Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
zahavasdadParticipant
Avram
by your ID you live in MD, its very possible the frum jews in NY have very different attitudes than frum jews Out of town. I do think there is more commuity and less division out of town.
I dont think for example you have in MD the plague of restaurants with 3 Hashghcas (None of the are anything less than Hemish)
zahavasdadParticipantThe sushi one Ive seen more in Israel than the US, However in the US I do see the anti-cell phone one even on bumper stickers on cars
When I first saw the Sushi one I was taken a little aback from shock
zahavasdadParticipantI think you might need to have a heart to heart talk with your son without Judgements about his living arrangements unfortunalty R’L even people from hemish homes might have such issues
zahavasdadParticipantThere is a feeling among some that anything from outside “frumkite” will damage the yiddishe neshama. Most people stop at language or dress thats which Lvush or Yiddish is so important to them. However some people take it to another level and add the chumra of not eating “Goyishe Foods” and Goysishe foods doesnt mean treif, it means foods that come from another source beside the Alte Heim. They can be made perfectly kosher, they are just not from the Alte Heim.
Sushi has become the symbol of these foods, Its very popular in the jewish community and some have this idea that if you eat sushi it will lead to going OTD because you have now had a “ta’am” for the goyish world,
zahavasdadParticipantMaybe it got lost in the post, but THAT was a subsitite for a negative reason not to go to a shul or not to eat from a hashghafa.
As far as eating in my house, the people whom I know are frummer, arent eating in my house anyway,
if you want to eat, Ill tell you what store I am going to and you can like it or lump it. I am not going to Borough park to some chassidish shechtah place when there is a pefectly fine store right near my house (Actually more than 1 perfectly fine store, like 5 or 6 of them). I live in a very frum neighborhood
zahavasdadParticipant“AND I UNFORTUNATLY I SEE THIS KIND OF ACTIVITY ALL THE TIME, PEOPLE ONLY BUYING FROM THAT HASHGHCA OR ONLY DAVENING AT THAT SHUL ETC”
Wait, I thought you said your problem was with people broadcasting those things, not doing them at all.
Maybe it was lost in a post, but the emplasis was they spoke those words, not just did them quiety. If someone goes to a certain shul and doesnt really say why , its not the same as broadcasting why they go to THAT shul and dont go to THAT other shul.
My point is , if you do a chumra , do it quietly
zahavasdadParticipantIf you want to be mechazek your kids, put the sign on the INSIDE of the door so the whole family sees it, A sign OUTSIDE the door is a broadcast to the whole world, you can uphold higher standards without telling anyone who didnt even ask, and if you only eat THAT Hashghca, you dont need to tell someone who eats from a difference hashcha that most eat from (I am talking about generally accepted hashghcas, not ones most dont hold from) why you dont eat from THAT hashghca
zahavasdadParticipantI have seen people post on their door in a big sign how they lived in a “Cell Phone and Sushi Free House”
If that is not trying to prove how Helig you are to the rest of the world, I dont know what is, If you dont want a cell phone and Sushi in your house, that is perfectly OK, but once you broadcast it to the whole world in big letters you changed the whole reason
And I unfortunatly I see this kind of activity all the time, People only buying from THAT hashghca or only davening at THAT shul etc
zahavasdadParticipantEven among the posters here there is ittle digs toward chumros,
I cant speak for everyone, but I think many peoples’s negatively towards chumros is not the chumra, but rather the person keeping the chumra, many times they use it as some sort of holier than thou weapon.
There is a difference between quiletly going to the store and only buying chalav yisroel products, that basically only your family knows about and it, Telling the whole world what a Helig yid you are because Chalav Stam never touched your lips
zahavasdadParticipantIts best not to enagage at all and just show that child love. “Tough Love” will likley fail and estrange you from the kid. Best hope is to continue to treat the child with love (and Boundaries like not breaking shabbos in house or bringing in Non-Kosher food..But most would likely accept that) and hope whatever turned them off will get lost
Giving them shiurum will likley not work either, if the person hates torah and learning, giving them more torah and learning isnt going to work
zahavasdadParticipantThe people whom I know go to Uman have the blessings of their families. Im sure not everyone has their family blessings, but you can pretty much say the same thing about almost any aspect of Yiddishkeit, I know people who went into Kollel with their family blessings and other without
zahavasdadParticipantSo just go then, if it doesnt work out, then never go again, It really isnt a big deal worth pondering so much. hashem will hear your tefillot wherever you are
August 23, 2018 5:26 pm at 5:26 pm in reply to: Is there a problem of ribbis borrowing from Kabbage? #1579483zahavasdadParticipantOne can buy on Alibaba without using Kabbage. Alibaba is just an ecommerce site like eBay or Amazon. It just concentrates on Chinese based wholesellers. It has nothing to do with Kabbage.
All people are using Kabbage for is to borrow money for Alibaba, if they get the money elsewhere they are not using Kabbage
August 23, 2018 4:53 pm at 4:53 pm in reply to: Is there a problem of ribbis borrowing from Kabbage? #1579475zahavasdadParticipantNo the lender makes the money off the interest. Kabbage makes money off servicing the loan.
August 23, 2018 2:24 pm at 2:24 pm in reply to: Is there a problem of ribbis borrowing from Kabbage? #1579372zahavasdadParticipantThey are not a loan orginator, they are a peer to peer lender. Meaning they get private people who are willing to loan money to those who want the loan
The also do credit check and help service the loan, however they do not make the loan
August 23, 2018 12:13 pm at 12:13 pm in reply to: Is there a problem of ribbis borrowing from Kabbage? #1579277zahavasdadParticipantyou do not borrow from Kabbage, you borrow from other people, Its peer to peer
Rob Frohwein does not usually give the loans
zahavasdadParticipantpart of Chassidus is to make things more lively, again its not for me, but it does appeal to some people
zahavasdadParticipantPeople have posted videos of Uman on the internet and ive seen them , its not for me but it certainly looks more appealing and lively than other places
Even the Kotel, On Fridays nights during Birthright season its very lively, but the shabbos the next day is pretty dead (The Kotel is not supposed to be a happy or lively place to visit, but this is the reality)
zahavasdadParticipantI have spoken to my neighbor about the dark side and they are very frum and they answered that you sort of have to look for it, if you are not looking for the dark side, you wont find it
zahavasdadParticipantHe is davening with a Minyan in Uman, you can daven anywhere. Hashem hears your tefilot in NY, Jerusalem or Uman
If he doesnt like it , then just dont go back next year, its not a big deal
Uman isnt my thing and I am not going and have no plans to ever go (I have been invited) but I dont see the problem for those who do go
zahavasdadParticipantIf you want to go, then go it isnt that big a deal if you go, you will still be davening B’Tzibur as long as you dont get up with the partying crowd, you might get something out of it. Go and enjoy and if you have a bad time, then dont go again
zahavasdadParticipantusually (and I said Usually) there are minyanim on direct flights between the US and Israel
While there might be 10 men on other flights, its much rarer (maybe a flight to Uman or something like that)
zahavasdadParticipantJoseph, be realistic. Don’t compare those times with current times. It says
הכהן אשר יהי’ בימים ההם the kohen who serves in that time. The Haflah says in sefer Panim Yafos that you cannot question from one time to another.
We currently compete with the Joneses.Actually many have to compete with the hipsters of Williamsburg who can afford to pay more and drive up the rents. Soon they will move to Borough park and Flatbush
August 17, 2018 11:55 am at 11:55 am in reply to: The military parade scheduled for November #1576038zahavasdadParticipantA virtual parade does not have the same effect as a real parade
zahavasdadParticipantThe Rambam writes that a typical Baal Habayis works 3 hours a day and learns 8. This is what a “working person” is. Three hours a day. 8 hours learning.
Unless you are a doctor, who can afford to live in Brooklyn working 3 hours a day, 18 hours a week, the rents are astronomical
August 17, 2018 10:32 am at 10:32 am in reply to: The military parade scheduled for November #1575985zahavasdadParticipantThe parade has been cancelled due to the high cost
zahavasdadParticipantUnless you are flying a direct flight to Israel, you most likely would miss a minyan (especially in the winter) even going on vacation to Israel, there are usually not enough religious jews on flights between the US and Europe on Normal Airlines (Like Air France or KLM)
zahavasdadParticipantMost Chassidim do not kill it in business, A few certainly do, but its a miniroity. Most are living in poverty.
Unfortunatly being a great learner does not get you a decent job in todays society ti support a large (or even a small) family
zahavasdadParticipantIt depends who you ask, there are opinions both ways, I personally have asked the shala and have been told it was ok , but I also know of plenty of opinions that forbid it
zahavasdadParticipantThere is a difference between Halacha and Hashkafa
zahavasdadParticipantIf you want to go somewhere tzniut, go to San Francisco. Nobody is dressing untzniut there, Its really cold there, I needed to buy a sweatshirt in the middle of August
zahavasdadParticipantGoing to Macchu Pichu isnt a problem, there is a Chabad house in Cusco which is near Macchu Pichu.
There is a Chabad House and some Shuls in Athens, Greece, It isnt Santorini, but it is close
zahavasdadParticipantThe reason more people get hurt Bein Hazamin is that they are out of the house, you are more likley to get hurt outside walking or driving than sitting in the Beis Medrash
zahavasdadParticipantTo put Trotsky and Ben Gurion in the same sentance is laughable
zahavasdadParticipantOne might ask why would the Ebeshter have created these locations if his yidden were foreclosed from seeing the wonders of his creations?
That line of argument could easily be used to rationalize transgressions.
I think its a Mitzvah to see a Natural Wonder and say a Bracha, I am pretty sure you at least say a Bracha on an eclipse
August 15, 2018 4:34 pm at 4:34 pm in reply to: If a pig was genetically modified to chew its cud, would it be kosher? #1574740zahavasdadParticipantI think a Mesorah for animals is debateable. Some will not eat Bison because there is no mesorah for them
zahavasdadParticipantIf the vacation (and I am discussing a vacation, a trip for pleasure, NOT the need to go somewhere for medical help or other pressing matter) to location X is desired because of specific amenities (eg, spa, roller coaster, hotel suite) not available elsewhere, it shows that amenity X is more important than tefilla bitzibur. to that I say, how sad, that someone doesnt understand the importance of tefila bitzibur, or assigns it a lower priority than that amenity
One might want to go on vacation to see a wonder of Hashem, many of these places do not have Minyanim, Like if you want to see the Aurora Borelalis , A Solar Eclipse or the Geysers of Yellowstone for example
zahavasdadParticipantThere are very few places that have Shabbos Minyans and even less with Daily Minyans
While you might make a list and think its alot, its really nothing. Even in New York state, remove NYC and Rockland, How many daily minyanim do you think are in NY , Not alot. Even places with Chabad houses or Young Israels dont always have Daily Minyans, they are really hard to get
zahavasdadParticipantStephen Wise was actually in a position to actually do something (He was one of the few jews who had access to Roosevelt) , unlike most people who really were powerless, even among the Reform his legacy was tainted for his inaction.
Hertzel is not the same as someone who tried to get Rav Shach to leave the Beis Medrash. Its unlikley there would be much torah learning in Israel without him (Even if he didnt intend it to be that way), While todays Israel is not what he probably intended he did plant the seed and put it on the political map (Getting it on the required help from Foreign governments)
zahavasdadParticipantSpecifics might make a differnece, It might not have been a “Stam reform guy” and might have been someone like Stephen Wise who did nothing while the Jews were killed in Auschwitz and was not a “stam reform rabbi”
zahavasdadParticipantUnderstanding Mental Illness is a relatively new thing (And we still dont totally understand it)
R’L for anyone who suffers from it
zahavasdadParticipantThe economy is not so simple. You can have more jobs, but if the Jobs are low paying without any benefits its a false statistic
zahavasdadParticipantThere was an uprising at Chelmno and about 300 jews managed to escape and live. Chelmno was not like Auschwitz, pretty much everyone was killed upon arrival except for a small amount to sort the victims stuff.
Chemlno was shut down after the uprising
August 9, 2018 12:05 pm at 12:05 pm in reply to: Different Circles Of Yidden Can Experience Great Unity – Achdus #1571495zahavasdadParticipantAnd that is the difference between those you call everyone a Rasha and those who use the term “Not yet Frum”
zahavasdadParticipantLess jews survived in Warsaw than anywhere else, because in August 1944 the Poles had their own uprising against the Nazis and the Nazis basically leveled Warsaw to the ground (The city was rebuilt after the war) There were probably thousands of jews in hiding and they were killed when the city was destroyed
The head of the Judenraat in Lodz was a Rasha named Mordechai Rumankowski who was a Nazi collaborator, he did manage to stall the deportations from Lodz until august 1944 and 750 jews were left behind to clean the ghetto. They were liberated when Lodz was liberated in January 1945.
More jews actually survived in Berlin than in Warsaw
zahavasdadParticipantIts not a cop out answer, because its not so cut and dry, there are different opinions on this
Mincha and Maariv are especially hard to get in many places, even if they have a Shachris
zahavasdadParticipantAsk your LOR
zahavasdadParticipantIts easy for someone to discuss armed rebellion who did not live in the Ghetto, this is a psak best answered by someone who knew the facts on the ground and not someone pasking from America. Being that a Gadol was in the Ghetto and knew the facts in the ghetto, His Psak is the most relizble
August 6, 2018 10:30 am at 10:30 am in reply to: The military parade scheduled for November #1569476zahavasdadParticipantIts one thing to give the $12 Million as some sort of bonus to our troops, its another for a parade
If you really support the troops let them get a bonus of some sort with the money. Many are struggling financially and in debt. It might be a drop in the bucket, but you never know
zahavasdadParticipantIts actually not so easy to put workers on 1099’s
-
AuthorPosts