Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
uneeqParticipant
bpt:But to create a post about strife? Its your perogative, but I’d focus on ideas of how to build bridges, not barriers.
I referenced to this in my post above that “Also, in a meta kinda way, the debate of whether Yiddish is (still) a true Jewish language has people arguing for a while already.”
However, I believe that by facing issues and debating them in the proper places, it would be considered building bridges and not barriers.
uneeqParticipantyitay: So why not recommend it to the friend that you originally wanted to recommend a book to?
uneeqParticipantbpt:From the OP’s choice of spelling,”mach LIO kes” (as opposed to mach LO kes), I’d say Yiddish speaking is a pretty sure thing for the OP.
I didn’t spell it mach LIO kes rather mach LOI kes. And not as opposed to to machlokes, rather machloket like I would pronounce in real life. You should know, I truly speak little yiddish, my vocabulary is limited to the yeshivish and popular words like shlepp and vaytar.
uneeqParticipantThe book that helped me greatly in the low point of my life, is The Road Less Travelled by M. Scott Peck. One of my rabbis introduced me to it and had a special session with me reading/learning from it. I slowly but surely turned around my life and am happy looking back at the changes I made.
I learnt what a true friends are, real love, disciplining one-self, and other great concepts that I have for the most part not forgotten even consciously.
uneeqParticipanti love coffee: It is not only done by the Persians but by the Sephardim in general.
Most sephardim do not do this. While I have seen persians and some morrocans doing this, I would definitely NOT say that this is the general custom of Sephardim.
uneeqParticipantGreat Bear: Do you mean that only Tawils who are Cohanim go back to Eli? There must be some Tawils who are not Cohanim considering that Jews were probably taller and healthier than Arabs and many were called Tawil which then became a surname.
I never heard of a Tawil that isn’t a Cohen so I can assume that they all got their name from some tall ancestor.
I also believe that all Maslaton’s like the one from Ahi Ezer are Cohanim.
uneeqParticipantSorry for staying on topic, but there’s a choshuv Sefardi rov that won’t let anyone kiss his hand. My friends have quoted him saying that the reason one kisses a tzaddiks hand is because of the kedusha in them from writing seforim. This particular rov never wrote a sefer, hence he never lets anyone kiss his hand.
uneeqParticipantGreat Bear: (all Dwecks are related regardless of spelling, and that includes the French Doueck spelling and Spanish Duek)
Actually that’s not true. The name had very high status back in Syria, as chief rabbis and very important people were in the family. Others have copied the name for themselves to sound choshuv. I have heard that this is the case with Dweck-Chalutzies but I am not completely sure.
Aside for the Dwecks, there’s also the Tawil and Maslaton families.
All Tawil’s trace back to Eli HaKohen. The Maslaton’s also have a very choshuv yichus but I don’t remember it anymore.
uneeqParticipantmoishy: Don’t worry too much. I doubt you would have to work hard to be the most intoxicated, od’d, snorting, harry-yeshivisher. In fact I’m not sure there are any of those harry-yeshivishers out there.
uneeqParticipantMost Overdosed, Intoxicated, Snorter, Harry Yeshivisher
uneeqParticipantI usually like the outside stuff the most. Spent an hour at night on the beach with a guitar, walking through parks, boardwalks. Coney Island is fun, my favorite is Deno’s Wonder Wheel, although the park and boardwalk are a bit scary these days.
Also, you can always check Mikomos for some great spots in practically any city.
uneeqParticipantI saw Rav Ovadia Yosef in Yechave Da’at is mattir to give a low-risk kidney donation.
uneeqParticipantUNLUCKY!
uneeqParticipantI think my current subtitle “member” is quite nice, especially compared to similar possibilities such as “dismembered” or “membrane” and “remember, remember, the fifth of november”.
So I think I’d like to stay with my current one, one that classifies me along with most of K’lal Yisroel, and to try to keep my uniqueness 😉
uneeqParticipantlongarekel: 7)it is not necessary mai’ikar hadin to wear a yarmulka.
S”A is pretty much mashma the same
–
???? ???? ????? ????? ??? ??? ?? ???? ????? ????
It’s mashma that only walking bekoma zekufa is ossur however, the next halacha is advice. I saw in halacha berura in the back that discusses it at length, and concludes that it’s only middat chassidut to wear a yarmulka.
147: Recitation of Tachnun on Yom ha’Atzmaut, and Yom Yerusholayim; Tachnun has no place in the liturgy of these 2 important holidays.
Prove to me that nowadays we can be metaken our own holidays. And I’m not talking about herzl, begin and other reshoim that have no say or place in true Torah Judiasm, but even the Gedolim nowadays don’t have that power.
uneeqParticipantThis is how you do bold
<str ong> insert text here </str ong>
This is how you do italics
<e m> insert text here </e m>
Just remember to remove the blank space in between the words “strong” and “em”
uneeqParticipantI have a hard time understanding certain aspects the issur of Ein Mevatlin by Bosser BeCholov. In a case where the meat wasn’t cooked yet with the milk, there is no issur that was created yet that has to be mevutal. So I wonder how in this case, where there is no intention to pour the milk on the meat, why would stirring it to save it from creating issur, cause an issue of ein mevatlin? Certainly I would argue that this is not a case of lekatchila being mevatel.
uneeqParticipantHealth: “Milchig-wise, Circa (Clifton Ave South) and Pizza Place (in West Gate) cannot be beat!”
And the reason I agree is because the Deal food places are so much better than the Lakewood ones!
Ummm…You seem to be neither from the Deal nor the Lakewood area. For some reason he was mentioning his favorite stores in Lakewood, so there’s no reason for you to agree with him.
uneeqParticipantYitay: Thanks. Correct me if I’m wrong, but there is no machlokeis between them, rather the S”A left it out in 104:3 and only brought it down in the B”Y beshem HaRashba, however the S”A will agree that chala and shichra are more stringent. I only saw the Kaf Hachayim because thats all I have available, and it seems that he doesn’t differentiate for Sfardim.
uneeqParticipantOn OS X, misspelled words are underlined in red. Right click on it and you get the right spelling.
uneeqParticipantyitay: The Rema says that with beer and vinegar one should be machmir and assume bugs and the like are nosen ta’am lishvach.
Thanks. What siman is this in? I would like to know what the S”A holds, being that I am sefardic.
uneeqParticipantIs the worms in a bottle of tequila considered nosein taam lifgam, or since it’s meant to be there its leshevach?
uneeqParticipantThere’s a bunch of parks you can walk around like the one on deal road. You can go to asbury park which is about 2 minutes away from deal. I recently added a bunch of things to do on mikomos in asbury park, like the boardwalk, cycling, pinball museum, glass making, and mini-golf. There’s also a boardwalk by pier village which is pretty nice.
Of course, you also have the beach, in the daytime I would go to hathaway ave as its most likely to be empty, Darlington ave or long branch at night.
Restaurants I like in deal, Down to Earth in allenhurst (healthy dairy), Ike’s Meathouse has the best deli style food around and they give really full sandwiches, 656 is a fancy restaurant but not really so worth it, stingers is the kosher bar attached to 656, or the J-Cafe in the JCC on Grant ave.
There is also Monmouth mall not so far away or you can go to Jersey Premium outlets about 10 minutes away.
Common hotels are the Ocean Place, and the Sheraton in eatontown.
If you need any other advice, ask away.
uneeqParticipantIIRC – If I Remember Correctly
DH – Dear Hubby, nothing else in this forum
E”Y – Eretz YIsroel
MO – Modern Orthodox, can be Modus Operandi (but probably not)
R”L – Rachmana Litzlan
LH – Loshon Hora
ROTFL or ROFL – Rolling On (The) Floor Laughing
VIN – Vehicle Identification Number
YWN – Yesterday Was Nice
CR – Crazy Retards or Community Rabbis
TLDR – Too Long Don’t Read, just a bunch of abbreviations
uneeqParticipantotr: All you say is correct, but you talking about hetero relations, and I am asking if there is an issur of lo sassuru when a woman looks or thinks about another woman for pleasure reasons.
uneeqParticipantMDD: Uneeq, “ma’ase eretz Mitsraim” is a z’nus-related issur.
Check my previous post, as the rambam I brought down clearly does not agree with you.
GAW: Not an American Posek. Thanks for the info, but not applicable to the OP (unless the OP lives in Israel)
I am neither a woman nor looking for a psak, so it’s not a problem. I am looking for a svara, a reason why someone would say its assur from lo sasuru. However I’ve never heard of the tznuis book. Anybody have a quote from it?
But thanks for bringing me the chinuch, as I never understood the issur of lo sasuru in that way. According to him, there is definitely an issur in our situation.
uneeqParticipantlongarekel: However the Rambam brings the halacha of ma’asei eretz mitzrayim in hilchos issurei biah which indicates that it is in the category of ‘znus’ and included in acharei eineichem.
I have found the rambam you mention in issurei biah 21:8 and he states clearly:
??”? ????? ?? ???? ??? ????? ????. ???? ?? ??? ????? ???? ??? ?? ???? ???. ????? ??? ?????? ?????? ???? ???? ??? ????? ??? ?? ???? ??? ???? ??? ????
The rambam clearly categorized this issur as NOT z’nus. Why is it in Hilchos issurei bi’ah? I would say, that although the transgressor isn’t considered a zonah, as you can see in the Magid Mishna 21:8 that we don’t pasken like rav huna that says she would be pasul for kehuna, it’s still relevant as some might think that its considered bi’ah or that it can turn a woman in to a zonah. I understand that the issur here is of going in the ways of the goyim.
I would like to see some of the sources that acharei eneichem applies to any aveiroh. I always thought that it only applied to z’nus aveiros.
uneeqParticipantMdd : And what if its not a picture but rather another woman undressed. would that be ok for a woman that has hirhurim for other women? Also i would like to see a source for all that you mention.
uneeqParticipantHealth: If it’s a case of Tzorech Godol -it pushes off the Shvus!
Actually, it’s a shvus letzorech gadol, which everyone assurs besides for possibly the debrencer rov (however you spell it) who supposedly matirs. Shvus d’shvus letzorech gadol that pretty much everyone I saw said is muttar.
uneeqParticipantLongarekel:acharei eineichem refers to looking at anything that could lead to any form of ‘prohibited relationships’ and this definitely applies to women as well.
What you refer to as “prohibited relationships” in my mind, is someone who has a relationship with an Erva. A woman with a woman is not an erva if I am not mistaken. If the whole issur of women being together is because we shouldn’t act like the mitzrim, then the avierah isn’t an erva issur, rather a “bechukosehem lo telechu” type of avierah.
Therefore the hirhur or looking at of another woman should not be an issur in itself. Hirhur avierah is not an aveirah unless the torah points it out.
uneeqParticipantSam, MDD: Thanks for the responses. However, I am asking if Lo taturu would apply for women looking at women. Many people are bringing me source that it would apply for looking at men.
Longarekel: I have to check it up. Thanks.
January 24, 2012 6:17 am at 6:17 am in reply to: question about rabbenu tam zman for ending shabbos #845621uneeqParticipantWhat’s that based on? Is it al pi din for Shabbat or is it for Tesefet Shabbat?
I really don’t know why, I can try to find out though. However, I was told it wasn’t al pi din, rather just a chumra.
uneeqParticipantI heard a tip to keep the conversation moving.
Talk about the JIFS.
Job: What jobs you have had, will have, want to have etc.
Israel: Experiences, politics, terrorists and yeshiva/seminary
Family: Family members, weddings, etc.
Summer: Experiences, what you have done/will do etc.
It worked for me!
January 23, 2012 7:11 pm at 7:11 pm in reply to: Help! Where to go on a date in Yerushalayim tomorrow? #845403uneeqParticipantlkwdfellow: Look on Mikomos.com – http://www.mikomos.com/wiki/Israel
Mikomos is really lacking mikomos in Israel. Especially for rainy days. (Feel free to contribute; you may as well get a mitzvah for all that time wasted on the internet.) I have recently added some places, but I wouldn’t really recommend it as a list until it gets fuller. Hence my contributions over here -mall, restaurant, hotel lounge, & bowling or go karting in talpiyot.
January 23, 2012 7:03 pm at 7:03 pm in reply to: question about rabbenu tam zman for ending shabbos #845618uneeqParticipantMDG: Rav Ovadia holds 72 minutes b’shaot z’maniot, which can vary depending on the time of year and latitude. So according to him 60 minutes could have been 72.
I personally know from a family member of his that he holds sha’ot zmaniot, but only lechumra. In the summer time he usually keeps 85-90 minutes and even in the winter time for some reason he doesn’t do less than 80. I was gonna write this before, but I felt no need.
January 23, 2012 12:27 pm at 12:27 pm in reply to: question about rabbenu tam zman for ending shabbos #845614uneeqParticipant147:clearly 72 minutes is way longer than the time it takes to get dark & have 3 stars emerge, therefore some fabricated Chumro cannot override any Chiyuv
Maran lived in E”Y and he paskened midina in siman 261 like rabbenu tam. Is he considered to you “a fabricator of chumros”?
Mik5:Am I yotzei with the shul’s Havdalah in this situation?
I’ve been to R’ Ovadia’s shul, who paskens like rabbenu tam, and he himself makes the havdala after 60 minutes (I think someone else drinks though). However it is mentioned in M”B to not be yotzei havdala in shul, in order to be able to get out of problems in being motzi the women. For example a woman cannot bless “borei meorei ha’esh” so in order to get out of problems of bracha lebatala it is better to not be yotzei in shul. Or you can be yotzei and let her make all the brachas besides for borei meorei haesh.
longarekel I understand that you follow the Sefardi custom and that’s fine.
Actually, many Sfardim do follow Rabbenu Tam. See chazon ovadia (I think chelek 1 page 89) where he brings down many rishonim that hold like rabbenu tam, and he paskens very strongly to hold 72. I’m actually unsure of the reasons why any Sfardi wouldn’t hold 72. The old opinion that rabbenu tam paskened only for his place is shot down by R’ Ovadia, based on the fact that Rabbenu Tam got his shitta from the machloket of tannaim living and arguing about Israel. And those who claim that it’s all based on metzius, should know that Maran saw the metzius many years and still paskened like rabbenu tam IN ISRAEL. So it shouldn’t make a difference which country you’re living in, if you hold like Maran, you should hold 72.
uneeqParticipantYou sound like you want and need a “Rebbe”, and it sounds like and he’s a maggid shiur, not a rebbe. A rebbe is a person that you have a kesher with, a person that you can talk with about gemora or about your life, even during his unpaid hours. Someone that you still talk to after leaving yeshiva.
However it’s more understood that you won’t have a kesher with a maggid shiur (in most scenarios). Most big yeshivas, the bochrim pack into a room to hear a shiur from the rov and thats it. Even if he would want to give you more time, he most probably wouldn’t be able to, even if he was the nicest person in the world.
This is probably the deciding factor between choosing a big yeshiva to a smaller one. A smaller yeshiva usually has a lower level of learning, but the cheshek is easier to attain, because there’s a connection with the rebbeim. While in a large yeshiva, the learning is most likely on a higher level, there’s a much greater need to be independent.
January 22, 2012 1:19 pm at 1:19 pm in reply to: Help! Where to go on a date in Yerushalayim tomorrow? #845393uneeqParticipantBased on the US-Israel time difference, you probably won’t get the mods to approve the responses in time. I suggest you ask a friend, or maybe the MODS can give you my email address.
January 22, 2012 11:06 am at 11:06 am in reply to: Help! Where to go on a date in Yerushalayim tomorrow? #845389uneeqParticipantI would suggest either malcha mall, go to a restaurant (I can give you suggestions), a hotel lounge, & bowling or go karting in talpiyot.
uneeqParticipantOneOfMany-Nice once!
Mods- Am i unique enough to deserve a subtitle? Maybe something like -unique but not *SPECIAL* , or -unique-just like everybody else.
uneeqParticipantICOT-That vote was taken by a few hundred voters out of the million plus contributors to the site. Several voters disagreed quite strongly.
First of all it was 1,800 voters, more than the few hundred that you mention. Second, anybody who really cared about it could have joined in the vote. The overwhelming majority were either supporting or strongly supporting the vote. I’m sure that many people saw the vast amount of supporters and got too lazy (try scrolling down the page) to support something so obviously (in their mind) right. So what if a couple of people disagree. That’s what discussions are about. And as wikipedia notes, it had by far the largest participation of a community discussion ever. And about the money that people donate-they donate it so that wikipedia can democratically run itself as it has since the beginning. If they wanted to complain, they could have done so easily enough.
But that knowledge has to be published somewhere for anyone to find and use it. Where it can be censored without due process, it hurts the speaker, the public, and Wikimedia. Where you can only speak if you have sufficient resources to fight legal challenges, or, if your views are pre-approved by someone who does, the same narrow set of ideas already popular will continue to be all anyone has meaningful access to.”
Therefore, I think that if someone is legislatively trying to get rid of half the attractions AND double your expenses of maintaing the playground, I feel you would be making a big mistake for not trying to get as much exposure as possible of the negativity of the legislation.
All in all, I respect your second post. Thanks.
uneeqParticipantThe wikipedia editors and community voted on it and decided to block the site today. That’s good enough.
uneeqParticipantSoliek: now ordinarily i wouldnt nitpick as much, but i know that you got those sentences from wikipedia where the grammar is explained in great detail and you therefore should have known better.
I did know better. I was going for shock value, so naturally I didn’t put in the punctuation.
uneeqParticipantI’m veering off a bit, but how about some of the most interesting, grammatically valid sentences-
Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo.
James while John had had had had had had had had had had had a better effect on the teacher.
uneeqParticipantHealth-how come Hello99 & DY are speaking to the issue and not you? Since you ran out what to answer you resort to rank outs.
I responded to you no less than 3 times. If you count the responses of the others, you have been responded and answered correctly more than 10 times. I am surprised that they haven’t run out of patience yet. It’s about time that you wake up. Others have complained about you in other places about this same exact issue. (see latest post in kanoyim campain by BTguy)
Parts of 3 different posts-
1) There are at least a couple issues at hand-
1) issur bishul of the heating elements
2) issur bishul of the cholent
You may argue that the heating elements don’t reach the deoraysa -glowing red hot- level, although according to the famous chazon ish, “chatzi shiur m’doraysa” and therefore even if it will never glow its still an Issur deoraysa. etc…
2) The problem of amira leakum is simpler. You cannot tell a goy to do a melacha for you on shabbos.
So as long as it’s not fully cooked, or it’s cold, it would be a definite Issur. etc…
3) Health- I mentioned what you said over here already (see right below). Although as DY points out, there is still an Issur of bishul. I pointed that out too. Only if it’s fully cooked AND still not-cold/hot will it be muttar to tell a goy. etc…
Almost as mature as any member of the Sikrikim whom you said that you hope they all are jailed.
Nice misquote of what I said. All I mentioned there is that its good that one of the bullys is off the local streets. I never said that I was happy that he’s in jail. And I never said all the sikrikim should be thrown in jail, even though that might bring the geula faster than I can pack my luggages.
uneeqParticipantWell said BTGuy!
uneeqParticipantHealth-A Crock Pot does neither; so it’s only Bishul or Aish D’rabbonon.
Since this is the case -Ameira L’acum is Mutter L’tzorech Godol.
hello99, DY: It’s clear from here (and other places) that Health has not the slightest clue about hilchos bishul. I’m not even sure how to respond to the unyielding “amaratzus”, without giving a 10 hour introduction course to Hilchos Shabbos.
A Poisek isn’t s/o who always finds an Issur. A Poisek is s/o who finds an Ousgehaltene Kula.
Apparently, anybody who has learnt more than Health, is suddenly surging with religious-zealot-hormones and has to blindly assur things. If only he knew…
uneeqParticipantHealth-And what I’m telling you is – Rav Moshe is a Chiddush regarding cooking in a microwave -you have no proof to apply this elsewhere.
To be a D’oraisa it has to be similar to Meleches Hamishkon -cooking in a crock pot ISN’T similar!
There are at least a couple issues at hand-
1) issur bishul of the heating elements
2) issur bishul of the cholent
You may argue that the heating elements don’t reach the deoraysa -glowing red hot- level, although according to the famous chazon ish, “chatzi shiur m’doraysa” and therefore even if it will never glow its still an Issur deoraysa.
Even if that wasn’t an issue, the cold chulent even if completely cooked would be ossur deoraysa to reheat, because of the Issur of Bishul Achar Bishul Be’Lach (liquids). However, if the chulent is hot, if it isn’t fully cooked yet, there is still the simple Issur of Bishul. As long as something isn’t cooked fully you can be OVER on bishul deoraysa. So no, you wouldn’t be able to tell a goy to turn it on in these scenarios.
uneeqParticipantHealth-There also isn’t a problem of Ameiras L’acum because Cholent is the main course. So to have a Cholent on Shabbos in a crock pot (where cooking is only M’drabbonon because of electricity) would be a Tzorech Godol -where Ameira L’acum is Mutter by an Issur D’rabbonon.
I mentioned what you said over here already (see right below). Although as DY points out, there is still an Issur of bishul. I pointed that out too. Only if it’s fully cooked AND still not-cold/hot will it be muttar to tell a goy.
The problem of amira leakum is simpler. You cannot tell a goy to do a melacha for you on shabbos.
So as long as it’s not fully cooked, or it’s cold, it would be a definite Issur. I’m assuming that you can get around the amira leakum problem, though. If the chulent is fully cooked and gets turned off in middle of shabbos, if it’s still piping hot, or according to ashkenazim, not cold yet, a goy would probably be able to put turn it back on (trei derabanan letzorach mitzva).
uneeqParticipantHealth- Assuming, arguendo, that he is/was still a member of the sikrikim and he is Oiver Oy L’resha Oy L’schaino
So it took me three posts to get you to admit the truth, even though you didn’t apologize. Now YWN can do the same and admit their mistake and they should also apologize!
As you can tell, I am only assuming for arguments sake (since I don’t have evidence on hand to prove to others) that he isn’t a criminal. Again, good riddance can mean that I am happy that he’s away and the problem is partially solved. Not necessarily that I’m happy that he’s in prison.
-
AuthorPosts