew, through a system of fire signals, which day was the correct one for Yom Tov). The exception was Rosh Hashana, and even in Eretz Yisrael Rosh Hashana is two days.

    in reply to: Eating in Sukkah on Shemini Atzeres #899027
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Dr. Seuss:

    The original takana of two days Yom Tov was because of a Safeik – in the times of the Beis Hamikdash, it actually was a question which day was really Yom Tov – and we keep that takana, even though it’s not really a safeik nowadays.

    in reply to: Eating in Sukkah on Shemini Atzeres #899017
    gregaaron
    Member

    The response to Shticky’s points is that we don’t do anything that would be an actual ????? to Shemini Atzeres (such as making a bracha on the Sukkah, or taking a Lulav). But eating in a Sukkah is something that could conceivably be done on a regular day (even if it’s not Sukkos), therefore we eat in there due to sfeika d’yoma.

    in reply to: Please vote. Who is correct? #818245
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Charlie:

    “Uncle Poppa” is not a valid name outside of various Southeastern states.

    in reply to: Please vote. Who is correct? #818232
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Yitay:

    “Just make sure you’re not too full for the meal. Though as Popa bar Abba, you probably won’t be.”

    Awesome!!

    And, in the immortal words of the royal Persian decree, ????? ?? ??? ???? ?????, feminists be, er, silenced!!

    Have a great yom tov (yuntiff) everyone…

    in reply to: Another view on reporting abuse #816317
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Happiest:

    Just so you know, in New York (as well as many other states) teachers are mandated reporters, meaning they have a legal obligation to report child abuse.

    HOWEVER (bold, italic, underlined): If Halacha conflicts with that, there is no question that someone in such a situation needs to follow the Halacha (Da’as Torah) over the law. I just wanted to make you aware of the fact.

    Personally, my own Da’as BaalBatim (worth diddly squat) is that if the father is not involved with your student or any other kids, there is probably no Halachic basis for saying something.

    Hatzlacha, and even if your student doesn’t realize all that you have done/are doing for her, there is certainly Someone upstairs who does!

    in reply to: Korbonos #815081
    gregaaron
    Member

    Okay, to play devil’s advocate…what chiyuv is there to say korbonos in the first place, that there needs to be a heter not to say them?

    in reply to: The Yankees and Yom Kippur #819616
    gregaaron
    Member

    @ronrsr:

    The fact that most Jewish players played for OOT teams means diddly-squat – in a league with 30 teams, 28 of which would be considered out of town (although Blue Jays fans try to be more in-town than Yankees or Mets) odds are that most players will end up with OOT teams. Signing players to appeal to the local demographic generally doesn’t work – the Atlanta Thrashers had by far the most African-American players of any NHL team last year in an attempt to draw more minority fans, and, well, MinyanGal can tell you how that turned out.

    in reply to: Sports Illustrated #813904
    gregaaron
    Member

    I was just about to say what MiddlePath did. ESPN is more interesting and has much less pritzus.

    in reply to: Lesson of bitochon in SHIDDUCHIM… #814028
    gregaaron
    Member

    Rejection hurts, but it sure beats being married to the wrong person.

    in reply to: Worst parsha ever! #921907
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Shmoel:

    The other posters explained how Netzavim-Vayeilech works.

    Vayakhel-Pekudei, Tazria-Metzora, Acharei Mos-Kedoshim and Behar-Bechukosai are generally used to fill the four extra weeks in a leap year (in non-leap years they’re together, but in a leap year, where we need for more Parshiyos, we separate them).

    Chukas-Balak is a makeup double Parsha if the 8th day of Pesach or the 2nd day of Shavuos are Shabbos – since Eretz Yisroel is one week ahead of America (because they didn’t have that extra day of Yom Tov, so they lained the regular Parsha), we double up Chukas and Balak to catch up with them.

    Finally, Mattos-Maasei is almost always a double Parsha, except for when we need to separate them to make sure that Tisha B’av falls between Devarim and Va’eschanan (like this year).

    I hope I got them all right. Corrections are welcome and appreciated.

    in reply to: black eye peas #811233
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Itche:

    That was the only line I could’ve said. Trust me, I’m not into it either…

    in reply to: Pictures on resumes #811474
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Imaofthree:

    Most of us (guys) are expected to have resumes as well. I’m almost always asked for one. (And btw, for some reason I actually find it sort of off-putting when the girl’s picture is on hers…)

    in reply to: black eye peas #811227
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Itche:

    And yungerman?? 🙂

    in reply to: black eye peas #811218
    gregaaron
    Member

    I gotta feeling that if you eat them on Rosh Hashana, that the night’s gonna be a good night…

    in reply to: REPLY TO mdd ABOUT CALLING GIRLS BY 1ST NAME #810735
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Health:

    She quit because it made her uncomfortable, not because someone else didn’t keep a Chumra. I agree with you that the other person did not do anything wrong in the slightest, and I personally also feel that it was a bit of an overreaction, but if she did not feel comfortable there, I can sort of understand why she didn’t want to be there.

    in reply to: Women Invalid as Witnesses #1137561
    gregaaron
    Member

    @PBA:

    If I recall the Gemara correctly, Poppa Bar Abba has several friends (and it’s not just the jokes that fall flat :-p).

    in reply to: Halacha on Divorce #810529
    gregaaron
    Member

    @AishesChayil:

    I don’t think you are right about the Kohen having to divorce due to just a ch’shash, although I still may be wrong about that. I would imagine that if the Kohen is truly worried about infidelity he should investigate it fully, but I don’t think we would actually make him divorce her. I definitely do think you are mistaken about there being a Mitzvah for a Yisroel to remarry an unfaithful wife, however.

    in reply to: Women Invalid as Witnesses #1137524
    gregaaron
    Member

    Gezeiras haKasuv. (Interestingly, they are believed in very specific cases – generally to say that a man has died and his wife can remarry. Certain relatives, though, who have a chazakah of hating each other, are not allowed to testify even then.)

    in reply to: Halacha on Divorce #810519
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Tums:

    If you want, you can check out the Gemara at the end of the first perek of Makos, which discusses your question.

    in reply to: Halacha on Divorce #810512
    gregaaron
    Member

    @AishesChayil:

    I think that you may be mixing up the obligation to divorce with there being a death penalty (which requires witnesses and a warning) or her forfeiting her kesubah (which needs witnesses, but not a warning). If the husband knows that his wife is being unfaithful, even without any witnesses, he has to divorce her (although I have been involved with cases where the psak was that if the husband does not know, there is no chiyuv to tell him). And out of curiosity, where did you hear that a Kohen has to divorce her even based on a rumor?

    in reply to: Halacha on Divorce #810487
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Sam2:

    Actually, I think we hold that purely al pi halacha, there is no reason that he CAN’T divorce her (last mishna in Gittin). It’s strongly discouraged, of course, but there’s a 3-way machlokes and I think we go the third way.

    @Shmoel:

    I believe the only time he has a chiyuv to divorce her (assuming, of course, that it’s a legal marriage) would be if she has been unfaithful to him. If he’s a Kohen there could be other situations as well.

    I hope that this is a purely hypothetical question; if it is being asked for any specific reason I hope that everything works out as well as possible for all involved.

    Hatzlocha.

    in reply to: #816356
    gregaaron
    Member

    @AmYisraelChai:

    I can’t say that I honestly know. Depending on how you would define abuse, I would say maybe one in 30 or 40. Either way, even one is far too many.

    I fully admit that I am possibly way off with my number; I suspect that there will be those who overdramatize and say it’s even more, or, I may be overestimating (I certainly hope so). I do know that the numbers that the so-called child “advocates” give for other types of abuse in our community are grossly inflated, but I have much less experience in the domestic abuse sphere to be able to give an answer.

    Again, even one is too many. And I have no doubt that the numbers are much, much lower in our community. I would love to hear your opinion of the numbers (I’m assuming you probably have a better idea than I do…)

    in reply to: #816343
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Aries:

    And do you think that, based on the state of mind he was most likely in at the time, that that would’ve stopped him? All we end up with is two people beaten up rather than one.

    in reply to: #816337
    gregaaron
    Member

    @AmYisroelChai:

    “Obaminator

    “it is relatively rare in our community”

    Unfortunately, it’s not as rare as you might think or hope. It is more rare for victims to publicly admit it.”

    His (her?) point remains, however – it IS relatively rare in our community, compared to society in general. Same for other, horrible types of abuse. Each individual situation is a tragedy, and the whole concept needs to be gone from our community, but those who exaggerate the extent of these occurrences to advance their own agendas (and I am NOT talking about you, chas v’shalom) cause needles amounts of Chillul Hashem.

    in reply to: girls!!!! DON"T SELL YOURSELVES CHEAP!!! #805772
    gregaaron
    Member

    And as usual, we have someone bashing all boys for any and every problem that comes up in Shidduchim. If he’s not sure if a girl is right for him so he keeps dating her to see if she’s his bashert, he’s “using her” and leading her on; and if he chooses to stop dating her, he’s contributing to the so-called Shidduch crisis by being too picky.

    By the way, Poppa bar Abba – I’m really, really enjoying your posts on this thread. Great work, as usual.

    in reply to: Life as the son of a Child Molester: My story #819746
    gregaaron
    Member

    …And every guy has baggage too.

    I, for one, assume that every girl I am going out with has some sort of baggage (hopefully not too big); assuming it’s something that she has been able to take the most out of and learn from, in my mind it’s an added bonus. ‘Cuz if I’m looking for someone who never experienced anything, I’m going to be in the Parsha for a really long time (okay, even longer :-p)…

    And I know what I’ve gone through, even though no one else would ever dream of it.

    in reply to: Should I go to Monsey for Shabbos??? #802282
    gregaaron
    Member

    Go – the overwhelming odds are that you’ll either be able to go Motzei Shabbos, or, if it starts that early, you should be fine Sunday night. (Just check traffic reports before heading back.)

    in reply to: Kosher Dunkin Donuts in Lakewood #797684
    gregaaron
    Member

    The ones in Cedarhurst (Rockaway Tpke) and Valley Stream (Sunrise Highway) are both under the very reliable Va’ad of the 5 Towns, as other readers pointed out.

    There is also a supposedly Kosher one in Monsey, on Route 59, but there are people who either will not eat there at all, or will eat the donuts (which are brought in from a kosher plant) but not the other baked goods.

    in reply to: Anyone working tomorrow? #795786
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Feif Un-

    Refuah sheleima!

    in reply to: Child Abuse #790060
    gregaaron
    Member

    Even with the knowledge of the laws of mandated reporting, if halacha and the law say two different things, I know which one I’m going with.

    in reply to: Divorce is Worse than a Difficult Marriage #1143097
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Englishman:

    “Studies I have seen (mostly in Europe but I don’t see why it would be much different elsewhere) indicate children of divorced parents generally are more troubled than their counterparts.”

    Without getting into whether or not the OP is right, do those studies control for children of non-divorced parents, who stayed together amidst constant fighting and tension?

    in reply to: Derek Jeter #784392
    gregaaron
    Member

    Yankees announcer Suzyn Waldman (who btw got overly emotional again, no?) is also Jewish.

    in reply to: Names in Shidduchim…. #783905
    gregaaron
    Member

    Is it a reason to say no originally? Probably not. But if you go out with her a couple of times, and the name still bothers you, then it’s probably a good idea to say no.

    gregaaron
    Member

    @Gavra & Haifagirl-

    Whether or not it would be assur to do such a thing, it would be condeming any child brought into that “family” to a life of misery – both at home, and socially (somehow I don’t think that the kid’s classmates would see that family as a usual situation, and (s)he would be easy fodder for taunting).

    in reply to: 7-11 = Coffee Room #780240
    gregaaron
    Member

    @minyangal:

    Looks like you got your wish!

    in reply to: Kohen Godol and Chalitza #780247
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Mod:

    The main answer is like Wolf and Gavra said; also, assuming you learned the Mishnah in Sanhedrin, it could be that it’s because it’s a continuation from the first part of the Mishna which says that a king does neither Yibum nor Chalitzah, so we stay with the same format.

    gregaaron
    Member

    @Gavra:

    I was referring to your, um, “unique” method of dealing with the shidduch situation.

    gregaaron
    Member

    “Please let this be a normal posting…”

    “With the Friz?”

    “No way!!!”

    Great post, MissFrizzle, couldn’t have said it better myself!!

    in reply to: 7-11 = Coffee Room #780237
    gregaaron
    Member

    @MinyanGal:

    Enjoy your last two weeks of summer :-).

    gregaaron
    Member

    @Pac-Man:

    So you feel that HKBH just forgot about our generation, and 40 days before we were born He just took the day off. And you can tell your friend AZ – numbers don’t mean anything if HKBH doesn’t want them to. If it was based purely on numbers, no frum family would be able to survive financially.

    @Gavra:

    I really, really hope you’re joking.

    edited

    in reply to: 7-11 = Coffee Room #780233
    gregaaron
    Member

    @minyan gal-

    I didn’t even know there were any frum people up there!! Mazel Tov on getting your hockey team back 🙂

    in reply to: Wedding Halls #780113
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Shein-

    Now there’s a good idea. I recommend the Metrodome in Minnesota – after last winter, there’s a hole in the roof for an outdoor chuppah, plus, even with the Vikings having been to four Super Bowls, the kallah would still be the first person there to ever get a ring.

    in reply to: People Who Should Never Get Married #777873
    gregaaron
    Member

    @DaasYochid-

    But she wasn’t necessarily a zonah before.

    I’ve always learned the same as Ender, that a Chalal is only from Kohein-specific issurim. Could be I’m wrong, though.

    in reply to: People Who Should Never Get Married #777867
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Haleivi-

    A half eved/half ben chorin cannot marry a shifcha, because he is still half free man. I believe there is a machlokes between Beis Hillel and Beis Shamai in such a situation, as to whether he is stuck, or we force the owner to free the slave “half” of the person so that he can get married.

    in reply to: People Who Should Never Get Married #777863
    gregaaron
    Member

    @Wolf-

    Where do you know that from? (This is a request for information, not a challenge.)

    Thanks!

    in reply to: People Who Should Never Get Married #777851
    gregaaron
    Member

    While there is no one who is not allowed to get married (at least at first), there are some people r”l who have an extremely limited choice of whom to marry. For example, a mamzer cannot marry anyone other than a mamzeres or giyores. Similarly, there are also certain physical problems which prevent them from having children(of which I have never heard about in the current day, but they theoretically do exist) who would be bound by the same limitations. The Gemara in Yevamos (eighth perek I believe) goes through who this would apply to.

    That being said, I can’t think of anyone who is never allowed to get married (with the possible exception of a kohein mamzer).

    gregaaron
    Member

    @Daas Yochid-

    Thanks! (That’s perfectly logical; why didn’t I figure it out on my own? Duh! Em!!) 🙂

    gregaaron
    Member

    @Ofcourse-

    In conversation with world renowned, professional roshei yeshiva and rabbonim (and shadchanim, come to think of it) (by the way, how do you italicize? Thanks!), I’ve heard them say that most guys who seriously date for more than 2 years and don’t find, are being faced with a nisayon, and should keep doing their hishtadlus and davening until the right one (ONE) comes along. And you’re right – if the right one was not red, and the boy keeps on saying yes and going out with girls, they both end up getting hurt. But until we come up with a system to identify who (whom?) the right ONE is ahead of time, it’s not fair to expect the boys to get married to a girl just because he’s going out with her. (Incidentally, have you head about the “divorce crisis”?)

    So I do respect your opinion, and you’re certainly entitled to it, but yes, I do disagree. I won’t deny that there are some boys who have issues, but to paint all boys who haven’t had the bracha of finding their bashert yet as being not quite on the derech is a bit unfair.

    in reply to: please pass along; cars being TOWED from toys r us parking lot!! #1017307
    gregaaron
    Member

    @charliehall-

    How is the fact that the zoo has frum visitors on Yom Tov good for business?

Viewing 50 posts - 101 through 150 (of 185 total)