Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
To DaMoshe
It’s amazing that this atheist rescue has gotten this far with his stupidity, not to mention his Kefirah. It appears that he invented someone he’s calling nevuah to spout his garbage and make it look as if he has supporters. It’s the same obnoxious writing style, but the genius didn’t make any spelling errors so he thinks I’ll be fooled.
To Always
What exactly am I looking for in Beitzah 25b. I’m actually learning Beitzah now. I’m on 19a.
To anIsraeliYid
You’re taking what he said out of context. Rescue has said on numerous occasions that the Torah is a book of morality. While that’s certainly true, it’s G-d’s morality and not ours. To that point I asked him if he agrees that someone who carries his keys in the street on Shabbos should be put to death, as will be the case when Moshiach comes, and he refused to answer because all the laws of Shabbos undo his central tenet.
To Simcha613
As I stated, you are clearly a Mensch, as am I and so I will respond in a civil manner. Today, Hakatan said to me, “It is you and your idol that are the definition of sonei Yisrael.” And the other day ujm called me a Mechallel Shabbos who prays in a Reform Temple. When I make statements, they are well thought out. I have consistently called rescue an atheist because that’s what he is, and that’s what he’s espousing. Now it’s telling that you addressed your comment to me and not Hakatan. The reason is obvious, you know that I’m rational and he isn’t. If you tried to get him to tone down his rhetoric, he’ll respond as he did to me. Sorry, you’re giving them the benefit of the doubt, but the fact remains that they are incorrigible. There is no hope for idolaters of any type. I’m not pushing you off, because you clearly have a Lev Tov, but these animals must be treated as such.
To RightJew
I certainly concur with everything you said, but AFAIK music is prohibited during Sefira. Please elucidate.
To Nevuah
Why don’t you explain, in your words, the message that recue is trying to convey?
To simcha613
You’re one of the good ones and you’re also intelligent enough to understand that there’s no way to get through to those who have created a wall of hate. I’m reminded of something I read many years ago. There were German and Austrian Jews who were taken to the camps, and they displayed the medals that they earned in WWI hoping that this would gain them their freedom. Obviously, the guards weren’t impressed. Nothing can be said to our resident Nazis, Hakatan and ujm, that will make any indentation. They’ve distilled the Torah into hating anything related to Israel. And as for rescue, he’s also severely disturbed, but he’s more nasty than hate filled.
To User176
When Moshe Rabbeinu tried to make peace with Dasan and Aviram they told him that he could take their eyes out and they won’t budge. Chazal tell us that the Yetzer hora for idolatry was eliminated. I would suggest that it morphed into different forms. So, we have Chabad which considers the Rebbe a deity, ujm and Hakatan whose god is wishing death and destruction on Israel and rescue who decided that he’s on equal footing with Hashem and can speak for Him. Having read your posts, you’re clearly a fine person and a true Ben Torah and I understand your exasperation. Rav Reuvein Feinstein once told me that Judaism is so simple, do the Mitzvohs and love other Jews. It really is simple, but the Yetzer hora is quite adept at messing with our minds. One thing is certain: there’s no way to get through to an idolater, so as Greg Allman sang, “Your wasted words should never be heard.”
to rescue
You write, “The Torah was created to teach you how to live.” How is it that you have this information? Are you a Novi? Or is it just your oppion? sic. BTW your writing bespeaks someone who’s in a psych ward. But I guess that compared to your mongoloid friends you’re probably the smartest one.
To the group
Rescue has stated that the Torah is a book of morality. I specifically asked him to explain the reasons and or logic for the law that if one carries his keys on Shabbos in the public domain, he’s subject to the death penalty. He ignored the question and then started another of his ridiculous threads. That’s not an accident; he doesn’t have the guts to admit he’s a worthless lying fraud. In fact, none of the 39 Melachos involve immorality. The only reason we can’t do them is because Hashem said so. And the only reason that Adam Harishon wasn’t allowed to eat the forbidden fruit is because Hashem said so. It’s as simple as that, and to suggest otherwise is Kefirah. I can’t say if this Minuval violates Shabbos, but he certainly believes that there’s nothing wrong with doing so. Checkmate.
To GadolHadofi
His fellow Sonei Yisrael Hakatan, stated that he davens for Hashem to eliminate the State of Israel, but not to harm any Jews. Let’s examine that line. Hitler yms said that the Jews are responsible for all the evils of the world and they must be eliminated. He then followed up on his belief. Hakatan and ujm say that Zionism is responsible for all the evils of the world and it must be eliminated, but then he says that he doesn’t want any Jew to be harmed. At least Hitler wasn’t a lying hypocrite. It’s shocking that monsters like ujm and Hakatan can mention Hashem.
To rescue
No, you dufus, I criticize you because you spell half of your words incorrectly. Yes, I’m sure you’ll answer that you have your own oppion as to how words should be spelled.
To Hakatan
What do they ask for?
To ujm
Yes, and the two Rabbis of the Temple are Rabbi Plutchok and Rabbi Fishelis. Which Nazi is the head of your shul?
To pekak
Your point is well taken since Shaatnez and plowing with an ox and donkey are both examples of Kilayim, but the Kofer will answer that he’s talking specifically about frequencies in textiles. The stupidity of his argument is that a wool garment which has one thread of linen is forbidden as Shaatnez but obviously one thread does not emit anything measurable. So again, he’s checkmated.
To always
They don’t leave it to kofrim. Now you seem to be endorsing this nut, which doesn’t surprise me because you’re a contrarian, but consider this, “Rescue posits that kosher animals and birds are kind and nonkosher are the opposite. Well camels are solely herbivores so why are they not kosher? And many kosher birds are omnivores.” Checkmate to you for being stupid enough to even consider his atheism as valid.
To rescue
So now you change your tune and say that “Mitzvohs don’t need a reason, but they sure as heck have one.” No, they sure as heck probably have tens of thousands of reasons, the vast majority of which, human beings aren’t capable of deciphering. So, we’ll ask you a simple question, “Can you explain why someone who carries his keys on Shabbos in the public domain is liable according to the Torah?” And if you can’t, do you carry yours? Checkmate.
To SQUARE_ROOT
You’re absolutely right, but I don’t hate Lubavitchers I just hate their false religion.
To Uncle Ben
If you assume that I’m Mechallel Shabbos because I watch TV, then you’re probably a follower of that foolish bigot Rabbi Miller. If you have some other reason for suspecting me, please share it. I learn about seven hours of Gemara a day and I write a weekly Dvar Torah that’s read by thousands of Jews over the internet including many Gedolim, so no, my office isn’t open on Shabbos, nor has it ever been, even though when I started practicing, I wasn’t fully frum.
To rescue
For someone who thinks he’s smarter than G-d you write on the level of a two-year-old. Checkmate moron.
To simcha613
ujm is a Jewish antisemite who dreams of the destruction of the State of Israel and the death of its Jewish residents. And he justifies this position because his Rav, Rabbi Miller was anti-Zionism.
To ??coffee addict
Rescue thinks he’s smarter than Hashem so Kal VChomer the Amoraim. You see, he watches YouTube videos and they make him very smart. lol
To Just a Yid3
I would count Claude in a minyan before rescue. Rescue has also said that G-d never really wanted us to keep the Mitzvohs that don’t make sense. He expects us to use our free will and reject them. His only response to the flak he’s received is to call his critics, particularly yours truly, stupid sheeple who dehumanize him. It would be interesting to find out which Yeshiva through him out. In an early post he railed against the fact that he can’t get a shidduch. You see the problem he has is that when they asked him to describe his religious affiliation, he said he practices rescue Judaism, which one day will replace our outdated system. More than likely his parents disowned him so that their other children will be able to find shidduchim.
To always
Are you agreeing with the lunatic that static electricity is the reason that the Torah prohibits wearing Shaatnez? But it’s prohibited to wear Shaatnez even if it has one strand of linen and the rest of the garment is wool. There would be no measurable effect in that case. Just trying to point out the idiocy of his claims.
To Simcha613
You’re correct, but if you follow most of the posters, and really most people, frum and otherwise, they’re convinced that they’re perfect and would never consider anything to the contrary. So no, they don’t view the Sefira as a period of reflection, rather it’s to criticize others.
To a Lamdin, DWKL 1 and JustaYid3
Thank you for stating the obvious about that retarded kofer. Now that he’s solved the Chok of Shaatnes, the idiot has moved on to explain Kashrus. “Kosher animals have good Middos and that’s why we eat them.” So let the boob explain why we can’t eat a kosher animal if it isn’t slaughtered properly, does its character change?
To user176
You put it beautifully. In a different thread this atheist wrote that many Halachos don’t make sense, which of course, to him means that not only are we not required to keep them, but G-d wants us to use our free will and reject them. I can’t explain his Kefirah and insanity, I am simply here to point it out.
To Hakatan
Who would you exclude from Amisecha? Second question, how do you define Daas Torah and who has it?
To rescue
Now that you’ve explained the Lav of wearing Shaatnez, why don’t you explain the cause(s) of the Holocaust?
To longmememory
I agree with you that we must be thankful for the State, but you can’t say that the Holocaust wouldn’t have happened if Israel existed then. No one can control what Hashem does.
To user176
Do you still think that all the posters are nice people?
To AAQ
I don’t see a problem with suggesting possible reasons for Mitzvohs and I think your point that Shlomo Hamelech made every attempt to figure out the law of Parah Adumah is correct. The problem is when you have a stupid atheist like rescue who thinks he can explain Chukim of the Torah. Many years ago, I had a friend who became a BT in his fifties. He was nice but he had some quirks. He called himself a Karaite and he rejected all Rabbinic statements, Gemara, Midrashim etc. To quote him, “I have my Hertz Chumash and that’s all I need to understand the Torah.” One day I said to him, “That’s interesting. King Solomon couldn’t explain the Parah Adumah but you’re good with it.” He responded, “It’s very simple. In the soap making process we combine two dirty components, and they produce something pure and the same is for the Parah Adumah.” I came back, “And do you think that King Solomon didn’t know that?” He answered, “No they hadn’t invented soap yet.” He happened to be very intelligent. He had a PHD in English and History, but when someone discusses areas of which he knows nothing he comes off as a fool. And in rescue’s case, an arrogant pompous fool. I’m still waiting for that liar to cite three examples of Torah laws that don’t make sense, because he said that he doesn’t keep such laws.
To the group
If there was any question that this sheigetz is a Kofer it should now be removed. There is one reason for the prohibition of Shaatnez and it’s the same reason why we can’t carry in the public domain on Shabbos and why we can’t eat Treif. That reason is because the Torah said so. If one would like to find additional support for Mitzvahs, he may do so, but no one can suggest that “HE” knows G-d’s reason. Dovid Hamelech wrote, “His greatness is unfathomable.”
To user176
Let me start by saying that I think you’re a fine person and you mean well, but hey you knew a but was coming, Anne Frank said that deep down all people are good at heart. Sorry, she was wrong. You can’t call rescue, who says that one need only keep the commandments that make sense, a Yirei Shamayim. And you can’t call ujm who said today that the State of Israel has less Kedusha than North Korea a nice person. What is true is that some people who should know better get caught up in the name-calling and that’s a problem. I try to keep my menschlichkeit but several posters are totally incorrigible. Still, I appreciate your input. We need more nice people on YWN.
To GadolHadofi
I can’t comment on his Nazi past, but there’s no question that he’s a rabid antisemite. He justifies his Jew hatred by saying that he’s following Rabbi Miller. That excuse won’t help him in the Olam Haemes. Rabbi Miller stupidly attacked many groups, e.g. modern Orthodox, State of Israel, but it wasn’t out of hate. He just wrongly felt that they didn’t represent true Jewish values. The problem is that trash like ujm seize on such statements and view them as a Heter to wish death on other Jews. I’ll give you an example of what I mean. We all know that Rabbi Miller led a crusade to eliminate TV from Jewish homes. About 35 years ago, I had a friend who was a big Chossid of Rabbi Miller and he shared this story with me. He was going through a bitter divorce, and he went to Rabbi Miller for advice. Rabbi Miller told him that if keeping the TV will save your marriage don’t throw it out. So, we see that Rabbi Miller was smart enough to know that Shalom Bayis is far more important than having a TV. BTW, they got divorced. Now ujm will claim that I made up the story. Pathological liars like this Nazi always accuse others of lying.
To the group
It appears that we underestimated this great genius who calls himself rescue, he’s able to explain Hashem’s Chukim something even the Gaon couldn’t do. But we have to remember rescue watches YouTube videos so I probably gets his Pshatim from there.
To rescue
You stated in a different thread that there are many Halachos which don’t make sense and so we don’t have to keep them. Would you be so kind as to name three of them?
To rescue
I have no kids living at home you idiot, so shut the you know what up and stop trying to advise me, you worthless atheist.
To GadolHadofi
I assume you’re referring to ujm. He’s totally psychotic, and a pathological liar.
To user 176
Very well said. Sadly, rescue has no concept as to how far his Yetzer hora has taken him away from actual Yiddishkeit. Let me just comment on TV because I kind of started this brouhaha. I showed up on a thread at YWN in 2023. At one point I mentioned, in passing, that I watch TV and it started a firestorm. I spoke to a local Posek at that time, who told me that there is no Issur whatsoever in watching TV, of course one should only watch things that are appropriate like sports. There have been Takanahs made by groups of Rabbis to ban TV, but they don’t have the force of making it Assur, rather it’s a recommendation that some people follow and others reject. One Rabbi, Rabbi Miller, turned TV watching into his “holy war” declaring that anyone who watches TV has no Cheilek in Olam Habo. but that’s just Miller being Miller. He said outlandish things knowing that his followers would treat them as Torah Misinai.
To Pekak
I assume you’re referring to rescue who has openly declared that G-d doesn’t “want” us to keep His Torah, rather He wants us to exercise our free will and only keep those laws that make sense. According to that “logic” G-d was kidding when He told us not to wear Shaatnez because clearly that makes no sense. Look, it’s very simple. If a Jew for Cheeses tried to post here, he wouldn’t get through, so it’s no different when someone presents views that are anti-thetical to the Torah.
To SQUARE_ROOT
How many posters would be left if only Kosher comments were allowed? In addition to the inappropriate issues that you listed are the lies that are routinely written and the lack of basic menschlichkeit. People can have differences of opinion but there’s no excuse for the nastiness that’s displayed. Again, the problem is that if only posters who have actual Torah hashkafah and values were printed most of the current contributors would be eliminated.
To the group
I’m not going to waste my time with an NK lover who openly pronounced on YWN that all problems in the Jewish world are due to Zionism. The reason he has such an odious view is because he’s a brain-dead Millerite as Rabbi Plutchok calls all followers of Rabbi Miller. Now this lying knucklehead thinks that Rabbi Miller was the smartest person who ever lived. Well, if he was so smart why didn’t he understand the problem with Chabad? Just to clarify the record. One, I never learned with Rabbi Miller. What I said is that I attended a Yeshiva run by Rabbi Miller’s Talmud Muvhak. Second, Rav Moshe’s grandson doesn’t come for cleanings. I’ve done extensive work on him. Unlike ujm who unemployed and living off welfare I’m successful, Baruch Hashem. Third, I don’t hate Rabbi Miller, I dislike him and I reject many things that he said. Fourth, Rabbi Plutchok was my Rav in 2023, but he moved to the Five Towns, so I rarely see him anymore. Five, as Rabbi Plutchok said, “A Rabbi has absolutely no right to tell someone what to do and so never did he ever mention anything about watching TV in the ten years that we were together.” Moreover, with only a few exceptions everyone in that shul had a TV, since the people weren’t particularly frum. Next, Rabbi Plutchok said that he considers Rabbi Miller a Gadol, but not a Gadol like Rav Moshe, Rav Yaakov etc. So, no he never said Gadol Hador. Next, the Gemara says that one can have numerous Rabbis and I do. Finally, one does not have to listen to what his Rabbi tells him especially if he has more than one Rabbi. Rabbis are meant to advise not to order. Tell that jerk, checkmate.
To ujm
Yesterday you wrote that I falsely claimed to be a follower of Rabbi Plutchok. I countered that I never said I’m a follower, what I said is that he is one of my Rabbis. You then quote me as saying, on several occasions, that he’s my Rav. Thank you for confirming what I said and demonstrating that unlike an NK lover like you, I don’t lie. Let me explain what Rabbi Plutchok said about followers, “Lubavichers and Millerites are exactly the same. They’re brain-dead cult members, and they don’t actually practice Judaism.” So, no I am not a follower of Rabbi Plutchok. Moreover, Rabbi Plutchok told me, “Rabbis have absolutely no right to tell others what to do.” That’s why he dislikes Rabbi Miller and he hates Millerites like you. Now let’s discuss Rabbi Fishelis. In 2023, when I was being attacked on YWN for saying that I watch TV I spoke to Rabbi Fishelis and he said, “There is absolutely no Issur regarding watching TV not Doraysa and not Drabonon.” Rabbi Fishelis and I know each other for 60 years and we’ve lived in the same building on the LES for the last 50 years, so I wouldn’t change a word that he said. I’ll repeat, “Only Rabbi Miller made a crusade against watching TV.” Yes, many Rabbis ruled against owning a TV, and I am definitely not advocating for people to watch, but none of those Rabbis said that someone with a TV has no Cheilek in Olam Habo. I asked Rabbi Plutchok and Rabbi Fishelis about this, and they both said that’s nonsense. You can continue lying to yourself and to the others on YWN but no one’s buying your Miller garbage. You’re almost as repugnant as rescue. Checkmate you lying moron.
To the group
“We have to bring context to the biblical text so we can understand the law_correctly.” Yes, that’s why we have the Gemara and the Rishonim and the Acharonim etc. But this worthless punk thinks that he has hegemony over the Torah.
To Little Froggie
That’s the least of his problems. It seems like he’s on the verge of breaking down. Let’s help this atheist get there.
To the group
Obviously, we must have one agenda, to get rid of this worthless punk who calls himself rescue.
To ujm
Would you care to cite the post in which I said I’m a “follower” of Rabbi Plutchok? What I said is that Rabbi Plutchok is one of my mashpiim that’s all, but he isn’t the Rav who said that there is no Issur of watching TV. That would be Rav Dovid Feinstein’s son-in-law. Now obviously I don’t believe you actually spoke to Rabbi Plutchok but if you want to convince me call him again and tell him to text the dentist from the Lower East Side with his Psak on TV. Now if you claim to be on such intimate terms with Rabbi Plutchok, I suppose you know what he thinks of Rabbi Miller and those fools who follow him. He calls them “Millerites” and said that they’re brain-dead cult members who don’t actually practice Judaism. So, if you call Rabbi Plutchok, you can ask him to confirm what I said. Unlike you, I don’t lie. Now, I’m waiting for a response to my challenge from the other day. I’ll repeat it, “Since you’re a follower of Chareidi Rabbis why are you violating their Psak and spending so much time on the internet?” Since I know you won’t answer me I’ll just say checkmate now. You should get off YWN, because no one is interested in your Rabbi Miller garbage. I know you hate the State of Israel because he hated the State. He also hated YU. He was a hatemonger and we should reject such rhetoric. On the other hand, he was a great Marbitz Torah and so Rabbi Plutchok told me that he considered him a Gadol. I agree with Rabbi Plutchok on that point.
To the group
Let’s consider the “logic” of this fungus who calls himself rescue. He argues that if I can go against what I’ve been told and watch TV he can go against what the Torah says and follow G-d’s “real” intent. Again, this maniac decided that Hashem never wanted us to keep the Mitzvohs. Aside from the fact that he’s psychotic, he’s also a total moron. No Rabbi ever told me not to watch TV. As I stated in 2023, I have a Psak from a world class Posek that there is no problem with watching TV. For those who choose not to, Kal Hakovod.
To 35T
We don’t need the moderators to get rid of the Kofrim. When I showed up at YWN in 2023 there were several Lubavichers who were spouting their Kefirah and idolatry. They’re no longer found, because rational Torah Jews called them out. Now we have an atheist called rescue who “posits” that Hashem never intended for us to actually keep His Mitzvohs. We must unite and call him out. He won’t give up easily because he’s practicing the most dangerous form of Avodah Zarah; the belief that he is a god.
to yittish
Rescue is running scared so he’s looking for allies. Call him out for the atheist /idolater that he is.
To haimy
You’re a Torah Jew and like all Torah Jews you’re repulsed by the worthless atheist who calls himself rescue. We must all unite to get rid of this lowlife.
To Pekak
I totally agree with you. I assume you’re referring to rescue who not only rejects Torah She Baal Peh but also Shebichtav. He thinks he has the right to decide which laws he has to keep if any.
To dlm
Let’s consider what the numbskull wrote yesterday in a different thread, “Querty I never said G-d has no right to keep our commandments.” What this functional illiterate meant is that we don’t have to keep G-d’s commandments. And I can prove that this was his intent from another post of his dated 2/4/26 on the thread involving Sheitels. “Do some halachos not make logical sense?” Alot of them don’t. Your(sic) allowed to admit that and speak the truth. Do you keep it anyways? Yes, but again that’s a personal choice.” So, we see this atheist’s attitude to our religion. If he feels like keeping something he does so, but if not, not.
To ujm
You are apparently a follower of leading Chareidi Rabbonim, so why have you ignored the Gedolim who banned using the internet? You are a total hypocrite. I can watch TV because my Rabbis permit doing so, but you reject the position of your own mentors. What a lowlife you are.
To dlm
I have no idea why YWN keeps printing this lunatic’s posts. He has every right to practice Judaism as he sees or doesn’t see fit and Hashem will then use His right to send him to hell. It’s really that simple.
To yittish
Not only are you completely correct, but you also write beautifully. At the end of the day, however, it all comes down to that jerk’s Gaavah. Rescue reminds me of a Reform Rabbi who wrote in the now defunct Jewish Week, “Maimonides is a Rabbi and I’m a Rabbi. Why is his opinion any more valid than mine?” Rescue is convinced that he knows more than all our Sages and he even has the hubris to state that Hashem doesn’t want us to keep the Torah.
To the group
When rescue showed up about two months ago, I immediately asked him for the name of his Rabbi(s) and he ignored my request. We now understand why. Rescue does not accept Dev. 17:11 which teaches that Hashem empowered the Rabbis to make laws. In fact, most of our religion was formulated by our Sages. Therefore, rescue rejects that we must keep two days of Rosh Hashanah even in Israel and of course the two days of Yom Tov in Chutz Laaretz. So, you might think that rescue is a later day Karaite who only keeps the Written Torah. Not so fast. Rescue has stated that G-d has no right to order us to keep His commandments. There is no point trying to deal with this idiotic Kofer. Checkmate.
To shkoyach r noach
I happen to agree with you but only to a certain extent. In 2023 I showed up at YWN and in the course of a certain thread I “admitted” that I watch TV. I was universally pilloried and one poster wrote, “watching TV is no different than eating a cheeseburger in Burger King.?” I made it clear that I wasn’t trying to convince anyone to get a TV, I was simply stating my situation. Eventually, I went to a Posek, and he told me that there’s no problem with watching TV. So how did it become ingrained in so much of the Yeshiva World that TV is the “Great Satan?” Decades ago, a certain Rabbi started a Crusade against the “Boob Tube.” and he was successful in developing followers even though there was no substance to his anti-TV rants. The reason I qualified my approbation of your comment is that it’s dangerous to endorse “rescue” who has publicly declared that one should not follow the laws of the Torah since they run counter to man’s free will.
To rescue
You asked R D Teitelbaum to cite a verse which teaches that one can’t talk about other religions. Dev 17:11 states that we must follow the dictates of our Rabbis. With this verse Hashem empowered the Rabbis to make laws for the people which must be followed. To that point, Rabbi Akiva said that one who studies Sefarim Chitzonim is an Apikorus. There are other such teachings which prohibit studying other religions. So yes, there is a valid source. Now why don’t you provide a source for your belief that G-d doesn’t expect us to keep His laws?
To 35
Why don’t you enlist and personally take him out?