Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
JosephParticipant
It was a big piece that paved the way towards legitimizing immorality.
Lawrence was worse than and paved the way for Obergefell. If Lawrence goes, Obergefell surely can go.
JosephParticipantSounds delicious. Make sure to save a piece for me!
JosephParticipantPlease keep us posted hourly on new developments.
JosephParticipantIt was me.
JosephParticipantZahava sleeps on a cot on the kitchen floor.
Not everyone is blessed with extra discretionary funds, Syag. š
JosephParticipantNechomah, what are examples of what salaries are like in EY?
JosephParticipantIt’s already past the sixth anniversary. Time flies!
JosephParticipantOkay, ZD, rent the Barclays Center and I’ll arrange rides for everyone to get there.
JosephParticipantZD, I’d like to organize that parlor meeting/asifa in your home and invite the neighborhood.
Are we on?
JosephParticipantadlc, to take an example (just one easy one from many many examples), in secular courts the prosecutor can get a conviction by “proving” the accused earned “X” dollars per year based on the testimony of a single “witness” who pled guilty to another crime/case and worked out a prosecutorial agreement for a lesser sentence in exchange for testifying against the accused in another case. If he doesn’t have anyone else to testify a crime against, he doesn’t get a lesser sentence. It is in his interest to “find” crimes he “knows” about and can offer to testify against so that the prosecutor is made happy to advance his career and public perception for fighting crime. Very often such witnesses testify falsely for that lesser sentence.
In a criminal Din Torah case such a “witness” would be disqualified for multiple reasons. Some of those reasons are a) he’s a single witness b) if it’s a she that alone disqualifies c) he’s a convicted criminal, which alone disqualifies him from being a witness.
JosephParticipantThe accusation of him having earned “X” dollars in another persons name might be “proven” via (false) single witness testimony that he was the underlying owner/earner, rather than whoever’s name was on the documents.
JosephParticipantSyag, how much would 7 K-12 Yeshiva tuitions cost in Cleveland and Detroit? How does the cost there of kosher food, kosher clothing and other Jewish items needed for living compare to Lakewood?
JosephParticipantThe threshold of evidence required to prove is most certainly far far higher in the Torah system than in the secular system. Many many, probably most, convictions obtained in American courts would not have met the Torah’s evidentiary requirements for conviction in a Din Torah.
JosephParticipantThe subject of Parah Adumah which begins this week’s Parsha is based on the concept of the Tum’ah of a dead body, which is the most severe form of spiritual uncleanliness and is called the ××× ××××Ŗ ×××××× – the father of the fathers of all Tum’ah.
As we learn about the function of the פ×Ø× ××××× in removing this highest form of ×××××, it behooves us to understand the reason why a dead body should be considered so impure. And there is another Halacha that requires an explanation. We are commanded to bury the dead body as soon as possible. Why do we have to remove the corpse from before our eyes so quickly. Once we begin to understand the laws pertaining to the dead body, we will be able to use these lessons to reach greater heights in our service of Hashem.
One important explanation for the severity of ××××× and the sight of the dead body is as follows: The ×××××Ŗ ××××××Ŗ in שע×Ø ×××× ×××¢×©× declares that the first and most prevalent doubt of all the important Torah principles is the doubt in the truth of life after death. Of course, you’re an Orthodox Jew and you undoubtedly believe in life after death. But because it is something that you have never seen, and never experienced, it is really far away from being something you perceive as real.
Now, we can readily understand the reason for the persistence of such a doubt, in the fact of death itself. When confronted by the catastrophic phenomenon of death, it requires strength of character, and strength of intelligence to overcome the powerful impression that it causes. The dead body, which is perceived by the weak mind as the end, the final chapter of a person, seems to be a contradiction to the truth of the Afterlife. An object which is capable of defiling your mind, by impinging on the great truth of life after death, is a dangerous object and must be avoided. Death is actually the greatest falsehood in the Universe, for the fact of death causes men to weaken in their belief in this most important truth of the Universe – which is the belief in our being greeted by Hashem after we take our last breath. The sight of a dead body, appears to be so much of a cessation, so final, that it impresses upon the mind that it truly is all over. Something that can contaminate the mind, something that can defile this important principle of life after death, is labeled with the highest form of ×××××, defilement, and should be removed from our sight as quickly as possible.
And don’t tell me that it’s not so. It could be that you never think about Olam Habah. And maybe real thoughts of Gehenim barely cross your mind. The whole concept of the Next World is so very weak in your mind, so you don’t even recognize that the image of death weakens it even more.
This enormous and dangerous impression created by a dead body is especially powerful on the minds of those who are in the same tent as the deceased. If life ends so completely, with such abrupt finality, it appears to lose its value.
<ZAP>
Very long posts are hard to moderate.
JosephParticipant1. Frum schooling is a must, not an option.
2. Larger housing is necessary when you have two parents and seven children versus a single parent, 2.1 children and a dog.
3. Cleveland and Detroit are not less expensive for kosher living with 7 tuitions.
Note: This comment of mine has nothing to do with the charges or underlying events.
JosephParticipantBTW, the Vaad statement was completely out of line. 1) Don’t make your educational courses on the backs of potentially innocents falsely accused; make your courses but don’t associate the announcement or timing with these charges. 2) Don’t incorrectly announce that Jews are permitted to accept or believe the judgements of the non-Torah court system that uses far lower thresholds of evidence than the Torah permits in accusations to be proven.
JosephParticipantLC: But in theory even in NY, under current law, the government can come swooping in demanding that certain subjects be taught. Even in private schools that take no government funding.
JosephParticipantviolation of ethics rules or workplace issues such as threats of violence, theft, etc. are easily fireable offenses since they are clearly wrongdoing.
OTOH, slacking off and barely doing adequate work, as long as you physically show up and leave on time, are far harder to prove and fire for than theft or violence. And as Avram in MD pointed out, it is difficult to fire a government employee, and as a result many managers are loath to undertake the documentation necessary to do so. (Especially if a hiring freeze may result in no replacement.)
JosephParticipantThe benefits each family received was several hundred dollars a month in food stamps, Medicaid coverage and some received a monthly rent stipend from Section 8. It wasn’t extremely huge amount of benefits. The media reports of each getting benefits totaling a couple hundred thousand dollars per family was cumulative over a six year period, ’09-’14.
The public reports do not indicate how much income each accused allegedly earned per year, except for one or two families out of the six charged. So I don’t see how anyone can say they weren’t truly needy trying to make ends meet, if you don’t know what they earned.
And that’s even before getting to the issue of the fact that there’s no right to believe the allegations they earned off the books money, despite that being alleged.
June 29, 2017 1:22 pm at 1:22 pm in reply to: How would you deal with Islamic terror if you were Trump (or May or Merkel)? #1307484JosephParticipantThose lot of smart highly paid anti-terror people clearly think your idea is bonkers, as they’ve not proposed anything of the sort.
JosephParticipantToday’s generation throws out good fixable stuff.
June 29, 2017 12:01 pm at 12:01 pm in reply to: How would you deal with Islamic terror if you were Trump (or May or Merkel)? #1307433JosephParticipantLike prove you’re a terrorist by conducting at least one mass causality event? Or prove you’ve done one in the past. And get your McMansion.
JosephParticipantMost US states and European states claim the right to set minimum educational requirements even for children attending private school with no state funding.
That, potentially, could include demanding toeiva be taught to little children as a normal lifestyle.
JosephParticipantZD, the government claims the right to dictate the educational curriculum and policy even for children who attended private yeshivos that take zero money from the government.
JosephParticipantHealth, where is the cost of living for a kosher yeshiva sending (for seven children) consumer less expensive than Lakewood?
June 29, 2017 10:51 am at 10:51 am in reply to: How would you deal with Islamic terror if you were Trump (or May or Merkel)? #1307233JosephParticipantDovid, everyone will become a terrorist if you did that. Or at least claim to be a terrorist.
JosephParticipantI think the problem is with the advent of air conditioning.
JosephParticipantQ:
How can I learn to concentrate when I’m learning Gemara? I find myself not remembering what I learn.A:
You can learn to concentrate by practice, and you practice as follows: When you learn something, have in mind that you have a responsibility to repeat it, to repeat it out loud when you finish that piece. If you’re just learning in order to get through the words, you’ll gallop right through, without any feeling of responsibility. That’s not going to work at all. But when you know that you have to say it over to yourself; as you’re learning, your mind is concentrating on, “What am I saying right now? What am I saying, because I’ll soon want to say it over to myself.”Whether it’s a piece of Gemara or a piece of Rashi or a Tosfos, while you’re learning it, think, “I’m soon going to repeat this to myself without looking in the Gemara, and in order to do that, I must understand what I’m saying.”
And this applies to women as well. When you’re learning a Mussar sefer, a hashkafa sefer or anything, don’t just say the words superficially. You have to make it part of yourself. You have to assimilate the Torah ideas into your mind. When you read words of Torah, don’t read it like you read the newspaper. Read it to know it.
So, always study with this idea in your mind, that you’re going to have to repeat it as soon as you finish. And then do it – repeat it out loud. What I’m telling you now is a segulah, a very important piece of advice. And it’s not patented; everybody can use it.
TAPE # 490JosephParticipantThey didn’t merely threaten to defund the Yeshiva. They threatened to close down any Yeshiva that doesn’t promote toeiva to 6 year olds through 12 year olds, as an equal and valid lifestyle (regardless of who funds the Yeshiva.)
JosephParticipantIām asking what your gems are.
Your garbage. š
JosephParticipantDoesn’t everyone have different tastes in music? Your garbage are my gems.
JosephParticipantWinnie, What Daas Yochid meant was:
<i>Winnie, although common practice is as you say — because yiras shomayim in our generation is lacking, but meikar hadin the owner is trusted (if he is a shomer Torah umitzvos).</i>
(I’m now repaying DY for being my Rashi by being meforesh his comment.)
JosephParticipantBoth sides agreed that this loss of hashgacha was not about money.
JosephParticipantI already called you my Rashi as of 4 weeks ago.
JosephParticipantYou’re saying Chazal are wrong?
JosephParticipantIs it fair to say that in many government jobs, once you’re past your probationary period, as long as you physically show up to sign in and sign out on time you can otherwise slack off on the job barely doing adequate work and have little worry about being fired?
JosephParticipantIsn’t the Halacha that you’re kona an item as soon as you pick it up, even before you pay for it?
JosephParticipantThe parish counts and records how much each Catholic put into the church collection basket every Sunday?
JosephParticipant@CTLAWYER Most Jews I know are in shul 7 days a week, not just on Shabbos. The ones who only comes to shul for holidays are folks who mostly handle money on Shabbos anyways.
JosephParticipantblubluh: “In Kiddushin 41b, the conduct of eating in public is likened to that of a dog.”
That would include eating in a restaurant with windows visible for the public in the street to see people eating inside. Let alone sitting outside the restaurant or outside the home for a barbeque. They all wouldn’t be exempt from Chazal’s comparison.
JosephParticipantQ-
Is it wrong to take one’s family on summer vacation?A-
It depends where and for what reason. If you’re taking them to a place like a frum bungalow colony where your older children will be able to learn all the time, the younger ones will be in a good environment and you’ll be able to be oisek in avodas Hashem – then why not? But if it’s just going away to stop learning – no, no.I want to tell you something. This whole business of vacations is not a Jewish business. In Europe the Yeshivas didn’t have any vacations in the summer time. They continued summer and winter exactly the same. And that’s how it should be. How can you take a vacation from shleimus, from perfection, from learning Torah? If the Yeshivas close down for the summer then all the Yeshiva men should make it their business to sit and learn all day long. Review. And review. Otherwise, whatever you learned you forget and the next time you look at the misechtah it’s like a new misechtah. It’s a pity. Spend the summer time learning and learning and learning. That’s our life – “Ki heim chayeinu.”
Of course you should always get fresh air. Even in the winter time. Every day you should take a walk – a brisk walk for a half hour or so. Always, always do what you can for your health. And I don’t say that you can’t go to the country. Go – but only if it’s going to help you in ruchniyis. If it’s only in gashmiyis but in ruchniyis there’s going to be a loss then it doesn’t pay to sacrifice so much.
Some people have achieved so much in the summer time – so much. They sit and they learn all the time. Schoolteachers have vacation all summer long – so they sit in the country for two months and learn. Ok. Why not? Nothing wrong with the country.
But otherwise our main criteria should always be – what’s the best for my neshama. And what’s the best for the neshama of my children.
TAPE E-237
JosephParticipantQ: Should I try to get a job that involves chesed, like a grocer or baker, someone who is involved in feeding the Jewish nation, rather than another job, where no chesed is involved?
A: You should get a job that pays the most money. That’s your job – to earn money. You’ll be doing the biggest chesed by bringing home a decent paycheck for your family.
Now, if you happen to be a baker or a grocer, it’s not a bad idea that when you hand the bread over to the customer, you should be thinking, × ××Ŗ× ××× ××× ×ש×Ø ×× ××¢××× ××”×× (Tehillim 136-25). Nothing wrong. Nothing wrong at all. You’re a ש×××, a messenger of Hashem, feeding His people. Nothing wrong with thinking that. On the contrary, why not utilize the opportunity? You can achieve greatness if you apply your mind and use your thoughts in the right way.
And so too, the mother who is serving food at the table, should think that she is × ××Ŗ× ××× ××× ×ש×Ø. She is doing it as a ש××× of ×ק××ש ××Ø×× ×××. If you think that way, it will transform your actions. You have to train yourself to transform the actions that you already are doing, by putting the right thoughts into them.
So make sure to get a job that pays the most money, and while you’re working in that place, use whatever opportunities you can find, to think about Hashem and to become great. You don’t have to be a baker or a butcher or a grocer to serve Hashem at work. The opportunities for greatness are endless at any job you have; only that it will take some effort on your part.
TAPE # 645
JosephParticipantlowerourtuition11210: “It might depend on if it is a child or adult that is eating in public.”
Are you implying that it’s okay for a child to do, since you’re asserting that it’s halachicly/legally acceptable, but that it’s not okay for an adult to do since it is unrefined behavior?
JosephParticipantHow do Catholic schools force parents of babies to pay money to the school?
JosephParticipantHow is government hiring conducted? Do government hiring managers tend to favor their own kind or friends or friends of friends? Or is government hiring strictly conducted based on merit?
JosephParticipantaishet, are whites fired much more often in government jobs?
June 27, 2017 1:59 am at 1:59 am in reply to: How do I know when my guilt is just yetzar hara? š³š #1304693JosephParticipantWhen one does something wrong it is correct and appropriate to feel guilty about it.
JosephParticipantDo Catholic schools allow the enrollment of very many children with non-paying parents or parents paying a very minimal tuition, as very many Yeshivos allow?
JosephParticipantI’m now told that “The Rebbe” refers to the Gerrer Rebbe, even among non-Gerrers.
June 26, 2017 11:02 pm at 11:02 pm in reply to: How do I know when my guilt is just yetzar hara? š³š #1304608JosephParticipantTo answer the OPs question, one must ask themselve — and honestly answer — whether you’re really guilty.
-
AuthorPosts