The House on Thursday cited Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. for contempt of Congress in a historic vote weighted with political significance, though it does little to break the stalemate over his decision to withhold documents over the Justice Department’s actions in a botched gun-walking operation.
The 256-67 vote amounted to a political spanking for Mr. Holder and President Obama, and 17 Democrats joined with Republicans in demanding the documents be released. Most Democrats, however, walked out in protest of the vote.
It marks the first time an attorney general has been held in contempt by a chamber.
But the White House dismissed the proceedings as a sideshow, and the vote does nothing to break the impasse, though it further poisoned feelings in an already bitterly divided chamber.
“No Justice Department is above the law, and no Justice Department is above the Constitution,” said House Speaker John A. Boehner, Ohio Republican.
Democrats pleaded with the Republicans to slow down the proceedings, saying the oversight committee, led by Chairman Darrell Issa, California Republican, has done a shoddy job in putting together its investigation.
Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee, Texas Democrat, even introduced a resolution demanding that the House reprimand Mr. Issa for partisanship and accusing him of having “engaged in a witch hunt.”
Many Democrats walked out of the contempt vote in protest, and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, California Democrat, said the vote was a black eye for the Republicans.
“Just when you think you have seen it all. Just when you think they couldn’t possibly go any further over the edge, they come up with something like this,” she said. “What is happening here is shameful.”
Democrats also tried to force the matter back into Mr. Issa’s committee, but the House defeated that motion.
As issue is the oversight committee’s investigation into Fast and Furious, an operation intended to track sales of U.S. guns and watch the guns be shipped across the border to a Mexican drug cartel, but the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) lost track of the roughly 2,000 weapons after they were sold.
Some of the guns eventually began showing up at crime scenes, including two that were recovered at the site of a 2010 Arizona shootout that left Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry dead.
Mr. Holder shut down the operation, but his efforts to clean up after it have come under scrutiny. The Justice Department initially told Congress it never knowingly lost track of guns, but after whistleblowers made it clear that this was false, Mr. Holder had to withdraw that claim.
The Justice Department has turned over documents about the actual gun-walking operation, but have refused to turn over documents about how it handled the false information it provided to Congress. Last week President Obama asserted executive privilege, arguing those documents are protected by precedent that governs internal deliberations.
Democrats said they aren’t defending the gun-walking operation, but said the committee should leave Mr. Holder alone.
Join the official YWN WhatsApp status
7 Responses
Holder is corrupt, and should have been impeached a year ago, both over this and over his turning the Civil Rights Division into the “Black Rights Division”.
So he could lie to a court/congress with NO consequence. Who cares about the VOTE when it is meaningless! He still keeps his job and does not go to Jail, while a normal citizen would have been locked up for a long time. (Had one of the MLB players been found guilty of lying to congress they would of paid a hefty fine and sat in jail for a couple of years)
Social Justice = NO JUSTICE !
There are a lot of issues with this case. ATF is trying to go after gun trafficking but there is no law against it: Congress won’t touch anything that hints at gun control.
Darrell Issa has a potential conflict of interest: when he was younger, he was caught with a concealed weapon and plead to possession of an unregistered gun.
The ATF “whistle-blower” was the one who was on the case of the weapons that got lost and included the gun used in the killing of Officer Brian Terry: the agent allegedly did not follow-up on the purchase of the guns.
I’m not saying Holder is right. I am saying that it is not as simple as the articles posted here could lead one to believe.
Y2r
The contempt citation is NOt for lying to congress. That would be perjury, a felony offense.
The contempt that the house “voted” on doesn’t begin to measure the contempt that the American people have for the house and it Lilliputian leadership.
Moose613, the contempt citation certainly is for lying to Congress, and for failing to comply with subpoenas. And why the scare quotes around “voted”? That is what they did. Holder is a contemptible person, and it’s high time the House took at least this minimal step. Really they should impeach him.
Shlomo2, what on earth are you talking about when you say there’s no law against it? Everything involved here was clearly against the law.
im probably politcally incorrect but others and I really feel the reason he’s having his mapala is because of the way he’s treating the rubashkin case. someone who KNOWS 0f this tragic injustice and STILL does nothing when he HAS the power to, will get severly punished.