There is no M’kor anywhere in Chazal, again, no-where in Shas or Midroshim, that we have a right to keep Shabbos and all the Yomim Tovim, based on our individual Time-Zones.
HKB”H keeps His Shabbos on the Time-Zone of Eretz Yisroel, and so should we.
Who gives us a right to eat Erev Yom Kippur, when its already Yom Kippur for HKB”H?
The writer is ill informed and unlearned to make such a blatent ignorant comment to say all yidden who do it at thier right timr are wrong CHAVAL ,Proof of your erroe,and loack of bekius It says about Makos bechoros Kchatzos as timw moved from E to W so was the makos bechoros moved in time minute by minute See Mayam Bais Hashaavoh by Hagoan R’ Shimon Schwab ztzal
2 reactions for ‘Yira.’ First, being that the idea of time zones (AKA “railroad time”) did not start until the late 1800’s, so it could not have been spoken about in Shas or Medrashim. Also, before this time, every city had their own time. So, there would NOT have been one time for the entire Eretz Yisroel at that time.
Second, where does it say that HKB’H keeps Eretz Yisroel time?
#2 Where in Shas or Chzal?
#3 The Chidoh writes that. Really, why wouldn’t Chazal ever mention this important Halacha that each location, can or can not, use their own time-zone for Mitzvahs? I have asked many Talmidei Chachomim.
Join the official YWN WhatsApp status
4 Responses
There is no M’kor anywhere in Chazal, again, no-where in Shas or Midroshim, that we have a right to keep Shabbos and all the Yomim Tovim, based on our individual Time-Zones.
HKB”H keeps His Shabbos on the Time-Zone of Eretz Yisroel, and so should we.
Who gives us a right to eat Erev Yom Kippur, when its already Yom Kippur for HKB”H?
The writer is ill informed and unlearned to make such a blatent ignorant comment to say all yidden who do it at thier right timr are wrong CHAVAL ,Proof of your erroe,and loack of bekius It says about Makos bechoros Kchatzos as timw moved from E to W so was the makos bechoros moved in time minute by minute See Mayam Bais Hashaavoh by Hagoan R’ Shimon Schwab ztzal
2 reactions for ‘Yira.’ First, being that the idea of time zones (AKA “railroad time”) did not start until the late 1800’s, so it could not have been spoken about in Shas or Medrashim. Also, before this time, every city had their own time. So, there would NOT have been one time for the entire Eretz Yisroel at that time.
Second, where does it say that HKB’H keeps Eretz Yisroel time?
#2 Where in Shas or Chzal?
#3 The Chidoh writes that. Really, why wouldn’t Chazal ever mention this important Halacha that each location, can or can not, use their own time-zone for Mitzvahs? I have asked many Talmidei Chachomim.