Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
yid.periodMember
Mod 80,
actually I’m pretty sure you didn’t get me this time. Exactly, a cross, if originally designed by a Jew, would not be inherently goyish. Now that is represents avodah zara, and has no other connotations, it is incontrovertibly goyish.
yid.periodMemberAs far as I understand though, we can only establish something as “not goyish” as opposed to “Jewish”. True, being made by a Jew does not make something inherently “Jewish”, but it does remove it from –Necessarily– being goyish.
Like I was saying to pacman, there isn’t anything making jeans “goyish” any more than commonly accepted articles of clothing such as wigs, certain tops, and as others pointed out borsalinos, the suit, and ties. etc.
yid.periodMemberMod 80,
as you said, “clothes you feel chashuv in” — that is a personal feeling. Many would argue that a yamalka is designed to distinguish frum Jews (and tzitzet if you wear them out), and that sets the standard.
yid.periodMemberMod 80
you can’t compare the two. a cross is a clear, indisputable symbol of avodah zara. Jeans were originally created for functional purposes, and in modern times, can sometimes be designed to be pritzusdik and untznius.
Wigs can be used/designed for pritzus too.
Someone else already mentioned women’s tops that are made tznius by adding shells or whatever. Long jean skirts that themselves were not intended for pritzus should be less controversial.
Pacman
Levi Strauss invented jeans as a direct result of his being non-observant? It came about as a product of secular ideals? No. Why are they goyish? Like someone else pointed out, what many consider frum garb these days was designed by goyim and were adapted from secular culture.
The burden of proof certainly lies on those who declare denim untznius.
yid.periodMemberpacman
they arent arguing in favor of jeans “because” a jew invented them, mikehall was debunking the people who are claiming they are bad because they are goyish.
yid.periodMemberJust to put this all in perspective, nobody would want to date someone who wears tanktops in public, for example. This isn’t quite that extreme, but it isn’t a sufficient resolution for me to just ask her to stop… it reflects on who she is, now, hashkafically. And this is a close friend who I can’t give a superficial answer to, and who wouldn’t accept a superficial answer for her relative. And whatever I say will be reported to said relative. And I would feel bad just going on the date to keep everybody happy and give it a try… I’m wasting everybody’s time and I probably wouldn’t enjoy myself at all because I already have all these notions.
yid.periodMemberpacman
I’m offering my business acumen free of charge! automation and specialization… gotta keep innovating to stay competitive these days!
yid.periodMemberI think you shouldn’t be so hard on yourself because “you aren’t living up to your name.” First of all, nobody is Chayav in all 613 mitzvot. Secondly, everyone is chayav in all of the mitzvot that are relevant to them, equally. So you’re name doesn’t make you anymore responsible than anybody else (take that as a good or bad thing). With that said, nobody is perfect. Most people are far from it. The only thing you can ask from yourself is to keep trying your hardest, always. Goals are supposed to increase your inspiration and devotion, not depress you into giving up. You’ll get where you’re supposed to be, just keep trying.
This applies to adorable’s thread before also I guess.
Sorry if that was a lot of stream of consciousness; I hope it helps.
yid.periodMembermewho
I’m trying to work on my passive aggressiveness…
yid.periodMemberMod 80,
we can never know how successful another’s marriage is
yid.periodMemberThanks all for your responses… we’ll see what happens
yid.periodMemberPacman
And who picked a wife for Yakov avinu? Moshe Rabeinu? I can go on and on…
yid.periodMemberadorable- because I’ll be asked for details… it won’t just stop there
I can only try- I’m worried that since it isn’t an issue about a chumra or being machmir, I feel disrespectful bringing it up as a chisaron… its the equivalent of the girl not covering her collar bone, not just that she doesn’t hold Rabbeinu Tam zmanim. Also I’ve never rejected somebody before so I’m worried about the person’s feelings. She’ll push for a reason from the shadchan too…
yid.periodMemberSorry, maybe I didn’t emphasize that a vague one-liner won’t do it because I’ll be asked to explain…
popa showing off them skillzzz
yid.periodMembermod 80
but those are both big “maybes” that cannot be undoubtedly observed ever… so most posters (and I think rightfully so) consider it irrelevant. The only real advantage of marrying somebody with yichus would be getting special treatment from all the people who consider yichus to be important.
yid.periodMembermy Rebbe in Israel always used to say “If you can’t explain it, it means you don’t fully understand it”
yid.periodMemberI think I’ll be extra careful and let my parents know the day before I go out on a date… but mostly so they don’t call and get worried when I don’t answer.
yid.periodMemberthe therapy comes from the belief/philosophy that when the body is in harmony with itself ie aligned, the body’s problems will go away.
The “pushing really hard” is the Dr. aligning your bones. I go whenever I feel the need. Personally, I love the feeling afterwards. Some people don’t like the process though; they find it unpleasant.
But the first time I went, after he cracked my neck I felt a huge pressure released that I had stopped noticing was even there because I had gotten so used to it.
yid.periodMemberperson3
There is no such thing as two people who are the same… Therefore, I would make a decision based on the facts about THE PERSON… I would have no hava amina to even ask about yichus or care to listen if it was being related.
Sorry I know it’s not the answer you’re looking for.
(btw, you could give the same dilemma about any trivial quality; doesn’t mean it’s worth anything)
yid.periodMembercooking abilities. Good food keeps kids otd (ON the derech).
yid.periodMemberoohh that would be interesting
yid.periodMemberoh well
yid.periodMembernfgo3
but those nonkosher versions are a fraction of the price (i got your back adorable)
And the second part isn’t necessarily true either, one can be healthy and big, or skinny and a walking time bomb.
broad generalizations make ignorant people sound stupid.
yid.periodMemberuh oh pacman that doesn’t sound so “yeshiva-world” like….
yid.periodMemberapy,
so what? Just because of those rare situations society at large should compromise tznius? (if one wanted to entertain the possibility that makeup is not–I’m not saying it isn’t)
yid.periodMemberdisseminating truth, insight and correct spelling in your neighborhood.
yid.periodMembercshapiro
football player to you is a girl with a brooklyn bump to me.
If by yichus you mean the chashivus of her parents’ bank account, then I think it’s very important.
yid.periodMemberLike I said, could be. Thanks for correcting me.
yid.periodMemberPoint taken on the capitalization of Torah; I apologize to anybody who took offense.
Apparently the R’ Akiva thing isn’t so clear though…
“We also know that Rabbi Akiva was either himself a convert or a child of converts:
We can hardly appoint Rabbi Akiva because perhaps Rabban Gamaliel will bring a curse on him because he has no ancestral merit. (Brachot 27b. See comments of Rav Nissim Gaon.)”- from Aish.com (mod 80 you can edit out this link but this is just for you if you’re interested: http://www.aish.com/tp/i/moha/48939037.html )
But fair enough, I am not sure… I said I didn’t remember how the story went…
yid.periodMemberPacman
And what was dovid hamelech’s yichus? born out of incest (moav and lot) and deception (tamar and yehuda)…
Avraham Avinu? (idol merchant father)
There was a good ruse I heard once (maybe someone can quote it) where a Rabbi asked a group of girls “Who would you rather marry?
1) A guy who is estranged from his siblings and obsessed with his good looks
2) A convert who doesn’t know a word of torah”
… There are two others
(btw, 1 is yosef, 2 is R’ akiva)
disclaimer- not saying marry a bad person, just saying yichus doesn’t matter
yid.periodMemberI’m sorry but this is a silly question
yid.periodMemberBefore I left Yeshiva in Israel one piece of insight that I was told really stuck with me. If I was not prepared to leave, Hashem would not let me. That does not mean that I cannot fail, but it means I have the tools to rise above.
If Hashem put you to the test of the internet etc, even if you failed, know you possess the wherewithal to succeed and fulfill your tafkid. Everything in goes in cycles, you had a rough patch, now take the experience, grow from it, feel a renewed sense of conviction not to fail and to savor the glimpses of purity you feel from your yiddishkeit and IYH youll be a better, stronger yid for it.
yid.periodMemberI’m also pretty confused, but I’d really like to understand because this is an important topic.
yid.periodMembermoishe dovid- start a new thread, interesting question. just be prepared for the wrath involved when questioning people’s established habits.
yid.periodMemberapy… reread your post… I think you meant to say something different. If not, I’m not sure what you’re saying, please rephrase.
yid.periodMemberapy,
I’m all for intelligent discussion, but many of the responses have been “It just is and who are you to question me!?”
I believe everyone agrees with the premise concerning tznius, that it is an attitude/spirit of the law as well as covering the knees and elbows…
With all of that said, it seems, at least to me, there is some explanation required. More than just “Women need to feel beautiful”… Halacha sometimes goes against our human urges
yid.periodMemberas soon as every girl here who wears makeup will avoid the uncomfortable confrontation of whether or not it’s actually halachikally permissible.
yid.periodMemberbooya! well said pac-man
yid.periodMemberdepends how high the mechizta is
yid.periodMemberJust for the record, as the OP, I wasn’t attacking women for wearing makeup, and I certainly don’t advocate burkhas (SHREK). I’m actually quite “lefty” (at least relative to most other posters here).
I was asking an innocent question regarding a societal phenomenon I had difficulty justifying, so I opened up a thread for other people’s input. I certainly didn’t mean to offend anybody and I apologize if to anybody who took it that way.
But seriously, I was just trying to include all the females in the picture and get their take on things. (hehe)
May 15, 2011 5:12 am at 5:12 am in reply to: Maccabeats hit "Candlelight" wasnt original music. Isnt it illegal? #766630yid.periodMemberThey gave credit where it was due on the youtube video’s description. Also, you can just change one note in a song and it’s considered a different song now.
yid.periodMembergood shabbos to all. speak to you soon
yid.periodMemberanon1mous
of course, in an ideal society men would not look at women. But lo nitnu hatorah limalachim. The world in its current state is not the ideal.
but there is another issue here, specifically addressing the women, regardless of any men around. One must still be tnius in the privacy of their own home. If “not being provocative” is an attitude, regardless of anything that may result ie men looking, whether men are looking or not is irrelevant.
manohman
the question is where “the feelings of the woman” are coming from and whether they are justification, in terms of halacha.
dy
clever haha. It’s interesting to see people’s opinions on the contrasting issues. Pacman is consistently for side of modesty when in doubt… I want the kindelach in here (teenage girl demographic) to see what they think
yid.periodMemberapushutayid
i don’t think presentable is as subjective a term as you are making it out to be. Presentable is not the same as attractive.
The fact is some people are more attractive than others… it’s just how Hashem made us.
anon1mous
doesn’t matter if someone’s wife is the prettiest woman in town, everything gets boring after long enough, and the new is exciting. Also, you are assuming just because someone puts on makeup they look equally attractive to everyone else. Having everyone dress up isn’t going to solve anybody’s problems.
yid.periodMembermanohman
As mod 80 said, nobody said women should be unattractive, only minimize the amount of attention they are drawing.
I’m just curious why you take it so for granted that wearing makeup is “part of being a woman, and feeling like a woman” ? This is in my opinion a societal phenomenon, not an instinctive one. It’s therefore important to evaluate how it manifests itself in the frum community.
Brushing one’s hair is making someone look presentable, which we all agree is expected of a yid… It does not draw or not draw any more attention IMHO.
I know if i said this is probably a self esteem issue that makes makeup such a necessity for women (and therefore should be avoided by young insecure girls) I’d be reprimanded by the women… so I won’t.
yid.periodMemberMod 80
I accepted your correction to my op; I didn’t write it clearly enough.
yid.periodMemberThanks Mod 80,
You remind me of a partial answer to my own question; in Taanis it discusses how a na’ara in aveilus R”L may be able to wash with cold water and wear her makeup.
Unclear how society worked back then though in terms of making shidduchim etc.
But the Mechaber discusses how grave it is for man to smell a woman’s perfume… so I just wonder if the gemara means that she should be presentable, not necessarily actively enhancing her appearance.
May 13, 2011 4:28 pm at 4:28 pm in reply to: Firestorm After �Der Zeitung� Deletes Hillary Clinton from Iconic Photo #1052775yid.periodMemberhealth
I’m not sure what your point is. When I’m wrong I’m wrong. When they’re wrong, they should, and did, own up to parts of it. I was addressing the rest of it, the parts that, some people here are still defending.
yid.periodMemberI heard knitting therapy is all the rage these days..
yid.periodMemberanyone ever been to meron for lag ba’ omer?
-
AuthorPosts