Search
Close this search box.

Israeli Lawyers: “The Histadrut Labor Union Strike Was Illegal”

Passengers look at the monitor displaying delayed flights at Ben Gurion airport, near Tel Aviv, Israel, Monday, March 27, 2023. Israeli Airports Authority says flights out of main international airport have been grounded. Israel's largest trade union group launched a strike across a broad swath of sectors, joining a protest movement against Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's plan to overhaul the judiciary. (AP Photo/Oren Ziv)

Millions of Israelis were outraged by the political strike called by the Histadrut labor union on Monday “in protest of the government’s judicial reform plan.”

A politically motivated nationwide strike that shuts down the Israeli economy sets quite a dangerous precedent. According to a Ynet report, Monday’s strike cost the Israeli economy about NIS 2.5 billion. The sum doesn’t include the emotional cost of those affected by the strike of the healthcare system. One Israeli cancer patient wrote an emotional post on Facebook about an important test that he scheduled months earlier that was canceled during the strike.

Additionally, the Israel Hotel Association reported a significant number of cancellations of reservations in Israel’s hotels. At Ben-Gurion Airport, tens of thousands of passengers were forced to wait for hours after their flights were canceled or delayed, and a number of airlines canceled their flights to Israel – leaving Israeli citizens, tourists and business travelers stranded at international airports.

Was the strike even legal? Not according to the chairman of the Constitution Committee MK Simcha Rothman, who is a lawyer by profession. Rothman told Radio 103FM on Tuesday that the strike was definitely illegal and a violation of workers’ rights, noting that many Histadrut members voted for the current government and support the judicial reform.

Yitzchak Bam, a lawyer for the  Lavi civil rights organization, wrote an open letter on Monday stating that the strike on Monday “is illegal according to the ruling of the Supreme Court” and calling on the Finance and Labor ministers to withhold pay from employees who took a vacation day. According to law, employees who take a vacation day during a legal strike must receive their wages but according to Bam, Monday’s strike did not meet the legal criteria for labor disputes, which must be declared to employers at least 15 days prior to the strike. Additionally, a strike must be called against a specific employer.

The Shas party was also outraged by the strike and decided to “take revenge” on the Histadrut in a different way.

Shas MK Moshe Arbel, who is a lawyer by profession, submitted a bill to reduce payments of membership fees to the Histadrut by 50%. Every person who works in a company or public organization under the Histadrut must pay membership fees, and now, if the law passes, the Histadrut will lose 50% of its income.

“The bill seeks to set a maximum ceiling for the amount of money allowed to be collected by union organizations of various kinds, in which there is no justification for the amounts they charge,” the explanation for the bill states.

Israeli media reported in January that opposition leader Yair Lapid tried to convince Histadrut chairman Arnon Bar-David to call a nationwide strike as part of the protests against the Netanyahu government.

(YWN Israel Desk – Jerusalem)



7 Responses

  1. I find it bizarre that a ONE DAY protest by labor triggers such outrage on the right when they were silent for months when frequently violent Peleg hooligans disrupted hundreds of thousands of Israelis in support of ILLEGAL draft dodging by yeshiva yungerleit. The hypocrisy is breathtaking but not really surprising when Bibi is having a lobster dinner on Shabbos in London insisting that his “reforms” will stop judicial outrages such as allowing chometz in hospitals.

  2. First thing to do is fire Kommandant Idan, then sue him personally for the losses caused by his heroism.

  3. “Shas MK Moshe Arbel, who is a lawyer by profession, submitted a bill to reduce payments of membership fees to the Histadrut by 50%. Every person who works in a company or public organization under the Histadrut must pay membership fees, and now, if the law passes, the Histadrut will lose 50% of its income.”

    Now you are talking.

    After that, you should pass a law breaking up the histradut into numerous, smaller, INDEPENDENT unions. Having the ability to call a nation-wide strike is beyond ridiculous and should be made structurally impossible.

  4. > Gadolhadorah

    You are comparing a traffic slowdown on Bar Ilan Street and some burning trash cans to a shutdown of the healthcare system and the airport (during the busiest season).

  5. Dorah,

    I find it bizarre that you post absolutely every manner of excrement, even against frum Jews in support of your woke coreligionists.

    Hypocrisy? That’s rich, coming from a person who wishes death upon someone after criticizing other posters for doing the same.

    Have you no shame, no sense of decency? Rhetorical question.

Leave a Reply


Popular Posts