rebdoniel

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 701 through 750 (of 1,881 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: The Cost of Being Orthodox #960396
    rebdoniel
    Member

    YES! It is incredible, too. Their wine is usually between $4-$6 a bottle. A lot of it is eino mebushal, though. SaraBee Moscato, Terrenal Argentinian Cabernet Sauvignon, and Terrenal Tempranillo (a Spanish rich red).

    They’re not earth-shattering, razzle-dazzle wines, but they are enjoyable and are a great buy.

    I generally prefer sweeter wines for drinking and dry wines for cooking.

    in reply to: The Rambam on Health #960933
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I beleive that a field of “Jewish complimentary medicine” can have great benefits and does share many parallels with ancient medicine. Certain wisdoms and truths are universal archetypes.

    in reply to: Greatest Frum Jewish Philanthropists #1029950
    rebdoniel
    Member

    One sentiment expressed in Hazal is the notion of giving tzedakah secretly, so as to not be a hypocrite and seek glory for one’s generosity. The inyan of “not giving alms before men” is expressed in Bava Batra 10b: What kind of charity is that which delivers a man from an unnatural death? When a man gives without knowing to whom he gives. and the beggar receives without knowing from whom he receives. Tosafot even say that this type of giving has the potential to save the giver from Gehenim.

    in reply to: Teens vs. Adults in the CR #960551
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I’d suggest saving money from being a cashier for school. Look into different professions- accounting, health professions, social work, etc.

    in reply to: Blame the shadchanim #963538
    rebdoniel
    Member

    If people lack anything exciting or unique to put on a resume, it will go into the trash heap.

    I’ve had resumes forwarded to me, and I can concur with the above poster, for instance: if they all say went to Shulamith, then to Stern for a BA in English, does bikur holim, etc. that gets boring and repetitive after a while. A resume ought to convey what makes a person unique. And let’s be honest: how many people at age 21 have really done anything yet with their lives?

    A good friend of mine got engaged 2 months ago, and he was 37, his kallah 39. He has semikha, moonlights as a hazzan, and is an accomplished attorney. He was previously a congregational rabbi for a couple of years. The kallah has a PhD in History, has authored 3 books, and has been a tenured professor for a few years.

    I’d prefer to finish my own medical training prior to going back into the realm of shiddukhim. I think a person should find themselves and identify their purpose in life prior to bringing another person into the mix. I learned this the hard way, through life exeprience, and I got burned along the way, but I am glad I learned that now. I don’t want to be settled down and married at 23. I want to achieve more in terms of education, learning, and parnassa prior to being bogged down by the constraints of married life.

    And marriage is largely like a job in many ways. I’ve long ago abandoned any romantic notions of shiddukhim. If two people have comparable worldviews, envision their lives similarly enough, find each other physically attractive, and value the other person’s life experiences, then that ought to be good enough to make a shiddukh.

    in reply to: The Cost of Being Orthodox #960394
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Haifagirl,

    There is such a concept as family planning. The idea that “G-d will provide” reflects mystical and magical thinking and a lack of hishtadlut. Humans are endowed with the ability to make wise and responsible decisions and choices, and there is a lot of truth behind the idea that siyata de shmaya comes to those who help themselves.

    The idea of volunteering in lieu of paying dues is something I wish more shuls did. There was a discussion about that I had with some rabbanim in the social justice sector last week.

    Most families I know that are Reform or Conservative have 2-4 children.

    And as far as meat goes, I find that I can get meat at prices not much higher than treif meat by shopping around at the right places in Brooklyn and Queens. I’ve done shabbat (2 meals) for around $50 many times, one meat and one dairy meal (wine from Trader Joe’s, hallah, a hearty vegetable soup for Friday night, salatim, pickles, olives, gefilte fish with chrein, kugels, roasted vegetables, chicken, steak, parve desserts, and for lunch, egg salad, cole slaw, potato salad, vegetarian chulent with kishka, halavi lokshen kugel, green salad, roasted vegetables, and dairy desserts).

    in reply to: The Rambam on Health #960930
    rebdoniel
    Member

    A lot of the eitzot have been proven successful and correct. Walking regularly, eating mostly fruits and vegetables, reducing portions, adequate sleep, etc. are sound lifestyle and nutritional advice.

    in reply to: Blame the shadchanim #963530
    rebdoniel
    Member

    A lot of people haven’t accomplished anything great or unique in their lives, especially at the age when a lot of people in the frum communities start dating. I’m fortunate in that I’ve been involved in things like community organizing, legislative advocacy, etc. since adolescence, but a lot of our youngsters are sheltered and don’t engage in those types of opportunities. I agree that a resume in many cases is futile.

    in reply to: How do you like your potatoes? #960414
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Moishyk,

    I have different recipes for potato salad, one is pareve, the other halavi, the other basari.

    The basari one is German potato salad. You take 8 ounces of either Jack’s facon or beef fry and fry it until crispy. Keep the oil from the “bacon.” Reserve the cooked bacon. Add a diced onion to the drippings and fry until soft. Add 3/4 cup cider vinegar, a little sugar, and a tablespoon of good, grainy mustard. Cook down for 2 minutes. Whisk, and add 1/4 cup of canola oil, slowly whisking it in. Season with salt and pepper, and add this hot dressing to your red potatoes, which have been cut into small chunks and boiled. Fold the dressing in, add chopped parsely and 8 thinly sliced scallions. Tweak the seasoning with salt and pepper.

    The halavi one uses a dressing of cider vinegar, sugar, salt, onion powder, garlic powder, celery seed, pepper, mayonnaise, chopped dill, sour cream, and diced red onions, along with diced cooked baby carrots, thawed frozen peas, chopped pickle, red potatoes that have been boiled and cut into small chunks, and hard boiled egg. Garnish with a sprinkle of paprika. This is an Israeli-style salad, with the addition of peas, carrots, and pickles.

    The pareve one is the same as the halavi one above, minus the sour cream. A pareve version of that potato salad can even be turned into the basari famous Russian Salad “Olivier” with the addition of chopped cubed chicken.

    A good potato salad is a great addition to a summer meal, and I actually enjoy potato salad a lot over Pesah. The above recipes are great for Pesah, except you’d want to leave the mustard out if you’re Ashkenaz and you’d want to use a non-kitniyot oil. And you’d want to leave peas out to, if you don’t eat kitniyot.

    in reply to: Greatest Frum Jewish Philanthropists #1029940
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Adelson is a major benefactor of the Birthright Israel, MASA, and other such programs, for better or worse. Ssdly, lots of unkosher money exists. How many frum institutions were built with money from people like Meyer Lansky and Bugsy Siegel (whose names are on the Le Zecher Olam boards at Orthodox synagogues), or from people like Milton Balkany, Samuel Hiller, and countless others who broke the law?

    rebdoniel
    Member

    The Igrot Moshe paskened that watches ought not to be worn on shabbat (OC 1:111). Plenty of people here in Brooklyn do wear gold watches on shabbat, since it is understood that such watches function like a takhshit and not for purely functional reasons, which would be assur. Thus, many poskim would say not to wear a watch unless you’d wear it even if the battery were dead.

    in reply to: Going back to work #960503
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I work at the Metropolitan Council on Jewish Poverty, in the Career Services division. I’d be happy to offer assistance for any services you may need looking to re-enter the workforce.

    in reply to: Working frowned upon in Yeshivos? #962370
    rebdoniel
    Member

    The vast majority in kollelim, especially in Eretz Yisrael, do not learn with any emphasis on bekiut or actually amassing much torah knowledge. The Torah admonishes in many places that torah without an honest day’s work is fruitless. See Avot 2:2- “Rabban Gamliel the son of Rabbi Yehuda the Prince said, Torah study is good with a worldly occupation, because the exertion put into both of them makes one forget sin. All Torah without work will ultimately result in desolation and will cause sinfulness.”

    Most people in kollelim don’t get semikha because semikha isn’t seen as inherently conducive to the goal of “torah lishma” promoted in the Litvish velt. The Hafetz Hayyim, zt”l, didn’t even have semikha until he required it for administrative purposes.

    in reply to: The Cost of Being Orthodox #960390
    rebdoniel
    Member

    We only do 3 red meat meals a week, including shabbat dafina/hamin and Friday night dinner, so we generally only do one non-shabbat meat meal per week. Sometimes, we’ll do a fourth meal of just poultry, and I’d prefer to keep this up when I am married.

    I think most Jewish families end up having 2-4 kids. I wouldn’t want any more than 4 kids, partially due to costs associated with education, but also I’d like the ability to be able to spend time with my kids, play with them, take them fishing, to ball games, to see rabbanim, to learn with them, do homework with them, help them study, etc.

    Most shul memberships are around $1000 a family, from what I see.

    in reply to: Salt and Pepper Tofu #960345
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I’d recommend using sesame seeds in the panko to give it a more Asian flavor.

    Oomis, can you share the coconut rice recipe?

    in reply to: How do you like your potatoes? #960410
    rebdoniel
    Member

    That is the best way to make a potato kugel, to heat the oil in the pan for a few minutes prior to pouring in the kugel mixture, as this promotes a nice crust.

    I like for halavi, mashed potatoes, scalloped potatoes, potatoes au gratin, and one of my favorite meals for Pesah and year-round is a baked potato with butter, sour cream, cheddar, chives, sauteed broccoli, olives, and other toppings. A Pesah baked potato bar is a fun and interesting option to present to your guests at a halavi seudah. We did that this year- we put out butter, garlic butter, sour cream, different kinds of cheese, broccoli, spinach, roasted red peppers, fried onions, fresh chives, paprika, mushrooms, sundried tomatoes with olive oil, and pesto to go with baked potatoes, and along with a green salad, baked salmon, a hearty vegetable matza ball soup, and a Pesah sundae bar (Klein’s ice cream, fresh fruits, Schmerling chocolate chunks, nuts, Pesah chocolate syrup, fresh homemade raspberry sauce, homemade ganache), it was a memorble Pesah meal to all those who experienced it.

    in reply to: Hakadosh Bar-b-que #963692
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Their bbq is absolutely excellent. I’ve had the pleasure of seeing them at many local events here in the city.

    in reply to: What in the world is "Cheilek Elokah Mima'al" supposed to mean? #960322
    rebdoniel
    Member

    You’re confusing me with Reb Dovid, maybe?

    in reply to: BBQ Food #1020793
    rebdoniel
    Member

    The issur of eating tzli esh by the seder is incumbent upon the minhag hamakom. Regardless, a person could eat grilled fruits or vegetables, fish, Sephardim can have grilled corn on the cob, etc.

    in reply to: BBQ Food #1020790
    rebdoniel
    Member

    If a person had a Kasher le Pesah grill, what could the problem be with a BBQ? Lots of people grill on Hol haMoed. You’re even allowed to transfer a flame on yom tov to light a charcoal grill. I think a yom tov “al ha esh” is a mechaya. Most things that people grill aren’t hametz.

    in reply to: The Rambam on Health #960924
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Rambam’s psak that a woman who refuses to make her husband’s bed, nurse his children, feed his ox, etc. ought to be compelled through use of the rod is also for a different time period.

    in reply to: Salt and Pepper Tofu #960341
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I’m not interested in childish games or making a milhama. The Yeshiva World is supposed to be an “ir miklat” for people, not a source of juvenile and sophomoric antics.

    in reply to: Why Do People Speak This Way? #1008325
    rebdoniel
    Member

    It’s essentially a frum English pidgin language that incorporates stylistic and other elements from Yiddish, Lashon haGemara, and Hebrew.

    in reply to: What in the world is "Cheilek Elokah Mima'al" supposed to mean? #960310
    rebdoniel
    Member

    The Transcendentalists believed (le havdil) in more or less the same concept.

    in reply to: What in the world is "Cheilek Elokah Mima'al" supposed to mean? #960304
    rebdoniel
    Member

    It means that all people have a spark of Divinity within them and an intimation of immortality. All souls stem from G-d and will ultimately find their way back to Him because all souls belong to Him, due to all souls containing a spark of the Divine with them.

    in reply to: Vaccines in the frum community #962979
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Infecting babies through a ritual that is not halakhically necessary is a major problem. So is wanting to reap the benefits of a Zionist state while trashing Zionism and conspiring against its military. I can go on and on, but really don’t want to go down such a trajectory.

    in reply to: Greatest Frum Jewish Philanthropists #1029929
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I don’t think Adelson is Orthodox, although he finances a lot of causes that many frum Jews hold by. And James Tisch is on the board of the Mesorah Foundation, which gave the world the Artscroll Gemara. His name is printed at the beginning of each Artscroll Shas volume.

    in reply to: Greatest Frum Jewish Philanthropists #1029925
    rebdoniel
    Member

    There are no Orthodox Jews on the Forbes list. Your question asked about Jews; people that aren’t Orthodox are still Jewish, and many of these philanthropists finance all kinds of Jewish causes and charities.

    in reply to: Choosing to be a teacher or a doctor #959922
    rebdoniel
    Member

    You can teach in a medical school without being a medical doctor, in the capacity of public health, health education, social work, psychology, or any other host of fields.

    in reply to: Greatest Frum Jewish Philanthropists #1029923
    rebdoniel
    Member

    James and Meryl Tisch

    George Soros

    Michael Bloomberg

    Irwin Jacobs

    Eli Broad

    Leonard Blavatnik

    Sheldon Adelson

    Ira Rennert

    Mort Zuckerman

    Daniel Pritzker

    Mark Cuban

    in reply to: Choosing to be a teacher or a doctor #959920
    rebdoniel
    Member

    How about going into Health Education? I hold very much of any health-related professions. An EdD or a DrPH or even PhD in the field of Public Health would be a great way to teach in a medical school or in a public health program.

    in reply to: About the RCA, I do shudder. #961973
    rebdoniel
    Member

    If the Haredim don’t hold by the Rabbanut, why do they insist on controlling its policies and putting their preferred pet candidates in office?

    in reply to: Vaccines in the frum community #962976
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Your pernicious worldview is obvious, Yitzchok M.

    The Haredim have invented a strawman in their minds. They perceive a conspiracy against them that doesn’t exist.

    Asking people to follow the law and act like normal, civilized, honorable citizens is not an attack against your way of life.

    in reply to: Salt and Pepper Tofu #960338
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Eh, tofu isn’t much competition against the types of foods I typically cook. The idea of any kind of rivalry between myself and the feminist would be tragic, considering the toxic real-life nature of things.

    in reply to: Rashi Biography and the Heart of Darkness #960282
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I never saw any conclusive historical proof or evidence that Rashi’s daughters wore tefillin.

    The Gemara does say that Mihal bat Shaul haMelekh wore tefillin and that the hakhamim didn’t object (Eruvin 96a). Amazes me how so many people nowadays object to the Gemara’s psak, “Nashim somhot reshut,” that women can perform mitzvot from which they are patur).

    in reply to: The Cost of Being Orthodox #960381
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I actually find Oberlander’s cookies for Pesah to be tastier than year-round ones, due to the copious use of almond flour. I love anything with marzipan, so Pesah almond-based desserts are right up my alley, including my Syrian family’s Pesah pistachio cookies.

    in reply to: About the RCA, I do shudder. #961964
    rebdoniel
    Member

    If you look at this psakim on kashrut, his views on minhagim, etc. it becomes obvious that he’s very much true to the Gemara, Rambam, and Maran haMehaber. His approach is a classic Sephardic one, and his psakim are actually quite sensible. I separate Hakham Ovadia the posek from Hakham Ovadia the politician.

    in reply to: Rashi Biography and the Heart of Darkness #960278
    rebdoniel
    Member

    If you want to read a good biography of Rashi, I’d suggest Avraham Grossman’s superb text, although he ventures more into social and cultural influences on Rashi’s thought. This book is more of an intellectual biography of Rashi, and is even part of the University of Chicago doctoral bibliography in Jewish Studies (for whatever it’s worth on a forum such as this). I would take most CIS books with a grain of salt, as there is probably no effort to produce books that are well-cited, academic, or peer-reviewed. Just look at the whole fiasco with R’ Nosson Dovid Rabinowich’s “Talmudic Methodology” book, which ended up being his plaigarizing Reform Rabbi Moses Mielziner’s “Talmudic Terminology.” Funny how Hakham Ovadia Yosef ended up giving a haskama to a book written by a Reform Rabbi.

    in reply to: Vaccines in the frum community #962972
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I care about children. I don’t like seeing children being infected with herpes, r”l, and neither do I like seeing children being abused or molested (and their abusers given a free pass), nor being the victims of poor parenting choices not to vaccinate or not to feed adequate fruits and vegetables. Helping people make healthy choices and giving others the knowledge to take wellness into their own hands is what I feel called to do.

    in reply to: About the RCA, I do shudder. #961961
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Hakham Ovadia doesn’t need my defense and words of praise. But, his statements should not be upsetting. He speaks his mind, and is one of the most sensible, articulate poskim ever known to the world.

    in reply to: Faux Crab Cakes #959879
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Thank you, Oomis. Cooking is definitely a favorite hobby of mine.

    in reply to: Blame the shadchanim #963499
    rebdoniel
    Member

    This is why there are other ways for people to meet, such as Frumster, mutual friends, etc.

    in reply to: BBQ Food #1020784
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Quality produce, kosher cheeses, spices, oils, vinegars, proteins, etc. are not cheap.

    in reply to: BBQ Food #1020782
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Thank you, tzaddiq. You can now see why I fret over the cost of kosher food, lol.

    in reply to: The Cost of Being Orthodox #960378
    rebdoniel
    Member

    The Forward is available free online. The only things I subscribe to are the RJJ Journal, the NY Times, the Jewish Press, the Yated, and the Hamodia.

    Most Anglos who make aliyah end up depleting their savings within 15-20 years of living in Israel, according to an article I read a while back.

    I’m pragmatic and realistic. Living a relatively Modern Orthodox lifestyle unfortunately is not cheap, and the social expectations that accompany life in our communities don’t shtim well with lower salaries.

    People say that the internet, pedophilia, and feminism are the 3 most issues impacting the community. I’d say that economics is definitely the most important matter of them all; in a capitalistic society, economics are of crucial importance, and given the expenses that living a Torah lifestyle here requires, there is a need for creative solutions to these problems, especially without compromising hiddurim and halakhic standards.

    I’ll ignore comments on the politics of NYC versus out of town communities; while many Orthodox Jews vote Republican, the level of antisemitism and prejudice in backwater places is startling. Most people in places like Texas are probably antisemitic, as they’ve probably not even seen, let alone dealt with, too many Jews in their lives. I love the fact that in NYC, I can walk down Madison Avenue and see lots of people in sheitels, kippot, and black hats, and never feel at risk because of wearing a kippa. I spent a shabbat in Austin and felt a lot safer wearing a baseball hat over my kippa. Perhaps I have a negative/dim view of human nature, but I try to look at things realistically.

    in reply to: About the RCA, I do shudder. #961936
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Hakham Ovadia is not bashful about what he thinks of other people and groups. I respect the man for speaking his mind, even if I don’t agree with his conclusions.

    in reply to: The Cost of Being Orthodox #960366
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I don’t wear kippot serugot, which are more expensive than suede or velvet kippot, so there’s a savings.

    My tayna against small communities is that they lack the same standard of living I am used to in NYC. I like the ability to buy kosher food at Goldberg’s at 2 am, and the freedom to learn daf yomi and shiurim with any host of great gaonim, including Rabbi Belsky, Rabbi Ralbag, Rabbi Boruch Simon, etc. OOT life is better suited for others, but I am born and raised in NYC. People are even slower outside NYC.

    I’m still figuring out how to make a cheaper Pesah. The cost of the seudot and everything else came to over $900 for a family of 3, with our hosting a hakham for the last days.

    in reply to: Vaccines in the frum community #962909
    rebdoniel
    Member

    Rabbi Dr. Tendler ought to be heeded. He is a man of great halakhic knowledge and immense scientific knowledge, as well. If believing in scientific truths is a crime, count me guilty. Public health is a great interest of mine, and it is of immense importance in promoting a society where people enjoy overall wellbeing and improved economic, lifestyle, and wellness indicators.

    in reply to: How do those wearing Yerushalmi kippot put on tefillin? #959577
    rebdoniel
    Member

    It’s like a Breslov Na Nach kippah, only without any writing. Large, white, knitted, with a little peak on top, and worn by a few Yerushalmi hasidim.

    in reply to: Vaccines in the frum community #962906
    rebdoniel
    Member

    I point out in my article that the failure to vaccinate can and should be understood in the broader context of antipathy to public health programs among some sectors of our community.

    This is a shame, since the public health field generally considers Vayikra to be an early example of a religious code dealing with a fairly advanced conception of public health/epidemiological concerns (i.e. isolation and quarantine for tza’arat reflects an advanced understanding of public health in the holiness code).

Viewing 50 posts - 701 through 750 (of 1,881 total)