“In a lengthily post on his Blog, Columnist Yossi Gestetner outlines how some in the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), use “anti-Jewish Shtick” to smear the Orthodox Jewish and Hasidic members of the Board of Education of the East Ramapo (NY) Central School District.
Gestetner writes, “I would like to say a few words about some who ‘Kvetch’ often about the Board of Education of the East Ramapo (NY) Central School District: They are driven by hate and anti-Semitism!
“They – The director of NAACP’s mid-Hudson and Westchester regions office, and the President of the Spring Valley, NY chapter of the NAACP – work officially to fight discrimination and to protect Civil Rights, but it is likely hate that drives them to file complaints and publish negative reports against the Orthodox Jewish/Hasidic Board members who have a majority on the nine-seat School District’s BOE.
“A sample of a disgraceful anti-Jewish move by the NAACP is the Press Release the Spring Valley chapter published in the afternoon of Monday, April 18, announcing that the US Department of Education’s Civil Right Division opened an investigation against The Board in response to a complaint filed by the NAACP. The problem? Well, the Federal DOE notified the NAACP and The Board in a letter dated ten days earlier – April 8 – about the inquiry. In fact, Wilbur Aldridge, director for the mid-Hudson and Westchester regions of the NAACP, told LoHud.com, the online edition of the Journal News, that news about the investigation came “last week,” (the week of April 10), yet the NAACP produced its Press Release only on Monday the 18’th, hours before the eight-day Passover holiday kicked in. With this deliberate delay, the NAACP limited the ability of The Board to respond to the allegations in a timely fashion, since the Board adjourned for the holiday with its majority Orthodox Jewish/Hasidic members about to fully observe – without cell phone and electronic communications means – five of the following eight days starting with Sun Set of the 18’th.
“The shameless act by the NAACP went a step further, including strongly misleading the press as to the will of the U.S. Department of Education. Wilbur Aldridge, the NAACP Mid-Hudson Director was quoted by the Journal News that “We cannot release any information as to what they’re looking at or what they’re looking for, but we do know that they have begun an investigation into the functioning of the East Ramapo School District,” and – reported LoHud – “adding that the U.S. Department of Education has asked [The NAACP] that the particulars of the investigation be withheld.”
“The above information is contrary to what the Civil Right Office wrote to the ERSCD Board in its letter informing them about the Investigation. The Letter writes, “Under the Freedom of Information Act, it may be necessary to release this letter and related correspondence, and records upon request.” But again, the NAACP told differently to the press, likely with the goal to paint the Majority Jewish Board members in a dark light at a time when they hat limited-to-no reasonable chance to respond to the allegations.
“Indeed, the NAACP reserved to these Shtick because after reviewing their three allegations of Civil Rights Discrimination, one would see it doesn’t hold much water:
“Allegation One is that the District provides Private School placements for White, but not to non-White, disabled children. Fact: Because – in many cases – The District cannot provide fair and appropriate education to some (such as Yiddish-speaking, culturally different) students, the District therefore pays for the severely handicapped and developmentally challenged kids to enroll in private institutions that fits their needs. This service is provided to any student on a case-by-case review if so requested by the parent.
“Allegation Two in the complaint is that The District segregates students on the basis of race by providing a “white-only” kindergarten. Fact: The District has a class of six severely handicapped and developmentally challenged Jewish kids who understand each other based on language and culture, not race. In fact, The District has similar – and perhaps lager – such classes for Haitian American kids with special needs. In addition, following the Haiti earthquake, The District put together a few of classes where only Haitian American kids were placed to make it easiest possible for them in this new country.
“Allegation Three: the complaint alleges that the District fails to recruit and hire a sufficient number of noon-white teachers and district wide administrators such as assistant super attendants. Fact: 1) The current Interim Superintendent is a member from a minority group, he is Jewish. 2) Two of the five current Assistant Superintendents were hired by the Jewish-led Board, and both hires are minorities. One is an African American Woman, and the other is from Puerto Rico communities. 3) At least fifty percent of the School Principles are member from minority communities.
“All in all it is a shame that people working for The NAACP, a group out there to advance the needs of minorities, instead uses religion and race to undermine members of another minority group while using severely handicapped and developmentally challenged kids as pawns. The disgrace grows even more when considering that the NAACP Spring Valley Chapter is located in one of “New York’s most diverse villages whose Orthodox Jewish and Hasidic members shaped history eighteen months ago by making possible to elect New York State’s first Haitian American Mayor!
“The Board Members at the ERSCD are using the success of the Private School system (where 2/3 of the local students are enrolled), to enhance multiple parts of the Public School system, most notably the Special Education division. This was done while keeping tax increases to a minimum; a move away from the past and a helpful move for locals in the troubling economic times of recent years. But from local groups and individual mouth-pieces, the Board gets mostly only complaints, fights, arguments and attacks, and at last this shameful act by the NAACP.
“I hope the national NAACP will move to denounce its Spring Valley chapter and the Director of its Mid-Hudson and Westchester regions, and instruct them to work hand-in-hand with members of all communities for the good and the education of children in The District.”
Gestetner tells YWN that he is in contact with attorneys to see if he can file any sort of defamation suits against the above members of the NAACP, but Gestetner stresses that “No one on the Jewish side is looking for fights and court battles, so I hope any actions in court will not be needed.”
5 Responses
This sounds like posturing.
From this letter, it doesn’t seem like the NAACP is calling for any curtailment of Jews’ rights. It seems like they are campaigning for dollars to be spent on their own community constituents. I don’t see how that makes them anti-Semites.
It could be that in their offices, they sit back twisting their mustaches while boning up on Jewish religious observances so as to perfectly time the release of their letter, but I’m betting this letter was the first they’d heard of Jews taking time off for Passover.
With all of the real anti-Semitism going on, with Jews being murdered in Israel for being Jewish, with kosher meat processing being banned in Europe because it benefits Jews, with a vote in California under consideration to ban circumcision because it is a requirement of Jewish life, perhaps we should contest anti-Semitism only where it actually rears its head?
It should be interesting to see which side of this the secular Jews come down on.
” It seems like they are campaigning for dollars to be spent on their own community constituents. ”
That is exactly what WE do! We have just been more successful at it.
Why is any group that puts their own problem ahead of others labeled anti-Semitic just because they happen to have Jewish neighbors?