NYC Mayor DeBlasio blew an opportunity on Sunday morning to explain a glaring double standard that has brought him under attack. DeBlasio fudged his way out of the question convincing even more people of their accusations.
As YWN had reported, the morning after Williamsburg’s Levaya incident last week, the NYPD was out in force and wrote nearly 100 summonses to pedestrians for not wearing masks. One each summonse, it was clearly written that the reason for the summose was “Mayor’s executive order”. Yet on Shabbos afternoon, the NYPD was out around the city and not only were they not giving summonses to people not wearing masks, but they were actually giving out masks to those not wearing them.
In fact, the main NYPD Twitter account proudly tweeted a photo of an officer giving a woman a mask and wrote “No mask? No problem. This park-goer in Domino Park didn’t have a mask, no problem, our task force officers were more than happy to provide her with one.”
No mask? No problem.
This park-goer in Domino Park didn't have a mask, no problem, our task force officers were more than happy to provide her with one. pic.twitter.com/qgSo1li2VH
— NYPD NEWS (@NYPDnews) May 2, 2020
Twitter exploded with outrage and criticism against the Mayor from elected officials such as Councilman Chaim Deutsch, Kalman Yeger, Simcha Eichenstein, Simcha Felder, former Assemblyman Dov Hikind and many other community activists.
[SEE TWEETS BELOW]
At his daily press conference on Sunday morning, the Mayor was asked by Hamodia reporter Reuven Borchardt about this double standard, and instead of addressing it, he just blamed it all on the Levaya incident and ignored the questions about why the NYPD was handing out masks all over the city, but busy writing summonses in Williamsburg:
WATCH THE VIDEO AND READ THE TRANSCRIPT BELOW:
Question: Hi, how are you? There’s some criticism of you on Twitter over the weekend by elected officials that I’d like you to respond to saying there’s a tale of two cities. On the one hand, you tweeted sharp criticism of a funeral, Williamsburg, and the next day police officers descended on the neighborhood giving out large numbers of summons. I know you mentioned the distinction between gathering versus a bunch of individuals, but those people who got the tickets the next day were just a bunch of individuals out in the street. Yesterday, there were many images of jam-packed parks in the city, people not wearing masks. You had no Twitter comment. Assemblymen Simcha Eichenstein wrote, Hasidism regressively slapped in summons of up to $1,000 for not wearing a mask, a tale of two cities. NYPD tweeted, no mask, no problem – this lady in the park didn’t have a masks, we gave her a mask. Councilman Chaim Deutsche responded, I’m confused, when do you give a mask to when do you give a summons? And so my question is, why – if you can respond to this criticism, the politicians are saying that apparently there’s one neighborhood that’s gets sharp criticism and the community called out by name, while in other instances there’s silence or the polite handing out of masks. Thank you.
Mayor: Yeah, Rubin. I just dispute that fundamentally. There has been enforcement for weeks and weeks. And look, I love my city and I understand everyone looks out for their own communities within this city, but I’ve ultimately heard critique of too much enforcement or not enough enforcement in a variety of different communities. So, we want to make this an entirely consistent reality. I want it to be abundantly clear, the NYPD will be out enforcing and a number of other agencies will be out enforcing in all communities the same way, period. What I saw with my own eyes on Tuesday night in Williamsburg was absolutely unacceptable and was something that we had not seen on that scale anywhere and it was exactly what we cannot allow to happen. And there had been other large funerals before in the community and we’re not going to allow that to happen. So, we had a particular problem we had to deal with. But we’ve had other types of problems in other places, and we’re going to deal with everyone equally. So, again, that hierarchy – and I’m sure Commissioner Shea will add to this – the worst thing is a large gathering. And if it’s dozens of people, it’s bad. If it’s hundreds of people, it’s worse. If it’s thousands of people, it’s terrifying. And Rubin, we saw on Tuesday night, thousands of people in close proximity. If they had not been broken up by the police, they would have stayed for longer, many of them did not have face coverings. This means lives will be lost. It is unacceptable. But that’s going to be true in any community. You talk about a really large gathering, absolutely acceptable, everyone’s going to get a summons. Anyone who stays, summons instantly. Again, whether it’s hundreds, same thing; dozens, same thing. We’re coming after all gatherings. That is different than a bunch of people in a park who are distanced from each other. If there’s small clumps that people are not distanced, we’re going to go in and tell them you have to distance immediately. If they don’t, they’re getting summonsed. Each situation is looked at in degree. If someone doesn’t have a face covering, we’re going to offer them a face covering. Someone says, I refuse to have it put on a face covering, they have a problem and they’re asking for enforcement. So, it is going to be done equally across all communities, one message that we have to save lives and anyone who is not following these simple rules is endangering the lives of everyone else. Commissioner Shea?
NYPD Commissioner Shea: Yeah. As I’m listening to the conversation, I’m reminded of – you know, to thank the officers that are out there every day doing this work and across the city from borough to borough, regardless of what neighborhood it’s in, officers are out there doing their best to enforce the social distancing, which is something six months ago we certainly couldn’t have even imagined it. I think that I would agree, every situation is unique. They do the best they can in certain situations, and, first and foremost, they’re trying to correct the condition, they’re trying to educate people, they’re trying to get compliance. The last thing they want to do is summons and arrest, and that goes from the Bronx to Staten Island. But there are some gatherings that we have said, we are past the point of warnings. And I think we’ve been consistent from the start, we’re out there across the city, engaging people and we get varying levels of compliance, and if it comes to summons, then, you know, wherever at the summons point. But we urge New Yorkers to hang in there with us. We are going to get through this, but we just need your compliance, we need your patients and we need you to continue to work with us. And that goes whether you’re in Williamsburg, that goes whether you’re in the Mott Haven, or whether you’re in Staten Island or Manhattan or anywhere else in between. I think that, you know, you can always find that an individual that’s not happy. I rarely come across somebody that is happy after they’ve received the summons. But I think that in the difficult circumstances that we are in, and we certainly are, the officers are doing the best they can in trying, trying times.
I’m confused…when do you give out a mask and when do you give out a summons? https://t.co/ixz3y68kwO pic.twitter.com/Ilhgq4dQVR
— Chaim Deutsch (@ChaimDeutsch) May 3, 2020
More than When. TO WHOM. And it's very clear.#DoubleStandard https://t.co/8HpXw9yXBi
— Kalman Yeger (@KalmanYeger) May 3, 2020
Yet chasidim were aggressively SLAPPED with summonses of up to $1,000 for not wearing a mask.
Tale of two cities. https://t.co/jlGBLoCAvK
— Simcha Eichenstein (@SEichenstein) May 3, 2020
Oh and EVERY video on this site shows ZERO POLICE enforcement today. Message: do whatever the heck you want if you’re not Chasidic https://t.co/5lG9Mg4go7
— David G. Greenfield (@NYCGreenfield) May 3, 2020
Stop the chaos and unite this city @NYCMayor. We need real leadership and one enforcement standard for all New Yorkers.
— Senator Simcha Felder (@NYSenatorFelder) May 3, 2020
This is the @NYCMayor’s famous “TALE OF TWO CITIES”:
No mask? No mask?
No problem! Summons! pic.twitter.com/CubTvdfNoB— Dov Hikind (@HikindDov) May 3, 2020
We can’t go on where it’s literally a “No mask? No problem” tweet and you’re handed a freeo, but two miles away youre given a criminal court summons. Can’t be “Open streets for fresh air!” but “there’s too many people out!”
Give us clear protocols & we’ll all get on with it. https://t.co/aWHFYovP3a
— Joe Borelli (@JoeBorelliNYC) May 3, 2020
https://twitter.com/DavidSchwartz48/status/1256785975528820739?s=20
Obviously a great program, why couldn’t this be done in Williamsburg? Why couldn’t @NYPDSpecialops SRG units hand out masks instead of $1,000 tickets? #ATaleOfTwoCities https://t.co/KfFhy1444v
— Yaakov (Jack) Kaplan (@JackKaplanNY) May 3, 2020
(YWN World Headquarters – NYC)
7 Responses
As heard on Fox News last week “”if someone was writing a parody of a tone deaf political dunce, this would be too on the nose”.
A democracy should have one standard for all.
But the action of police should fit the severity of the transgression and the acuity of the situation.
As a physician I dare to say that the situation in Williamsburg with the concentration of so many people without social distancing was a greater threat to the health of New York City than the concentration of people in the parks who displayed a modicum of social distancing.
The mayor still has some explaining to do but the police actions were appropriate to the situation.
R
Why is he wearing a bandana, instead of a normal mask?
Let’s ignore who was wrong at the funeral for a moment (because we can do something wrong AND deblasio could be a anti semite at the same time)
The definition of a anti-semite is someone that incites and blames the Jews
It’s clear that the funeral was planned with the NYPD (they even brought barricades)
Now If they started the event and then realized that it won’t work out as planned do they cancel the event and disperse the crowd …… OK
but the mayor coming himself and DENYING that this was a coordinated event then BLAMING the Jews ….. that is THE definition of antisemite
And all those ASKANIM and POLITICIANS saying he is our best friend make me want to through up (I get that we still need him sometimes) but to throw the jews under just to curry favor with this pig (that consistantly was against jews (metzitza, schools, even the kosher grab and go)) is DISGUSTING
Now in regard to the funeral
It was wrong on a halchic/Jewish level because we value life more than the mayor (who supports abortion, was ok with EMS not resuscitating)
But it was as coordinated with the mayor’s office and nypd
So as far as the mayor he has no right to utter a peep about it
The most he could say is that we thought we could do it with social distancing and it didn’t work out that way so we had to cancel it
Whether or not there was a double standard depends on the context of the summons. Were they people who were walking alone without a mask (like with the women in the photo) or were they gathered in a crowd or talking with other people?
Truth be told, if one really wants to criticize the mayor, it would be as follows — what took so long? Why wasn’t such a policy instituted (fairly and evenly) over a month ago? In short, what took so long. In Israel they have been giving out fines for a long time already.
As far as our response to the mayor — I think we should spend less time complaining about a double standard (even if true) and more time with focusing on the irresponsiblity of having such a large levaya. Even if it was coordinated with the police — when people saw that it was getting out of hand they should have moved away. We all know that we have to social distance. We all know that this is an issue of pakuach nefesh. We probably all know people who have died from this dreaded virus. So what gives — why are they all standing so close (with or without masks)?
So rather then complain about a poorly worded tweat in the heat of the moment or double standards, let’s complain about those among us who are not taking this seriously enough. Yes, the letter written by the community afterwards was beautiful, but why was such a letter necessary in the first place.
> Ronnbo
What are you really talking about? The few minutes of a (relatively) few people at a funeral are a problem to you? Not long ago there was the Blue Angels and Thunderbirds airshow which was “packed shoulder to shoulder”. The only difference is the airshow had so many people the police were just too scared to do anything.