Search
Close this search box.

Taking A Stand: NYC Rabbi, Imam Unite


im.jpgAs we saw after Sept. 11, 2001, the invisible victims of Islamic terrorism are other Muslims, millions of people who are horrified by the thought that some of their own could turn the words of the Quran into a justification for murder.

On Thursday, some of them took a stand against terrorism.

At the 96th Street mosque, there was something you don’t see everyday – a rabbi and an imam embracing, and then standing together in unity.

“These intended evils must be condemned, and I’m here to condemn it,” said Imam Shamsi Ali of the Islamic Cultural Center of New York.

“Any attack on a Jewish religious institution is an attack on any and every religious institution,” said Rabbi Marc Schneier of the Foundation For Ethnic Understanding.

It was Imam Ali who suggested the joint statement of condemnation. He said the very word “jihad” has been perverted.

“Life in Islam is so sacred, and any individual taking lives is basically taking the lives of all human beings as the holy Quran mentions,” Ali said.

No one knows for certain how many Muslims live in America. The United States census doesn’t collect data on religious identification, but estimates range from 1 to 8 million.

But a study by Columbia University puts the number of Muslims in New York City at 600,000, many of whom live and work in neighborhoods like one in Brooklyn along Atlantic Avenue.

And whenever something like this happens, the thousands of good, law-abiding, patriotic Muslims worry that once again, the stereotype of a violent Islam is once again being perpetuated.

According to the Pew Research Center, fully a third of all Muslims in this country are African-Americans who, like some of the bomb-plot suspects, converted to Islam either in prison or in their urban neighborhoods. But just because they share a religion with the bomb plotters, they said, does not mean they share their violent beliefs.

Rabbi Schneier shared some letters with CBS 2 HD he’d received from the Muslim community, including one from the Islamic Society of North America, which said in part, “any form of terrorism is against Islam. We applaud law and order authorities for being alert and detecting the potential threat.”

(Source: CBS2 HD)



7 Responses

  1. This is good news, representing the kind of mutual work for the common good that honorable, good-hearted people should engage in. Imam Ali and Rabbi Sheier are to be commended.

  2. I DON’T RECALL EVER SEEING RABBI MARC SCHNEIR (FOUNDATION OF ETHNIC UNDERSTANDING) AMBRACING A CHASSID.

  3. Dear Rabbi Marc Schneier. When Imam Shamsi Ali will in return offer to embrace you and repeat his statement in a ‘synagogue’, We can then applause you of a real achievement in this very hostile world. thanks for trying anyway.

  4. There are many ‘spins’ on Islam, “Only 1 percent of [Muslims] are radical…”

    Okay, what is 1 percent of 1.3 billion?

    Scary!

    Gut Shabbos

  5. I think it’s time for everyone to take their head out of the sand. THE KORAN PREACHES VIOLANCE. Always has always will. There is only one way to interpret it. Personally, that picture makes me sick.

Leave a Reply


Popular Posts