HaGaon HaRav Meir Tzvi Bergman, a senior member of the Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah and the son-in-law of HaGaon HaRav Elazar Menachem Man Shach, z’tl, published a letter on Wednesday regarding the threat of bnei yeshivos being recruited to the army.
“When misguided brothers came to sabotage the yeshivos kedoshos which is the foundation of our existence, in their attempt to reduce lomdei Torah, bnei hayeshivos, all of us are obligated to declare that ‘העולה על רוחם היה לא תהיה’! – what they imagine won’t happen! And to be mechazeik ourselves, that whatever may happen, Am Hashem won’t abandon the Torah Hakedoshah under any circumstances.”
“תורת ה’ לעולם היא תמימה – we’re not the owners of it, גוילין נשרפין ואותיות פורחות [When Rebi Chaninah ben Teradion, one of the Asurei Harugei Malchus, was put to death by the Romans by wrapping him up in a Sefer Torah and setting him on fire, his talmidim asked what he saw and he responded: ‘The parchments are burning but letters are soaring on high.’] And just like we have no authority and ability to change any of its details…we also don’t have any permission or ability to stop even one lomeid Torah.”
“We can’t see the swallowing of the kodesh, to stand from afar and agree to even the theft of one nefesh from Yisrael – we’ll oppose it will all our strength, that the possibility of every ben Yisrael to sit in the ohel of Torah and serve Hashem – is not denied – and this is not open to negotiation at all.”
“And I already wrote [in 2000] in the name of Rabbeinu HaGadol Rosh HaYeshivah [HaRav Shach, z’tl], that if becomes נוגע למעשה – to publicize to the public in his name that the gezeirah of the recruitment of bnei hayeshivos is a gezeiras shmad [שמד] and it’s necessary to be moser nefesh for it like it’s explained in the Shulchan Orech Yoreh De’ah.”
“And therefore, if we are tested in this, we must oppose it with all our strength, to the point of mesirus nefesh.”
“And if we are strong in this, those misguided brothers will internalize that there is no benefit or purpose to their misdeeds, in their attempt to threaten the Olam HaTorah, and b’ezras Hashem, they will leave us alone.”
“And you, the bnei yeshivos hakedoshos…do not fear, and don’t be afraid of them! Because we don’t live according to them. Your value and the value of your Torah is priceless”
“When they come to bnei yeshivos with complaints or various ways of persuasion, for good or for bad, bnei yeshivos should not enter a debate on the topic at all.”
“And I’ve already said what I was instructed in my youth by the Chazon Ish, z’tl, that when they came to persuade the bnei yeshiva in Lomza yeshivha to go and protect Eretz Yisrael, especially through the claim of הוראת שעה, the Chazon Ish instructed me not to respond to what they were saying but to firmly tell them that my only desire is limmud Torah. And not to add anything else – without all the explanations. Because just entering into a debate with them is the beginning of falling into their trap and who could predict what the end will be.”
ונזכה כולנו לישועת ה’ על עמו ונחלתו, כאשר אין ידוע מה ילד יום ה”י, ונהיה אנחנו וצאצאינו כולנו יודעי שמך ולומדי תורתך. ומלאה הארץ דעה את ה’ והיתה לה’ המלוכה.
(YWN Israel Desk – Jerusalem)
6 Responses
I’d truly be interested in hearing a cogent explanation for the Shita expressed in this letter. I’ve seen a number of Halachic arguments going the other way, but very little for this side – whose main argument seems to be “that’s what Rabbanim 50/70/80 years ago said then” but with no accounting for differences in metzius between them and now.
My Rebbi, a well-known and well-reapected American Rosh Yeshiva, never hesitated in laying out the Halachic basis for his piskei halacha – and he was fine with being pushed to defend his view. It’s sad that the Chareidi leaders do not seem to have the courage to do so.
an Israeli Yid
Letters from gedolei Yisroel citing testimony from giants of earlier generations should not be opened to comments that can certainly lead to bizoyon talmidei chachomim by kalei Hadaas whose hearts are blocked from seeing the emes by spending endless time on the World Wide Web
So…does that mean that Peleg was right all along, or is he saying that now the derech of Peleg is the course of action?
lbj – citing those from previous generations has value but should not always be determinative – especially when circumstances on the ground have significantly changed from the times of those earlier generations. It is necessary to provide the background for the position and give the sevara as to why the earlier guidance still applies.
an Israeli Yid
an israeli yid the sevara is that the atmosphere and promiscuity is hepech of the metzius of a yid just like the medinat yisroel is hepech the metziyus of a yid.
the culture in the gaas and in the idf is worse than in previos doros and therefore rav schach and the chazon ish’s dictates apply mi’kal vechomer
further rav schach was instructing his much younger son in law about guidance for doros haboim and was a tzavaah ledoros.
peleg was/is a hemshech of rav schachs shittos
rav shteinman did not follow to a tee what rav schach said in the past, and what he likely would of applied to the present.