Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
shlishiMember
also in a mixed gender chat room many times you know their gender, even though you may not know their identity.
shlishiMemberHomeowner, like all good Jews, I believe Halacha takes precedence over all else. Your disagreement,and misrepresentation, notwithstanding.
shlishiMemberisn’t the point of the backup eruv, to backup the main eruv? if you are in an area that is outside the main eruv — but within the backup eruv — you have no backup for the backup eruv, if the backup is down (unbeknownst yet to the public.)
shlishiMemberthere used to be a barbie doll that when you pulled its stings it would say “math is hard”.
shlishiMember(i assume everyone else missed BasYisroel’s age on her SN.)
shlishiMemberet tu, mod 80? you have an ipod?
shlishiMemberhappy golden anniversary!!
shlishiMemberso if you knew then what you know now, if you knew before the divorce that he would lie to them postdivorce and turn them against yiddishkeit and make them OTD postdivorce, if you knew all that beforehand what would happen after a divorce, would you still have gotten divorced?
also, #4 was during marriage or afterwards? if it it was during, how would a divorce stop it (especially since some of the kids are [or were] in his custody or with him)?
shlishiMembereclipse, considering what the acrimony from your divorce caused to occur to your daughters, was the divorce worth it? would it have been better to live with a difficult marriage in order to save the children and have saved them from going OTD? i ask earnestly, not making any assumptions.
shlishiMemberwhy would not being 1,000% certain of a posters gender affect whether its permissible?? if a boy and girl, who never met each other, were “pen pals” and wrote platonic letters to each other every day, would that be okay? can he/she excuse it with the excuse that maybe the pen pal is not being honest about his/her gender? i dont see that. for the most part, i think most posters know other posters gender, and whether it is the opposite of their own.
shlishiMemberCan you summarize the Gemora? Thanks.
shlishiMemberare you talking to me or to the author of that sh”ut statement in Even Yisroel (rav yisroel yaakov fisher ztl)??
shlishiMember“By the same token, vaccinations rob us of the zechusim of bikkur cholim.”
You don’t see a difference between a monetary need, that can be fulfilled with tzedaka, and a health need, that cannot?
shlishiMemberRav Yisroel Yaakov Fisher (Even Yisroel 9:161) was asked if it is proper to insist that every member of the community purchase life insurance so that the burden of supporting the Almana and Yesomim does not fall on the tzibbur?
First of all says Rav Fisher, I don’t understand why money is collected to marry off Yesomim, while they are still children. If you tell me it is because they invest the money and then there is more later on, I can accept that. Nevertheless, I don’t think you can obligate people to buy life insurance. Without the protection of life insurance, Hashem would be more inclined to keep the family’s natural bread winner alive in the zechus of the wife and children. Once there is life insurance this zechus is irrelevant.
Furthermore, says Rav Fisher, the collection of funds for Yesomim and Almanos is a great zechus for Klal Yisroel. Life insurance will rob us of the zechusim of tzedoka and chessed that are so dearly need in our situation, Hashem Yirachem.
shlishiMember“A person can be chozeir b’teshuvah, but he may not be able to make it a complete teshuvah.”
Why would a person not be able to make a complete t’shuva? Is not one of the tenets of Judaism that one can always to a complete t’shuva?
shlishiMember“Offen Gemorah Bava Kama”
At least share which daf. Or better yet summarize what the offene gemorah says. 🙂
shlishiMemberI heard from rabbonim that the divorce crisis is in large part because people put too much emphasis on looks rather than middos and other appropriate things to look for in a spouse.
shlishiMemberGetting your attention is the point of advertising.
March 30, 2011 5:33 pm at 5:33 pm in reply to: Is it permitted to sell – Store Credit or a Gift Card? #753954shlishiMember“Probably, unless it says “non transferable”.”
If it says “non transferable”, it may be a breach of contract to sell it, but it still wouldn’t necessarily be illegal. There is a difference between breach of contract (between two private parties) and breaking the law. Breach isn’t necessarily an illegality. The aggrieved party will, of course, have recourse for the breach though.
shlishiMemberThe reason why I asked this question is because I remember hearing that the Chazon Ish holds that one should not have life insurance because if someone does it could work against him. The reason is that perhaps the reason why he is spared death is because of the financials problems he will cause his family, but now that that issue is no more, he might die.
Am I quoting him correctly? Has anyone heard of this?
Also, assuming what I said is the Chazon Ish’s shita, I have a kasha. According to him, wouldn’t health insurance fall into the same category? Perhaps a person is not getting a sickness due to the financial strain it would put on his wife or children who dont deserve it, but now that he is insured that problem is gone, so Hashem will send the sickness.
So how can anyone follow the Chazon ish’s shita on Life, and at the same time have Health? Is that not a stira (assuming I have all the facts right)?
I think there is a difference between the Chazon Ish’s position not to get life insurance — because if someone’s wife and children were not slated to be punished by not having parnass but the husband was slated to be punished by dying, the RBS”O would spare the husband’s life on account of not punishing his wife and children financially. If he gets the life insurance, his wife and children wont suffer (as much) financials if he dies. That issue doesn’t happen with health insurance.
shlishiMemberlooks have a place in shidduchim. no one says otherwise. the problem is the priority given to looks in todays society is inappropriate and out of place. it comes after many other priorities like middos, etc. no one should be looking for miss america or some kind of a model.
shlishiMemberim not quite understanding some peoples point. if women are on a higher madreiga, why did Chazal institute the brocha of shelo asani isha for men?
shlishiMemberthere are different shittas. some allow life insurance, and some do not allow it.
shlishiMemberis this setting that can be modified somewhere in the area where you click your screen name on the top of the screen, where it says ‘welcome’?
shlishiMember“the guest IS permitted to eat even from food that was cooked in a pot that previously held gebrochts.”
that is incorrect.
shlishiMemberis their a halachic difference between a cold mikvah and a hot mikvah on shabbos?
shlishiMemberwhere is this ad? what is it for?
March 30, 2011 1:51 am at 1:51 am in reply to: B'chor Doing Avodah in Beis HaMikdash & Yerusha #1050356shlishiMemberWhat if you were a ???? yourself, who would cover your minor son (the ????)?
March 30, 2011 1:33 am at 1:33 am in reply to: B'chor Doing Avodah in Beis HaMikdash & Yerusha #1050354shlishiMemberWe still have unresolved regarding whether ????? ?????? is like ????? ???? and applies to a ??? ??? firstborn son of the mother (and therefore a father can have more than one such ???? – each from a different wife), or ????? ?????? is like ????? and applies to the firstborn son of the father, Reishis Ono, who needn’t be a ??? ???.
Using my own logic, without knowing the sources, since the idea of ????? ?????? on ??? ??? comes because the Jewish firstborns were spared from ?????? ??????????, and Makos B’choros is also the reason the ?????????? were chosen to do the ????????? in the ?????????????????, it would seem that ????? ?????? would only apply to a ??? ???, and as such someone born via C-section wouldn’t be included.
Another point that wasn’t addressed is whether the ????? ???? says that a ???? today receives ?? ????? (a double portion) for his ????? from his father.
March 29, 2011 10:13 pm at 10:13 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #760015shlishiMemberwhy dont you quote the full statement in context, rather than a snippet out of context? in that case it would be clear to you that it is permissible to do the right thing (i.e. a bris mila in the soviet union) even if its against the secular law. my quoted point being that if the authorities will harshly punish someone for making a bris (or other good deed), he might be exempt from doing it if he might get caught.
shlishiMemberDerech HaMelech: what about each persons individual keilim (plates, bowls) that have gebrochts (like matzo in soup, etc.) put on them on shmini shel pesach? you dont replace your entire sliverware and keilim each pesach.
shlishiMemberpba: how’d you do it with your sn?
DY: how’d you shorten your sn?
shlishiMemberDerech HaMelech: And you don’t put the gebrochts (like matzah into the soup) from shmini shel pesach into each persons individual plates or bowls? if so, those keilim are the same you use all pesach.
shlishiMember“Actually, my family is makpid not to eat from keilim that had gebrochts cooked in them in the past 12 months. My grandmother has a special frying pan that she uses for shmini shel pesach to make gebrochts.”
why? the next time you’ll use the shmini shel pesach keilim will be 12 months later anyways.
March 29, 2011 7:48 pm at 7:48 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #760011shlishiMemberagittayid: so the yeshiva objected to a sheitel store which displayed much less sleaze than this h&m ad did. if even that was objectionable, how much more so this ad was.
March 29, 2011 7:35 pm at 7:35 pm in reply to: B'chor Doing Avodah in Beis HaMikdash & Yerusha #1050352shlishiMemberFor a ???? to do the ????????? in the ?????????????????, does he have to be a ??? ????
March 29, 2011 7:13 pm at 7:13 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #760008shlishiMembercherrybim – not the one you must have asked. which was?
shlishiMemberDY: how can you start a sn with someone elses existing one? when i experiment it says name already exists.
shlishiMemberreal-brisker: how can i do it myself?
shlishiMemberam i a posek now?
shlishiMemberyikes! can i morph back?
iow, only a mod can duplicate a sn? so on the tefila the second popa was really a mod??
shlishiMemberreal-brisker: how can two different screen names both be exactly popa_bar_abba?
even 3 screen names can be popa_bar_abba
shlishiMemberin the tefilla thread there is two popa_bar_abba’s. one with a subtitle and one without. how could that be?
March 29, 2011 5:40 pm at 5:40 pm in reply to: B'chor Doing Avodah in Beis HaMikdash & Yerusha #1050348shlishiMemberWhy should a C-section be treated differently for ????? ???? than for ????? ?????? (or ????? for that matter)? Either he is considered a ???? or not.
March 29, 2011 5:24 pm at 5:24 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #760000shlishiMemberthe boys dont owe the advertisers a dime, since it was wrong of them to put up images of semi-dressed women in a residential neighborhood in the first place.
shlishiMemberIn Orchos Rabbeinu (vol. 1, p. 170) it is stated that the Chazon Ish did not even allow a child to utilize the eruv and carry in Bnei Brak on Shabbos.
shlishiMemberi dont think the other non-kosher items are prepared in the store. they are likely prepackaged and therefore do not need to be handled with any utensils.
although, if they cut treif pastries with utensils they later wash with the coffee utensils, it may open a whole new can of worms.
shlishiMembermbachur: i found this via google. can anyone verify?
“This derivation indeed seems to be the basis for a whole set of
requirements that one use the right hand. Much of the work in the Beis Hamikdash must be performed with the right hand.
In fact, left- handedness is one of the 90 types of “mum” which cause a Kohen to be unfit for work in the Beis Hamikdash. Rashi in Behorot 45b explains that a lefty Kohen is rejected because much of the work must be done with the right hand and he can’t do it this way.”
“The Gemarah and Rambam say a left handed person may not do avodah. Not all agree that left handedness per se is a P’gam. Some hold (Ramban) the left handed acts are not “k’darko” that is not normative, and therefor should not be performed in the mikdash.”
“Avodah – sacrificial acts in the Temple – must be performed with the right hand by righties. There is an opinion that lefties are considered as having a mum, while Rashi seems to say that performance of these acts with the left hand is not the proper “way” that is it does not honor the Temple.”
shlishiMemberthe chofetz chaim and rav moshe were righties.
shlishiMemberis being a lefty a mum in the beis hamikdash?
-
AuthorPosts