Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
WinnieThePoohParticipant
What about the concept of Psik reisha?- that involved a chicken/rooster.
WinnieThePoohParticipantSome high traffic areas of Manhattan have no honking signs. It’s so the neighbors don’t suffer all day from drivers with no patience who honk their horns in standstill traffic because somehow they think that will get all the cars moving. I don’t think it is illegal in all of NYC, but I could be out of date, it’s been a long time since I have been there.
October 17, 2017 2:05 am at 2:05 am in reply to: What sounds like a shofar, in the suburbs? #1382712WinnieThePoohParticipantAll of Elul I hear Shofars in the morning- from nearby shuls. I don’t know whether you are in shofar-hearing distance of your local shuls.
Sometimes at random times, it could be people practicing. Or kids trying to see if they can blow their father’s shofar.WinnieThePoohParticipantThis is actually a real question that can potentially involve 2 issurim- 1) getting a garment wet can be an issue of cleaning (melaben) and 2) of squeezing (sechita, the mealacha of dosh), if the garment gets wet enough to squeeze. As far as I know the Halacha, and it pays to ask your Rov of course, wiping with a disposable napkin is ok, or something like a rag that is designated for spills. You would still have to be careful not to squeeze-meaning avoid getting it soaking wet- whether it is the cloth or your skirt that got soaked by sitting in the puddle.
There is a story I heard once about a Rav who got out of bed in the morning and stepped into the negel vassar water with his socks on. Since he was afraid if he stepped down or pulled off the sock he would squeeze, he sat like that the whole shabbos.WinnieThePoohParticipantI would imagine a dining room table would be more expensive- it’s usually heavier, made from solid wood.
To answer your last question, the Torah is read from the Bima, and it does not have to be read by the Rabbi, but by any male over 13 who knows how to follow the musical intonations- he is called the Ba’al Korei. It can be a designated person, or can change each time, or can be a Bar MItzva boy. In shuls where the only learned person is the Rabbi, he would be the one doing the reading, by default.
WinnieThePoohParticipantJoseph, maybe among the Yiddish speaking chasidim, they use Yiddish names. But Litvish chareidim do not. If they name after someone with a Yiddish name, they change it to the Hebrew equivalent (eg Faiga becomes Tzipora, Gittel, Tova). I am speaking from my experience- from hearing the names in the playground, seeing the names on class lists, knowing girls who if they do have a Yiddish name (because they have American parents), hide them, change them, use only a middle/first name instead.
Back to the OP, most Americans who hear Sivan would think, why would someone name their kid after a month? If it was just a made up name with no other meaning, I think it would be less likely that the kid would feel uncomfortable.
WinnieThePoohParticipantMany kids are not happy having a name that stands out too much- so even if a name is popular in one culture/society (say secular Israeli) but is not popular in the society that she will grow up in, it could be a burden to her. I know kids from American families growing up in Israeli who feel uncomfortable with the names their parents gave them, since although those names are perfectly normal in the US, in the Israeli society they are growing up in they are not used- like Yiddish names, or names that have different connotations in modern Hebrew, or sound like Hebrew words that are not appropriate for names. Sivan could be the same sort of name for your baby if she is not growing up in Israeli secular society.
October 10, 2017 1:15 am at 1:15 am in reply to: I think we need a new forum specially for GoGoGo’s mishugassen #1379831WinnieThePoohParticipantYou’re right, of course, RebYidd, but Gox3 was referring to annarexic, whatever that is…from the context it seems it must be a positive superlative.
WinnieThePoohParticipantI knew a Secular Jew named Sivan. She explained that her parents wanted to name her after a relative called Ziva, but since that name when written with the letter Ves has a negative medical meaning, they chose Sivan since it sounded similar.
I’ve also met a Nissan, a girl born during that month, and a boy named Aviv. Aviva, on the other hand, is fairly common among frum JewsWinnieThePoohParticipantI grew up with a Hungarian grandmother and her choleptzus was my favorite dish- she served them sukkos and Purim. When she was no longer able to make them herself, I realized that the only way I could still eat them was if I made them- my mother never made them, because my grandmother supplied for the whole family. I made them happily for a few years, until my husband finally got up the courage to tell me that he does not like choleptzes. Haven’t made them since, but this thread is making me hungry for some.
WinnieThePoohParticipantCan you translate the hieroglyphics in the OP to English please?
WinnieThePoohParticipantMy kids have seen more real guns in real life on security guards, policemen, soldiers. On the other hand, they don’t watch TV.
Even though I discouraged guns as toys, somehow, boys will be boys and they will play “cops N robber” and improvise a gun. And they gravitate to the Playmobil police sets, guns and all. Oh well. At least they think of guns as something to protect you, not hurt you.September 26, 2017 5:49 am at 5:49 am in reply to: The Top Ten Challenges the frum world faces right now. #1369859WinnieThePoohParticipantZD- here’s the rest of the list:
8. Education standards are dropping. People can’t even count up until 10 these days.
9. The tendency of burying one’s head in the ground and not facing the pressing issues, so that one can only come up with 7 major challenges.
10. Placing all the responsibility on the shoulders of others- for example, expecting Haimy to come up with all 10, and not taking responsibility, by heeding his call to “feel free to add what you think..”WinnieThePoohParticipantwow, a whole thread about me!
The problem is that there are no maple trees in the 100 Acre Woods where I live, that’s why I eat what comes from the hives- whether it was honey or maple syrup.
Can you send me some pancakes please, I’m getting hungry!September 19, 2017 6:50 am at 6:50 am in reply to: Shmiras einayim sunglasses and covered bus windows #1366657WinnieThePoohParticipantI think it is great- someone wants to be machmir in a certain area, and instead of making a big ruckus about how everyone should conform to their self-imposed standards, they are doing something very individualized, so that they can keep their standards without forcing it on anyone else. I don’t see that anyone is handing out these glasses in the local shuls, or demanding that Egged place such windows on public buses. So what is wrong with someone trying to do what he feels is right for himself? maybe that is not what Hashem wants from you, but he feels it is what he needs to do.
September 19, 2017 6:50 am at 6:50 am in reply to: Why its important to show pictures of Married Couples #1366655WinnieThePoohParticipantI’m not commenting on whether is is appropriate to publish photos of women or not, but I would like t o comment on the premise that this picture is a reason to permit:
Yes it is a touching picture, but still, do you really learn what a happy, healthy marriage is like from looking at a picture of a husband and wife? even people in bad marriages can pose with smiles. And if one says that R’ Wosner’s expression is showing how to relate to one’s wife, then it would technically be enough just to show his face, with a caption stating that he was looking at his wife at the time of the picture.
If one wants happy, healthy role models than the proper way would be, if possible, to spend time in such a couple’s home. Stories about how gedolim treated their wives can also teach something, much more clearly than a picture, which is subject to the interpretation of the viewer, can.WinnieThePoohParticipantA very quick google search brought up a couple of articles describing this myth and how it was debunked, almost 20 years ago. Seems the time machine is at work here too.
WinnieThePoohParticipantI imagine there are also many BT families and young men in the Chabad community, that it should not be so difficult for you to marry into Chabad. But…
Just curious, have you explored your rich sephardic heritage too..perhaps as a great-granddaughter of the Baba Sali you will find treasures of your own?WinnieThePoohParticipantI see this has gotten no responses yet, so I’ll try to give a little insight even though I don’t think I can answer all your questions.
There’s gematria and there’s gematria. Anyone can make up a gematria- I’ve been to plenty of Bar Mitzvas and Sheva Brochos where the gematria of the boy or couple’s names are used to link to something like
“mazel tov” etc. It’s nice thought, makes a nice speech. It can be used as a tool to inspire someone or make a point. But I doubt it is holy. But there are gematrias that are brought down by chazal or great Rabbanim that obviously have more weight and significance.
No one knows why Hashem is doing things, even if they have a great gematria to back up their opinions. One is supposed to always learn from the happenings around them, try to figure out what personal lesson can be derived from world events and be inspired to do Teshuva, but no one cay say for sure, Tragedy X happened because person/people Y did Z. One can and should use world events as an impetus to inspire people to improve, but we do not have prophecy today, only great yehidim (individuals) come close to having Ruach Hakodesh (Divine Inspiration), and I would be wary of anyone claiming that they know exactly what Hashem is thinking.
Gematria can be used as an emphasis or hint for many different idea, I don’t think it is a specific tool for the type of diagnosis you are referring to.
Some examples brought down by chazal/our rabbanim:
Tzitzis ציצית in gematria is 600, add the 5 knots and 8 strings and you get 613= wearing tzitzis is to remind you of all 613 mitzvos. (Rashi, quoting Medrash Bamidbar Rabba, Bamdibar 15:38)
Yaakov told his sons R’du, go down to Mitzrayim, and not just Lechu, go. Rashi, quoting the Medrash Rabba, states that R’du רדו in gematria is 210, as a hint to the 210 years of slavery in mitzrayim. In this case it was prophetic.
We don’t eat nuts on Rosh Hashana because Egoz אגוז (17) is gematria of Chet חטא, sin (actually 18, in this case you have to leave off the aleph, which is not heard in the word, so it comes out to 17)- this is symbolic that we should avoid sin.
we find by the “presents” that the Nissim brought to the MIshkan at its inauguration many gematrias that gave symbolic meaning to the present and/or its quantity- ie a silver bowl, קערת כסף 930 – symbolic of Adam living 930 years. etc- see Rashi on Bamidbar 7:18-19, quoting the Medrash.
None of the gematrias were used in the way you are describing.September 13, 2017 2:13 am at 2:13 am in reply to: The Casualties of Yiddish in Litvishe Chadorim #1362563WinnieThePoohParticipant770chabad- back to the Yiddish in Chabad school issues. I’m asking out of curiosity, not to put down. I still don’t see how this works- I can see how it works in other chasidus, where they are insular and Yiddish speaking at home. But I never suspected that Chabad, with the large influx of BTs, was the same way- so you are saying that kids from BT homes, who never spoke Yiddish in their lives, whose parents don’t speak Yiddish, will switch out of public school, say at age 9, and go to a Yiddish speaking school, and the sefarim you described is enough to get them through? Or maybe these kids stay in the local Chabad day schools? But then you are creating a sub-community within the community, the BTs will never integrate.
The other issue that you did not answer, is how a boy who only learned to speak, read, and write English at home in his after-cheder time, can grow up to be an eloquent Shaliach who can communicate articulately with the people in his very out of town communities where the locals do not speak Yiddish. I imagine that shlichus goes beyond putting tefillin on someone and teaching them how to say shema and serving lots of meals on yomim tovim- they must talk and express themselves, teach deep concepts etc. How do they manage?WinnieThePoohParticipantI read reports of people being rescued from flooded buildings in Northern Florida. If residents of Southern Florida had not evacuated, there would have been many more such stories and potentially, loss of life, and catastrophe, as there was with Harvey. B”H Irma was not as strong as she might have been, but there was still some pretty serious flooding and damage, and no one should get complacent and think that the authorities and weather folk over-reacted.
I don’t think residents of the Caribbean Islands or the Keys, or even those million without power in Florida, would call Irma a dud.September 12, 2017 12:23 am at 12:23 am in reply to: The Casualties of Yiddish in Litvishe Chadorim #1361493WinnieThePoohParticipant770chabad- your brothers really don’t learn any English? How does this work, considering the number of BTs in the Chabad community, who obviously feel much more comfortable in English than Yiddish? Where do their kids learn- or are there separate schools for FFB Chabadniks and BTs? And how do bochurim with no English skills grow up to communicate effectively with an English speaking secular Jewish public?
WinnieThePoohParticipantJoseph’s Primer for the Kiruv Professional:
1. Whenever you meet a non-observant Jew, make sure to tell him the magnitude of his aveiros.
2. Remind him that had he lived 150 years ago, he would have been subject to stoning, lashes, etc.
3. Before all else, teach him Yiddish so that he can communicate with his fellow Yidden across the globe. The feeling of connection to all other Yiddish speakers will surely be the key in making him frum.
4. If he has kids, remind him that liberal use of the stick will ensure that his kids follow the right path.
5. If for some reason, the above does not lead to success, consult the CR to figure out why.
5. If all the above fails to make him frum, then just ram him through with a spear.WinnieThePoohParticipantYes, Syag I was thinking the same, but acknowledge that for some families that could be very difficult to impossible to do.
Another point in favor of the healthy baby- why should the babysitter get sick? Or catch something that she could pass on to her family/little kids, as the case may be?WinnieThePoohParticipantwith marshmallow fluff- the fluffernutter.
September 11, 2017 11:48 am at 11:48 am in reply to: Traditional clothing choices amongst religious Ashkenazy and Sephardic Jewry #1360445WinnieThePoohParticipantknafaym- did R’ Ovadya wear the traditional garb before he became the Rishon L’tzion? I was under the impression that the clothing was associated with the title, and not with being a major sefardi posek.
September 11, 2017 11:47 am at 11:47 am in reply to: The Casualties of Yiddish in Litvishe Chadorim #1360441WinnieThePoohParticipantI learned many years ago in a BY that translated the chumash into Hebrew and then English, and limudei kodesh were taught in Hebrew. I say Hebrew and not Ivrit, because it was closer to lashon HaKodesh than modern Hebrew- we used ashkenazi pronounciation (kita beis, not Kita Bet) and regularly used words/phrases that would have gotten strange looks had we used them in Israel. We had a lot to unlearn by the time we went to Israel for seminary and had to speak Ivrit to the natives. But it was useful in that it strengthened our language skills so that we could learn chumash and mefarshim and other sefarim.
With hundreds of thousands of cheder and BY kids learning and living in Ivrit in E”Y these days, it is no longer a Zionist tool of assimilation, as it once was. The question is what today’s gedolim have to say about learning in Hebrew in the US today, not what R’ Aharon paskened several generations back when things were very different.WinnieThePoohParticipantDaddysgirl, to answer your question on the other closed thread about why I did not join this party until now:
1. I don’t usually hang out at mixed parties that rock with guys and gals, even if they are virtual ones, and even if the food is good.
2. I usually only contribute to threads if I have something new to add to the conversation, or an important point to stress. Since I have not yet figured out how to post those cute pictures, I have nothing to add to this topic. Nothing personal. I did find it ironic that the two threads were going on simultaneously, almost back-to-back- one where you welcomed yourself to the CR, and one where you discussed leaving.September 11, 2017 4:55 am at 4:55 am in reply to: Traditional clothing choices amongst religious Ashkenazy and Sephardic Jewry #1360195WinnieThePoohParticipantEven frum sefardim in E”Y don’t live in a third world country. Culture may have been a bad choice of words- I was not thinking of music entertainment and sporting events. More like the economics, the technology, the world-class universities, medical centers, the form of government, infrastructure- these things are commonly found in western societies, but not, say, in sub-Saharan Africa or the majority of the Mid East. Frum people are affected by these factors, whether they fully participate in general society or not.
September 10, 2017 4:07 pm at 4:07 pm in reply to: Should I stop coming to the coffee room? #1359759WinnieThePoohParticipantIt’s a natural outcome of an anonymous online forum- natural barriers are removed, so a teenager can be talking to a respected Zeidy like a peer, when normally that would not be happening in real life.
By the way, Daddysgirl, does this mean the welcome party on the other thread is over?
September 10, 2017 3:28 pm at 3:28 pm in reply to: Traditional clothing choices amongst religious Ashkenazy and Sephardic Jewry #1359755WinnieThePoohParticipantWestern as in cultural, not geographical.
WinnieThePoohParticipantChazal compare someone who gets angry to an idol worshiper – because they lose control and no longer can think rationally. That sort of anger is never good or healthy.
Yet anger of a different sort can be good, sometimes, I think. Say someone gets angry at an injustice, and it propels him to take action to correct that injustice. But that is not the type of anger where one loses control, I am not sure it would even qualify as the basic definition of anger.
Slow to anger means it takes a lot to get angry, the person does not easily get angry.September 10, 2017 2:34 pm at 2:34 pm in reply to: Traditional clothing choices amongst religious Ashkenazy and Sephardic Jewry #1359721WinnieThePoohParticipantBoth Ashkenazim and Sefardim mostly live in Western societies today, and their clothing reflects that; this style is closer to traditional ashkenazi cloting (whatever that means) than traditional sefardi style clothing.
WinnieThePoohParticipantChochom: “By the way did you know that it was really meant to be called hurricane Israel but some senate people had it taken down from the name list?”
Couldn’t be. They alternate male and female names. Harvey and Jose are male, Irma is female. Maybe Israel was suggested a different year?September 7, 2017 2:50 pm at 2:50 pm in reply to: Is It Just Me, Or Are Frum Homes Becoming ‘Colder’ And More Like Offices? #1357862WinnieThePoohParticipantI just made an appointment with an allergist for a couple of family members. I figured I should do my part to, and gave the main living area a real thorough dusting (still have to climb up to attack the light fixtures). The style the OP described sounds more tempting now. An allergy sufferer’s haven.
WinnieThePoohParticipantIronically, I just had such a case, but I doubt it is a cause for OTD. My boys’ school is doing an Elul campaign to promote proper davening and neigel vasser- they get a stamp from the Rebbe each day that they daven nicely and bring in a note from home that they washed properly. The note explaining the campaign to the parents said the kids should be encouraged to wash with water next to their beds, as they learned in school. Now I know many people are makpid on this, it happens to be that we are not and go by the opinion that it is fined to wash in the sink too. My son mentioned this to me, before I read the note, and I said, but we follow a different opinion, and the point is to wash neigel vasser and it’s fine if you do it from the sink. I don’t know if I would have said differently had I read the note, I didn’t know I was outright contradicting what the principal had said. On the other hand, is it proper chinuch to set up water bowls by their beds just during the next 2 weeks of the campaign? Besides that, practically speaking, considering how tight their beds are, someone is sure to end up with a very wet bed.
WinnieThePoohParticipantLF, Although I have no idea how these things work, I doubt that operating/maintaining the electric grid is totally automated and does not need humans at all. Someone has to fly the kite, no? Do ConEd, PSE&G et al. shut down on weekends and holidays and have no staff working?
WinnieThePoohParticipantGadol, I don’t understand what you are saying- are you saying that there is no place for a bright kid to ask a challenging question because it might disrupt the flow of the lesson, and that just doing so is chutzpadik? But what are bright kids supposed to do when they have questions? Resort to finding answers online? The only “question” that we ignore is one from the Rasha, who is not really asking a question, but has an agenda to shove. Is that what you are talking about? It didn’t sound like it from your description. I don’t think any legitimate question, from any kid should be pushed aside and labeled chutzpa. No question coming from intellectual honesty or curiosity should be thought of as a disruption. If the teacher can’t handle it during class time, he should discuss it- or have someone else discuss it if it is beyond his league- with the student after class. Kid should not be expelled for that!
WinnieThePoohParticipantGenerators in use today must be more powerful than the ones used in the past; I know many people using them in places that can get very hot in the summer, I can’t believe that they are all melting every shabbos for months on end. also generators are used in some shuls that for sure have the A/C on all day.
Nechama- strange, I remember Yerushalayim as being very bearable in the summer, maybe with just 1 week of really hot weather that you would need an A/C – That’s when people went to visit their friends and relatives in hotter places like Bet Shemesh that did have A/C. Now, everyone I know in Yerushalayim has it and can’t seem to survive without it. It seems that Yerushalayim during the day time can get as hot as Bet Shemesh, difference is the nights/evenings are cooler. And it seems we have not seen below 30 degree weather since early June.
Boy, things must be very tame in the CR if we are talking about the weather!September 6, 2017 6:56 am at 6:56 am in reply to: Inappropriate intermingling at Chasunas 💃🍸🍷🕺 #1356260WinnieThePoohParticipantSheino Yodeia Lishol: “There are no mechitzos in the grocery stores with tight isles; @ pta in the schools; in doctor’s offices. why all the fuss ”
there are in certain places- I have been to medical clinics in chasidish neighborhood that in addition to the regular seating, have a separate area that men can sit with a curtain around the area. And there are grocery stores with separate hours for men and women- (I have yet to see an island, tight or not, in a grocery store- but they do have aisles). And I am sure that in the chasidishe school system, Tatties go to meet the boys’ Rebbes, and the Mommies, to the girls’ teachers.
WinnieThePoohParticipant25+ year old is not considered a “newer” building, not for a country that is only 70 years old, with most people probably living in neighborhoods built post-statehood, or post 6 day war. I’ve lived in those types of buildings too; the “central heating” found in them ran on oil, not electricity.
By the way, Rav Shach was obviously not my acquaintance, I wrote that I heard a story about him. And he lived in Bnei Brak, where heating is not so necessary. I trust Rav Shach would have known whether it was halachically ok to use alternative sources of heating when it was necessary, and the difference between chumra and halacha.September 6, 2017 6:56 am at 6:56 am in reply to: Is Loud Music At Weddings Causing The Shidduch Crisis? #1356265WinnieThePoohParticipantYes and no.
yes: like RebYidd said.
No: Loud music means that boys and girls have to leave the hall to hear themselves think. Once in a mechitza-free zone they can mingle and meet their zivug. So loud music solves the too tall mechitza problem discussed on another thread. That is assuming that 1) shidduch age kids think and want to hear themselves do so; and 2) their hearing has not been permanently damaged and they can still hold a conversation outside with their zivug; and 3) Joseph’s tznius patrol doesn’t shoo them back inside behind the correct sides of the mechitza.WinnieThePoohParticipantIf the Rebbe/Morah teaches something wrong, it should be corrected. But how it is done is the key- no making fun of the Rebbe/Morah, putting him/her down for not knowing. It could be explained as “everyone makes mistakes, forgets something, even a Rebbe, or maybe he was referring to a meforesh or source that I am not familiar with; there is no one, no matter how big a talmid chochom, who does not have more to learn, etc, but he still has a lot he can teach you and still deserves your respect.”
In terms of school rules not conforming with family standards, a parent can explain, we do X, and we follow a valid halacha/hashkafa, but the school says to do Y, and it is important while you are in school to be a part of the school and follow their rules. If their is a situation where a school is following a questionable approach to halacha (say a local day school has girls perform/sing at graduation in front of the fathers), then it can be explained that the school has its reasons, maybe not all families are at a level to follow the halachca properly, but we are, so we should not do X. In other words, there does not have to be 100% agreement, but their should always be respect.WinnieThePoohParticipantWaze is useful, and every time we get lost or end up stuck in a construction zone, I wish we had it.
yet Waze is not fool -proof, and relying on it blindly has gotten people into trouble- like leading you into non-safe neighborhoods (like Arab rock-throwing areas in Israel), or unlit, winding back-roads that might shave a few minutes off of the travel time, but are not as safe as the main roads at night. It’s a bad idea to lose those map-reading skills. Just as it is a bad idea to lose the ability to communicate with others in person with full sentences.WinnieThePoohParticipantAvi K – can you explain what you mean about central heating not controlled by individual residents? Don’t newer buildings use either central or split units to heat and cool, which run on electricity, each apartment having their own unit(s)? The really old buildings have furnaces for the whole building with radiators in each apartment, and the tenants had to decide together when to heat- but those ran on oil. then the more modern buildings started putting in mini furnaces (Yunkers) into each apartment, also oil or gas based. But now I think people realize that electricity is the cheapest option, and they use the “mazgan” to both heat and cool.
which reminds me of a “cool” story told about Rav Shach (I think). Someone offered to buy him an A/C for his house, but he turned down the offer because he would not have been able to run it on the generator on shabbos, and he did not want to be more comfortable during the week than on shabbos.WinnieThePoohParticipantIn Israel, the answer is simple. Boys chadarim and Talmid Torahs start Rosh Chodesh Elul, same as the big boy Yeshivas, while girls follow the education ministry’s calendar, starting Sept 1. Except this year they started 2 days earlier than that, I guess so they can squeeze in everything they need to before yom tov. Last year Rosh Chodesh Elul was Sept 4, so the girls actually started before the boys.
September 5, 2017 2:56 pm at 2:56 pm in reply to: Is It Just Me, Or Are Frum Homes Becoming ‘Colder’ And More Like Offices? #1355344WinnieThePoohParticipantCome visit us. Comfy worn out chairs/couch in the living room, Jewish art and kid art and pictures of kids on the walls, and various playmobil and clicks construction projects underfoot. not a bit of marble anywhere- except the small, round kind that seem to roll everywhere.
I think what you are describing must be some sort of style, but I can’t believe it works in a home with small kids.WinnieThePoohParticipantOur building has one tree growing on the shared building property, next to the parking lot. It gives a bit of green amidst all the grey concrete. It shades the parking spots, shades our windows and gives us a bit of privacy so the neighbors in the next building do not have a clear view of our windows.
Until… one neighbor decided to build his sukka last year in a public area next to the parking lot (right under our bedroom windows). And under the tree. So he cut down all the branches on 1 side. There were 3 limbs left. This year, he decided the largest limb was covering a corner of his very large sukka. He asked one neighbor if they minded if he cut down the tree. They said they did mind, but he can trim a bit if it blocks his sukka. He went and cut down the largest limb. Never asked us, even though that limb was closest to our apartment. Now we have no shade and no privacy, and while he may enjoy his super large sukka for 1 week of the year, we are left to suffer for all 52 weeks. I miss that branch. Now every time we hear the neighbor drilling on his sukka (last year it took him about a month to build it, usually around my kids’ bedtime) I will miss that tree even more.WinnieThePoohParticipantLB, I don’t get it- if you wrote a letter on Fri, then it has Friday’s date, why would anyone thing you wrote in on shabbos? (By the way, there may be an issue with putting the card in the mailbox right before shabbos if you know for sure that the mailman will pick it up on shabbos – it may be an inyan of amira L’goyim- asking a non-Jew to do a melacha for you; I am not sure, you wold have to ask a Rav about this, or one of the CRers will pipe up)
OP- why do you have to refer to any week, just use the date and the day. Motzei shabbos in actually Sunday (we just are reluctant to let Shabbos leave, so we still refer to it in terms of shabbos, even when it is over), it’s the first night of the new week, you date it with Sunday’s date if you are using the Hebrew date. ie Motzei Shabbos, 12 Elul, or Sun 12 Elul, or Motzei Shabbos, Sept 2. Are you asking whether you write, Motzai Shabbos Parshas Ki Tezei (meaning the Parsah read that morning) or refer to the coming week’s Parsah? I think since Motzai refers to the past shabbos, you can write the name of the Parsha that was just read on that shabbos (ie which shabbos was just over? Parshas Ki Tezei).
WinnieThePoohParticipantTo continue what iacisrmma was saying; The Mishne describes 10 items that were created during twilight of erev shabbos, Pi Haaretz was one of them. These are things that are above the natural order- which is why they were not created during the 6 days themselves, but still part of the physical world, not totally spiritual, which is what shabbos the 7th day represents- hence they were created in the time between the 6 days of creation and the actual start of shabbos.
Moshe specifically asked Hashem to make a new creation- V’Im Briya Yivra Hashem-, to show everyone that Korach was wrong.
Yet, The Ibn Ezra in 16:30 argues with those who say Briya means a new creation, and that it wasn’t something new or special- but like any other earthquake (I think his description more resembles an earthquake than a sink hole, because he talks about countries, medinot, being split- a sink hole would be in a specific small area). He then continues in passuk 35 to say that Korach himself was not swallowed but was burned up with those who brought the ketores.
The RaMBaN argues with the Ibn Ezra and stats Briya has to mean a new creation- and the novelty wasn’t the earth swallowing people- because that happens a lot – he specifically uses the term Ra’ash, meaning earthquake, but the fact that it closed up as if it never had opened, like a mouth opening to swallow something and then closing- that was the supernatural part. Rashi also holds it was a supernatural event -
AuthorPosts