Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
mytakeMember
Depends how much I need the money. Also depends if I feel I can handle it without letting it get to me.
mytakeMemberI was raised to give when someone asks. I don’t feel comfortable taking the chance of not giving just because he MIGHT be a phony.
January 3, 2012 4:07 pm at 4:07 pm in reply to: "Where Are the Men"-Article in last week's Mishpacha #844433mytakeMembercantgetit
That’s my point: They already know that they’re not dressed appropiately. So they don’t need to be told. They problem is not a lack of knowledge.
January 3, 2012 2:44 pm at 2:44 pm in reply to: "Where Are the Men"-Article in last week's Mishpacha #844429mytakeMemberThe Horse’s Mouth
“…Most frum people will stop doing an aveira if told they are sinning. “
In which case I have to assume that 90% of girls are sleeping through class and never heard the basic halachos.
January 3, 2012 2:40 pm at 2:40 pm in reply to: "Where Are the Men"-Article in last week's Mishpacha #844428mytakeMemberessy8
Yes, I believe it is Rabbi K from Prospect Park
January 3, 2012 2:40 pm at 2:40 pm in reply to: "Where Are the Men"-Article in last week's Mishpacha #844427mytakeMembercinderella
“Most people know the halachos of tznius, they don’t need to be reminded of them. Cover your knees, your elbows, nothing tight… we all know that. A father telling his daughter halachos of tznius will not help in the slightest.”
Thank you for pointing that out. This is EXACTLY what I was thinking while reading the article. I’m pretty sure that almost every single litvishe, chassidishe, and MO girl is very well aware of the basic halachos of coverage and tighness.
Blaming the husbands and fathers for the widespread negligence in this area is oversimplifying the problem.
I believe that if men were to start inspecting their wives and daughters clothes, it would have the same wonderful affect as when women become their husbands Mashgiach, and constantly bug them about learning more.
It IS a very sensitive issue to most women and girls. And although I agree that a father/husband has a responsibility to point it out when he halacha being violated, I believe here it would have no or negative affect.
So, back to Rabbi Kelman’s original question: If women DO know the relevant halachos, why do we dress the way we do?
mytakeMembergolden mom
“i did hear people strongly suggest not reading the bina (which i understand)”
What exactly is objectionable about the Bina? Just curious, because I read it here and there and never found a problem.
mytakeMemberBanned by whom?
mytakeMember????? ???? ????????
Rabboisai, we must protest! Everyone who reads this wesite should stop immediately! We must boycott the ads!
???? ???? ?????
mytakeMemberIf you listen carefully to how to talk about their friends, family, co-workers, etc. an appreciative or unappreciative attitude can be picked up.
Hatzlacha!
December 29, 2011 6:10 pm at 6:10 pm in reply to: Does it really matter why kids go off the derech? #842155mytakeMembersoliek
I agree with you. I enjoy reading ur thoughts on OTD kids, btw. Keep em coming.
mytakeMemberI sometimes do dances that are obviously meant to be provocative, if performed among men. I also sometimes listen to non-jewish music. This isn’t a confession, btw, there’s a point coming…
Being a good dancer and someone who really enjoys music doesn’t make things easier. But at least my sensitivities aren’t dulled to a point where I don’t see anything wrong with it. There is a reason why I would be shocked beyond words if I saw the wife of our Rav dancing like that, or listening to non-jewish music. And I hope one day I will be strong enough to stop doing both.
All I’m saying is, if you find it hard to stop, trust me, I get it. But don’t pretend that there’s no problem with it.
mytakeMemberWIY
Well said. Some parents don’t care, and some are so busy proving to everybody that they’re not being “extreme” and that they’re “with it” and so they basically hand their kids a free pass to the biggest filth on earth. Shame on them.
Having said that, it’s important to find a way to make technology available in a kosher way. It doesn’t work otherwise, and in the battle of technology advances vs. the bans put up by the frum communities, teachnology WILL win. So every parent must find a way to make it work without compromising their children’t ruchniyus.
And BTW- those things that must be banned totally (social networking sites, phones and electronics that don’t accept filters)must be spoken about. You can’t just ban it without an explanation. It makes kids (especailly teens)too curious! Most teens who get into this kind of trouble, weren’t looking for trouble, they were simply curious to see what all the hock against it was about. Explaining the spiritual/physical dangers involved can help-especially if you’re dealing with a sechel’dige kid.
mytakeMember“Just wondering, It is not debatable that the reason for seminary is to get a good shidduch.”
I must be doomed. Never went to Seminary. Oh, well, I’ll just hafta settle. Smoker, maybe.
December 26, 2011 3:21 pm at 3:21 pm in reply to: When Parents' interests are mutually exclusive to their children's #838403mytakeMemberYeah, well, it aint easy raising parents.
December 26, 2011 3:17 pm at 3:17 pm in reply to: When asked Shiduch info: Do I have to tell the girls side that my friend smokes? #838377mytakeMemberSee, this is why I like the CR. Great place to hang out and marvel at Hashem’s wonders. They say that the idiots and fools in this world is just God’s sense of humor.
BTW- I personally wouldn’t marry a smoker. And I would only ask the boy himself whether or not he smokes.
mytakeMembera mamin
I don’t want to risk anyone identifying me, so I’d rather not give her Tehillem name. (It’s on every Tehillem list I know of,though, including the one on YWN)
A freilichen Chanukah to you too!
December 23, 2011 3:33 pm at 3:33 pm in reply to: A "prayer" for a soul searching for his/her Zivug #998818mytakeMemberSilentOne-Wow. That is so beautiful! May your Tefillos be answered very very soon!
December 23, 2011 3:28 pm at 3:28 pm in reply to: When asked Shiduch info: Do I have to tell the girls side that my friend smokes? #838327mytakeMemberI’d ask my Rav, considering that this can be a very big issue to many girls (sometimes even a dealbreaker).
I’m with BTGuy on this one.
mytakeMembera mamin
Thanks for your reply. I had a feeling it never goes away. I too find tremendous comfort in talking to Hashem and I’m grateful that I feel that connection, it makes this whole experience bearable when it really isn’t.
I guess it’s just that even if I’m able to deal with my fears/stress/sadness, it takes so much emotional energy to do so, and I find myself feeling exhausted and emotionally drained all the time. Like I can get to that point where I can calm down and stop worrying or being scared but that whole Emunah workout takes a lot of koach out of me. Anyways, just putting my thoughts out there…I know it’s part of the package deal, I’m sure I’ll be ok. Always am 🙂
Thanks again for sharing.
May Hashem bentch us and our families with good health always.
mytakeMembera mamin
This question is off-topic, but if you don’t mind sharing I’d appreciate it.
I’m just wondering if at some point the fear of relapse goes away. My family memeber who is sick was first diagnosed about five years ago, was in remission for a few years, and then relapsed a while ago. Hopefully, with the help of Hashem, she will go into remission soon. I just keep thinking about those years when she was in remission the first time around, and there was a point where I stopped worrying about it on a daily basis. When she relapsed it was twice as hard for me to deal with the blow than by the first diagnosis. Somehow I now feel that I’ll never be willing or able to put this behind me. What if….? Is this gonna be a permanent cloud of fear over my head for the rest of my life?
Don’t feel pressured to talk about it if you don’t want you. I was just wondering, since you’re b”H ten years past that parsha.
Either way, it made me smile to hear that the patient is healthy. Thanks for sharing.
mytakeMemberYes, it’s a great place and getting quite popular around here.
December 22, 2011 3:06 pm at 3:06 pm in reply to: If somebody wants to work on their middos, where would you tell them to start? #838262mytakeMemberI agree with ItcheSrulik. Ask someone who knows you.
mytakeMembera mamin
Thank you for your post, I hope whoever in your family was sick is ok and stays that way always!
I can relate to literally every word you say, and it was nice reading your post, because like you said, anyone who hasn’t lived through this doesn’t understand. That’s pretty obvious from some of the posts on this thread. (But b”H they don’t, right?)
Since we’re dealing with a relapse this time, we have the benefit of experience and we try to make sure the patient only travels with family or friends to and from the hospital. The first time around, however, we were naive and believed that these organizations are as nice and helpful as their fundraising literature claim. Yeah, well…I don’t have to tell you how horrible it is to travel after a day of chemo. And that goes for the smoothest, most quiet ride. So when a volunteer messes up it’s a lot more than just an inconvenience. (BTW- I got the Bikur Cholim van and system abuse line soooo many times.)
We should probably team up for that book, I have some good stories 🙂
mytakeMemberWhich thread was published?
mytakeMemberLifeisgreat
In answer to your original question (I’m guessing you want my opinion, not a psak halacha, otherwise you would have asked your Rav), I think it’s okay to make the party. But teenage cousins of the opposite gender should not shmooze. My opinion.
mytakeMemberI don’t care what other people do, but if I’m ever rich enough to afford the extras, I hope I will focus more on sharing my wealth with others than sitting around and wondering if I’m too materialistic or not.
mytakeMembermra01385
I think you should make it a point to notice if he helped out. People appreciate it when their help is noticed and it encourages them to continue helping out. (It also feels kind of odd sometimes to anounce it…)
The same way how a mother would make it her business to notice if her child cleaned up the kitchen, she should notice if her husband helped. People like when their work is acknowledged, no matter their age.
BTW, the husband should mention it to his wife if she happens not to notice it once in a while. Why shouldn’t she know what you took the time to make things easier for her?
mytakeMemberreal brisker-
The point of my post was simply to remind volunteers to be a little considerate, and I think I was very clear with that.
mytakeMemberaries-Thanks & Amen.
mytakeMemberReal brisker
I never put any blame on the organization for these girls behavior. See my original post. Nothing about the organization.
May people like you never need to be on the receiving end of such “chesed”. May you always have the option of taking “taxis” vs. taking favors from “good volunteers like you”.
mytakeMemberoK, real-brisker, now you hit a nerve.
“These people are voluntering their services (you think they have nothing better to do with their time?”
If you have anything pressing to do at the time, DON’T VOLUNTEER. When you are in a rush while volunteering, you make the recipient of your chesed feel very bad. When you volunteer, to give someone a ride, for example, the recipient has every right to assume that you have the time/or made the time to do them this favor. Making them feel like a pain in the neck isn’t called doing them a favor.
“Anything extra is a bonus, if you don’t like the way they are offering it don’t take it. Asking for more is merely being a kofuy tov.”
You offered a ride at 10:00pm, for example, right? So that means I have a right to expect you at 10. I’m not asking for more.
You are talking about a rude ingrate of a hitchhiker. I am forced to rely on the help of voluenteers of an organization who claim to dedicate themselves to easing the burden of the patient and family. I wish I didn’t need their help. But if YOU CHOOSE to volunteer for them, don’t make things harder. Do it because you WANT to help me.
mytakeMemberI have had dealt with many chesed organizations that help cholim including:
Bein Ish Ubein Achiv
Chai Lifeline
Mekimi
Zichron Shlome
And several Bikur Cholim’s in the NY area
They are run by wonderful people and assisted by countless wonderful volunteers. None of them are perfect, though, and some are more focused on providing to the patient and family than others. However, like I said in my previous post, I don’t feel like I have a right to criticize any of them, being that I have (and continue to) benifit from them. For the same reason, I prefer not to single out one in particular. Doing so would feel wrong.
I am very grateful to all of them, no matter how uncomfortable I may feel about certain issues. I am equally grateful to Hashem that this experience is teaching me the kind of things about true giving that I probably wouldn’t have learned otherwise.
mytakeMemberSoliek
“There are so many kids that come from normal families who fell through the cracks due to getting involved with the wrong crowd or internet….”
I agree with your post. Let’s put “getting involved with the wrong crowd or internet” under “spiritual problems” and add that to the above list.
WIY
“I know plenty of people from messed up families and the only reason they got somewhere in life is because they decided to take responsibility for their lives.”
Assuming the kid is willing to take responsibility for their life, they are still going to “need to shift their priorities in order to survive. But when that happens, even though they are, in effect, the products of a normal society, abnormalities and all, they get shafted by the community, seen as second-class citizens, judged unfavorably. So where does such a person go?”
We have to stop tolerating all this garbage and stop enabling kids to think that they have an option to go off the derech.”
I’m sorry, but the last time I checked, these kids don’t ask for anyone’s permission before going OTD. So what exactly are we doing that “enables” them to have this option?
mytakeMemberHealth
In this case I don’t think it had anything to do with the organization. Nobody has to tell them that common sense says, keep things more or less quiet.
(BTW-Unfortunately I’ve been on the receiving end of chesed from many organizations for a while now, so I’ve had a chance to see up close what the flyers and auctions booklets and don’t tell you. And you are right that chesed is not always their primary motivation. But as someone who has benifited in different ways from some of these organizations, I don’t feel that it’s my place to criticize them…For those of you who might feel that I am being “too choosy for a beggar”- know that I am talking about basic mentchlichkeit, not being pampered. But those who have been there, know what I mean. I apologize if I sound demanding or critical. If you heard some of my stories you’d wonder how come they get away with it. But like I said, it’s not my place to fix these problems. )
mytakeMember“But I think you are wrong on excpecting an apology, or having any complaints. As the famous saying goes “beggers can’t be choosey”
Is it too much to ask that chesed should be done with a little bit of mentchlichkeit?
December 2, 2011 4:12 pm at 4:12 pm in reply to: Articel on NY Post Web-site on religious Jews child abuse #832514mytakeMemberI feel sick. And angry. If everything that aries said is true, I wanna do something about it so so badly. And I don’t know what.
I wish I knew for sure what the deal is with all the “covering up”. I wish I knew WHO the “Rabbanim” who cover these things up are. It makes me sick thinking that their book(s) may be in my house. I wish things were simpler and I can comfortably believe that our “Rabbanim” know what they’re doing and I should trust their judgement in dealing with these monsters. I wish we were living in world where money, power and kavod don’t get in the way of doing what’s right.
If I am ever lucky enough to be in a position where I can help even one victim, or protect even one potential victim, I hope Hashem will give me the strength, courage and clarity to fight like those who could’ve should have.
December 1, 2011 5:29 pm at 5:29 pm in reply to: Articel on NY Post Web-site on religious Jews child abuse #832476mytakeMemberI’m trying to understand something. If it’s true that “for the most part molesters are protected, hidden and swept under the rug”, then how can we really know just how widespread and common this issue is?
mytakeMemberLove Eden’s frozen broccoli or cauliflower florets. I find that their pieces are bigger than the other brands.They’re not cheap, though.
mytakeMemberMazal Tov!!!
mytakeMemberoriginial thinker
Ok, so now I’m an teensy bit confused…What exactly is your question? Are you saying that you’re afraid of death because you’ve done some things (“taryag avairot”)you shouldn’t have? Or that you’re afraid that your self image has become so distorted (“And if he can be so distorted in his thinking what about me?”) that you don’t know anymore if you’re doing/did good or bad….?
mytakeMemberHow come “S’vert mir lichtig” and “S’vert mir shvartz far di oigen” means the exact same thing…?
mytakeMemberGAW
According to zeeskite’s last post, a lack of Tznius may very well be a major cause of our troubles.
mytakeMemberMazal Tov! It’s sweet of you to post that. May you and your chosson share many happy and healthy years together! He sure is one lucky guy to get such a sensitive wife like you.
November 30, 2011 5:09 pm at 5:09 pm in reply to: Do you still get childish impulses to do silly things? #1060048mytakeMemberalways runs with scissors fast
Thanks for the laugh! Ur funny…
mytakeMemberOf course I’m not arguing with the Gemara. Especially since I’m a woman and I’ve never learned a stitch of Gemara in my life. But all you sem graduates must be able to help me out here…
We’ve all seen the sources that say that a lack of Tznius causes much Tzaros. Or causes Hashem to withdraw His protection from our homes/lives. I just can’t remember them. Anyone?
(Actually I did think of a possible explanation for the Gemara you mentioned. But like I said, I don’t do Gemara talk. Sem grads: Help?)
mytakeMemberoriginial thinker
“In short what can we do to be sure of a favorable judgement?”
It’s good to be in touch with our mortality. It keeps us focused on what’s important in life, and forces us to think about our purpose on this world.
The truth is, that’s all Hashem really wants from us. Stay focused on the big picture, and give every day your best. When you worry about a favorable judgement, keep in mind that Hashem sees your sincerity and efforts and you don’t have to be afraid so long as you’ve tried your best.
Don’t compare yourself to Tzaddikim. You are YOU, not them. Do YOUR best, and connect to Hashem in YOUR special way.
mytakeMember“If your father can’t afford it then don’t go. You are still young but realize that $18000 is a lot of money in this day and age (to make) and its not fair to expect your father to “cough” it up for you so you can have fun in EY for a year. This whole mishigass is not sustainable and I hope all of these Seminaries close down. People can’t afford them and it causes unnecessary financial strain on people.”
Well said, WIY.
mytakeMemberObviously I’m not paskening, just giving my opinion…..
If you have an excellent filter, I’d go with Jewish sites online versus the radio.
-
AuthorPosts