yehoshuaahron

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Hungarian Yidden #1739112
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    My 2nd great-grandparents name were R. Nathan Hershkowitz & Miriam Hoffman. He was born on May 10, 1884 In Sighetu Marmației, Maramureș, Austria-Hungary. All I know about him is he had smicha.
    What are the chances he was a Satmar Chossid? Where most yidden there Chassidim? He left Hungary to NY in 1910. Always wondered… my grandparents weren’t frum already.

    in reply to: Is Yiddish Holy? #1736413
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    The Lubavitcher Rebbe said that although Yiddish originally was spoken to refrain from speaking Lashon Kodesh, since it was used for Torah study and mitzvah observance for over a thousand years it gave it a measure of sanctity beyond other non-Hebrew languages,9 similar to the holiness conferred to a physical object used for a mitzvah.10

    9. This is similar to what we find in the Talmud as well as in halachah, that certain languages such as Aramaic and ancient Greek have a certain level of holiness above the average language. See Jerusalem Talmud, Megillah 1:9, and Babylonian Talmud, Megillah 8b.

    10. Additionally, by using the language of Yiddish for Torah and spiritual purposes, the rabbis were able to spiritually elevate the language. See Likkutei Sichot, vol. 21, p. 448; Sefer ha-Sichot 5748, vol. 2, Vayeishev, sec. 5.

    in reply to: Is Harry Potter kosher #1732956
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    Ok firstly I can’t argue with the internet replies… Your right.
    It’byt it’s still different though, by having filtered internet although you do have access to news and some goyish influence, that’s still different than buying, bringing, and putting that in my shelf. My kids would understand that I have a computer for the purpose of business, otzar hachochna, communication, etc. But I’m mode anyway. I should have a white* list internet filter not just the regular.
    Worth to mention the Rebbe said having a TV is like bringing the galach himself through the door… Kal vachomer internet… But I don’t know what he would say about filters… probably white list… Matan Torah is coming up, I should think about this one…
    “קבלת התורה בשמחה ובפנימיות” to all. (Nusach of the Frierdiker Rebbe’s)

    in reply to: Is Harry Potter kosher #1732631
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    To me these posts are unbelievable, I never knew the strong contrast of Chassidim and non Chassidim (no offense, but misoch Ahavas Yisroel whoever has such a mentality will never really* taste the sweetness of pure kedusha), I’m a Lubavitcher chossid and anyone in my community even the more modern ones (who might not hold all chasidishe standards at the moment) would agree that’s pass nisht for a Yiddishe home. First it’s bittul Torah, bechukoseyem lo seleichu! How much goyishkeit subconscious influence! I would be embarrassed to have such a book in my house! I’m an open minded person, but my Rebbe, Menachem Mendel Schneerson Z”L taught me Yiddiskeit and chinuch for our children must be 110% pure! Chinuch al taharas a kodesh, The RRebbe was even against having pictures and toys of non kosher animals at home, said chinuch starts in the womb literally.

    in reply to: When did Chabad become a Kiruv oriented Chassidus? #1729929
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    The term “kiruv” is antithetical to everything that Chabad and the Rebbe stand for.

    Take the case of the rabbi who wrote to the Rebbe boasting that he was involved in outreach. He used the Hebrew term kiruv rechokim. The poor rabbi must have really regretted that letter. The Rebbe wrote back indignantly:

    You call them “distant”?! What gives you the right to say that you are close and they are far? You must approach each one of them as though you are the King’s servant sent with a message to His most precious child!

    Others who spoke with the Rebbe on the subject have similarly groped and fallen. One Chabad supporter told the Rebbe about a Shabbaton he had sponsored for over forty couples who “had no Jewish background.”

    “No what?” the Rebbe responded, as though in shock.

    “No Jewish background,” was the hesitant response.

    “Tell them that they have a background! Their background is that they are children of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob!” the Rebbe replied.

    in reply to: When did Chabad become a Kiruv oriented Chassidus? #1729928
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    The first one to send “shluchim” for kiruv purposes was the previous Rebbe, meaning Rabbi Yosef Yitzchok Schneerson (the Rebbe’s father in law). Here is some info I found about this in Wikipedia:
    “During the last decade of Rabbi Schneersohn’s life, from 1940 to 1950, he settled in the Crown Heights section of Brooklyn in New York City. Rabbi Schneersohn was already physically weak and ill from his suffering at the hands of the Communists and the Nazis, but he had a strong vision of rebuilding Orthodox Judaism in America, and he wanted his movement to spearhead it. In order to do so, he went on a building campaign to establish religious Jewish day schools and yeshivas for boys and girls, women and men. He established printing houses for the voluminous writings and publications of his movement, and started the process of spreading Jewish observance to the Jewish masses worldwide.

    He began to teach publicly, and many came to seek out his teachings. He began gathering and sending out a small number of his newly trained rabbis to other cities – a trend later emulated and amplified by his son-in-law and successor, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson.”

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1709667
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    It’s very bothersome how some people here are saying such words against The Rebbe Zt’l. if anyone would bother learning any of these Sichos instead of just quoting it upside-down then there would be no debate. Rav Solovechik had great Kavod for the Rebbe till gimmel Tammuz and learned the first Sichos and mamor of The Rebbe when he took on the Nesius where the Rebbe Zt’l says explicitly The Fridiker Rebbe will take us out of galus (after his histalkus) and speaks of the Zohar quoted about Atzmus. Tell where exactly to find this 1979 “Atzmus Sicha” to check what it actually says please. In general every Jew has a חלק אלקה. As far as I know all the Rebbe said about an Admur is that since such a person’s neshama is b’giluy as it is ” above” therefore “Man PNEI Adon Havaye da Rashbi” but in truth the same could be said of every single Jew as the Rebbe said various times.

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1709649
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    For whoever List of last names descendants of Dovid Hamelech:
    (Some last names there are descendants because a
    a person with that last is a descendant of one of the
    main families who are part of the list), for example the Altschulers descend from Chajes/Chayut. That’s for
    whoever It was that didn’t understand what the point
    of the hebrew Wikipedia article on The Rebbe’s yichus was.
    Lubavitcher Rebbe – Shalom Shachna Altschuler – Chayut –
    Dovid Hamelech. Anyone with knowledge of genealogy knows
    the Chayut family are eineklach of Dovid Hamelech,
    thats why I didn’t bother to explain it there.

    Abarbanel*
    Adler
    Alter/Rotenberg
    (Ger Chassidim)
    Altshuler
    Ashkenazi
    Auerbach
    Averels/Everels
    Babad/Heschel*
    Bach
    (descendants of Sirkes)
    Bachrach
    Beharier
    Berdugo
    Berlin/Berliner
    Bernstein
    Biederman
    Birnbaum
    Breslav Chassidim, Nakhman
    Burstein
    Caro/Karo
    Charif
    Charlap*
    Chayes/Chayut
    Cohen (various families)
    Dayan*
    Don Yechia/Ibn Yechia*
    Edels
    Ehrenreich
    Ehrlich
    Eichenstein
    (Zditchov Chassidim)
    Elfandari
    Enzel
    Epstein*
    Falman
    Fishel
    Freidensohn
    Frenkel/Frankel*
    Frenkel-Teomim*
    Friedland
    Friedman (Rizhin, Sadagora etc. Chassidim)
    Fuchs
    Ginzburg/Gunzburg
    Glickman
    Goldman
    Gombiner
    Gordon
    Halberstam(ZanzChassidim)
    Yisroel Karduner Halpern
    Meshulam Shraga Feivish Halpern
    Yehuda Leibish Halpern
    Heilprin/Halperin*
    Heller*
    Helman
    Hertzkes
    Heschel/Babad*
    Hillel and the Nesi’im*
    Horowitz/Hurwitz
    (various Chassidim)*
    Ish-Zvi
    Isserles/Isserlin*
    Itinga/Ettinger/Ittingen
    Jaffe/Yoffe* / **
    Kalb
    Kalmankes
    Kalonymus*
    Karo/Caro*
    Katz (Maharal of Prague)
    * / **
    Katzenellenbogen*
    Klauber
    Klausner*
    Klingberg
    Landau
    Lau
    Levinsohn
    Lichtenstadt
    Lichtenstein
    Lifshutz/Lipshitz
    Loeb*
    Loewenstam
    Lowe*
    Lubarsky
    Lukashevesky (Lux)
    Lurie/Luria*
    Maharal of Prague * / **
    Malavski
    Margolioth
    Margulies/Margolis
    /Margaliot*
    Meisels*
    Mintzberg
    Mirels
    Mirkes
    Morgenstern
    (Kotzk Chassidim)
    Moskowitz
    Yisroel Dov Odesser
    Oknovski
    Openheim
    Paprosh
    Parnas
    Pereles

    in reply to: Chabad? Most non religious Jews are not halachikly Jewish. #1701447
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    “As as I understand it , if someone comes to Chabad and is a zera yisroel, they urge them to convert (Plenty of poskim like Rav Ovadiah Yosef hold this position)”
    The Rebbe’s policy bus Chabad don’t do Giurim. If someone wants to convert there are plenty of batei dinim they are refered to if persistent. In Chabad we don’t urge someone with a Jewish father to convert unless he decides to. Also, no Goyim come to Chabad House’s, unless it’s a specific case like a Jewish woman marries to a goy who will only come with her kids if the goy husband comes along. I’m surprised no one realizes that the Rebbe started the “mi hi Yehudi” campaign. In Chabad we are very careful in regards to Yichus, win regards to putting on Tefillin in the street the person is asked if his mother is Jewish. By the time someone comes to a Chabad house the Shliach will find out if there are any doubts on his Yichus by the first meeting. A giur is only encouraged if the person is a Baal Yeshiva already and there is a sefek in his Yichus. Kiddushin is an entirely different story, need kesubos, check kvarim, or giur lechumra.

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1700616
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    דוד אלטשולר – ויקיפדיה

    “סיבת כנוי המשפחה הזאת אלטשולר, והיא כי כולם היו גאוני וחסידי דור דור, ומקום מולדתם היה בפורטוגאל; ואחרי אשר גלו משם בעת הגירוש, נשאו עימם אבנים מבתי כנסיות שבה, לקיים “כי רצו עבדיך את אבניה”. וכאשר באו לפראג וקבעו משכנם בה … בנו להם בית כנסת, ושמו בעצמם לתוך הבנין [את] האבנים אשר הביאו איתם. ויען היו האבנים מבתי כנסיות ישנים, לכן נקראו אלטשולר [אלט – ישן, שול – בית כנסת]; ומשם נפצו על פני הארץ.”

    הכוונה, ככל הנראה, לבית הכנסת “אלטנוי שול” הידוע שבפראג[3].

    משפחתו של ר’ דוד הייתה מיוחסת למשפחת חיות – הוא היה נכדו של ר’ מנחם מאניש חיות, רבה של ווילנא, שהיה בנו של ר’ יצחק חיות הראשון, מחבר ספר “אפי רברבי” (“פני יצחק”) ורבן של לבוב (למברג), קראקא ופראג; גם סבו של ר’ יצחק, ר’ פתחיה חיות, היה אב”ד פראג. עוד התייחסה המשפחה לרבי יוסף כ”ץ רבה של קראקא (ה’רע”א, 1510 – ה’שנ”א, 1591), מחבר ספר “שארית יוסף”; לרבי יחיאל מיכל מנמירוב, רב בנמירוב ומחבר הספר ההלכתי שברי לוחות, אשר נרצח בגזירות ת”ח ות”ט (1648); ולבעל הש”ך (ה’שפ”ב, 1622 – ה’תכ”ג, 1663). המקור הקדום של המשפחה הוא בפרובאנס שבצרפת.

    אביו של ר’ דוד, ר’ אריה ליב אלטשולר בנו של ר’ פתחיה מפראג, היה מחשובי העיר יאברוב, וככל הנראה היה אחיו של ר’ יחיאל מיכל אלטשולר, בעל ספר “משנת לחם”. גם ר’ דוד שימש בתפקיד נכבד ביאברוב, וכבר בשנת תפ”ו (כשהוא פחות מבן ארבעים) הוא נזכר כדיין או רב בעיר. נראה שלאחר מכן המשיך במסורת המשפחתית וכיהן גם כרבה של פראג.

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1700572
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    רבי שלום שכנא (אבי אדמו”ר הצמח צדק) היה מגזע של המצודת דוד, שהיה צאצא של דוד המלך, בן אחר בן.

    המקור לכך הוא הרב ישעיה הורוויץ (בן הרב אשר יחזקאל, בן הרב ישעיה שנשא לאשה את בת אחותו של אדמו”ר הצ”צ, בספרו ‘עדן ציון’ עמ’ קסא.): “שמעתי מא”א זלה”ה, אשר זקנינו [אבי אביו של הצ”צ] ה”ר נח, היה שם כינוי משפחתו אלטשולער כי היה מגזע הרה”ג ר’ יחיאל הלל בן הרב ר’ דוד אלטשולער מק”ק יאברוב אשר אסף פירושי אביו על נ”ך והוסיף עליהם מחכמתו והיו לאחדים בידו בשם מצודת ציון ומצודת דוד”. עכ”ל.
    “פירושו “מגזע:
    שהוא היה בן דודו של המצודת דוד או בדומה, וזהו כוונתו “שהיה מגזע בעל המצודת דוד”. ולפי זה נמצא שהוא גם כן היה בן אחר בן לדוד המלך, כמו המצודת דוד.

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1700509
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    The Rebbe is ben achar ben from Dovid Hamelech through Shalom Shachna Altschuler (Tzemach Tzedek’s father) , an ainekel of the Metztudas Dovid (Dovid Altschuler), who in turn is ben achar ben from Dovid Hamelech.

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1700497
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    That’s exactly the problem, how you misconstrue everything, you know he didn’t mean Hashem is person. No one in Chabad believe I any sort of kfirah nor say anything that sounds like kfirah, if you lechatchila have a bias irrational hate against Chabad or any group, you’ll find a way to twist everything.

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1697173
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    Anyusernameopen?:
    By the way, in reality the Rebbe himself from the beginning in fact the first day (1951 in Basi leGani) and throughout his whole nessius spoke of Moshiach min Hameisim when saying Vehu Yigalenu in reference to the Frierdiker Rebbe. It wasn’t until gimmel Tammuz that Moshiach min Hameisim was spoken about in Lubavitch.

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1697094
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    Daasyochid:
    Instead of just telling me to hold Rambam straight, why don’t you define for us what is Chezkas Moshiach if you actually have a argument. And for what you said about Moshiach min Hameisim, Yidden have always believed in that possiblity and no one had to “look up” mekoros lol, you call learning Gemara (Sanhedrin 98b) and Zohar looking up mekoros!? The only reason I can think of that you should be uncomfortable with Moshiach min Hamesim is that Christians believe in it too. So, why don’t you stop believing in Moshiach altogether if Christians believe in it lol. If Goyim start putting on Tefillin you’ll stop too!?
    And for you’re last comment. The Rebbe never said he is Moshiach. Period.

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1697074
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    Joseph: 2 answers:
    1. A Talmid should believe his Rebbe is Moshiach. (Sanhedrin 98b) where the Gemara relates the opinions of four schools, each of whose Talmidim thought that their Rebbe is Moshiach.
    2. On Sanhedrin 98b, the MaHaRSha, comments that Rebi and Daniel are specifically mentioned as examples as candidates for Moshiach because they had already been leaders of the Jews of their generation during the period of exile, (Bereishis 49:10): “The scepter [of rulership] shall not depart from [the tribe of] Yehuda.” The, Be’er Sheva, gives the same reason for Rav Nachman (Amorah) saying, in the above Talmudic passage, quoting a Scriptural verse (Jeremiah 30:21) to prove that if Moshiach is one of those living in his time, it would be he.
    In other words, besides the conditions specified by RaShI, MaHaRShA and Be’er Sheva emphasize that Moshiach will be one who has been a leader of the Jews of his generation, as were Rav Nachman, Rabbi Yehuda HaNassi and Daniel.
    The Rebbe has fulfilled all these conditions . . . Not all great Tzaddikim were “Nessiim”. Obviously according to this lav-davka only The Rebbe, but it does narrow it down to certain Tzaddikim.
    So Meshichistim believe (emphasis on believe) being that The Rebbe was the Nossi of OUR dor it makes sense he would be the appropriate Goel if Moshiach’s time is now (specially in light of what Chazal say about Shimshon, in which case The Rebbe could still be considered the current Nossi as his presence is strongly felt, batei Chabad, The Rebbe’s Shluchim, Hafatzas Hamayanos etc…) So, The Rebbe, in contrast to other great talmidei chochomim was chezkas Moshiach not just because of his Torah and Yichus.

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1696983
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    Daasyochid, am haaretz, a Moshiach sheker is someone who claimed he is Moshiach and then was kofer or killed, no Lubavitcher claims The Rebbe is/was Moshiach, only that he has the status of CHEZKAS Moshiach. Moshiach Vadai has to rebuild the Beis Hamikdash etc etc… NO Lubavitcher claims the Rebbe IS Moshiach. Meshichistim believe that being that The Rebbe is still bechezkas Moshiach even after his passing, as he was not killed but died as a Tzaddik through a natural death, and having been a Nossi of this for, it is only logical, that if it will be min hameisim, that he will be Moshiach. However any Meshichist would agree that if Moshiach is min hamesim it could be the Baal Shem Tov, or any Tzaddik that was bechezkas Moshiach before his histalkus. Obviously you didn’t read my post with the Mekoros of Moshiach min Hamesim, and what Chazal say about Shimshon being Nossi after his death. If you don’t believe Moshiach could come from the dead you are a kofer in Toras Moshe and have no chelek in Olam Habo!

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1696882
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    Did you even learn Basi legani!? Why don’t you learn some Chasidus and befriend some Chassidishe Lubavitchers before being motzi shem-rah on kesherim shleimim un Yereim! This is a quote from Basi Legani, the Rebbe says the Frierdiker Rebbe is should be Moshiach and that’s AFTER his histalkus. The Rebbe never saw himself as Rebbe, he always refered to the Frierdiker Rebbe as the Nosi Hador (after his histalkus).
    “All the above is accomplished through the passing (histalkus) of tzaddikim, that is even harsher than the destruction of the Beis HaMikdash. Since we have already experienced all these things, everything now depends only on us — the seventh generation. May we be privileged to see and meet with65 the Rebbe here in this world, in a physical body, in this earthy domain — and he will redeem us.
    65. See end of Sefer Chassidim (quoted in Gilyon HaShas, Kesubbos 103a); Bamidbar Rabbah 19:13.”
    Once the Rebbe was asked how he could say the Frierdiker Rebbe is Nosi after his histalkusand said that there’s stira of two pesukim – about shimshon in shoftim :
    in the first posuk it says that shimshon had judged Klal Yisroel for 20 years, but another posuk says that he judged them for 40 years. Chazal answer the stira saying that since the Pelishtim feared the Yidden for 29 years after shimshon was nistalek, he was considered the Nossi for those next 20 years. Meaning that in some cases the Nossi continues after his histalkus if his Hashpoho is still felt in the world. (The nossi Hador is moshiach shebador).
    Also the Zohar haKadosh (See Zohar I, 140a; Chiddushei Ritva on Rosh HaShanah 16b; Responsa of Radvaz, Vol. III, sections 1069, 644; Migdal David, p. 83a; Biurei HaZohar of the Tzemach Tzedek, p. 134. See also Sichos Kodesh 5710 (Kehot), p. 100, and Likkutei Sichos, Vol. II, p. 518.) says that certain Tzaddikim will have Techias Hamesim before the main Techias Hamesim hakloli, the Rebbe explains that if Moshiach is Min Hamesim then he would have Techia amongst those special Tzaddikim. (This explains how Moshiach can be min Hamesim if Techia is after Moshiach reveals himself). Moshiach Min Hameisim mekoros:
    Sanhedrin 98b. Abarbanel, Yeshuos Meshicho p. 104. He cites a passage from Tractate Derech Eretz Zuta: “Nine people entered the Garden of Eden alive …Mashiach.” He explains that according to this view, a righteous individual deemed to be the Mashiach will live, then die on account of the sins of his generation, but will eventually be resurrected.
    Sdei Chemed, Pe’as HaSadeh, Maareches Alef, footnote 70.
    R. Chizkiyah Medini states that if Israel is exceedingly meritorious, Mashiach will be resurrected from the dead in a miraculous manner.
    See also Or HaChaim, Parshas Balak, on the verse (Bamidbar 24:17), “A star shall shoot forth from Yaakov”: “If Israel are found worthy, Mashiach will be revealed from heaven.” See also: Zohar I, 203b; Arba Meios Shekel Kessef (by R. Chaim Vital), p. 68; Shaar HaGilgulim, ch. 13; Meorei Tzion, ch. 97; Biurei Zohar by the Alter Rebbe, p. 106b; Biurei Zohar by the Tzemach Tzedek and Yahel Or of the Tzemach Tzedek on Tehillim 82; Or HaChamah on Zohar I, 7b, and I, 212a. Note the closing phrase (“and he will redeem us”) of the first maamar of the Rebbe (entitled Basi LeGani 5711 [1951]), translated by Sichos In English in Basi LeGani: Chassidic Discourses (Kehot, N.Y., 1990), p. 103.

    in reply to: Joining Chabad #1696243
    yehoshuaahron
    Participant

    First of all becoming Chabad doesn’t mean necessarily changing your minhagim, Chabad is a Chasidus meaning a derech in Avodas Hashem as Talmidim of the Chabad Admurim. Second the Inyan of Shlichus only started with the last two Rabbeim (primarily) and is not AT ALL, what defines Chabad’s Derech. Chabad Chasidus is without a doubt the deepest Chasidus with the most Torah (tens of thousands of Maamorim) and clear Derech in Avodah. The sheifa of a Chabad Chosid is to be a true Eved Hashem, a Tolmid Chochom, and Talmid of The Rebbe. (Not to become a Shliach, that’s just one prat although crucial to the needs of Klal Yisroel letzaareinu, but only additional to what being Chabad is.

Viewing 19 posts - 1 through 19 (of 19 total)