qwerty613

To Haleivi

Not only is it tiring but it’s a total waste of time, but he has nothing else in his life than to spout his Kefira.

To ??coffee addict

Thank you for calling my attention to that post. In fact, I did write that I would ignore him completely. If this has the status of a Neder then I will have to be Matir Neder. I plan to speak to my Rav tonight and ask him this Shailah. In fact, however, as you can see from my response to you, I never intended to ignore him. I came to YWN in 2023 determined to fight Chabad. Baruch Hashem our side was successful, and we no longer have to look at their garbage. I feel exactly the same way about this psychofer although he’s far less dangerous since he’s nothing but a stupid Daas Yachid. Bli Neder I’ll get back to you tomorrow with what my Rav said. I enjoy our discussions. They’re challenging and truthful.

To SQUARE-ROOT

I wholeheartedly agree with the sentiments of the author. Some may dismiss what he said as simple jealousy, but I think that Gashmius obsession also affects those who have enormous wealth. We’re in this world to serve Hashem not show off to others and this is lost on so many. Baruch Hashem I’m married to someone who doesn’t make excessive demands of me so that I’m free to learn and write, but I think she’s the exception not the norm.

To Pekak

Always is a nice guy and a Torah Jew, but he’s a contrarian. He’ll find one case out of a billion and then say that this represents the rule. Obviously, Hashem is the true judge of the world. He knows everything about each of us and He judges accordingly. As for Mendelsohn, it’s not so clear that you can dismiss him as a Rosho and then impute that his family went lost because of his false ideas. Rabbi Yisrael Salanter was as great as they come, and he had a son who left the faith.

To rebEmes

Now you’ve been exposed to the psychofer. He is like BMG guy, but BMG guy is even worse. They’re both total atheists. As for your comment “even the Tanya” this implies that you don’t hold from the Tanya, but I don’t see why. The Baal Hatanya was a Gaon Olam and a perfect Tzaddik. Chabad as it’s presently constituted has nothing to do with the Alter Rebbe.

To ??coffeeaddict

If memory serves, I told you not to get into discussions with the atheist and I also said that I would avoid doing so, but I never said that we should ignore him and allow him to spout his Kefirah. If my recollection is incorrect, please give me a citation and I’ll act accordingly.

To rebEmes

YWN has its own kofer, the mishugenah who calls himself Nevuah. He decided that Hashem, who he calls god, wouldn’t punish anyone for violating the Mitzvahs because he’s a loving god.

To evalimoshavio

I recently heard that two Chassidishe gedolim, I forgot their names, went to daven at the kever of the Ohr Hachaim when Rommel was preparing to invade Israel and they got a sign from Shamayim that he wouldn’t be successful.

To always

Let me explain what happens when the Tinok Shenishba argument is taken to its illogical conclusion. About two years I was arguing on VIN with this fellow who quoted the Chazon Ish as saying that all irreligious Jews today have the status of Tinok Shenishba. I wrote back to him that Alan Dershowitz can’t be called a Tinok Shenishba because he was raised frum and walked away from it because he felt that the religion would stunt his children from reaching their potential. He didn’t leave Judaism because he was molested or for some other trauma, he proudly announced on the radio that this was a decision that he made when he was 29 years old under no duress

To rebEmes

Thank you for responding to my question. You and I are in complete agreement that if a person decides to live his life in a manner that’s contrary to the Torah, he will face serious consequences, be it in this world and or in the next. This said, the Chabad Rabbi, Manis Friedman stated the following, “Today, because of the long bitter Golus, no Jew can be punished no matter what sin he committed.” This is outright Kefirah, but it’s in line with Chabad theology that the Rebbe will come back to save every Jew. Let me explain why I’m writing to you. I think you can see that I’m well thought out. As do you, I also write on VIN. You know me as “Drop Dead”, the fellow who has been fighting with BMG guy. The other day you endorsed BMG guy. I assume that you aren’t aware of why there’s an argument. I pointed out that Manis Friedman is a Kofer and he went insane. BMG guy is no longer frum but he’s in love with Manis for saying that nothing will happen to sinners. BMG guy has used my actual name to slander me. He has written that my office is open on Shabbos, an outright lie, and he writes that I have insulted Gedolim, another outright lie. The only Rabbi I have criticized is Manis Friedman. If you want to confirm what I’ve said I can send you the link to hear Manis spout his Kefirah I don’t lie. I don’t need you to apologize I just want to clear my name from that Moser who lies about me in public, and he fools people into believing him. If you’ll look at that thread, he wrote that Galachim know more Torah than our Gedolim. The problem is that he uses my name when he writes his garbage because he wants people like you to think I’m crazy. I am very respected on YWN because they don’t allow psychos like BMG guy to write. Let’s continue this discussion.

To Nevuah

Everyone thinks about you as I do including your family. What sets me apart is that I’m speaking out because I want you to get lost. Despite what you would like to believe a Jew doesn’t have the right to create his own G-d.

To ashergg

You’re doing a great job of engaging this Kofer. He thinks he can Pasken from Posukim. So, he finds a verse(s) that he can twist to fit his atheistic agenda. Again, he has stated clearly and he’s saying it again in this post that we should only follow those laws of the Torah that make sense to “HIM.” He decided that he has the right to decide which of the 613 Mitzvahs we should keep. I know that you want to get through to him, but it’s not possible. He’s an atheist and an idolater. He worships himself, believing that he can tell G-d which laws apply today. He knows that he has rejected our religion, but he could care less. He constantly speaks of a loving G-d who will never punish anyone if they feel that certain laws are restrictive. He’s not only a Kofer Befarhesia he’s also a Chotei Umachti because he’s trying to convince people to join his invented religion. It is what it is.

To ashergg

You almost have it, but I’ll fill in what you’re missing. When Nevuah showed up about three or four months ago he called himself rescue. At that time his Kefirah was blatant. What he said is that G-d doesn’t want “sheeple” who blindly follow what they’re told in the Torah, rather He wants people to use their free will and only keep those Mitzvahs that make sense. I then challenged him to explain the logic of one being put to death for carrying his keys in the public domain on Shabbos. He refused to answer which likely means that he does so. When he says that he isn’t an atheist he means that he accepts the concept of a G-d, but not a G-d who commands us to follow the Torah. That’s why he danced around the words Har Sinai in his last post. He probably accepts that G-d gave the Torah to Moshe, but now he thinks it’s our job to interpret the Torah according to our logic. Clearly, he’s a Kofer and so there’s no point trying to continue this discussion. He’s also a total idiot and so he’ll probably play the Qwerty take your meds game. My suspicion is that he’s been diagnosed with serious mental disabilities and so he’s projecting his infirmity on me.

To always

You make a good point, but let’s not lose sight of the fact that the Tinok Shenishba card is overplayed. Jews who grew up frum and left the faith are not Tinok Shenishba. They may have a reason for having gone lost, but to say that they’re Tinok Shenishba makes no sense. Troubled yes. But let’s not take it any further. RebEmes lies to write on VIN. He’s the typical hate filled Yeshiva junkie who looks for ways to convince himself that all Jews except for himself are going to hell.

To the group

This is a meaningless argument. Hashem knows every person’s life story and so only He can decide. Someone asked Rabbi Miller to comment on Tinok Shenishba and he sort of pushed it off. I think the reason he did so is because this is one of those subjects that only Hashem is privy to.

To Nevuah

The Gemara reaches that when someone accuses another of something it’s because he himself is guilty of that same thing. Therefore, since you try to impute that I’m crazy, it’s because you’ve been given that title. Obviously, your wife and your Rabbi, who know you well, came to that assessment which is why custody of your kids was awarded to your spouse. Checkmate. I’ll leave you alone if you come clean. Everyone know that fakenews is right about you. We just want to hear your side of the story.

To nevuah

I haven’t said anything contradictory. As fakenews said apparently the reason for your Kefirah is the raw deal that you got in your divorce proceedings. Now you see yourself as an expert in many areas, but my expertise is relatively limited. One subject that I do know is music. Meatloaf had a hit with “Two out of Three Ain’t Bad.” I would suggest that title applies to your marriage. You got screwed up while your ex and your children are celebrating their freedom. Am I right?

To nevuah

Shadchanim are very wary of dealing with “people” like you who ruined their first marriages. Generally, the recidivism rate is very high. You’re probably viewed as damaged goods.

To SQUARE_ROOT

Rav Moshe Feinstein of course. His position was that he wasn’t necessarily in favor of establishing the State, but once it became a reality, he said that it has to be supported because of all the Jews who live there. I don’t know if this statement is in writing but growing up in his neighborhood that’s what I always heard. Therefore, this idea that every Gadol is anti-Israel is total hooey.

To Nevuah

So, what’s the name of the Rabbi who stabbed you in the back during your divorce proceedings? Inquiring minds want to know. Before your divorce were you Shomer Shabbos or did you leave the faith even when you were married?

To @fakenews

I wasn’t sure if you were correct about Nevuah/rescue but now I’m convinced because he ignored your post and continued his stupid rants on other threads. It’s the Kofer’s MO to mach nish vissidik when his position is refuted. I thought he was just an angry OTD, but your depiction is a better fit. If you’ve been paying attention most of his insults are directed at me. Last week he started a thread, “Qwerty is Ill” implying that I’m crazy. And on several occasions, he wrote that I need a psychiatrist, an obvious case of projection. So why am I his whipping boy? He’s insanely jealous of me because he thinks my life, unlike his, is perfect. In fact, I have plenty of problems really serious ones, but I consider them tests from Hashem and so I try my best to deal with them. This kofer, on the other hand, reacted to the mess he made of his life, and yes, it’s his fault, even though he probably blames the entire world, by rejecting the Torah and Hashem.

To IMHO

I absolutely love this topic so let me offer my two cents. The Gemara says that the Beis Hamikdash was destroyed because the people kept the Torah. The Gemara then asked the obvious question, “Was that a reason for the Temple to be destroyed?” It answered that the people didn’t go “Lifnim Mishuras Hadin” beyond the letter of the law. So, what does that mean? Let’s say you walk into shul and find someone in your seat. According to Halacha you can ask that person to move, but menschlichkeit speaks otherwise. You must assess if the person will be upset, and or insulted before acting on the Halacha. Yesterday, I was in a thread on VIN which discusses the Mitzvah of rebuking another Jew. Some people wrote that it’s a Biblical obligation, but I noted that it should only be done if one is relatively certain that the subject will listen to him. Let’s look at Tinok Shenishba. About two years ago I debated this point with a Lubavitcher on VIN. He blanketly said that according to the Chazon Ish every nonobservant Jew today is a Tinok Shenishba. I said that’s ridiculous because only Hashem can decide who falls into that category. He wouldn’t budge so I cited Alan Dershowitz who publicly announced that when he was 29, he walked away from Yiddishkeit because he didn’t want his children’s potential to be stunted by its rules. The guy wasn’t interested. People latch on to some statement by a known Rabbi and apply it as one size fits all. As for Dan Lkaf Zchus this only applies if you don’t know the religious status of the person in question. If, on the other hand, you know that the person is observant than if you see him step into a car on Shabbos you must assume that it’s to perform a Mitzvah. And if you know he isn’t frum then you can assume the worst. It’s when you don’t know about the person that you have to give him the benefit of the doubt. Yasher Koach for starting this thread.

To @fakenews

This jerk has decided that he’s the moral compass for YWN. First, he decided which Mitzvahs of the Torah people should keep, and now he wants to tell parents how they should raise their children. He’s OTD and instead of getting help he rewrites the religion in his image of Kefirah. He’s single with no prospects for marriage and so he compensates by telling normal successful people how they should live.

To Koifer

If, at 120, Hashem asks me why I didn’t go Baruch Goldstein and blow up the Knesset, I’ll tell him that Rav Moshe, the Gadol and Posek Hador supported the State once it came into existence. Checkmate.

To SQUARE_ROOT

This thread really gets it. Rabbi Miller said that a person can keep the Torah and still not have any idea as to what Judaism really is. A person has to think about what Hashem wants from us and not only what He tells us.

To pure yiddishkeit

I certainly agree with you that he’s a Kofer as well as a worthless lowlife and he should be banned from any Torah website. He showed up several months ago demanding that people respect his oppion, that’s how the retard spells opinion. To be fair, he does show respect to other people’s points of view. When that crazy Lubavitch woman said that Schneersohn is G-d’s physical son, several posters took her on, but this “Tzaddik” came to her defense attacking us for bullying her into accepting our position. And when he’s called a Kofer for rejecting our Mesorah, he argues that his oppion has to be respected. Sadly, AAQ has decided that this nut job is a latter day Rambam and Ramban put together since he can explain the reasons for the Mitzvahs. He can explain the reasons for Mitzvahs like Mandani can become Moshiach.

To ?? coffee addict

I do ignore most of his comments. I’ll try to heed your advice and ignore him completely. Unlike most posters, I accept Mussar if it’s appropriate.

To ?? coffee addict

I would think that you’d follow the advice you gave me and not try and engage him in discussion. Everything he writes is meaningless gibberish and empty platitudes. Moreover, he’s psychologically incapable of acknowledging that he can be wrong, so he ignores all refutations to his position.