Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
November 14, 2010 8:39 pm at 8:39 pm in reply to: Tomorrow 11 Cheshvan is the Yahrtzeit of Rachel Imeinu Aleha Hashalom #709074WIYMember
Vladimir
Just because you don’t know a mekor doesn’t make it made up!
November 14, 2010 7:49 am at 7:49 am in reply to: Kids or teens who leave the Shabbos table to go read… #709398WIYMemberI don’t think its appropriate. The parents should say something to the kid and make it clear that he/she belongs at the table. But it depends on the family. Some houses are more “chilled.”
November 14, 2010 7:02 am at 7:02 am in reply to: Whats the deal with Yeshiva/BY closures lately? #708898WIYMemberdvorak
Yeah I read that article and the amount that they owe is ridiculous!
WIYMembermdd
“those who need an English translation of the MB do not medakdek in Halocha in the first place.”
Wow you really should get off your high horse! Not everybody makes a great reading of Hebrew seforim, that doesnt make them someone not medakdek in Halacha! Besides there are people who can read some Hebrew but not all or it takes them very long and to spend a half hour to try to figure out what a MB is saying may be very discouraging. Additionally there are many in the BT community who cant read Hebrew well yet. They care plenty about Halacha but feel handicapped with their lack of Hebrew reading skills.
WIYMemberDeiyezooger
I agree with smartcookie. Please use a spell checker. Your post looks ridiculous.
WIYMemberSacrilege
“The same thing bothers me.
It also bothers me when my “super masmidim” family members do it at family sheva brachos and at the shabbos table.
Learning is learning and mentshlachkeit is mentshlachkeit.”
If nobody is speaking theres no problem if they feel like taking out a sefer and learning as opposed to shmoozing and making small talk. Unless you are referring to while someone is speaking, then yes it is wrong and is arrogant and shows a clear lack of respect or a disdain for the speaker.
WIYMemberSJSinNYC
You are 100% right, but talking doesnt affect the neshamos, it can only distract others listening to Kaddish to answer and its actually a very improper thing to do. People do not appreciate the value of Davening in general. Kaddish suffers along with Chazaras Hashatz and leining.
Im always bothered when I see people who look like they had a proper yeshivah education, some even are in Kollel or look like learned people and they will talk during Chazaras Hashatz or Kaddish. However my opinion is it is a general feeling of disconnection from Tefillah.
I have a theory and I hope Im wrong but to me it seems that most people dont believe Hashem is listening to their prayers or they dont believe that their prayers even mean anything or have the power to accomplish great things and therefore why bother Davening with Kavana or caring about Davening too much or the fact that one can be disturbing anothers Davening.
WIYMemberpopa_bar_abba
Does he do broadway too?
WIYMemberI dont know. But frankly I think its very rude to “bike ride” through a cemetery. I dont know if its a Jewish one or a non Jewish one, but regardless, the families likely dont appreciate it and anyone there at the grave of a loved one at the time of this recreational activity will likely be very bothered.
WIYMemberSino steak works for me, Sesame chicken is good so are the cold cut sandwiches.
November 14, 2010 5:37 am at 5:37 am in reply to: Whats the deal with Yeshiva/BY closures lately? #708895WIYMemberdvorak
Most schools especially decent sized ones that have been around for a while own the property for a while so the mortgage if there ever was one is paid off. I dont think there are many schools that rent.
WIYMemberSacrilege
Ooooh now I am really curious what you said lol!
WIYMemberThe Wolf
First of all I dont know you personally but you have this manner of putting yourself down and saying negative things about yourself which really makes me uncomfortable. I dont think its proper for you to put yourself down whether you really have a low self image or just for fun because some people will take it seriously and if you really feel this way about yourself you need to speak to a professional. If you are doing it for humor, its not funny and insensitive to those who themselves struggle or have struggled with self image issues.
Now on to your post.
I think you have made a very valid point and I have seen this done elsewhere. You are 100% correct that it is wrong and disrespectful. It shows I dont care what you have to say r that you are boring…Its especially rude when the person is right in the line of sight of the Rav or speaker…If the Rav is speaking for a long time and goes on and on and is really very boring, I cant judge someone who is sitting in the back and knows for a fact that he cant be seen by the Rav for taking out a sefer and finishing maavir sedrah or whatever.
WIYMemberTheChevra
Ok so they reveal the skin of her chest thats opposite her heart but it says they tie a rope above her breasts so that her clothing stay on. I dont believe theres actual nudity involved. Maybe theres the kind of viewage you see today by some non Jewish women who wear plunging necklines but no nudity was visible. I could be wrong. But so it seems from reading what you cut and pasted.
WIYMemberWhat you are saying is WRONG. Even on the most chomer aveiros including murder, eishes ish, etc. one can do complete teshuva.
Many people somehow have a wrong hashkafa on this matter.
Incorrect. Once you brought a Mamzer into the world thres no undoing that. Although there may be some way to do Teshuvah Im not sure theres a 100% Teshuvah for making a Mamzer.
November 13, 2010 11:43 pm at 11:43 pm in reply to: Whats the deal with Yeshiva/BY closures lately? #708892WIYMemberZach
“Its not so much the Recession as organizations not running on sensible budgets. Recession or not if you spend more then you take in you go broke. And you can’t out earn or fundraise careless spending.
(Yes this means some hard choices are going to have to be made)”
But what does that mean? The typical mainstream Yeshivah and BY do not pay high salaries the food is generally subsidized by the govt and is 2nd rate at best and these schools arent exactly offering anything that should cost them through the roof.
Unless Im missing something, with tuition being paid in full by most students and the extra fundraising, dinners…a yeshivah should at least be able to stay afloat. But to fall into heavy debt? I just dont get how thats possible unless Im missing something big.
November 12, 2010 8:03 pm at 8:03 pm in reply to: Whats the deal with Yeshiva/BY closures lately? #708887WIYMemberPopa
I know. I really can’t understand how that school is having financial problems.
WIYMemberSjs, myfriend and Wolf.
Thanks!
WIYMemberSacrilege
I can’t believe you have no response to my comment. I thought you would find it punny 😉
WIYMemberSacrilege
Shacharis and Mincha silly!
WIYMemberSacrilege
The Rabbanan in the Gemara say that Tefillah is an exception bedcause Tefillah is a request from Hashem for mercy and women need that just as much as men do.
At the minimum you should Daven Shemonah Esrei. I think any competent Rav would agree with that statement. I challenge you to ask one.
With all do respect its not up to you to do “what works for you.” Trust me my life would be soooo much easier or entertaining if “do what works for me.”
I once complained to a Rav “I don’t feel like doing xyzabc so I don’t do it, I want to feel like doing it but I don’t. Well he said “your mistake is viewing it as though you have an option. You don’t have an option. You must do what Hashem commanded you. Now once you are going to do it anyways because you must, doesn’t it make more sense to try and do it with as much enthusiasm and enjoyment as we can muster?”
WIYMemberMODs
Is there a way you can create an option for threads to open up from the last page or most recent page first. Its a bit cumbersome when opening a thread with many pages to have to click click click to get to the most recent stuff. Especially if someone is using their smart phone to browse the web and view the coffeeroom.
November 12, 2010 6:28 pm at 6:28 pm in reply to: Dealing with difficult or annoying people: My theory #713732WIYMemberChesedname
You said things to me?
If you did I forgive you but I don’t recall anything.
WIYMemberMod 80
You are right about that.
TheChevra
Oy vey. Her HAIR is uncovered.
November 12, 2010 6:05 pm at 6:05 pm in reply to: Dealing with difficult or annoying people: My theory #713730WIYMemberMyfriend
Correct. Sorry maybe the Mods can move it.
WIYMemberSacrilege
Aha. Well for parnassah we can also live on a bare minimum. We can wear second hand clothing..but nobody wants that!!
Judaism isn’t about doing the bare minimum. A single girl should not be cutting corners. A married woman who has kids and is busy taking care of them has all the Halachic excuses. You have none except your contrived ones of course.
Most Halachic authorities hold like the Ramban that a woman must daven shacharis and mincha. The minimum is 2 shemonah esreis a day. I know you are a lawyer but there aren’t real loopholes for a single girl.
WIYMembersqueak
You are right. Give all your assets away to charity and then get back to me 😉
WIYMemberWolf
Rabbi Shafier from the Shmuz discusses it in his Hilchoos Teshuvah boot camp 3 shiur series. Worth a listen!
WIYMemberSacrilege
Well if you took on Maariv for a particular reason definitely stick with it unless it becomes too much of a burden.
But seriously you have a chiyuv to daven Mincha. Its not really optional. I don’t know your work environment but I can’t imagine there isn’t even 5 minutes to quickly Daven a Mincha.
People find time to do the things that’s important to them (like eat, go to the bathroom, shmooze with friends, send text messages…) nobody has time for Hashem. Its depressing.
WIYMemberSacrilege
I think wed do great together because I’m a Fun-gi.
November 12, 2010 4:59 pm at 4:59 pm in reply to: Falling Down and Getting Right Back up Again #709618WIYMemberAnyone?
Don’t be afraid to try something new if you never watched a shiur online. Its time well spent and you will find yourself wanting more.
WIYMemberSqueak
Hi how are you? What’s doing? Maybe we should sit down for coffee one day? 😉
Sacrilege
I doubt anyone with that kind of cash is sitting here on this forum. Well except for me that is…yeah I wish lol.
WIYMemberSacrilege
Mincha according to many seforim (Halachically Shacharis is most important) is the most important or powerful Tefillah of the day because during our hectic work day we take off the time to recognize that there’s a Creator and everything we do in business or elsewhere in our lives is totally worthless without His blessing and help. We can’t succeed without Him. The Gemara says that Eliyahu Hanavi was Davening and Davening and was finally answered by Hashem at Mincha time (on Har HaCarmel)
That being said your father can be matir your neder if you never said bli neder. I don’t know all the rules but its an easy process.
If you already are Davening 2x a day make Mincha #2.Mincha is shorter than Maariv, its just ashrei shemonah esrei and aleinu I don’t even think you need to say tachnun. Look at it as though you are davening “Maariv” a few hours earlier.
You certainly have the 5-10 minutes it takes to Daven a quick Mincha. Although it may mean less time in the CR here we will all be happier knowing you are Davening to Hashem and putting Him before us.
November 12, 2010 4:24 pm at 4:24 pm in reply to: Fathers and brothers dancing with the Kallah #709260WIYMemberMyfriend
Don’t bother quoting from that “extreme” text called The Shulchon Aruch iit may offend some peoples “sensitivities.”
WIYMemberThe Rambam says you can do Teshuvah on anything however If a Chillul Hashem is involved it will require Missah to be completely mechaper.
However the Rambam and Shaarei Teshuva as well as other sources (I believe its a Gemara) That if one sins and says Echta Veashuv – I will do Teshuvah afterwards his Teshuvah is not accepted.
Your question wasnt can someone do Teshuvah on murder but “how can someone.” As though it happened…Im trying very hard not to read too much into this…
Either way if you want to know how to do Teshuvah on such an Aveira you should learn through the Rambams Hilchos Teshuvah which isnt too long and the sefer Shaarei Teshuvah by Rabbeinu Yonah.
WIYMemberSacrilege
Why dont you Daven Mincha too? You have more of a chiyuv to daven Mincha than Maariv?
WIYMembertwisted
You reminded me of some weird stuff I have had. Lychee fruits Sabras and wheat grass!
WIYMemberSacrilege
“No. I usually copied :)”
You are way too proud of that “accomplishment” 🙂
WIYMemberMod-80
Personally I think Mitch Hedberg (RIP) is much funnier than SW.
Heres a few.
I don’t own a cell phone or a pager. I just hang around everyone I know, all the time. If someone wants to get a hold of me, they just say ‘Mitch,’ and I say ‘what?’ and turn my head slightly.
I know a lot about cars. I can look at a car’s headlights and tell you exactly which way it’s coming.
I like rice. Rice is great if you’re hungry and want 2000 of something.
I like to play blackjack. I’m not addicted to gambling, I’m addicted to sitting in a semi-circle.
I wanna hang a map of the world in my house. Then I’m gonna put pins into all the locations that I’ve traveled to. But first, I’m gonna have to travel to the top two corners of the map so it won’t fall down.
The depressing thing about tennis is that no matter how good I get, I’ll never be as good as a wall.
With a stop light, green means ‘go’ and yellow means ‘slow down’. With a banana, however, it is quite the opposite. Yellow means ‘go’, green means ‘whoa, slow down’, and red means ‘where the heck did you get that banana?’
You know, you can’t please all the people all the time… and last night, all those people were at my show.
I like an escalator because an escalator can never break, it can only become stairs. There would never be an escalator temporarily out of order sign, only an escalator temporarily stairs. Sorry for the convenience.
I’m sick of following my dreams. I’m just going to ask them where they’re going and hook up with them later.
I play golf. I’m not good at golf. I never got a hole-in-one. But I did hit a guy. That’s way more satisfying. You’re supposed to yell “Fore.” But I was too busy mumbling “There ain’t no way that’s gonna hit him.”
I went to a doctor. All he did was suck blood from of my neck. Don’t go to see Dr. Acula!
Hope you enjoyed 🙂
WIYMemberI bought a blank tape, went home and played in on my stereo and turned it up full blast. A few minutes later a neighbor came over to complain… He was a mime…
-Steven wright
November 12, 2010 12:32 am at 12:32 am in reply to: Falling Down and Getting Right Back up Again #709617WIYMembertheprof1
Shkoyach. Im just trying to get people to watch a great Torah shiur. I hope at least one person watched it. Hes very interesting and entertaining, he has a great sense of humor and communicates his message very well.
WIYMemberSacrilege
Talmid Chacham, Ben Torah same difference.
No its not and most girls wont say they are looking for a Talmid Chacham. A talmud Chacham is a serious Torah scholar someone who “knows his beans” not just a guy who can learn a Daf Gemorah or knows some things.
(From askmoses.com)
DEFINE YOUR TERMS
I was once talking to a tourist on his first visit to Israel. He seemed disenchanted.
From Rav Noach weinberg Zatzal.
squeak
Correct English would be get hold of. Or a hold of ahold is not actually a real word although it kind of evolved into one. I have the red misspelling squiggle under ahold.
November 12, 2010 12:23 am at 12:23 am in reply to: Fathers and brothers dancing with the Kallah #709241WIYMemberSJS
The “Is fun allowed” was a question to Squeak who said we were reverting back to germanic wedding styles. As I’m half German and understand the “no sense of humor” thing, it made me laugh and was a natural question.
Again, where did I define my version of fun?
Sorry it got lost in translation. I thought you were talking to me and saying that teen boys and girls should look at each other because its fun.
WIYMemberI can remember the first time I had to go to sleep. Mom said, “Steven, time to go to sleep.” I said, “But I don’t know how.” She said, “It’s real easy. Just go down to the end of tired and hang a left.” So I went down to the end of tired, and just out of curiosity I hung a right. My mother was there, and she said “I thought I told you to go to sleep.”
– Steven Wright
WIYMemberBP Totty
Thanks for trying to set us up but I honestly think we arent for each other. Our views on things dont exactly match up. Besides, shes looking for a professional and a Talmid Chacham of which I am neither.
November 11, 2010 9:52 pm at 9:52 pm in reply to: VOTE HERE if guys in BMG should wear name tags #729131WIYMemberdunno
Great now I have someone else on my case 😉
WIYMember1987
“So before anyone wants to start a new topic that they KNOW will cause such discussions, please refrain.”
You forgot to take your own advice…or was this what you wanted…?
November 11, 2010 9:45 pm at 9:45 pm in reply to: Fathers and brothers dancing with the Kallah #709215WIYMemberkapusta
I think Im entitled to have something to say to someone who thinks boys and girls mingling and looking at each other is fun and should be allowed and the idea that it is assur brings her to say “Is fun allowed?”
Sorry if it offends you or anyone else that I stand up for whats right.
November 11, 2010 9:20 pm at 9:20 pm in reply to: Dose of reality: Kids kicked out of school #709039WIYMemberSJS
“why are there organizations out there geared towards helping them leave the ultra-orthodox lifestyle in which they were raised”
You mean why are there Reshayim in the world and people who are choti umachti es harabim and mesis umadiachs? Great question!
WIYMembermama
“wiy – i dont need to speak to a rebbetzin. i know what i want.”
That doesnt mean you shouldnt speak things through. I know plenty of people including myself who “thought” they knew what they wanted, then had a heart to heart with someone older and wiser who explained some things that we hadnt thought of and made us realize that maybe some of ideas are wrong or misguided. Im not saying you dont know what you want, but what you “think” you may want is not necessarily what you really want and may be clouded by emotions or whatever.
You can do whatever you feel like but you can only gain by talking things through thoroughly with a Rebbitzen, (former sem teacher whatever…)
-
AuthorPosts