Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
JosephParticipant
I agree with RebYidd23 that you have the record for average per year. You beat popa_bar_abba, the previous record holder for that category.
But for all time topics started by one person, there’s someone whose count is measured in four digits.
JosephParticipantOrange juice.
JosephParticipantNo.
JosephParticipantMeno gets it, indeed.
JosephParticipantWhat is the oilem’s thoughts about those that marry someone davka who comes from a moneyed family (or is producing a good income herself) in order to enable himself to remain in learning much longer?
JosephParticipantUnlike employers, who set a salary without regard to family size (young single guys can be paid a fortune while married guys with many children can be paid a pittance), government entitlement benefits pay more benefits the larger the family size. Thus a larger family loses more when switching from government benefits to employment than a smaller family.
JosephParticipantDY: It’s more of an issue for families with many children, such as most of our communities and largely not so much in non-frum communities, since government social benefits are financially much more valuable to a larger family than to a smaller family.
So the head of household with many children who takes a not so high paying job loses much more social safety net benefits than a head of household with few (or no) children.
JosephParticipantDY’s point that if the RY suggests another Beis Medrash, indeed the question becomes why he so suggests that.
Some reasons we’ve heard so far are:
1. Desiring a closer kesher with the RY, and a smaller BM enables that.
2. Wanting to be closer to home. (Presumably this is more relevant to those outside the New York metropolitan area.)
3. Not being accepted to BMG.Some follow ups are:
1. What are the advantages of going to BMG, for the majority that chooses to do so, despite the apparent greater difficulty of establishing a kesher – compared to a smaller BM.
2. What reasons would BMG decline to accept a talmid.For the uninitiated, can someone describe the typical Yeshiva path for American bochorim starting immediately following their completing Mesivta, starting from first year Beis Medrash and going through marriage and Kollel?
JosephParticipantThose who used their PELL and TAP for a BTL, must realize it won’t be available for a future college.
JosephParticipantYes, that was the song I always heard as a child when the girls were jump roping in my neighborhood.
JosephParticipantsqueak accepted my offer to split the cookie with him taking black and I the white.
JosephParticipantYes, doable with father or other person as rebbi. But in real life it is exceedingly difficult to actually pull this off. And is rather rare.
JosephParticipant“J-J Cholov Yisroel…”
Is that still the official jump rope song for girls?
JosephParticipant9. 15%.
10. He never angers or raises his voice other than in defense against attacks on the Torah.
11. He slows down so that car can safely pass.
12. His mother insists on doing it, despite his offering to do it. He does it when she’s away.
13. Same as 12.
14. Applesauce.JosephParticipantWolf: Brian Marsden’s claim was widely reported at the time and citations to it can be easily found. Additionally, that wasn’t his only retraction. While it took him about two decades to retract his 2026 claim regarding Swift-Tuttle, in 1998 he made another similar claim that the he was forced to admit was wrong hours after he issued his attention-seeking press release.
July 9, 2017 8:00 pm at 8:00 pm in reply to: Yeshiva High School Graduates versus Public High School Graduates #1313598JosephParticipantI’ll venture that even if you took all Yeshivos and Beis Yaakovs in the 50 United States compared to all public schools in all 50 United States, the Yeshiva guys and Beis Yaakov girls will come out on top. Even if I’m off somewhat, I’m fairly certain the average public school pupil in the 50 United States is not far above the average Yeshiva and Beis Yaakov pupil in secular studies.
And all this is despite the fact, as mentioned, Yeshiva and Beis Yaakov students get far less hours studying secular studies than their public school counterparts. And have a far richer and longer school curriculum than public schools.
And, furthermore, as I’ve mentioned above, this comparison is not even taking into account the great and very valuable practical life values that Yeshiva and Beis Yaakov students gain through their long, detailed and in depth advanced studies they have as part of their daily curriculum in Bible, Hebrew, Talmud, Aramaic, Jewish history, commentaries and much more that isn’t considered in these secular comparisons but provide significant educational and life benefits to Yeshiva and Beis Yaakov students.
JosephParticipant“my very existence is the result of not following the mitzvos and that, because of this, I am a completely wicked person with no opportunity to actually go back and correct matters.”
You’re certainly no worse than a mamzer, who is not blamed for his status and is surely not considered a rasha. Indeed, he can be the biggest Talmid Chochom and receive the greatest reward in Olam Haboa.
“I highly doubt any astronomers made any such statements”
Brian Marsden at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics in 1973 made such statements.
“And, as it turns out, further observations since then have ruled out a collision.”
Ah, so Rav Miller was correct even by the scientists own later admissions.
JosephParticipantCG17, I take it you object to state laws enforcing prohibitions against pubic nudity that are based on religious morals.
JosephParticipantQ:
What is the problem with looking at the face of a wicked person? [ אסור לאדם להסתכל בצלם דמות אדם רשע – “It is forbidden for one to gaze at the face (image) of a wicked person” (Megillah 28a). ]A:
If you look at the face of a רשע, you become a רשע. And I’ll tell you why. We are influenced by people. And the face of רשע is a screen. It’s a projector. And his נשמה projects its image on that screen. So his רשעות is on his face.You might not recognize it, you might not see it, but the רשעות is on his face. And when you look at his face, it becomes stamped on your נשמה. What you see is stamped on your נשמה.
That’s very important. What you see will affect you. Don’t be מסתכל בפני רשע. Don’t look at the face of wicked people. And don’t look at people doing wrong things. As much as possible, avoid getting the stamp of wrong things on your נשמה.
And I want to tell you something else – another reason. Hashem doesn’t like the רשעים. A רשע is busy frustrating his own purpose in life and is busy ruining others as well. And Hashem is disgusted with that. Now, when someone feels disgust with somebody else, if you’re really disgusted by someone, then you don’t even want to look at that person. And Hashem doesn’t want to look at the רשעים. And if you walk in the ways of Hashem, you will also be disgusted by the רשע and his behavior. You don’t even want to see him. You don’t want to look at his face. And that’s why we don’t look at the face of a רשע. We are training ourselves to be disgusted with those who disgust Hashem.
TAPE # E-220
JosephParticipantIt harms the patient the same way it harms society. The patient can develop a resistance to antibiotics. (Which he might also spread to society.)
JosephParticipantmentsch1, I don’t understand how you can agree to harm your patients, just because they insist on being harmed, in order that you not lost business.
JosephParticipantMeno, what’s your expertise in this area?
July 8, 2017 10:29 pm at 10:29 pm in reply to: Another glorious nonsensical back and forth between Health and Ubiquitin #1313144JosephParticipant“Larges families mean more hospital stays for women and kids are always getting sick”
Federal and State laws prohibit charging higher insurance premiums for women, even though they have higher medical costs (i.e. childbirth, etc.)
OTOH, the law does allow charging higher auto insurance rates for men.
July 7, 2017 7:40 pm at 7:40 pm in reply to: Yeshiva High School Graduates versus Public High School Graduates #1313131JosephParticipantYour data is from an unrepresentative tiny subset. It’s category of yeshivos is very far from comprehensive.
JosephParticipantIf the cause is incorrect overuse, is there any reason to not place the fault on physicians who prescribe too much?
JosephParticipantIs the fault of bacteria mutating to resist antibiotics the result of physicians administering too much antibiotics to patients?
JosephParticipantWhat can be done to avoid bacteria mutating to resist antibiotics?
JosephParticipantWhy did the antibiotics cause it to mutate?
And how does the new mutation affect others who later develop the bacterial infection but hadn’t previously been treated with the antibiotics?
JosephParticipantTo query for an explanation of the point of your comment. (Which yet remains pending an answer.)
JosephParticipantYou’ve answered my rhetorical question with a rhetorical answer. Congratulations.
July 6, 2017 10:50 pm at 10:50 pm in reply to: Another glorious nonsensical back and forth between Health and Ubiquitin #1312760JosephParticipant“An ER will provide the minimum (i.e. cheapest) services to deal with urgent medical needs.”
An ER will provide non-major medical services as well. And most ERs in the US go beyond the minimum.
JosephParticipantIs discrimination always bad?
July 6, 2017 9:23 pm at 9:23 pm in reply to: Another glorious nonsensical back and forth between Health and Ubiquitin #1312743JosephParticipantUniversal healthcare and universal healthcare insurance are two different things. America already has, and has had for many many decades, universal healthcare. Any ER in the US will serve anyone regardless of ability to pay.
JosephParticipantNeed a list of questions for the girls
1. What’s her favorite perek in Tehilim?
2. How long does it take her to set the table?
3. Can she bake Challah well?
4. How long is her skirts?
5. Does she go to shul on Shabbos?JosephParticipant1. MyZmanim
2. Chatzos, Erev Shabbos
3. Sunday morning
4. Cying with tears rolling down her face every day while saying Tehilim in the living room
5. Rugelech
6. Taster’s Choice
7. No
8. N/AJosephParticipantThe guardsmen were shot at by a sniper, which triggered their response shots.
July 6, 2017 12:13 pm at 12:13 pm in reply to: Another glorious nonsensical back and forth between Health and Ubiquitin #1311928JosephParticipantUbiq: No, there is currently no universally guaranteed right for poor people to receive Section 8 housing. And even those poor lucky enough to be on Section 8/HUD, they don’t get their full rent paid even if they have zero income.
Good luck trying to get on Section 8 in NYC.
Ubiq: Do you support the absolute right and entitlement of every poor American to have their rent paid by the government?
Why aren’t those demanding universal healthcare also demanding universal rent subsidies?
July 6, 2017 11:40 am at 11:40 am in reply to: Yeshiva High School Graduates versus Public High School Graduates #1311913JosephParticipantEvery state and many cities each have their own DOE. You’ve vaguely referred to supposed data from NY and NJ without identifying which state, which city, which DOE, which yeshivos or which pubic schools. In short, your vagueness leads to nowhere.
Again:
Which state?
Which cities?
Which DOE?
Which yeshivos?
Which pubic schools?What’s the name of the DOE document in question? Where on the site is the data? And what’s “TFD”?
July 6, 2017 11:08 am at 11:08 am in reply to: Another glorious nonsensical back and forth between Health and Ubiquitin #1311846JosephParticipantUbiq: I support homeless shelters, at minimum. Do you support universally government guaranteed fully paid rent Section 8 vouchers to every family of parents and children who have no income?
July 6, 2017 11:08 am at 11:08 am in reply to: Another glorious nonsensical back and forth between Health and Ubiquitin #1311845JosephParticipantShouldn’t every unemployed family of parents with children be absolutely entitled to rental free Section 8 housing that covers their entire rent as long as they have no income?
It is at least as vital as having universal healthcare (and by that I mean more than the right to go to any ER in the US for treatment, which anyone can already do for the last 40+ years.)
July 6, 2017 11:06 am at 11:06 am in reply to: Discouraging Making Aliyah: Satmar Rebbe in France #1311843JosephParticipantJews in the State of Israel face a greater terror threat than the Jews in France. Furthermore, it has been proven from past experience of many Jews moving to Israel that the government works overtime — unfortunately successfully in the past — to shmadb them against the Torah or otherwise turn frum Jews into chilonim through pubic schooling, etcetera. Hence the rabbonim shlita (including Rav Dovid Feinstein shlita and others), led by the Satmar Rebbe, are working to avoid such a catastrophe by encouraging French Jewry to build up their Torah community in France.
July 6, 2017 1:45 am at 1:45 am in reply to: Discouraging Making Aliyah: Satmar Rebbe in France #1311643JosephParticipantThere are Satmar rabbonim in Eretz Yisroel. But the Rebbe is in America.
Regarding France, to the best of my knowledge there aren’t even any Satmar Chasidim living in France. Though the Rebbes are involved in holy work for Klal Yisroel around the world, including for non-Chasidim. Satmar is renown for their chesed that they do for every Jew.
JosephParticipantAll rioters/protesters were given a legally upheld order to disperse that they refused to obey. As such by illegally remaining in the company of the violent rioters throwing gas canisters and rocks at the police, firemen and guardsmen, even if they weren’t throwing these objects at law enforcement officers their illegal presence with those violent student goons placed themselves at their own peril and they bare responsibility for the subsequent results that occurred to them when the guardsmen rightfully opened fire after a sniper starting shooting the guardsmen.
July 5, 2017 10:54 pm at 10:54 pm in reply to: Another glorious nonsensical back and forth between Health and Ubiquitin #1311573JosephParticipant“A hospital emergency room is not always enough.”
A homeless shelter is not always enough. For example a married couple with five children can’t be dumped in a homeless shelter with dozens of derelicts. They need privacy as a married couple and for their family of five children.
Are you opposed to a government guarantee of universal family housing for all, whether or not they can afford paying a penny they will be placed in private family housing with heating, hot water, electric, ac, gas, etc., with the government picking up the tab for every American who can’t afford it?
July 5, 2017 9:27 pm at 9:27 pm in reply to: Requesting information about frumteens and R’ Yaakov Shapiro (hear me out mods!) #1311547JosephParticipantI didn’t explain it to him, I explained it to you. He didn’t explain his views at all, other than to self-describe to the category of Chareidi. But even that category, as much as he may self-identify to it, doesn’t imo correctly fit the multitude of views he’s expressed in writings. Indeed, a number of years ago Rabbi Sherer publicly criticized him from the podium of the Agudah Convention for his criticisms of Chareidi life. That wouldn’t happen if it were only an isolated, rather than continuous, criticism of Chareidim.
JosephParticipantThe Constitution doesn’t provide the right for Kent students to riot. There is no constitutional right to throwing beer bottles at police cars and breaking downtown storefronts, breaking into a bank, lighting a bonfire on the street, burning the campus ROTC building, throwing rocks at firemen and police extinguishing the fire, refusing legal (upheld) orders to disperse and instead throwing rocks and gas canisters at the National Guard, and with it all leading up to a sniper firing a gun on the guardsmen leading them to fear for their lives and rightfully return fire on the rioters.
July 5, 2017 8:48 pm at 8:48 pm in reply to: Another glorious nonsensical back and forth between Health and Ubiquitin #1311522JosephParticipantA homeless shelter isn’t decent housing. The government should be universally providing decent family apartments so that poor or unemployed parents can live together as a family even if they cannot afford to pay a penny in rent.
Would “universal healthcare” being that anyone can always go to any hospital emergency room to get treated satisfy supporters of universal healthcare? If not, homeless shelters shouldn’t satisfy them either for universal housing.
July 5, 2017 7:36 pm at 7:36 pm in reply to: Requesting information about frumteens and R’ Yaakov Shapiro (hear me out mods!) #1311491JosephParticipantRabbi Adlerstein’s original multi-page Jewish Action article on frumteens is available online as a PDF. It is clearly effusive in lavishing high praise on both the frumteens site and the work and success of the rabbi behind the site in helping Jewish teenagers, via the site, in remaining frum.
Sure Rabbi Adlerstein mentions in the article that many readers of the OU magazine will greatly disagree with the sites strong position against Zionism and its criticism of Modern Orthodoxy. And after the article was published RYA felt the strong heat from the farbrente Zionist clientele of the OU magazine’s subscribers in letters to the editor that were openly bitter that RYA dared to lavish such high praise upon RYS, despite his highly admirable and undisputed success in saving Jewish lives — as documented in detail in the Jewish Action article — since RYS was outspoken in his writings against Zionism and MO leaders. And for this clientele, Zionism was the greatest form of their religion. Speaking against Zionism was heresy to them and wiped out even saving lives.
With the intensity of that heat RYA indeed wrote a letter in a following issue apologizing for not further making clear he certainly doesn’t agree with RYS’s positions on Zionism and Modem Orthodoxy and their leaders. But even then he still acknowledged the article itself was entirely accurate in describing the many young Jewish lives saved by RYS through frumteens.
Whether RYA describes himself as Chareidi, MO or anything else, even a cursory reading of his many writings in cross currents and elsewhere makes abundantly clear that his underlying hashkafas, and not just his endearment to Zionism but his overall views and take on religious events, is far closer to Modern Orthodoxy than to Chareidi. His site partner Rabbi Yaakov Menken is a bit more to RYA’s right and RYM could be better described (in his worldviews) as Chareidi-light.
July 5, 2017 7:03 pm at 7:03 pm in reply to: Yeshiva High School Graduates versus Public High School Graduates #1311493JosephParticipantWho are the “represented yeshivos” and who are the public schools? And which DOE? And what was the data collected from and based on?
July 5, 2017 5:17 pm at 5:17 pm in reply to: Requesting information about frumteens and R’ Yaakov Shapiro (hear me out mods!) #1311300JosephParticipantBashing the State in front of non-Jews is a Mitzvah in order to educate the non-Jewish world that the State does *not* represent Judaism or the Jewish world, as the State and Prime Minister often falsely claim to represent on the world stage.
By educating the world that the State’s position is a false narrative, we can hope to mitigate the negative reaction of the world when the State of Israel does harmful and reprehensible things, from the world blaming Israel’s badness on Jews in general, since the State of Israel falsely claims to represent world Jewry.
But all of that is aside from your demonstrably false claim that the Rov is affiliated with NK. He is not and never was.
-
AuthorPosts