Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Shopping613 🌠Participant
I think in high school there should be in depth classes about tzniyis. In seminary we had an entire week dedicated to it. We had 10 lessons with a Rav and posek and we learned the halachot and hashkafa inside from the very first time it’s mentioned in the torah till today….
We had many more classes… But yeah.
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantI agree 100 percent. I beleive I wrote this on the other thread- you can agree to disagree. As long as you don’t ilegitimize the school. Meaning saying they are wrong, bad etc.
For the most part though, you should agree with the majoirty of things…
Your father could of added “I beleive you are right, the Rebbi probably made a mistake, or he thought you were talking about something else, or there really are two Avimelech’s” etc.I don’t think you should ever say “he was wrong” and that’s it. Unless it’s something really horrible, like getting thrown out and publicly shamed for something very small- then you should speak to the principal…and your kid.
I’m saying, always try to add things, be dan lkaf zchut, and show how this is gray and can be interpreted differently.
September 6, 2017 6:56 am at 6:56 am in reply to: Ok…About The Whole Hair Measuring Thing…Please Help Me Understand 👧📏✂️ #1356263Shopping613 🌠ParticipantChabadgal I agree. But the problem there wasn’t the rules. It was how they gave punishments. You could have threes rules and still make that mistake and you could have 76 rules and give consequenses is a not traumatizing your kid for life type of thing.. Two desperate issues completely.
It was stopped… At a price. Thousands of people have seen the video, and people are making a mockery of this type of Judaism.
I’m saying it’s stupid to have an outrage online. If you truly think your kid is being degraded go do something useful!!! Don’t you think your older kids didn’t see people bashing online if you grant them Internet access? You helped share the negetivity by bashing it.
I disagree fs12.
Rules are important. Hashkafah is important too. Why can’t we focus on both? Surely if a school is focusing on only rules that would be bad. But actually in the case of this Lakewood school I see a lot of people annoyed. Read the mailbag on the homepage of a mom who is extremely happy with their chinuch a a claims her daughter has a strong hashkafah and love.Of course that clip didn’t go viral. Why I assume they only focused on rules? From a 3p second viral clil? They learn 8 hours a day.
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantI’ve been so many cities here that have central air. In beit shemesh, Yerushalayim, beitar etc. Almosy all new apartments have it.
September 5, 2017 8:58 pm at 8:58 pm in reply to: The Downsides to Mega sized Yeshivos & kollelim #1356045Shopping613 🌠ParticipantHmmm maybe a solution would be to make smaller rooms… Like classrooms all in one building. At least you could get to know the people in your room
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantWell when I get married I’ll make sure whoever does the music knows what a safe level is. I’ll find someone knowledgeable in the area and known for playing at safe levels…
You’re all invited! Now I just need to find a chassan….
September 5, 2017 8:57 pm at 8:57 pm in reply to: Ok…About The Whole Hair Measuring Thing…Please Help Me Understand 👧📏✂️ #1356036Shopping613 🌠ParticipantDY. I agree with both points. Especialy the last one. I see POV of the other side.. I just think it’s wrong. It’s stupid and immature to bash things online like this. Wash just trying to show how stupid the idea of bashing them really is.
Basically trolls.
Under the guise of “this is why people go OTD”
ACTUALLY that sounds a lot like Joseph and Rebyidd…I have coined a new term.
Frum soldier trolls.I am a genious lol
September 5, 2017 7:14 pm at 7:14 pm in reply to: Ok…About The Whole Hair Measuring Thing…Please Help Me Understand 👧📏✂️ #1355753Shopping613 🌠ParticipantDY:
1. Genuine concern? People make it out like this is abuse, which it most definitely is not. If you think it is, don’t send your kid there. If you are sending your kids there, it’s not abuse…unless you think your abusive for sending them to an abusive school.
2. I used to have sources…I could most definitely get them. Speaking as a girl, not yet married- I personal have struggled with hair. I don’t just cut my hair off for nothing. I truly beleive long hair is not tzniyudsik. Sure it’s a chumrah, but it has basis, not kihalacha per say but more like something that isn’t advised and brings negetivity, and pritzus to the world… (last I checked I’m pretty sure the Zohar said that…plus there are some other sources. Plus on another note, my hair is actually bright. It’s red. It’s curly. If it’s long you can see it from 3 blocks away (I’ve had people tell me that beofre)….definitely falls under “eye catching”. Hair also smells good after showering, and the longer it is the more scent it takes up…point is I’m saying it’s not bidavka the length, it’s what comes out as a direct link from the length.
3. Sure it’s not comfortable, life isn’t always comfortable. But it’s a school rule. They aren’t always comfortable either. Like wearing nude tights in middle of the winter in Yerushalayim when it is snowing!!
4. If you really cared, and it truly bothered you, and you truly did not agree with the school you’d move elsewhere for your kids’ chinuch’ sake….just saying. Or you would shut your mouth. You wouldn’t blow up on twitter and push your kids to be negetive toward their own school.
5. What is venting going to do? Make you feel better? Why do it online? Why cause this uproar? If you have a problem, why publisize it for no reason? If you cared enough you would take action, call the school, etc….you obviously don’t care if you are making an uproar…to just vent. Do you feel better after venting on the internet in a anonymous comment senction maybe 600 people will actually read?6. If you don’t know the school…why do you care?
7. Agreed. lol.Chabadgal:
1. It’s online…close enough.
2. Aha….okay. I read it, maybe missed that part. I thought they were okay with long hair being OUT.
3. Yes, I don’t agree with it either. At least not publicly….but yeah, I’m saying this isn’t a new concept. But the internet thinks it is.
4. Um you know….to other schools. They exist.
5. That’s true, but that was done by an askan from lakewood. Why did it have to be a public issue worldwide?
6. Good
7. Many many many frum schools have chumros, we weren’t allowed cellphones in high school (even kosher ones) or technically we had to call before going to babysit and ask if they had any secular books, media, movies, music, magazines, or newspapers…oh and unfiltered internet. If they said yes to any we weren’t allowed to babysit. Or if they let us use any electronics…
If you don’t agree with chumros, don’t send your kids there. Chumros isn’t new. I have yet to see a BY without chumros in their rule book. What makes this chumrah different?ubiquitin
1. See DY answer
2. Ditto
3. They have a rule, this doesn’t look so public. It looks like there’s a line, it’s not a ceremony or a football game where everyone is watching. They just need to check it…
4. Ditto
5. Ditto
6. Ditto I guess
7. Ditto…September 5, 2017 4:48 pm at 4:48 pm in reply to: Ok…About The Whole Hair Measuring Thing…Please Help Me Understand 👧📏✂️ #1355642Shopping613 🌠ParticipantSyag- the way they threw him out was definitely wrong. No matter what rule you break. That has nothing to do with what he did. A school should never throw out and embaress someone publicly. Sorry if I didn’t mention that part. I was just thinking about how we got sent home in high school for socks and shoes…but it was never like that.
September 5, 2017 11:45 am at 11:45 am in reply to: Ok…About The Whole Hair Measuring Thing…Please Help Me Understand 👧📏✂️ #1354928Shopping613 🌠ParticipantI’be got two minutes to add to syags post.
I do think it would be better if things were outlines better. In 12th grade my school totally redid the rule book and separating things under 3 catrgories;
– uniform/ in school rules
– halacha
– hashkafa aka chumrah.How a bas yisroel should act out of school and rules about Internet etc was a seperate. And everyth8bg has sources or letters from rabanim in the rule phamlet.
If your school doesn’t do this perhaps call them up and request them to. When I send my kids to school one day I will ask them to do that and even offer to write the phamlet for them. 8f that doesn’t go well i would sit with my kids and go through each rule and have a discussion.
Whoever got thrown out for wearing the wrong pair of socks that was about uniform. He knew he could get thrown out as did we when we tried to skirt the rules. No one was surprised.
Parents should take the responsibility to make sure there kids adhere to uniform and let them know if they skirt the rules any issues are their fault.
September 5, 2017 10:54 am at 10:54 am in reply to: Ok…About The Whole Hair Measuring Thing…Please Help Me Understand 👧📏✂️ #1354873Shopping613 🌠ParticipantHey golfer
So basically I think what is causing kids to go OTD is when they hear contradictory things. Such as hearing a rule from a school then hearing their own parents bash it by saying it’s wrong, unbiased on hlacha, bad, extreme, etc.What causes a stable kid is when the important people in their life are on the same page and they listen to the child and their needs. Not every kid should go to the same high school or yeshiva.
Of course you can disagree with some decisions or rules. But you need to do it nicely. With the agree to disagree attitude. Not negativity and outright put downs that confuse the child. Forgrt it if the entire Internet is bashing a child’s authority figure….
Oh and DY I have questions back for yours. I’m just on busses and out so I can’t write that now. Bezras Hashem I can respond in a few hours.
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantOk I’m here.
Welcome newbie, I have faith in your survival.Shopping613 🌠ParticipantI think though, where the majority still have kosher phones with no text even, in Israel- they will keep coming up with solutions. Here they have kosher smart phones, etc, but I think they will survive a good while without smartphones of any sort. Although the other people who live here aren’t too happy at having to change things and work with people who don’t have smartphones, they make it possible to do things and the goverment is quite aware of this large group who doesn’t have smartphones. So they make more machines, up phone hotlines, and do things that will work without a smartphone.
September 1, 2017 6:37 am at 6:37 am in reply to: sub-titles and privacy !SAY NO TO SUB-TITLES #1352797Shopping613 🌠ParticipantMany others have rejected them. I have a theory about subtitles and rejection somewhere around the CR. I beleive I made a thread about it once.
RebYidd, want to find it? lol You seem to be good at that.
September 1, 2017 6:37 am at 6:37 am in reply to: Is it unethical for mods to change your subtitle without your permission? #1352795Shopping613 🌠ParticipantThink you missed a few subtitle threads…I know there’s more than what you bumped…
Shopping613 🌠Participant@chabadgal
It’s not just the ease of getting somewhere bad, and being oiyver on the issur “so sitain michshol” (to yourself, if you don’t have all the nessesary filters). You can get inapropriate things sent by whatsapp now, sent around to frum people. I myself have gotten many things- the most recent a man singing along with some of the dirtiest songs, and then showing how he thinks he’e singing, verus what how he sounds to everyone else. Cute, but I did not want to hear thosae songs, nor did I know they would be in the clip.
Many people are against instant messaging as it is addictive, and ruins relationships. Do you suggest we all have smartphones that don’t have any instant messaging? Social media is horrible too. So is youtube. Email is distracting on the go. Games are addictive.
It’s like setting yourself up for failing, There’s too many ways to fall. Why put yourself in that position?
Myabe you need a chainsaw, but do you need a chainsaw, knife, gun, and army tank all in 1? and in the same place?
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantMagen Avot boys is more dati leumi, sending afterwards to army and yeshiva together, doing bagruyot, etc.
I can talk high schools, is that what you want?
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantMazel tov! Where do I go? lol….
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantI have great yichus, I’m a descendant of Avraham Avinu and Moshe Rabeinu- how good can it get?
I’m also descendant from the chassam sofer apparently. We aren’t sure how, but it’s highly probable.
Shopping613 🌠Participanthey
August 21, 2017 4:30 pm at 4:30 pm in reply to: Let’s Hock About The Woman On The Bus Who Refused To Move #1343633Shopping613 🌠ParticipantHuh, wonder if that was me.
August 21, 2017 2:25 pm at 2:25 pm in reply to: Let’s Hock About The Woman On The Bus Who Refused To Move #1343600Shopping613 🌠ParticipantHooligans are worse. I was on a bus with a bunch last month, 11.30 PM blasting the latest horrible song on a public bus…..
August 21, 2017 12:01 pm at 12:01 pm in reply to: Let’s Hock About The Woman On The Bus Who Refused To Move #1343534Shopping613 🌠ParticipantIf SOME girls? More like 75 percent of young girls.
It’s not just buses, it’s everywhere. Execpt that you aren’t forced to sit next to them for 40 minutes to 4 hours.August 21, 2017 7:27 am at 7:27 am in reply to: Let’s Hock About The Woman On The Bus Who Refused To Move #1343278Shopping613 🌠ParticipantLeft to right is a stupid idea. Forget the clothes issue and assume the men will look the other way, women and young girls like myself can be extremely loud, yelling, hugging, talking, etc. I am guilty of doing many of these although I’m trying to work on it. Especially for me, I have an issue where I cannot sense when I’m being too loud or too quiet, my friends remind me a lot when i don’t even realize I’m talking so loud.
1. There’s more than one bus company. If you are pregnant-take another company. Or sit in the middle-as in the front of the women’s half.
2. I’ve been on MANY mehadrin buses and I see couples all the time-sitting together in the middle of the bus.August 21, 2017 7:26 am at 7:26 am in reply to: Eclipse! Freaking out about driving during the eclipse. #1343277Shopping613 🌠ParticipantThe thing is your brain is tricked into thinking its safe when is reality the radiation from looking at the sun it twice or even triple the normal ammount. A second or two can cause partial blindless.
August 16, 2017 8:56 am at 8:56 am in reply to: Which CR Poster do you want to meet in real life? #1339934Shopping613 🌠ParticipantActually i if I could carry 613 shopping bags….
August 16, 2017 5:01 am at 5:01 am in reply to: Which CR Poster do you want to meet in real life? #1339903Shopping613 🌠ParticipantK so when we meeting at the kosel? I’m game. Lol
Am I supposed to yell out my screename or what? Or am I supposed to just carry like 50 shopping bags…..August 15, 2017 9:15 am at 9:15 am in reply to: Which CR Poster do you want to meet in real life? #1339262Shopping613 🌠ParticipantHm…. PBA, lightbright, TAOM, Shticky, RebYidd, LF, Oomis, Joseph, and like everyone!
LF I live here! lol
Edited
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantAnyone can get as long as they want one. Age and colors are based off of where they are holding in ther tzniyus and what they want.
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantI’ve said this before here. I broke through k9 as a kid and so did many of my friends. If you have kids, GET SEOMTHING ELSE.
That said, as an adult who won’t spend 15-40 minutes breaking it, it’s really good and nice. You can get certain sites whitelisted.
BTW youtube itself has a “kid friendly” filter. Do a google on it.
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantWow. I didn’t even bother reading the comments. This thread boggles my mind. I mean, Joseph you must be having a good day. Such an insane post to a very obvious question needs no reply….
Nice to see PBA, it’s been months…or even a year or two when I last saw your name round town. No wonder this thread has actually been continued if PBA is here.
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantThe uninformed do not understand the title
August 7, 2017 6:34 am at 6:34 am in reply to: Smartphone Vegetables! It’s Soooo Sad! 📱🍆🍠🥕🌽🌶️🍅🥒🍄😢 #1333372Shopping613 🌠ParticipantActually there’s another point about texting, that most people are actually addicted to it. I’m no exaggerating. You see your brain is very smart, it learns slowly slowly that when it hears a ‘ping’, someone is messaging them, and that makes them feel good. It makes them feel wanted, needed, popular, etc. You ussually check your phone if not immediately, within the next few minutes, and when you do you get a rush of “feel good” hormones. Your brain understands that to checking the phone feels good, and it brings a rush of that to you.
That’s why it’s so hard to not check your phone, your brain may be hardwired to do so. Don’t worry though, Hashem made our brain very flexible and you can rewire it by training it to wait to see texts, etc. And don’t give me “But it might be important”. Do yourself a favor and give your spouse and other important people a seperate ring tone and ping noises, if you aren’t expecting anything important-it’s probably not.
August 6, 2017 7:34 am at 7:34 am in reply to: Smartphone Vegetables! It’s Soooo Sad! 📱🍆🍠🥕🌽🌶️🍅🥒🍄😢 #1333030Shopping613 🌠ParticipantThis isn’t everywhere. In Israel the majority don’t accept smartphones, and if they have any type of device that is kosher and can do other things, a lot can’t text still or have whatsapp.
I read a study about how just having your phone out in visible sight during a conversation can affect the other person and how they veiw you and how they think you respect them.
I tell people I’m friends with that I’m going to hang out with them only if they put their phone away. I make sure the majority of my time with them is spent face to face, second in line phone/skype, and afterwards messaging. If messaging ends up taking up more time, I’ll limit it. I’ll “not be avialable” in middle of a text conversation I’ll say “Hey, I want to talk about it like fact to face, let’s wait till then and change the subject” or “i MISS your voice, let’s talk” or “my hands hurt from typing” or “I gotta clean my room, but I want to talk to you, so let’s speak over the phone and I can do both!” etc.
You aren’t a slave to yourself, to society, to anyone. If it’s harming your life, get rid of it. Be honest with yourself and don’t think about “what they’ll say” and I promise anyone who drops you cuz you can’t text, whatsapp, etc isn’t a real friend.
If you live far apart you can email, like people write letters, you can talk on the phone, video chat on skype, or hangouts or lots of other stuff.
August 4, 2017 10:13 am at 10:13 am in reply to: Do any frum poets know how to write anything other than free verse? #1332659Shopping613 🌠ParticipantI write poetry, as a kid I did not know free verse existed till about 8th grade. I used to love haiku’s, couplets, and some other names I can’t remember.
I also like writing the one that can go up to down and down to up (Don’t know the name), a lot of my poetry are also songs so they definitely rhyme!
In any case, why would you make such a generalization? Where do you even view frum poetry?!
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantSem was the best thing that ever happened to me. Not sure yet about the future, living in Israel it’s very possible to get by without a degree, but I’m not sure what I’ll do just yet.
Baruch Hashem I am busy, I’m not online so often since I still don’t have a computer so everytime I come here, sign in, post, sign out, delete history, etc.
How is life by you?
July 31, 2017 4:48 pm at 4:48 pm in reply to: Fromer Friends from Yeshiva avoid me (troll thread) #1330128Shopping613 🌠ParticipantThis is so sad.
We need moshiach.Shopping613 🌠ParticipantBh it is!
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantWow I was not expecting such a response! You guys!!!!!!
@Streekgeek, it’s wonderful to hear you are married. But we went through that…I hope I still have your email from when you tracked me down IRL….(If I don’t, you know where to find mine, please email me!) I beleive we did help each other surive, I found some old threads and was shocked to see how close we all really were.
@TAOM, OMG I’m so happy you actually responded!!! I wish there was a way I could contact you off site, I remember so much from back then, I want to hear about how you are doing today!!! It sounds like things are a lot better, I wish I got a more detailed response but that’s how this site is.Yeah 29 and 127 have given me a lot of advice too….
Back on my track of life, I was in sem this past year and it was really good for me. Idk what’s next for me, but I’m making a lot of decisions and taking responsibility for everything now. I’m an adult…yeah, it’s not easy.
July 27, 2017 6:32 am at 6:32 am in reply to: Requesting information about frumteens and R’ Yaakov Shapiro (hear me out mods!) #1326033Shopping613 🌠ParticipantWell I’m seeing all this information way too late. I had a vision that this wouldn’t get posted and I checked and well…I guess it took a while for them to let it through and by that time I had stop checking the CR cuz I figured it wasn’t going through.
Ok I actually learned a few things thanks stalking, um I mean researching online.
I actually managed to track down Rabbi Shapiro and speak to him myself.About being anonymous: This site was started in the 1990’s when that’s what worked for people, every blogger was anonymous and people followed them.
2. He wanted people to listen to him, not because he had a fancy name (he is a huge masmid of Rabbi Shneur Kotler (Son of Rabbi Aron Kotler) (who actually told Rabbi Shapiro to create the site) but because what he was saying actually made sense.
3. It was huge back then, he didn’t want people stalking him, and he said although he was anonymous many people found him and sent him hate mail, threatening him (for making their kids frummer and “extremist” (oh you mean chareidi?) and his children.I spoke to some Rabbis from my seminary, from Aish, and from other places that are very credible and a lot even knew him and praised his work very well.
If you aren’t chareidi then you may find his hashkafa not your type, but that doesn’t mean he’s bad.
Why was it shut down? Well he transfered to an updated site called JewsWithQuestions, but when the internet asifa happened they lost 50 percent of their traffic and people just stopped coming. He also didn’t have time, it was his students and other people he supervised that did frumteens.
When I spoke to Rabbi Shapiro he actually praised me for being so cautious about using and trusting his site. I was extremely cautious when I called him and told him that I want to know who he thinks he is, and how can I know if he’s credible. (I really asked such a big Rabbi that…I needed to know) again he said that the formula was helpful 10 years ago, but the world is different now and anyone going online has a good reason to be cautious as there is no credible information online about him, his website, etc.
Sam2, as with anything in the frum world, everyone is so different. You create a formula or a system that helps 90 percent of people, there’s always the ones that need something different. I’m sorry, but that’s not a condemnation of him.
Syag, he’s saying that this was online, no names, nothing. It could not of hurt that much. Most kids have enough self esteem not to take anything online that seriously.
I hope this sheds some light on this.
One last point, when speaking to my principal from seminary (a well known BY seminary, plus my principal speaks in many other seminaries like Darchei Binah, Pninim, Seminar, etc.) he told me that Rabbi Shapiro is chariedi, but represents someone with extreme veiws. His veiws aren’t wrong, but sometimes if you aren’t chariedi yourself you will find his veiws “exteme”.Shopping613 🌠ParticipantTo everyone,
Perhaps I was upset because I am aware how bad chat rooms really are, and it is really a negative thing to see a thread calling this place a chat room. This baruch hashem is nothing like a chat room, and the title is very misleading to anyone who knows what a real chat room is.Randomex- I myself see many problems, but everyone is holding in different places. I could sit here and tell every poster what I think is wrong about their hashkafa and how they are talking. (Not every poster, I’m exaggerating of course. I mean to say that I myself do so many things wrong…)
In the case of any frum place, a magazine, website- the moderators and website need to a set a tone of what their hashkafah is. You can’t run a place based on every user. So it may be true that there’s loshon hora, and other things, and I surely don’t agree with that. But I don’t agree with things in Mishpacha magazine too, or AMI magazine, but I still read it. I don’t agree with the way all of my friends talk, but they are still my friends. I just make sure the majority of the people and things I’m very close to are helping bring me up.
So again, true there may be things that we both can agree are completely assur to say or do (like loshon hora), not everyone is holding there, and not everyone is so makpid, etc. And although you may counter that the website needs to set the tone, they do. They are setting a tone. I’ve had posts blocked.
Just because it’s not exactly your tone or my tone or anyone’s tone is okay.
Shopping613 🌠Participantbump
Shopping613 🌠Participant***************************Bumpppppppppppppppppppp*************************
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantHey, I just got back from sem.
I know it’s tough but you can do it,
Letakein girl, nice seeing you around again.Shopping613 🌠ParticipantDear Haimy,
Look, there was a thread just like this a few months back. EVERYONE THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A FORUM/MESSAGE BOARD AND CHAT ROOM! Please get yourself educated before you condemn something. A chat room is more like a highly inappropriate version of whatsapp groups. Chat rooms are known to be horrible places nowadays. It’s immediate conversations that are one or two lines with an ability personally message anyone in the group.
This is a forum. There are many frum forum. GuardYourEyes has a forum, Imamother has a forum. These forums are conversations and discussions that are often longer than a few lines. They are moderated, and there is no way to personally contact anyone off the forum. There is no way to share personal information.
About your feelings towards the way people treat each other and the topics discussed-I don’t vouch for anyone here. This is the internet, it’s 2017. Everyone has different hashkafos, chumros, etc, and well you may be holding where another one isn’t. But that isn’t a condemnation of forums, it’s a condemnation of all frum materials. I have the same issues with frum magizines and any frum website. You take 500 hashkafos and expect them to share and agree on everything…hahahaha
Basically get a tough skin and continue here at your own risk. There is nothing wrong with the forum or you, it’s the objective reality of being thrown into a mold with everyone else you may not necessarily agree with.
That;s allShopping613 🌠ParticipantNothing that is frum media and has more than 3 people working on it can be given a label of any sort. This includes forums, magazines, websites, etc.
You stuff everyone who “calls” themselves yeshivish, chareidi, frum, orthodox, ultra orthodox, modern orthodox, and dati leumi machmir into one box and expect them to all have the same hashkafos.
And when they don’t everyone is shocked.
Give me a break. Everyone has a different definition of yeshivish and every other label. Everyone has different chumros, values, and hashkafos.All any media, website, or magazine can do is attempt to run with guidance from a small select group of rabanim and call themselves whatever those rabanim do.
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantHi mod. Thanks for your critique on my posts. I appreciate the mesaage, honestly. I am also glad that you did no delete the entire thread, rather posted your thoughts. It is much apperciated.
I think that if men are looking to listen to women, they aren’t exactly looking for frum women or YWN to tell them where to go. But if you think it is a nichshol then edit out the women.
mother point is, even if there is a lot out there, I feel it’s hard to sift through it all and find the really good stuff. I hope people can share here about people they like that aren’t extremely well known and maybe I will get a chidush of new music and names.
It is a true I’m pessimistic about the drum entertainment area. It’s so hard when you can’t seem to find the style you like. Although I’m sure it exists it’s hard to find frum books about dragons and magic or frum music that’s heavy metal, dubstep, orchestra dubstep, etc.
Without even addressing the almost unaddressable ending to your post I will say that when you are speaking to Jews, and about Jews, you need to keep your pessimism to yourself. Being discouraged does not excuse disparaging attitudes. There are ways to ask for things without putting people, or an entire people, down.
I don’t know that I share your gratitude regarding leaving the thread. And it’s not about the music.
Shopping613 🌠Participant@apushuta yid
@everyone else tooAs someone who actually LIVES in this country, this is my insight on the matter:
1. Besides for the fact the army is anti chareidi, and the fact that there are thousands of boys and girls together on bases, the government is now trying to create mixed BATTALIONS. Young women and men in the same group, sleeping together, etc. This is a new update and the dati leumi and mizrachim are also against this and are trying to fight it. Although we are against the army as a whole, this takes things to a new level for someone who is going to go to the army and wants to be any type of religious.
2. There is a HUGE difference between a protest, and defacing property, being destructive, etc. I don’t beleive the gedolim ever instructed anyone to beat up women, wreck buses, throw tear gas, fire crackers, etc.
Have you ever seen a protest in the USA? They are not like that. I can tell you right now that the real bnei torah are not the people looking for an excuse to burn garbage cans. Most of the bochurim causing destruction are doing it without the excuse of a protest. There are thousands and thousands of normal people actually doing a protest (as can be seen on a video on YWN news where you can see big rabanim talking to thousands about what a horrible thing this is..etc)
3. If people think this is a chilul hashem either out of ignorance of what are values are, or ignorance of knowing what a chilul hashem is, that is not YWN news’s problem. You know, people throw out the term chilul hashem. Do you honestly care that much about Hashem’s name to feel that these people are desecrating it? Or do you just ‘feel’ it’s wrong to protest and be so loud?
4. Come to Israel. If you want to get anything done…you need to protest. Example: bus strikes, garbage strikes for weeks, ummm remember the government promised the settlement of Amona a new settlement…that hasn’t happened. Some families are on a food strike. That’s how you get people to nitce you here. Again I will say there is a huge difference between a protest and being descructive.
Shopping613 🌠ParticipantI really dislike the new layout. I feel like everything is all mushed together and is one color, like the seperation from post to post is very light.
Oh and SBUBTITLES?!!!!!!! HELLOOOOOOOOOO
March 29, 2017 8:23 am at 8:23 am in reply to: Subtitles were a very special thing and now they are gone! :-( #1246252Shopping613 🌠ParticipantStreekgeek!!! Welcome back!! Omg it’s so good to hear from you!
I believe the mods said that subtitles will come back eventually… -
AuthorPosts