Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
YW Moderator-42Moderator
Barlev, I knew someone would ask that. I forgot to add a disclaimer to my post that there are shaylos about bathing on Shabbos even if the water was heated in a halachikly muttar way. Which might be why such a thing hasn’t taken off. But there are circumstances when it can be muttar and it can even be helpful just to avoid the accidental issur of turning on the hot water faucet in the sink. During the winter I often turn on the hot water faucet for general hand washing because the cold water is very cold and the weather is freezing. I have to remember not to do this on Shabbos.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorHow about invent a hot water system that can be used on Shabbos. We have urns for coffee. Why not make the actual boiler work in a similar way so that you can turn on the hot water in the sink/shower to wash dishes etc.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorCatch yourself, nowadays people are too busy texting to honk their horn right away when the light turns
YW Moderator-42ModeratorGoq +1
YW Moderator-42ModeratorPattur Aval Assur +1
December 9, 2014 12:54 am at 12:54 am in reply to: Calling uncles and aunts without using their title #1136745YW Moderator-42ModeratorMy nephews and nieces call me Uncle Joseph.
If your aunt has Semicha, what should she be called?
YW Moderator-42ModeratorYW Moderator-42ModeratorRCCS. Raffled off 1000 doughnuts today. Is pba the guy in their video?
YW Moderator-42ModeratorAll the world seems in tune on a spring afternoon
When we’re poisoning pigeons in the park…
YW Moderator-42ModeratorTry Smokey Joes in Teaneck.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorMazel tov to 42 on becoming a grandfather, born to his daughter Chelsea.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorTzom Gedalia is always a nidcheh. The real date is 2 Tishrei.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorI got an email yesterday from them that they will be sending reminders again this year. Good stuff
YW Moderator-42ModeratorWhatever suits you
September 10, 2014 7:50 pm at 7:50 pm in reply to: Expanding on the Shidduch Crisis Math (Catastrophe) #1036536YW Moderator-42ModeratorLet’s say there are 10 boys and 15 girls in the shidduch pool, so now 33% of the girls will never get married. If one of those boys now goes and marries one of the girls there are now 9 and 14 left, so now 35% of the girls left will never get married, so anybody who gets married – no matter what their age – is making the crisis worse.
Unless of course, one of the boys goes and marries 2 of the girls. So there are now 13 girls left and 9 boys so now only 31% will never get married.
In conclusion, the only way to solve the crisis (assuming as we always do, that there are more girls than boys) is to rescind the Cherem D’Rabbeinu Gershom
September 2, 2014 10:55 am at 10:55 am in reply to: Do people with Ruach HaKodesh exist today? #1031107YW Moderator-42ModeratorAs far as I can remember, I haven’t had a nevuah during the last 9 years.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorIf they don’t accept paypal then perhaps you shouldn’t do business with them…
Does Hamas accept paypal to fund their tunnel project?
YW Moderator-42ModeratorYW Moderator-42ModeratorYW Moderator-42ModeratorPBA will need to have all of his wives pour a bucket at the same time in order to qualify.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorI challenge:
Hakatan
Akuperma and
Popa_bar_abba
To take the Ice Bucket Challenge or donate money to the IDF.
YW Moderator-42Moderatorsbgh613 asked a year ago “Who was Serach’s biological father?”. Does anybody here know the story with that? Why wouldn’t it be Asher as the pasuk states?
August 27, 2014 12:15 am at 12:15 am in reply to: Wow…just wow…who would put up such an ad??? #1030002YW Moderator-42ModeratorWhy what?
Put yourself in his position and think what you would do…
August 26, 2014 11:27 pm at 11:27 pm in reply to: Wow…just wow…who would put up such an ad??? #1030000YW Moderator-42ModeratorI saw a similar ad for $10,000 USD.
10k NIS is fairly normal for someone that age. In terms of the age difference, it is a suggested range. I’m sure if you suggested a 46-year-old he wouldn’t say no. The lower limit of 30 is a way of showing potential shadchanim that age difference doesn’t matter. A shadchan who sees 48 might not think to suggest a 37-year-old but by saying 30-45, it gives them the hava amina. It is all a mind game to get you to suggest shiduchim.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorI read somewhere (probably in the CR) in the name of R’ Yaakov Kaminetzky, that Yaakov originally only planned to marry Rachel, but then Lavan tricked him into marrying Leah. Once that was done, he was stuck. It wouldn’t be nice to Rachel not to marry her after he had agreed to. Since his keeping the Torah was only a chumra (since the Torah was not yet given), he couldn’t use his chumra if it would cause pain to Rachel.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorThis is a great solution to the shidduch crisis. All older girls should become mekubalot, then the boys will come to them.
YW Moderator-42Moderator“A grand jury in Austin, a liberal bastion in
otherwise largely conservative Texas,
indicted Perry…”
YW Moderator-42ModeratorOld timers?
Feivel/80
Mdlevine
Asdfghjkl/jax
Mepal
Areivimzehlazeh
Ames
Jothar
Just smile
Charlie brown
SJSinNYC
Cantoresq
Pahuteh Yid
And of course AYC!
YW Moderator-42ModeratorWas there as big of an age gap with that generation? I get the feeling the men from that generation got married younger. They didn’t have bullet-proof mechitzas in those days so the boys and girls met each other earlier…
YW Moderator-42ModeratorI’m still the cooliest.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorI think. Therefore I am.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorSorry I missed the 18th. A belated happy birthday to The Goq!
YW Moderator-42ModeratorIt is a good idea to take a Brisk walk every day.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorReading through the comments on the 2 articles, I’ve noticed a few comments mentioning the freezer. This is not a problem. It actually solves a problem of people going to Lakewood just to get married. The point of this article is to get people into the freezer earlier so that they can get out earlier or get them married before the freezer. The freezer is just a few months and does not significantly impact this problem.
Getting boys married before they even get to Lakewood would be the ideal for the age-gap crisis. Or better yet, b’mchilas kvod kol hatalmidei chachomim b’Lakewood – boys should stop going to BMG altogether. And b’mchilas kvod Artzeinu Hakdosha, boys don’t have to go to Eretz Yisrael either!
“Aseh l’cha rav” in a small yeshiva and then stick with your Rebbe long-term while you get married, get a job, etc. Why should you ever leave your rebbe? R’ Rechnitz has a whole arichus here about the “rosh yeshiva shiur system”. I don’t undersatnd the system at all. It encourages boys to leave their Rebbe eventually.
I feel the ideal would be to have boys go to smaller yeshivas and stay there. Go out of town and stay there if needed as well. Brooklyn and Lakewood are not Yerushalayim! There is no mitzvah to live there. There is no mitzvah to even learn in BMG for a few years. There are plenty of wonderful, growing, frum communities in places like Dallas, St. Louis, San Diego, Denver, and even Las Vegas! The cost of living in those places is much less than in NY and contrary to popular belief, there are real frum people in those communities – kollels, shuls, schools, etc. If, for whatever reason you need to stay in the North East there is Waterburry and Baltimore as well.
All of these places have yeshivas that boys can go to for a few years and they can then get married and stay there! There are jobs available in these communities both in klei kodesh and the secular workplace.
The problem with this is that currently all the boys and girls are in NY/NJ so they stay there for shiduchim. And girls are brainwashed to only marry Lakewood boys. If R’ Rechnitz can fund LA girls going to NY for dates, I’m sure he can fund dating between all of these communities as well. This will help solve the parnasa crisis as well since the cost of living for frum families is much lower in those communities.
How about if R’ Rechnitz were to pay for boys to go learn in these communities on condition that they stay there long term. He can pay for families to move there to help the communities. And then we need the seminaries to encourage their girls to date boys from these places. It will take a complete over-haul of the entire yeshivish mentality but who better than R’ Shlomo Yehuda Rechnitz to bring this to reality!
YW Moderator-42ModeratorAnother point – if we really want to solve the age-gap issue, we need to get the 19-year-old girls off he market. When boys start dating, whether they are 21 or 24, they should be required to go out with girls older than themselves or within 1 or 2 years younger. Part of the problem is that the girls are desperate and therefore enter the market at 19. Once they hand in their resume, they are given boys and these boys are often 2+ years older then them. This should be stopped. If all 23-year-old boys give the 21-23 year-old girls a chance before the 19-year-olds then it will help even the age gap.
The big question is how to enforce this. Shadchanus is a business and shadchanim will continue to do whatever has the best chance of working. If setting up 19-year-old girls has the best chance of results, that is what they will do, no matter how much money you throw at them for the older crowd. There is no oversight of the “business”. So it is hard to enforce anything unless each rosh yeshiva encourages his own talmidim to follow the “rules” and not go out with the 19-year-olds. Everybody, man and woman, considers themselves the exception (and they might be right). The problem is that there is nobody to enforce any such takanos. If just a few roshei yeshiva don’t follow the rules, the 19-year-olds will get dates and that will ruin the whole system.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorAnother related point is the parnasa crisis – the father-in-laws of yesterday are no longer. The sons-in-law of yesterday who sat and learned and were supported by their parents/in-laws are now parents of kids in shiduchim and don’t have money to support. The money has to come from somewhere and it isn’t coming from Obama.
So those who want to learn have have to have A) real mesiras nefesh to live a simple life-style and B) a wife who makes a real parnasa.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorIt is true that many 20-21 year old boys are not ready for marriage and should not be thrown into the shidduch system too early as this will just cause a divorce crisis.
But a lot of the problem is the entitlement mentality. 20-year-olds feel they are entitles to at least a few years yeshiva, camp, seed, vacations during bein hazmanim, etc all at their parents expense and then expect support in kollel.
Even the ones who plan to go to college want a few years of leisure first and once they get to college they spend all of their bein-ha’semesters relaxing. In the olden days, boys used to start working at 13-14 years old and that was real manual labor for very little pay – a lot harder work than anyone does nowadays.
Boys need to be taught responsibility, the idea of not taking hand-outs, lead a simpler life style if necessary. That is what we call mesiras nefesh for Torah.
And after all this, if they are still not ready for marriage at age 21 that is fine. But when they get to 23-24 they should be dating older girls who have a degree/job/plan – especially if they want to continue learning.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorFrancorachel3, bashert doesn’t necessarily mean what you think it means. check out these mareh mekomos: http://t.co/WSUfbm5OAs (especially #11 and #12 which explain what bashert/zivug rishon/zivug sheini means according to R’ Dessler and the Meiri)
YW Moderator-42ModeratorTopic Canceled
August 18, 2014 6:03 pm at 6:03 pm in reply to: What is your favorite out of town community #1028884YW Moderator-42ModeratorIf you enjoy humidity, move to Houston
YW Moderator-42ModeratorDoes Rabbi Kimmel sell Kangen water?
YW Moderator-42ModeratorFiveish.
YW Moderator-42ModeratorHow can one grow out of Marvelous Middos Machine?
YW Moderator-42ModeratorChocolate
Twizlers
Jolly ranchers
Chips (especially bbq)
I’m getting hungry…
YW Moderator-42ModeratorCE/Web Chaver is good because it will tell your chaver if u uninstall it. Thoughit could be there are ways around that. There are ways around everything if you are motivated enough. The best we can do is use these tools to act as a reminder. It is a lot easier to stop yourself from doing an issur when it takes work to do whatever it is you are doing. We need to do our hishtadlus to minimize the nisayon.
You should have both a filter and a chaver and know yourself etc as pointed out above. I would also recommend adblockplus, flashblock, and if you can handle it imglikeopera.
August 11, 2014 12:25 pm at 12:25 pm in reply to: when do we start saying vsan tal umatar this year #1196783YW Moderator-42ModeratorInteresting. Why would you not follow the minhag hamakom when you return?
YW Moderator-42ModeratorGI Pig?
August 10, 2014 5:41 pm at 5:41 pm in reply to: Girl I want to get engaged to wants me to change my Rabbi #1047114YW Moderator-42ModeratorSam, if I said to you “don’t tell popa_bar_abba that I made his pot fleishig” would it be Lashon Hara for me to do so? There are situations where one must “violate” such requests and this to me sounds like one of them. This is his personal Rav who has been his dating coach, etc and now he has a serious “dating shayla”. Though perhaps in this situation, because the Rav is personally involved in the shayla, he should ask a different Rav.
He should probably first try to have an open conversation with his woman (that was for goq) about what exactly she doesn’t like about his Rav. If she doesn’t agree with some of the Rav’s hashkafos then they are going to have issues going forward in marriage as I assume this guy wants to run his home based on his rebbe’s hashkafos. As has been discussed elsewhere in the CR, in general couples will follow the husband’s halachos. The guy here should explain to his potential kalla that when it comes to halacha, you can’t just pick and choose rabbanim – if you have a Rav who you have always followed, you should continue doing so unless there is a very good reason to switch such as the Rav ch”v going off the derech. If the wife isn’t going to respect her husband’s Rav’s opinion then the husband is going to have a hard time getting her to follow all the halachik of this Rav.
I don’t think “hakaras hatov” is necessarily the issue here. It sounds like the Rav has been very helpful to the couple but for whatever reason the young lady felt that he was rude or something and is uncomfortable with him. It is very possible that this was a simple misunderstanding between the girl and the Rav. Which is why the guy needs to speak to her to find out specifically what bothered her and then needs to speak to a Rav (possibly this one, possibly another) to see whether her complaints are valid.
August 10, 2014 11:57 am at 11:57 am in reply to: Girl I want to get engaged to wants me to change my Rabbi #1047104YW Moderator-42ModeratorUm… Ask your Rebbe.
-
AuthorPosts