Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Smerel,
You are sadly mistaken. The reason halacha seforim don’t bring down the issurim from the shalosh shavuos is because halacha seforim are for halachos for a specific individual. An issur which is incumbent on the whole of klal yisroel isn’t relevant to such a sefer.
But the Rambam does actually bring the shalosh shavuos when writing a letter to Jews who were planning to move to eretz yisroel. He said that the shavuos didn’t apply in that case but never do we find that a rishon or any gadol before Zionism and after that says that they just aren’t ‘binding’.It’s not about who I choose to be gedolim. If I would just mention the rabbonim who hold chillul shabbos is assur, would you also accuse me of this?
Zionism is a clear issur from the gemara (shalosh shavuos). And if you’re going to do your logic where everything that anyone argues is a legitimate machlokes, no matter of the consensus of rabbonim, just know the same argument could go for reformed rabbis and shabbos.Zeff, I am simply echoing the words of the gedolei hador at the time time of the States founding.
Using the words the Brisker Rav, Chazon Ish, Satmar Rav, Nitra Rav, and R’ Aharon Kotler is not ‘hate’. All of the gedolei were always against Zionism and Zionism is the ideology that the state of Israel is based on.This whole thing is very very silly. Originally, a majority of the moetzes was pressured into allowing agudas yisroel to send out flyers. They didn’t know the details of the rally. As it turned out, there was a priest, an actress, and secular singer edited. There were no tefillos.
Therefore, many gedolim came out against it (R’ Yitzchok Sorotzkin, R’ Malkiel Kotler, R’ Elya Brudny, R’ Yerucham Olshin, Others). Including Rabbonim who were previously supportive (R’ Aharon Feldman).
This rhetoric by those lowlifes who think that they’re a bar daas to disagree with gedolei yisroel is disgusting. If your rabbi tells you to go, nobody is attacking him. The idea that we have to be ‘united’ with the wicked members of the zionist ideology is the thing that started this 70 year tragedy of a state.
It was helped to be founded by Agudas Yisroel, standing with the the evil ben gurion in his demands for a state like every other nation. Stop making the same mistakes over and over again.