The following is an unedited article via The San Diego Union Tribune:
In a parking lot behind a Pico Boulevard building, inside a makeshift tent of metal poles and tarps, a man in a white coat and black skullcap grabs a white-feathered hen under the wings and performs an ancient ritual.
He circles the chicken in the air several times and recites a prayer for a woman standing nearby whose aim is to symbolically transfer her sins to the bird. The young man then uses a sharp blade to cut the hen’s throat.
In the days before Yom Kippur, the Jewish day of atonement, this ritual will be repeated untold times in hastily built plywood rooms and other structures in traditional Orthodox Jewish communities from Pico-Robertson to Brooklyn, N.Y. Promotional fliers on lampposts in the area advertise the kaparot service at $18 per chicken or $13 apiece for five or more.
But the practice is increasingly drawing the ire of animal rights activists, and some liberal Jews, who say the custom is inhumane, paganistic and out of step with modern times.
“An animal sacrifice in this day and age?” said Wendy Dox, a Reform Jew and animal-rights activist who lives near the Pico alley. “That is not OK with me.”
This year, activists have launched one of the largest, most organized efforts ever in the Southland to protest the practice, known variously as kaparot, kapparot or kaparos.
Over the weekend, a coalition of faith leaders and animal-rights proponents held a “compassionate kaparot ceremony” during which rabbis used money rather than chickens for the ritual, an accepted alternative. Organizers say more than 100 people attended and some stayed to demonstrate late into the night.
Since the ceremony, activists including several staunch vegans and alarmed residents have taken to Pico Boulevard each evening, handing out fliers, setting up candlelight vigils and even bargaining with one kaparot manager to rescue chickens on the chopping block in exchange for protesting more peacefully.
The demonstrations have sometimes gotten testy. Protesters and kaparot managers alike contend that they have been peppered with anti-Semitic slurs.
In one instance Monday night, police were called after a woman refused to leave a parking lot where she heard the screeching of fowl. By the time police arrived, she had walked down the block. No one was injured and no arrests were made.
But activists said they were expecting business at kaparot sites to soar as Yom Kippur, the holiest day of the year for Jewish people, draws near. The holiday begins Friday evening.
“We’re sick and tired of people making money off of these animals,” said Rabbi Jonathan Klein, co-founder of Faith Action for Animals, which organized the weekend protest. “These people are not doing this out of the goodness of their hearts. They are not doing it because they want to remove people’s sin. They’re doing it because there’s money in it.”
Practitioners typically donate the slaughtered chickens to feed the needy, but that doesn’t satisfy critics who decry the conditions under which the birds are caged and stored.
Resident Ken McPeek, 65, has posted his own fliers protesting the practice. Five years ago, he was walking down an alley near his house when he saw people clustered around a parking lot and heard the squawks of birds. When he peeked in, he saw a man slitting the throats of chickens and throwing the corpses into a barrel “like they were footballs.”
“I’ve been to Vietnam, I worked in packing houses, but this was particularly shocking,” he said. “I told them — and I remember what I said, ‘You’ve gotta stop this. This is wrong,’ They laughed at me.”
Kaparot is mentioned in Jewish law texts at least as far back as the 16th century and was originally meant to jolt practitioners into recognizing their own mortality, according to Rabbi Yitzchok Adlerstein, an adjunct professor of Jewish law and ethics at Loyola Law School. The idea was to encourage them to transform sins into good deeds.
Many Jews living in the Pico-Robertson area immigrated from countries where families invite kaparot practitioners to their homes to perform the ritual. Here it’s more out in the open.
Bait Aaron, a Sephardic Orthodox outreach organization, this week has been performing the ritual in a tent in the parking lot of the corner building it rents at 8701 Pico Blvd. In the alley behind were stacked wire cages filled with clucking hens, their white feathers matted together with the sticky residue of yolks from the eggs they had laid and smashed.
After each ritual slaughter, the man in the black skullcap drained the chicken’s blood into a white plastic bin then put the bird on ice. Two butchers schooled in kosher practices stood by to pluck and dress the birds.
Rabbi Yakov Nourollah, a spokesman for Bait Aaron, said the kaparot crew “were doing everything within code … and in a humane way.”
“We’re not going to change our tradition,” Nourollah said. “We’re in a free country. This is America, you know.”
Still, Terrance Powell of the Los Angeles County Department of Public Health said he was surprised to hear that the birds were being dressed on the spot rather than in an approved slaughterhouse. “We’re very mindful not to interfere with religious freedom,” he said. “But that’s something that would have to be discussed.”
Asian, Latino and other communities have also grappled with outcries over cultural practices involving the slaughter and handling of animals.
Most rabbis would not consider the slaughter of chickens in compliance with kosher law as animal mistreatment, Adlerstein said. But he added that reports have surfaced that chickens were not stored and fed properly before slaughter and that chicken corpses were sometimes tossed into the trash.
“If you think about what the ritual is in its element, you’re taking chickens that are destined to die anyway … and people are paying good money for the right to have those chickens slaughtered and then fed to the poor,” he said. “That’s the way it’s supposed to be. People would be grossed out a little bit if they found out they were just spending money to draw the blade against the chicken’s neck, and that’s it.”
(Source: The San Diego Union Tribune)
16 Responses
A pretty well-balanced article
why the surprise. countless gedolai ha’poskim since the times of the late rishonim expressed opposition to what has been labeled a foreign custom.
Interesting how these liberals sympathize for chickens, yet they have no hesitation to kill humans through AIDS with their immoral repugnant behavior!
” as Yom Kippur, the holiest day of the year for Jewish people, draws near. The holiday begins Friday evening.”
Yowza. I’m not ready! who knew
Interestingly “Resident Ken McPeek, 65” hasn’t aged at all since this he was first quoted in LA times 9/11/13
https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-orthodox-jewish-chickenkilling-ritual-draws-criticism-protests-20130911-story.html
Potting animal live above human live is a direct path to Nazism. All these anti-caparot zealots will stop at nothing in order to butcher little babies even at the time of birth.
“Practitioners typically donate the slaughtered chickens to feed the needy…”
After the scene in Brooklyn last year it was a mess with blood and chickens in the garbage. (Pictures and videos are in the photo blogs in this site http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/news/ywn-videos/474739/shocking-video-kaparos-found-in-garbage-bags-strewn-all-over-street.html)
I agree that changed need to be made.
If the chickens will be given to food pantry’s or soup kitchens I would think they should just modify kaparos as it was – tarp the floor, clean up after ourselves.
But if we are just tossing the chickens in a dumpster and leave the streets a mess I would say to use the money not the chickens.
@moisheingolus
Take it easy.
Look at the photos and videos of the mess of carcas’s left in the street and blood for others to clean.
how about we lead by example. show the emes of how a yid behaves the right way and perhaps the goyim will like our methods and behaviors.
who is putting animal lives above human lives in this case?
The entire article is a mistake
They don’t slaughter chickens
They are preforming post hatching abortions
One of the noblest causes known to all animal rights activists anywhere
sammydoesit, go see Gosnell movie and compare is to “the mess of carcas’s left in the street and blood”. Cleaning the mess left behind after kaporot will not change minds of these anti-human, anti-GD lunatics.
Califfornia, especially LA, is loonie liberal land. They hate us because we respect G-d.
Kapporos also gives people the opportunity to do the mitzva d’oraisa of kisui hadam. So it is not ‘just a minhag’ (though that too is halacha as the Rema stated that no minhag can be mocked or abolished (Orach Chaim 690:17) And yes, even today there are people who still call for abolishing gragger on Purim because the idea of zechiras Amalek also bothers them…
It all starts with removing religious exemptions…. Scary
Lets turn this around for a minute. Lets say the goyim in your neighborhood started slaughtering animals on your street and maybe did less than a perfect job cleaning up how would you feel
@flatbush Tzadik – exactly my point and well said!
if we lead by example and clean up and give the chickens to poor people they will want kapparos to be done. if we do a mitzvah and it causes others harm/filth/detriment was it really a mitzvah? we would we then have to redo kapparos for making it a mess and causing a potential aveirah?
Weird. Who’s doing kaporos now?
Fact: there are other more humane versions of Kaparot, maybe we should be switching over to them in this time. I haven’t done a chicken kaparot in years, and now just do it to money that I then go and donate as well. same idea. If you need it to continue with a live being, then switch to fish. God likes fish better anyways, they are considered a humble/hidden being, which is why fish is a big part of Adar. and we say Yom Kippur is like Purim anyways, so now you can make a stronger connection between the 2.