pcoz

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 401 through 450 (of 541 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: When a child eats traif. #881212
    pcoz
    Member

    kares means that a jew is excised from their spiritual source

    in reply to: Wedding Intro #881564
    pcoz
    Member
    in reply to: When a child eats traif. #881208
    pcoz
    Member

    Kozov – if the jew has destoyed their chelek elokah mimaal (im timze lomar), then they are no longer a chelek elokah mimaal

    in reply to: Calling all Talmidei chachomim – can you help? #880934
    pcoz
    Member

    takkeh yichus

    in reply to: holocaust #880879
    pcoz
    Member

    thanks, rather looking for material for an adult audience

    in reply to: When a child eats traif. #881202
    pcoz
    Member

    disagree – depending on your definition of Yid

    in reply to: When a child eats traif. #881199
    pcoz
    Member

    shaigetz – Aryeh Kaplan has the observation that every Jew is descended from approximately every Jew that lived 500 years ago about every 500 years

    in reply to: Hashkafa for entering secular workforce #880998
    pcoz
    Member

    working is a moyredike zechus becuase you can learn from your boss what yiras shamayim means

    in reply to: …do I also need to… #1082306
    pcoz
    Member

    I was once at an aufruf in the Mir, one of the roshei yeshiva was talking and everybody was being very attentive. Rb Chaim Shmuel Lopian z”l though was enjoying his apple strudel, I was very impressed by this (although I never have understood anything he says on shev shmatsah)

    in reply to: Hashkafa for entering secular workforce #880991
    pcoz
    Member

    I am open to all offers to anyone who wants to support me

    in reply to: Inaccurate things we learned as kids #1222355
    pcoz
    Member

    although I think the gemara is keneged the metzudos becuase the gemara explains lo kom ruach be’ish since krias yam suf means no-one frequented that establishment

    in reply to: Inaccurate things we learned as kids #1222354
    pcoz
    Member

    Funny thing, I had it the other way round. I told the other kids in my class it meant an inn-keeper (following the metzudos) and they didn’t believe me

    in reply to: Inaccurate things we learned as kids #1222350
    pcoz
    Member

    the teachers are chayav misah!

    the gemara says that when dovid’s only killed the male amalekim becuase his teacher taught him timcheh es zachar amalek – dovid hamelech said to the general’s teacher – arur oseh meleches hashem remiyah vearur moneah charboh midam, ika de’amri katlei (dovid hamelech killed the teacher) veika de’amri lo katlei

    in reply to: chicken #881024
    pcoz
    Member

    Csar: In either case, asking a shaila isn’t sufficient.

    Agreed. I am highly allergic to people asking rabbonim dinei mamonos queries that involve them.

    in reply to: Hashkafa for entering secular workforce #880979
    pcoz
    Member

    far east – I think the point is – ein hachi nami – klal yisrael needs all sorts – but the Rambam is just coming from a perspective of ‘why me?’ – why should I be the dufus (like me) who goes to work and not learn. He is not making an empirical statement.

    This is along the lines of the gemara which says ee ephshar leolam belo burseki uvelo bursi – aval ashri mi sheumnosoh bursi oy lemi sheumnosoh burseki.

    Sure the world needs both, but why do you need to be the sucker if you don’t have to be?

    Apologies to all in the trhead if this is a bit straightforward

    in reply to: chicken #881019
    pcoz
    Member

    yitay.. hageh atzmechah!

    If you say that the chiyuv for nizakin is that you are automatically chayav on all nizakin that your mazik does – just that shemirah paters you from the hezek (chakirah in rashi of kol shechavti bishemirasoh…b”k 9b) … would you say when you buy a chicken from the butcher’s you have been koneh a mazik and you will be chayav in its smelly nizakin unless you are shomer it?

    Avadah and avadah nicht!

    If it gets smelly, then sure it’s a mazik, but before that it’s schnitzel and all good things

    in reply to: When a child eats traif. #881155
    pcoz
    Member

    The worst thing is when people try to cater for you and then you get there and you figure out that you don’t eat from the standard of kashrus they have organised – that can get veery sticky

    in reply to: chicken #881017
    pcoz
    Member

    Var vost host du nicht dahert meine gevaltige chiluk? Ich geh uber chazeren noch a mohl;

    Ah chicken heist nicht a mazik!

    Of course scientifically a chicken has the capacity to be spoilt, but this is a farout and extremely odd case that this propensity should cause hezek. Therefore it is not classified as a davar hamazik therefore leaving it in a car is not a maaseh hezek.

    in reply to: chicken #881015
    pcoz
    Member

    yitay…: Yes, I have accepted shemirah on your house – that my pit bull terrier won’t rip it apart while I leave it there.

    I have another taynah / chiluk though;

    As Reb Chaim would say – ah chicken iz nicht a mazik!

    Hesber – I don’t think anyone would consider a chicken as a davar hamazik. In the case of avno sakino umasao – it is obviously a potential danger to leave something on the edge of a roof where it can fall. When it falls – that item causes damage.

    Chickens don’t cause damage, only rotten chickens do. A rotten chicken iz ah shinuy maaseh from the original fresh edible chicken. Therefore there is less of a maaseh mazik here than in the case of avno…

    in reply to: chicken #881011
    pcoz
    Member

    In your comparison to avno sakino umasao do you mean to say that seeing as the av here seems to be esh which always has a koach acher meurav bo therefore there is no requirement to have an original maaseh mazik?

    i.e. would you agree that for other other avos nezikin you do need a maaseh hezek for a shomer to be chayav?

    in reply to: chicken #881007
    pcoz
    Member

    The mishnah has 2 cases – hiniach bireshus and hinicah shelo bireshus. In the first case I am patur for the hezek caused to the baal hachatzer’s animal, in the second case I am chayav.

    In this case, I was meniach bireshus but it was understood this was for a limited time only. The hezek was caused becuase I left it beyond the permitted time.

    In the case of the mishna, of hiniach shelo bireshus, my hanacha is the kerias bor – so is the maaseh mazik. In a case where I was machnis bireshus and the hezek only could have come about becuase the object was left there for too long, is there a petur that there is no maaseh mazik?

    My initial hanachah was not a maaseh mazik because it was bireshus, and just leaving it there longer is not a maaseh.

    Vos sogst du?

    in reply to: Hashkafa for entering secular workforce #880964
    pcoz
    Member

    umalah haaretz deah es Hashem kemayim leyam mechasim – the chafetz chaim says this means that although the surface of the sea appears to be flat – the depth of the sea depends on the depth of the sea bed.

    Similarly when mashiach comes the amount of deah es Hashem that will be given to each person will be toleh on the amount of hachanah they made in olam hazeh.

    According to me this means that if you go to work becuase it is a mitzvah then when mashiach comes all your professional knowledge will be converted to Torah.

    in reply to: What's a Goy Better Off Doing? #880567
    pcoz
    Member
    in reply to: What's a Goy Better Off Doing? #880564
    pcoz
    Member

    mdd: eternal Gehenom – not according to the Ramchal

    in reply to: Jokes #1202191
    pcoz
    Member

    What is the father of all corny jokes? Pop corn

    One word for an ill bird? Illegal

    One termite walked into a bar and asked the other termite, Where is the bar tender?

    in reply to: Is it possible to be happy in a job you hate #880745
    pcoz
    Member

    it is a mitzvah to hate work, Reb Tzadok says that it is reasonable to daven that you should be able to just learn

    in reply to: Job #880573
    pcoz
    Member

    keep formal records of what you are accomplishing and chat with him about it informally

    in reply to: What's a Goy Better Off Doing? #880551
    pcoz
    Member

    Abe: Bemechilas kovod torasoh I still think the question dosen’t make sense. If a goy is nisgayer they are kekoton shenolad – it is not the same person, this is giyur and this is shehivdilanu min hatoim. Your question implies that the 2 tzedadim are in the same ball park.

    in reply to: What's a Goy Better Off Doing? #880544
    pcoz
    Member

    “Is a goy better off in the Olam HaEmes if he is mgayer” – if a goy is megayer then he is Jewish and not a goy

    in reply to: How and where do they get the Parchment for Sefer Torahs? #880402
    pcoz
    Member

    In the tannery I used to work in they called them slinks

    in reply to: How and where do they get the Parchment for Sefer Torahs? #880400
    pcoz
    Member

    Some gelatin which is used to make lollies and ice-cream is made from cow face pieces. That means you have a person standing in the tannery cutting the faces of the cows from the hides, they remove the ears becuase these are made into dog chew treats. I hope your animal rights activists don’t like ice-cream.

    in reply to: Popa on parenting #971318
    pcoz
    Member

    What do you use?

    in reply to: Infertility treatments – Tzedaka?? #883869
    pcoz
    Member

    I don’t think according to the Rosh there is a chiyuv of maaser kesafim. I think the link to dinonline is incorrect becuase the sort of precedences listed in the link relate more to the type of town centric tzedaka that you find in the first perek of bava basra, not to an individual’s obligations. I can’t remember off hand who wrote the hagahos but it has a haskomoh from Rb Avrohom Gurwicz shlit”a.

    in reply to: Infertility treatments – Tzedaka?? #883862
    pcoz
    Member

    I think according to the hagahos on my Orchos Chaim le’Harosh beyond a very basic chiyuv each year which does not amount to much where you give your tzedakah is up to you.

    in reply to: How and where do they get the Parchment for Sefer Torahs? #880394
    pcoz
    Member

    ItcheSrulik – you can get shlil today, the industry term is slinks. These are normally from aborted foetuses taken from milk cows where the cow was brought to that state in order so that it would produce milk. Slinks are quite cheap becuase they don’t have many other uses.

    I have seen the diamond pattern, but I guess not all klaf is necesarily dried the same way. There were some yungerleit who started producing chemical tanned klaf in Israel a few years ago. Anyway I doubt if you are buying klaf today that this is hand tanned and frame dried unless you paid a premium for it.

    pcoz
    Member

    We had that problem once, it was due to possums in the roof pushing out the screws from the plaster

    in reply to: How and where do they get the Parchment for Sefer Torahs? #880391
    pcoz
    Member

    most klaf nowadays is machine processed, not ‘stretched between a wooden frame etc.’ That’s why if you look at the klaf of new sifrei torah you will see a diamond pattern which is the pattern of the metal grid the klaf was dried on. Also I’m not sure it’s still done with lime (which is quite slow). The old style klaf is becoming difficult to get hold of and does provide a better writing surface.

    in reply to: Negavtive Speach ? Is that our way ? #880171
    pcoz
    Member

    Musser zoger! That is pure loshon hara

    in reply to: Going off the Derech #1181729
    pcoz
    Member

    This thread is out of my depths, but here’s a thought from Rb Yitzchak Blazer z”l

    The passuk says hu yeshufcha akev veata teshufenah rosh – he will strike at your ankle and you will crush his head.

    He explains that when the yetzer hara attacks he does so in a way in which the situation gets progressively worse, the attack starts from the heel and works its way through the rest of the body. However when the yetzer hatov wins the situation changes suddenly for the better, similar to the snake’s head being crushed.

    I don’t believe that any effort anyone ever made was lost, so regardless of whether or not there seems to be an effect at the moment, something always sticks.

    in reply to: Infertility treatments – Tzedaka?? #883839
    pcoz
    Member

    I find this thread very weird

    ??? ??? ?????, ??? ?? ????? ????? ??? ????. ??? ????? ?? ??? ?? ??? ??? ???? ??? ???? ????? ??? ???, ????? ??? ??? ?????.

    Why are we raising as a discussion helping people in this situation?

    pcoz
    Member

    funny you ask

    in reply to: Going off the Derech #1181721
    pcoz
    Member

    slightly off topic but not really:

    simchah is a function of accomplishment and people feel good about things that they are good at. For someone to be attracted to a particular lifestyle, they have to be allowed an opportunity to excel at something which is admired within that society. Blandness is very off putting especially for teenagers. So whatever your son is good at, I suggest that he cultivates it and is praised for it.

    in reply to: Infertility treatments – Tzedaka?? #883823
    pcoz
    Member

    apushatayid: This is absolutely incorrect, the halacha is that if a rich man becomes poor you are obligated to give him tzedakah so he can resume the standard of living he once had including slaves to run before his chariot. Mah nomar umah nedaber in this case. In the days of the shulchan aruch it was not possible to treat these things medically, now it is.

    in reply to: job advice needed #882646
    pcoz
    Member

    Statistician

    Data analyst

    Data modeller

    Operations scheduling

    in reply to: CCTV on Shabbos #879655
    pcoz
    Member

    Rb Frand gave a shiur that this is mutar – he was discussing faxing to America when it is shabbos in USA but in your timezone shabbos is out or not yet in. He said it would also be mutar for the recipient of the fax to read it in this case.

    in reply to: CCTV on Shabbos #879651
    pcoz
    Member

    So why should a CCTV camera be assur? Even if the image is recorded to a hard disk this is not kesivah just as erasing a file with the Shem Hashem in it would not be mechikah

    in reply to: CCTV on Shabbos #879649
    pcoz
    Member

    Sam2: This is not the minhag ha’olam. According to that psak if you ever loaded a website or document that showed a shem Hashem you would have to leave your computer and monitor running forever untouched.

    in reply to: CCTV on Shabbos #879644
    pcoz
    Member

    If I write a shem Hashem on a computer screen, there is no issur mechikas Hashem for me to switch the computer off becuase the writing was never meant to stay there in the first place. This is better than writing with fruit juice say, becuase in that case the writing is at least nominally writing which is meant to have some permanence, but here no-one would think that any writing on a computer screen is meant to be permanent in any way, otherwise you wouldn’t be able to continue using your computer to display other things.

    The same would seem to apply to walking in front of a CCTV camera, which should be mutar.

    I don’t think the notion that ‘the machine (camera etc.) is doing it, not me’ has any validity becuase machines aren’t sentient and they simply do what you make them do.

    in reply to: Where to find Making Of a Gadol #901680
    pcoz
    Member

    I don’t but I have figured out a great get rich scheme. You publish a book, get it put in cherem, and keep a few copies to sell yourself on e-bay.

    in reply to: Kids at Kiddush #934690
    pcoz
    Member

    herring and eier kuchel is wasted on kids

Viewing 50 posts - 401 through 450 (of 541 total)