Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
June 22, 2011 2:42 am at 2:42 am in reply to: The definition of Kulos/Chumros and the psak halachah. #779061ChachamParticipant
NOt to rely on an eruv, Reb Shlomo Zalman in Halichos Shlomo on pesach by gebrokts, is maarich about the chiluk of a minhag and some chumrus. His example of an extreme chumra is to not rely on eruvs. He says if one is makpid on this his son is not mechuyav to follow since there is no reason meikar hadin not to use an eruv. There are many complex issues that can go wrong while making an eruv, which might make one extra nervous, but nobody holds that there is no such thing.
June 22, 2011 2:21 am at 2:21 am in reply to: The definition of Kulos/Chumros and the psak halachah. #779060ChachamParticipantWhat I was saying about sheitils is that some very choshuve poskim assur it. It is not an insane chumra to listen to rav wlyashiv and chacham yosef. But for some whose rabbi is Rav Yosef Or Rav Elyashiv than it is meikar hadin not to wear a sheitil. But I am not saying that nobody should wear a wig. Only those that consistently those rabbanims psak
ChachamParticipantMichigan High School Football Coaches Association ?///?????????
June 17, 2011 7:09 pm at 7:09 pm in reply to: Kula Creep – The Creation and Use of Non-Existent "Kula's" #779669ChachamParticipant– Relying on Chalav stam for cheese.
– Using ”certain” eruvirm that the only rav theat holds of it is the Eruv Rav.
ChachamParticipantand some waiting for moshiach are also mekayeim mitzvas yishuv ha’aretz. I am writing this from the airport. I iy”h am zoche to be oileh regel for shevous.
ChachamParticipantShema yisrael hakosel shelamu was said as a response to
the lynching on yom kippur in 28. This was said after they put a.mechitZa at the wall against the will of the British and Arabs .
ChachamParticipantWe are not talking About hAkaras hatov to the medina.that is regulAr Shlomo shel malchus. We are talking about what the maskana is. That is the ability to live in the old city and davening at the kosel,. This is a good maskana so we celebrate it. A neiss can happen Through a radish . This has always been the case. In navi you have this many times such as the havtorah of metzorah in which four metzoraim discover wheat And flower for the Jews who had a very bad drought . These metzorahs were according to the Gemara in Sanhedrin , gechazhi and his sons who have no cheileck in plan haba
ChachamParticipantLast I checked poskm do not come to agree with the shulchAn Aruch. And FYI on yom kippur of 1928 there was riots at the kosel killing the mispAllim whom were ultra orthodox just because they were praying to rebuild the temple and they went nuts when they blew the shofar by Neilah . Only after this did the violence really start. So davening at the kosel in a way caused the whole matzavv . I guess you will be reallecting obama who wants to return the old city and the kosell and much of the land Aquired by the
Massey satan “naska” of 1967
ChachamParticipant“This statement I agree with, but most celebrating Yom Yerushalyim are celebrating the Medina and not Hashem!”
So how come you wrote ” We are still in Golus and goyim still go up everyday onto the Har Habayis. This is a terrible disgrace. So what are you celebrating exactly?”
This post was started asking how come there was no mention of the great nes of 28 iyar on ywn. It was not started asking all of us to sing hava nagila and hatikva. So yes I do celebrate the nes of 67 which was carried out al yedie the tzahal. I do not idealize the idf at all, but without them many of our brothers throats will be slit. read the news what happened on the syrian border today.
And Heath, the din of hakol maalin is nogeah bizman hazeh . I am not making this up look in the shulchan aruch even haezer siman 75
ChachamParticipantgoldenkint thank you
also about the chasam sofers opinion, if you use is for kidsha rishona and kedushas yerushalayim look at the words of the chasam sofer in succah 36a dh ????
ChachamParticipantshlishi you obviously missed the boat
The fact that some of those gedolim were against zionism have very little shayachos weather there was a neis in 67 and it is good we got the kosel back.
The point is when a neis is done to klal yisrael are job is to thank hashem. It is quite obvious from the tzitz eliezer that he is thanking hashem for the nissim
whether zionism itself is good or evil i believe there are around 50 other forums about this on ywn
ChachamParticipantregarding the din of kidsha rishona kidsha leosid lavo, the chasam sofer is k’maat a da’as yochid of the achronim to pasken that way. In teshuvas rebbi akiva eiger he writes to the chasam sofer about this inyan and argues strongly with it.
Anyone who wants a full biur in kidsha rishona can look in tzitz eliezer 10:1 where he spends 80 pages going through this topic, the kedusha of the kosel etc.
And if you say the halacha is clearly like the chasam sofer, that would permit going on to har habais which 99% of gedolei doreinu assurred.
About the above mentioned gedolim most of them did not hold it was a maaseh satan. MOst clearly the brisker rov who said if it was really maaseh soton, it would make the soton stronger than hashem (bmechitzosom Loritnz) And most of them held of living in eretz yisrael and the kedusha of yerushalayim.
The tzitz eliezer can be foound here http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=14509&st=&pgnum=10
ChachamParticipantlook in the hakdama of tzitz eliezer chelek 10.
ChachamParticipantI found a griz brought in nesivas hakodesh on menachos 34a dh veha that asks from the mishna in brachos that an eved kenani is chayav in mezuza. how can that be. the gemara is mevuar that it is a chovas hasocher v’ain kinyan l’eved . so he answers The chiyuv is not talui in his kinyan in the huse. It is talui on for whom the house was meyuchad for. so even if it is only for avadim they are a dweller and will be mechayav in mezuza
for a full cover on this sugya ( chiyuv on socher) look in the mesivta in otzar iyunim maareches 17 .1 .2
ChachamParticipantme too
ChachamParticipantAccording thh shiur I quoted before, Rav Belskey told his sons not to wear it.
April 28, 2011 9:31 pm at 9:31 pm in reply to: Can YWN Radio adopt Sefira Music only policy? #983250ChachamParticipantmost poskim hold it is assur to listen to sefira music. ask your rav
ChachamParticipantlisten to the shiur at 53 minutest in
ChachamParticipantPatur Aval Assur
Rav Scheinberg k`yeduah wears around 80 pears of tzitzis. Some of the 80 are techeiles.
Listen to the shiur yourself and see.
ChachamParticipantAccording to R Nissan Kaplan’s shiur on this inyan, there are actually many rabbbanim who do where tcheiles including
Rav Chaim Pinchas Scheinberg- ( he called his son to find out and was told that some of his tzitzis are tcheiles)
Rav Zalman Nechemiah Goldberg
And Rav Yaakov Kamenetzky told a well known rav ( who shall remain anonymous) that if he learns it up and thinks it is tcheiles than he should where it btzinah.
Rav Chaim Kanievsky said it is like dam chamor and it is worthless but can’t hurt.
Rav Elyashiv in a mefursam Teshuvah (kovetz teshuvas chelek 1 siman 2) says although there is many proofs to this [murux] tcheiles we could still be choshed that in later doros it will get disprooved, like the radzhiner.
?? ?? R nissan kaplans shiur ( can be found online in halachah 5770-55-tzitzis-2-techeles.mp3 (31.02 megs) )
I personally where this tcheiles and so does my father and brother. I am not mizrachi . But the reason it is popular amongst the mizrachi crowd, is probably because the murux was decided as the chilazon over 70 years ago by the cheif rabbi (who then was actually a rabbi in Ireland) Reb Yitzchak Isaac Halevi Herzog ZT”L. [ who was held of in the chareidi circles] He had many proofs but could not figure out why it was not blue but rather purple. Than 20 years ago it was discovered that if you leave it in the sun for a half hour it turns blue.
ChachamParticipantThis is bad news for the Jews. The Muslim Brotherhood [known as Islamic Jihad in Gaza] is behind it. They are causing unrest in many other countries besides for Egypt including Jordan. If the Government falls we are in trouble being that they are armed with the finest american weapons including the M1 Abrams tank. The difference between Iran is that Iran has no problem killing anyone who disagrees with them. Also it seems a lot heavier than Iran being that it is in more than one country. We all should just daven and hope for the best.
ChachamParticipantI learned recently and I am about to finish a megillah on time or purim i’yh. The halachos I used Mishnas Hasofer and Otzar Sta”m [3 vol.]. I think that Otzar Stam is much more clear, while Mishnas Hasofer discusses everything.
To learn the umnos I learned from a sofer in lakewood who writes and taught me one and one. It is best to learn one and one then with a group especially for shapiras ha’osios. If youb are willing to come into lakewood I am sure my melamed will be happy to teach you.
ChachamParticipantI once heard Hamezalzel BEchachamim ain Lo Chelek Lo`alam Habaah and the scource is very reliable- a gemara in chelek
ChachamParticipantshabbos in outer space reb shlomo zalman ztl [ teshuvos in the bach of shulchan shlomo on yom tov] paskens that it has the din of someone lost in a midbar who is mechuyav to keep shabbos all 7 days [if he lost count] O”C 344
ChachamParticipant”shvartze-WOLFISH MUSINGS”
ChachamParticipantit only starts at 9:54
and he is mostly repeating and quoting harav elya weintraub zatzal famous speech in lakewood.
ChachamParticipantmaybe shlomo hamelech taught it to the queen of sheeba.
and it is for sure over 1100 years old being the gemorah mentions it
ChachamParticipantmazal tov a sach nachas
ChachamParticipant“between my father and the old fool”. by yosef neumark
June 29, 2010 9:10 pm at 9:10 pm in reply to: Sforim that have Segulas associated with them #1115084ChachamParticipantits a good thing he said that now i am going to learn it
June 29, 2010 8:38 pm at 8:38 pm in reply to: Sforim that have Segulas associated with them #1115083ChachamParticipantif learning all these seforim is a segulah than i can be sure learning some torah ,neveim kesuvim, mishnah , tosefta, bavli, yerushalmi , midrash ..etc….etc… is an extremely powerful ”segulah”. [actually the nefesh hachaim [maggid fun veluuzhiiin] explains the kochos of limud hatorah in shaar daled.]
also yw esitor. there are six chalakim in most mishnah beruros [ unless you are not counting chelek daled].
and i personally learn torah because that is what I am here to do {avos 2:8} not because this and this person said it is a segulah for that.
also is it to hard for you to fast and have all the aveilus in the middle of the summer. don’t worry giva a thousand dollars to kupat ha’ir and reb chaim kanievski will do all the aveilus for you 🙂
ChachamParticipantIn lakewood there is a gemach for these gemoros , but I guess you feel uncomfortable with someone elses
ChachamParticipantvolvie, actually according to Reb Moshe Feinstein the din Lifnei Eiver by giving food to somebody else is not a problem if that person has a respectabloe rov to be soimech on.
ChachamParticipantAny new ones for this year ?
ChachamParticipantAlthough this can be in a humor thread google translate…
?? ?, ? ??? ? ???? ? ???? ?????? ????? ?? ??? ?????? ???? ??????? ?????? ???? ??????? ?? ??? ??????? ??????? ???? ?”?. ?????? ?????? ?? ????. ?”? ???? ?? ????? ???? ????. ???? ???? ???? ???? ????? ????? ?? ?? ????? ?? ??? ??? ??? ?? ?? ??? ???? ???? ?????? ??? ?????. ??? ?? ???? ???? ??? ?? ????? ????? ?? ???? ????? ?? ????? ???? ????.
Page A, a period of a year went a Corinne Since when the priests heard Barbin Ncnsin hour and contribution by the end of the first night watch words of RA. Wise say until midnight. Gan says to raise dawn. New act came from the banquet and told him not screened the audio told them if I could not dawn Hiibin them happen. Not only that but they said all they said smart until midnight to raise Mtzotn dawn.
ChachamParticipanti know everyone is saying there is no decent orthodox books. but i thinks avner gold is amazing.
ChachamParticipanti heard a new pshat in BING
Bill Its No Good
ChachamParticipantalso i think chasof zeroah from baruch levine chasan hatorah and shweckey1
ChachamParticipantfor your information i just flew to eretz yisrael on continental airlines. some 3 and a half hours into the 1050 flight from Newark was sunrise but i could not get to my tefillen because of turbulence. after that i wanted to daven as early as possible i asked another frum man about making a minyan. he told me he asked a few people who refused and the rest were sleeping . so i went to the kitchens and ASKED the flight attendant if he minds if i pray here. the continental attendant said he has no problem so i davened there and one by one the rest of the plane came there to daven
ChachamParticipantbecause the way you think becomes the way you feel…becomes who you are forever THESHMUZ.COM
-if you have no destination all roads get you there.
ChachamParticipantagav many things are pronounced wrong
example reish there is the eemerrrrican rrrrr israeli rwri from the back of the throat and the brisker grgrgrgrgrgrgrghhhhhrgr also from the back of the throat. al pi dikduk the correct way is from the roof of the tip of the mouth similer to a lamed and tes/tav [like some chassidem do it]
ChachamParticipantchofetzchaim
ChachamParticipanti saw this shtickel a long time ago but should one switch by all or just shema or should he not switch at all
ChachamParticipantmy mother got jury duty the day before my sisters chasunah. it got pushed off to the day of my brothers bar mitzvah than it got pushed off to some date the next year. my mother said at least i know when the next simchah is!
ChachamParticipantpashuteh yid —the rama himself says that.
icwill look for the maareh makom later.
ChachamParticipantI guess we all learned that gemarah in Hamocher es hasphinah
ChachamParticipantcheck all zmanm at myzmanm.com
ChachamParticipantPeople should also mark if home baked goods are yoshon
ChachamParticipantWhy does it take reb bentzion of bobv forever to lain mogellah?
they clap by mordechai [ modcheh duvid]
why does it take forever for satmar to lain the migeelah?
they clap by Medinah
-
AuthorPosts