Barack Obama has gained the support of Edgar M. Bronfman in a column on the Huffingtonpost.
Bronfman asserted that Obama is the candidate who will act in the best interest of Israel. Of Obama’s Republican rival, the philanthropist said: “As an American Jew who loves Israel, I cannot support John McCain.”
Bronfman, a former head of the World Jewish Congress, wrote in the piece titled “Israel’s Best Interest is a Morally Strong America” that an honest broker was needed to push Israelis and Palestinians toward a two-state solution.
Below are excerpts of the article:
I am supporting Obama for president for two reasons: one is my disdain for the McCain-Palin ticket, and the other my respect and admiration for Barack Obama and Joe Biden.
Among Jewish voters, some feel the basic question is which candidate will act in the best interest of Israel. The answer is Barack Obama. As an American Jew who loves Israel, I cannot support John McCain. To have the United States and Israel both regarded by the rest of the world as unreliable and in isolation is no way to solve the problems that plague both countries. This has been the effect of the Bush policies, and these are the policies that John McCain has promised to continue. Barack Obama is the candidate who can restore America’s moral authority in the world and position our government to help negotiate peace.
The most vexing problem Israel faces is its relations with its neighbors. From the inception of the state until today, Israelis have felt besieged, surrounded by enemies who want to make them disappear. The constant security threat has made it very difficult for Israel to address the long list of problems that for the most part have been swept under the rug while awaiting peace. These include a disastrous educational system, a widening gap between rich and poor, and bitter division between secular and religious Jews. Israel desperately needs peace if it is to come anywhere close to being the “light unto nations” of Jewish dreams.
I quarrel with the oft-heard assumption that “George W. Bush is good for Israel.” He gleaned many Jewish votes on that slogan, but I take a contrarian’s position. Israel is further from peace than it was at the end of the Clinton administration. The smoldering hatred between Iraq’s Sunni and Shi’a has burst into flames as a result of the American occupation. An emboldened Iran, with its Shi’a majority, has strengthened and armed Israel’s enemies Hamas and Hezbollah. But Israel’s most immediate danger comes from a nuclear Iran. Under the Bush administration, conversations with the Iranians began only at the end of May 2007 and have been badly mishandled. The result of the Bush doctrine in the Middle East has been an America and an Israel that are regarded with hatred and fear.
The region requires an honest broker that will push both sides towards a workable solution and a two state outcome. I remember the scene at the White House when President Clinton helped Prime Minister Rabin to shake Arafat’s hand. Whether an American president is prepared to preside over another handshake–one that could build lasting peace–should not be measured by his professed love for one side or the other, but by his judgment.
John McCain’s choice of Sarah Palin as running mate is the towering example of his poor judgment. Palin’s ignorance of public affairs is monumental. Especially disturbing to the Jewish voter should be her willing acceptance of the campaign assignment of demagogy, which has stirred up racism and hate. The prospect of our having a 72-year-old president in poor health raises the real possibility that Palin could be our president, a thoroughly frightening thought. (I am well aware, in my eightieth year, of the flagging energy of any 72-year-old.) McCain’s choice of Palin was a bid to the extremists in the Republican party, not the considered choice of a man who puts his country first.
Barack Obama is the leader who can begin to undo some of the damage done by Bush’s policies. His background as an American who has lived among diverse cultures makes him sensitive to the cultural and religious motives that shape conflicts. He is cerebral, measured, calm, and pragmatic. By his character, he will engage these issues with more than stonewalling and weapons. He is brilliant in his choices of advisors. He is a tough idealist who has the courage to imagine an America that may inspire hope, not fear, in the Middle East and around the world.
Voters who care about Israel’s welfare should ask which candidate will help sustain the ties between Israel and American Jews. Those of us who were alive at the creation of Israel have a love for Israel that is tied to the Holocaust, to the displaced persons camps and to the early struggles for a Jewish homeland. We were all as generous as we could be in support of Israel, as donors and as advocates. Now there is a generation growing up that is more distant from Israel than I should like. Young Jews do not automatically support Israel, and many are rightly troubled by what they learn about the ill treatment of the Palestinians under Israeli occupation. No longer motivated by fear of anti-Semitism, they seek to understand what Israel stands for, not to say “my Israel, right or wrong.” Without strong support among the younger generation of American Jews, Israel may lose its vital relationship with the US government.
Obama can inspire much-needed support for Israel among this next generation of American Jews. He reflects their idealism and speaks in the language of hope they understand. His approach to international affairs shows a commitment to restoring America’s reputation and to working with our allies to combat war, poverty, disease, and environmental destruction. He has articulated a vision for American society that does not ask us to ignore our differences–religious, racial, or economic–but to set aside divisive rhetoric and acknowledge that we all have a stake in building a more ethical society. Under his leadership a renewed America can help to foster a renewed Israel. Barack Obama is an inspiring American, willing and able to lead this nation and the world to new heights in very perilous times. I will vote for him with enthusiasm.
(LINK to Huffingtonpost article)
20 Responses
a hechsher on his tarfus
what took so long for this endorsement to come? polls perhaps?
That is the difference between a yorei shomayim and not. We endorse who is right and not who is going to win….
I always suspected Bronfman was a shaigetz. He uses his platform as a former head of a tzioini organization to endanger eretz yisroel and klal yisroel.
He says “The prospect of our having a 72-year-old president in poor health. . .”
Excuse me, but Doctor says McCain is in “excellent health” with “extraordinary energy” …
http://www.cnn.com/2008/HEALTH/05/23/mccain.health.records/
This profound and well written article, should be the poster and classic example of how the liberal Jew can convince themselves and say the ridiculous, in a sophisticated style.
Rather than give credence to Mr. Bronfman by wasting time to refute his non-sensible and illogical notion, that Mr. Obama is the better choice for Jews, let us simply review Mr. Obama’s endorsements.
A) Hamas B) Al-Qaeda C) Ahmidinijad D) Farrakhan… and the list goes on.
The twisted liberal Jew will convince themselves by maintaining that all the foes of the Jews will make peace with us under this unifier.
To that I say; Edgar, you will get what you vote for…..
probably he already has a hechsher from the “naturei karta” for being ready to join them and embrace the madman from iran…
What els would you expect from WJC…
Face it, neither candidate is any good.
Anyone who posts on the Huffington site is someone who’s opinion I ignore.
Bronfmann must have been shiker.
Does anybody know how to contact Bronfman so that we can ‘Bombard’ him with e-mails and faxes?
Please all should be done with decency. Just educate him concerning his ignorance.
Tell him that jews are being silently laughed at because people like him are voting for the same person that his/our enemies are voting for. A real disgrace.
We all must do our hishtadlus to keep Obama out of the White House.
apparently bronfman’s brain is flagging more than his energy.
Did any of you actually read or bother to think about Bronfman’s words before casting them aside? Given your responses, I think that question could be left a rhetorical one. (Actually, given the majority of the comments ever posted on this site, I think the question is always a rhetorical one here.)
How right he is!
“Bronfman, a former head of the World Jewish Congress, wrote in the piece titled “Israel’s Best Interest is a Morally Strong America””
Israel’s best interest is in a president that won’t negotiate with achmadenejad and isn’t supported by palestinians and hamas!
Until we as Yidden do teshuva, it will not matter at all who the president will be. The fate of Israel is by Hashem and the real issue is what are each and every one of us doing to deserve a favorable outcome in Israel? Our midos need attention, our lawlessness needs attention, our hipocracy needs attention. Once we clean up our own yetzer hara problems, then Israel will be at peace. It has nothing to do with who is the president. All is by Hashem and He gives us what we deserve.
you have to love the argument of the leftists:
we can”t take a chance on McCain because his running mate (a Governor) does not have national experience (hmmm, billy clinton – anyone ever hear of him, or perhaps jimmy carter???) and she may (yes there is a chance) be called into Presidential service. they seem to ignore that their candidate has neither governing experience and limited state and national experience. the absurdity of the left and their complete lack of logic would be laughable if it didn’t have the potential to have such terrible consequences.
#15, Great Post!!!
Yasher Koach Leah from BP! YWN should post your words as their headlines in bold print.
Zevulun from Skokie
#16 – Good point
#5 – The Washington Post and AP reported that al Qaeda has actually endorsed McCain for president. Check your facts.
McCain has no analytical ability and a life long problem with a very poor memory. He juts from tactic to tactic, and can’t think strategically. The sad truth is that Iran cannot be contained militarally. Iran wants us to be in constant wars in the Middle East to deplete our economy and to deplete our troops–that’s how Iran wants to destroy us. That is their strategy and unfortunately, it is sadly a very brilliant one. Their military proxys in other countries are skilled, willing and able to carry this out. This is the chessboard of life that we face and we as a nation need someone who can figure out a solution. McCain is not that person. He is erratic, he graduated bottom in class, he can’t remember the difference between the Shia and Sunnis, and his Palin choice just feeds on the yetzer hara of men. Statistically, one out of seven vice presidents assends to president. Palin uses tactics like the Iranians by stirring up hate and resentment, if she were to take office we would have our first ayatollah as a president.