The members of the Va’ad HaChamisha (Committee of Five), which oversees Kever Rav Shimon Bar Yochai, intend to close the compound to visitors on Thursday in the wake of an insurance crisis that places the committee members at risk of personal liability suits, Ynet reported on Monday morning.
One of the many consequences of the Meron disaster was that no insurance companies will agree to continue securing the site. That means that if one of the thousands of daily visitors at the site is injured, the members of the Va’adas HaChamisha are at risk of being sued for damages.
The committee’s members held a meeting with Religious Affairs Minister Matan Kahana on the issue and he instructed the relevant professionals to find a solution but no progress has yet been made on the matter. Therefore the members of the Va’adas HaChamisha, which oversees the site, made a decision to remove itself from responsibility of the site and will close the compound beginning on Thursday (Wednesday night at midnight).
Eli Friend, the director of Kever Rashbi, sent a letter on Sunday to Religious Affairs Minister Matan Kahana, informing him of the committee’s decision.
He noted in the letter that the Va’ad HaChamisha is responsible for the management of the Meron site the entire year except for the day of Lag B’Omer, when the state of Israel is responsible for the site [since Va’ad HaChamisha is not equipped to oversee such a large event].
“Prior to the tragedy, the Va’adas HaChamisha was continuously insured throughout all the years without any issues,” Friend wrote. “An absurd situation has developed that due to an event that happened on the day that the State is responsible for the site, the Va’adas HaChamisha is paying the price and today most of its members (except for the committee chairman who is an employee of the State) are vulnerable to personal injury lawsuits in the case of someone being injured at the site, chas v’chalilah.”
“You are aware that Va’adas HaChamisha has and is engaging in multiple efforts to find a solution to the problematic situation that has developed. Likewise, a meeting was held in your office ten days ago, during which you instructed all relevant professionals to find an immediate solution to the insurance issue, but the problem has not yet been solved.”
“In light of the situation, we are hereby informing you that if no solution is found in the form of an indemnity or an insurance policy for the Va’adas HaChamisha, the committee will be forced to announce the closure of Kever Rashbi beginning on Wednesday, Yud Aleph Teves, at midnight.”
(YWN Israel Desk – Jerusalem)
Join the official YWN WhatsApp status
6 Responses
Its not a bid deal if the site is closed for a while, but only IF it will lead to some long-term structural changes in how the site is managed and who will be responsible for security 365 days a year.
Reb Shomon was a Heligeh Taanah like all the other Tanoiem in the Mishnah and Breisus. It’s just that someone in the thirteenth century decided to write a Sefer Zohar and make a false claim that he found this Sefer in his basement, written by Reb Shimon himself.
Is is not B’Kovid for such a Taaneh, for us to accept these stories.
So when there’s a chance it’ll hit them in the pocket the Vaad decides to back off.
We’ve heard that before.
והכסף יענה את הכל
We do have to give credit, along with our deepest heartfelt sympathy, to the victims’ families who refused to accept the offered bribery and let the investigation of the tragedy go forward.
the painfull message from the power that be that run the Meron compound is clear
if your life is at risk,, then the Bashefer will watch, the zechus of Reb Shimon will watch… nothing to worry about, don’t let the government make the place safer lest they take away some of our controll, let us be “in charge”.
if their fortunes are at risk and they just might be held responsible.. ha that’s a different story.. lets shut the whole thing down immediately, we can’t take that risk….
OUCH, this is what has become of us when we allow untouchable and unaccountable “askanim” run our affairs. the Askanim want “all the power” with “non of the responsibility”
ader you’re an apikorus. The Torah world has accepted the Zohar’s authorship from Rashby.
If the vaad is sure that everything is safe there, they could easily self-insure, maybe collect 10 shekalim from each visitor for unforeseen events.