Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Dear Proud,
You are allowed to vote for Trump, even though he ignored his duties by not fighting the pandemic.
Dear Som,
If the feds would have done what the states did, it would have had a huge impact. China only had one epicenter. The U. S. is on it’s fourth.
Dear Participant,
Did you notice that the U. S. is the only country in the developed world that was so badly hit? Nobody thought this would happen.
Dear Two,
You are getting closer. It is called optimizing public assets. Without it, all the private companies would have ten-fold expenses. And, marginal profits. The USPS could be closed when it is no longer needed. Not when it is no longer a cornerstone of the US economy.
The funny thing about this thread, is that everyone jumped on if 9/11 was Clinton’s or Bush’s fault. There is a much better debate about the other event in the OP. Oslo came after the longest republican run in the white house, since the state was created. Israel had it’s first public spats with the american president in the eighties. ALso, the PLO was resurrected before Clinton took office. If Carter had won a second term, there probably would not have been an Oslo or an intifada. Though overall, Israel could be in a worse situation.
Dear Avi,
That is the interview that we have been discussing.
She was answering why she is okay with the possibility that some other leader can take over the BLM movement. Government and civilization are not part of the interview. Therefore, lack of central leadership, has nothing to do with anarchy. Incidentally, one can have Marxist views, and be completely opposed to anarchy.
Marxism has nothing to do with the ‘no rules anarchy’ concept.
Dear Proud,
To whom do you refer as ‘liberals’, and why do you think they are bad?
Dear One,
The Obama administration was not hostile to jews. This is the USA, not Argentina or Pakistan.
Biden is the same gaffe expert in his seventies, that he was in his forties. He wasn’t being called senile then.
Your facts are fictions. Again. I enjoy the parody.
Thanks!
There is an esteemed yeshivishe posek, who supports calling Hatzolah when there is a car crash on shabbos.
How would Hatzolah know if the person is jewish or not? I never heard them asking during a call.
Dear Reb Eliezer,
This is all after the fact. If a congregation would require everyone to daven bareheaded, there is no clear reason to stop them.But to not misunderstand me, if one decides to wear a (black) hat then he should. There is nothing wrong with a (black) hat.
IF the USPS would close, the cost of delivery to the boondocks would be astronomical. We would probably see the costs of all delivery services go up a lot. Which would be a blow to all the home delivery throughout the nation. Even Amazon could take a big hit. ‘Free’ economics, is never a vacuum.
Dear Akuperma,
Your insistence on the lockdowns not being justified, is akin to confusing east and west.
Dear Gadol.
Trump is not credible. He never was. He always makes it up as he goes along. Everybody who knows him understands that he exaggerates. Why would you believe he is following a strategy? I doubt he ever has counsel on these allegations. Counsel is for solving his legal troubles.
It is puzzling to me, that somebody who was in the public eye for so long should be so misrepresented by both his supporters and his detractors.
October Surprise? Ask Russia.
Pence does not have broad appeal, even among Republicans.
Welcome to the we know zero about american politics thread!
The country’s overall direction, is much more dependent on the politics of states and cities. On the federal level, congress is a greater driver than the white house. Presidents have an effect, but it is not so simple, as the President being Republican or Democrat. The President’s abilities are held by Congress. (They used to be. The system has been severely tested the last twenty plus years.)
Any tune/song/lyric preferred by a committed jew, is a jewish as music can be. (It is an art = culture, which is a different symbolism than religion.)
Dear Two,
The Wuhan lab was not a secret one. It collaborated with many international scientists. Over fifty american scientists have visited the lab. This strain of coronavirus was unknown to all of them. It is more likely to assume that it was in some secret lab, than to believe it was kept hidden in the Wuhan lab from so many experts. [Or that they are lying.]
Good question!
It is a mitzvah on the witnesses to carry out the execution. I am unsure if the requirement is on them personally. Perhaps they can send an emissary.
If they refuse to even be nominally involved in the execution, it is possible that the criminal would be released. I assume that the din of ‘the walking dead’ would apply. This does not seem to be a reason to retroactively negate the testimony.
I would not consider their defiance as challenging the bais din. Rather, it is an unwillingness to perform a mitzvah. I doubt the rule of makkos maardus applies to communal mitzvos. So, the only consequence the witnesses face, is being called reshaim, by denying justice. The same as a witness who refuses to testify.
I have had no problems ,leaving a nebulizer on all shabbos. If it gets turned off, it can be turned on with a spoon. If it gets unplugged, it can be turned off plugged in and then turned on with a spoon.
The same could be said for (black) socks.
Silence is better. The only reason people know about these far left nobodies in congress, is because the center right decided to respond to them. That gives them exposure, and they learn how to handle the spotlight. Given enough attention, they could turn into sustainable politicians. I wonder if it could be said, that the mainstream left created Trump and the center right strengthened Pelosi.
בנים means children. Being a masculine word, all the pronouns will be masculine. There is no difference between sons and daughters in basic jewish education. The parshah after the wise child, specifically mentions daughters.
I doubt the whole theory that the mitzvah of sippur yitziyas mitzrayim has more to do with your sons than your guests.
So?
We seem to agree that clothing does not make it’s own meaning. I think it has to come from the surrounding culture. You seem to say, that meaning can be put into it intentionally. That is our disagreement.
Rav Miller’s essay does not support your theory. It points to specific clothing being silly. (The mets cap.) People could attach serious thinking to their clothing. But they do not. You have even attempted to make that argument with the yeshivishe levush.
In the old world, there was a lot of importance attached to many trivial matters. Therefore, everything in life was attached. Changing your outfit could lead one to being excommunicated. It is not like that today. And it is a poor argument that we are inferior because of it.
The fact that it is required points to how shallow it is. If it really meant something, than the value of it could be taught. Then, people would want to wear it. Only because it is meaningless, it has to be “enforced”. Clearly, meaning still has not been put into it. If your friends want to make meaning out of it, they can go right ahead. But who is to stop them from attaching some awful meaning to it?
I do not know of any regular yid (Not a king.) from after Elkanah to Rabbeinu Gershom that had multiple wives.
Anything is possible. If this coronavirus was released from a lab, it likely was not from the one in Wuhan.
Am I supposed to question the whole theory of an obligation to cover the head? Or, how we get from covering the head to wearing a (black) hat? Or, why do you jump to the tallis now?
When the talking points keep changing, it makes for a poor argument.
Dear Gadol,
If a student in BMG develops symptoms, he is old enough to seek medical help on his own. [BTW- There is some setup for ill bochurim. There always has been.] Rapid testing can be done at Friendly Urgent Care. Quarantining in a dorm would not work. There are better questions to ask.
Dear Reb Eliezer,
I am not clear on what you meant to say after the comma.
Dear Rational,
For what is there to blame? Seems like a nice story.
Dear Reb Eliezer,
Wearing a hat was a sign of respect in 1920, not 2020.
Dear Simple,
Who said the world put chashivus into it? It is the same shirt as before. That was exactly the point the Rosh Yeshiva I quoted before was trying to make.
Gold has value because it does not rust. And lasts better and longer than common metals. Same for diamonds.
The Chazon Ish is in line with the tzaavah of Reb Avrohom Danzig: the author of Chayai Adam. There was a point in history that yidden thought that way. About everything. So what?
People attach all kinds of silly ideas to the black hat. There is no reason for someone who is growing without one, to get mixed up in it.
Ask your friends. I am the opposite. I get invited to all these places, with my hat, jacket. and white shirt. Maybe your friends can’t separate their clothing from who they are. A pity.
I am saying the opposite. People giving a “reality” to something that has no distinction, is propaganda. Such a “reality” would have to come naturally from the surrounding culture itself.
Day and night has meaning all by itself. And so do a million other nouns. Adjectives need context.
Dear Sam,
Those reasons are attached to the clothing. They are not the reasons behind the clothing itself.
Dear Charlie,
If you can please help me locate the Rema you mentioned.
The rulers of the land are required to maintain the peace. Therefore they are not held accountable for executions, unless it is for nefarious purposes. (Such as Achav and Navos.) Similarly, they are allowed to conduct destructive military campaigns, as long as they are not excessive.
Dear Ctr,
Herd immunity after a seven week lockdown is meaningless. It is a good indicator of the effective method used in the northeast. I’m not saying it was worth it, but it works.
PS Lakewood can have larger gatherings than the rest of NJ, because it is mostly the same people in the same place everyday. There is still very little eating out. And no big indoor parties etc.
This vaccine inoculates against science.
Dear Reb Eliezer,
What behavior? I disagreed with everyone and defended nobody.Dear Mesivta,
Nice post!Why does the ‘kosher flip phone’ deserve a mention? (Is it about Talmud Torah or not?)
Dear Ben,
I could not find the interview in text. I listened to the original interview. She is discussing that BLM does not need to be centrally controlled as a movement. That should dispel any notion of anarchy being their stated goal.The theology of Marxism has nothing to do with revolutions, genocide, or even governments. The entire chiddush of Marx, was that the future is always more about the class struggle, than the will of the rulers. This has been thoroughly played out in the last 150 years. It could now be stated, that today’s political platforms are yesterdays class struggles. And today’s class struggles will be tomorrows platform. The scientific method has found that this applies throughout history without many exceptions. (Yes, I am totally ignoring the Leninist variation of Marxism. Every anybody does.)
Dear Two,
There has not been a clear match in the wild for this virus. There are currently two theories as to what this means. 1) The virus was circulating in remote parts of China for years. 2) Maybe it did not originate in Yunnan Province. These are only guesses. It is still mainstream opinion that it emerged in humans in China sometime last year.I was not going by the data from China. If you look at the whole region (South Korea, Taiwan, Japan, Hong Kong, etc.) there is no comparison to the western hemisphere. There are other factors also. But there has been significant research that claims the strain in Europe was more contagious.
Some science:
1)It is no longer absolutely certain that this virus originated in China.
2)This specific coronavirus was unknown in the Wuhan lab. It is unbelievable for it to have been genetically manipulated and not been discovered after this much scrutiny.
3) China had a less infectious mutation than Europe.
4) The data from Jan-Mar is lower because of less testing.
5) There is a gigantic amount of information coded into each virus. Of all the data that was decoded to this point of history, none of it is political. Absolute zero.
6) Viruses are part of our existence. Blame whomever you blame for your own existence.
Dear Rebbu,
Why do you say iyun is the ikkur? I never met someone who learned real iyun who thought iyun is the ikkur.
What part of Torah has shaychus to Sinai? (I am not ch”v refuting anything. I doubt this question could be answered accurately without a lot of knowledge. You shlugged up yourself.)
The purpose of learning in Brisk is primairily to bekoine seder kodhsim by roshei yeshiva who have devoted their lives to this seder,
If this was the primary reason to go to Brisk, there would only be a dozen bochurim. There are other roshei yeshiva who fit that billing more than the Soloveitchik. In reality, if Brisk would offer the regular mashechtos there would be more of a clamor to attend.
” in accordance with their hashkafah.”
Well, I could go meet the mayor or got to a wedding in rags.
Dear Maivin,
“what makes something a kavod to where, is how the chachamim of our dor dress”Not sure what you meant. Anyway I read it, it is not true. And the Rambam makes no mention of it there.
If you meant the Rambam quoted by the next poster, it has nothing to do with how he dresses.Dear Gadol,
“any mitzvah” This explains why people do not give tzedakah on their way into shul. They have to put on their hat and wash their hands first.Dear True,
The food is served outside. The yeshivaliet can eat wherever they choose. (This is second hand information).Dear Ben,
My point is, that when BLM activists say “we are trained Marxists”, they mean they are experts in the understanding of class struggle. They were not advocating for socialism in any form.
Dear Rebbu,
Yeah, it is like first seder in any yeshiva.