Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
np. I like his pshat, too.
anti- I’m not being cynical. I’m simply stating that a person who feels that wearing a white shirt on weekdays is kneged the gemara, and accordingly are makpid on themselves not to wear one doesnt mean that they can apply that chumrah to me. And if they will respond that they think its a mifurash’ gemara, then I answer that there are gedolim who wear it themselves and permit their talmidim to wear it, too. And so, please dont force your chumras on me.
whoops sorry. But i have seen this as a shat before. i just looked it up in artscroll. gasp. Quote-“Young men and also maidens.” The use of the word vigam,and also, is noteworthy.The Psalmist does not say that young men and women will be together,because such mingling would be immodest.” (Sefer Chassidim)
yes,yes. Shame of all of us.
yup.thats a pshat from R shamshon raphael hirsch ztl I think.
Logician- I cant figure out what you wrote.
Yakov l- if you pour FIRST, before drinking, after the bracha, then its not pagum. if you make a bracha and then drink and then pour into cup b its pagum. if you drink from the same cup after the same bracha, its ok.
and you mixed up what i wrote- the MB is mifurash.
If you pour into another cup- cup b- the wine in b isnt pagum and doesnt need adding. once a cup is drunk from, it becomes pagum. clear enough?
it feels like mexico.
its an excuse to get hammered.why do they farbreng. seriously.
mr. Leider- The poskm say two reasons why youre wrong. 1. The original kli wasnt made to be used many times and your decision does not remake the kli. 2. R moshe says that any kli that is used simply because the thing being stored in it needs a kli doesnt need tvila.
The MB is mifurash on the subject of kos pagum. With regard to many people drinking from one cup, the shaar tzion says its ok, but if you want to pour into a different cup you must add wine. Or you can pour to another cup and then drink from the kos.
Darn, I thought this was gonna be a drum thread. O well.
cherry- R Gedalia schorr in his sefer ohr gedalyahu explains the reason we make a vort. And its not some warm and fuzzy im in galus reason. A bar mtzva isnt celebrating a birthday, its celebrating that a person is now a mitzuveh vi’oiseh. zayin adar is also Moshe rabbeinu’s yuhrtzeit, and thats why most people celebrate it. Lubavitchers celebrate the rebbes b day cuz hes not dead, so he cant have a yuhrtzeit. anything else?
147…
The rabbanim mentioned above know all the gemaras you bring down better then you, and still allow their talmidim to wear white shirts, imagine that! I guess theyre not nervous of going against the gemara. maybe you shouldn’t be, either. And if you are, your personal chumra shouldnt keep others from wearing white shirts, ok?
Gabi- you wish that was the worst of it.
yit- And the chasam sofer’s not so humble opinion is not like you. BTW, the havana in celebrating yamim tovim is not that they are anniversaries of anything- go ask your rabbeim about that.
they have a very weird blueprint for a husband-wife relationship. if he doesnt plan on keeping their weirdnesses then fine, but you should have them ask specifics. you’d be very surprised. And for those on here that will call me a hater, you should ask someone who is involved and knows what they do. You would be very surprised.
147- or youj just spewed up a nice coincidence with which to further your anti-dass-torah shittos. And make fun of the Chasam sofer. Not a smart move.
“I circumvent issues of starving all Shabbos morning V eating before going to Shul to say my prayers, and circumvent issues of having 2 meals on a short Shabbos afternoon almost in immediate succesion.” What am i misunderstanding.
Itch- So youre saying S’A isnt important. Could you further elaborate on your stance on the S”A’s relevance in daily life?
after?
Go learn S’A- youre not allowed to be stuffed before your seuda on shabbos morning. Thats how you handle it. See? Halachah cares about your wife more then your kiddush experience.
147- How exactly did you eat before shachris. Its assur.
I’m not coming to argue against the chasam sofer (if its true), but I heard from a rebbi that the only place we find a birthday party in the Torah is by paroh. And he was bad.
usually between 2-3 bottles of wine.
Aom- your point about the back of the bus isnt accurate. The nk arent behind it, even if they agree with it.
Wolf- Your second point is totally irrelevent. Who cares if it’s off topic- halacha is halacha.
But you can be bothered to carry your kindle.
sam2- yay. your not afraid to drop a sidur. if it falls it wont smash into itty bitty pieces and have you going to best buy or searching online for a new one. why do you nitpick when youre maskim?
This woman is everything in america that is wrong.
I want 147 to see this.
knock knock. knock knock.
Wifey ,”Slicha, ba’ali lo babayit.” knock knock. knock knock.
zdad-your more afraid to drop it. your post is, once again, disappointing.
Dont know. But theres a street in toronto that been called this since i can remember- so thats at least one thing brooklyn didnt have first. haha. lol
Its not a mitzva to hold it. The cheftza isnt a chaftza shel mitzva, and you dont need to hold it to be mikayim your mitzva.
In th home, its important that children see a level of affection between parents, ie. being called dear,holding hands, hugs and pecks on the cheek. BUT, outside your home, why are you flaunting the most personal thing in your life? Do you really need to show the world that you’re attracted to each other? yuch.
As far as i remember, theres a mifurash’ halachah stating that it is asur to daven while holding an expensive item, because kavana will be difficult as a person will be mashgiach on it. why would this be different?
Im bumping this again because I have an agenda.
You gotta wonder, how much are their shverrs shtelling?
147- Funny point you raised about motzei shabbos megillah. The gemara in megillah says that one of the reasons we dont read the megillah on shabbos is because the aniyim so much look forward to the tzedaka they recieve and theyll miss out if you read it on shabbos. So maybe your right. And maybe your cynicism is unwarranted.
yuch. Feminism strikes again.
Mods the language being used here isnt fit for the teens and children that we are told time and again use this site. please mod the comments or delete the thread.
I shudder when I type in two words and see how the goyishe’ velt usually ends off my sentence.
Im just saying what i heard. i dont know.
There’s supposed to be a karaite temple thingy in the old city, with a klala theyd never get a minyan. They have nine men, and whenever they give birth to a boy one of the men dies.
147- How you managed to take my post so out of context is beyond me. I made two clear points.
1. That one of the reasons people get mad at these mishulachim is because they can’t fathom the degree of poverty the collectors live in and, if they would try to put themselves in the collectors shoes, maybe they wouldnt get so mad.
2. People need to take a look at their motives for scowling at the mishulach. Do they brush them off because theyre a nuisance or because its in middle of davening.
I hope i’ve cleared up whatever threw you off.
Zeeskite youre making me feel guilty
bump