Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
motchah11Participant
I believe one can be nisgalgel a maximum of three times.
motchah11ParticipantThe answer I gave is the explanation given by Rabbi Noach Weinberger z”l from Aish Hatorah.
motchah11ParticipantBecause Hashem wished to create beings as like Himself as possible. And just as it is impossible to give anything to Hashem, He created humans to strive to be givers and not takers. Thus, nahama dich’sufah, the bread of embarrassment. We cannot easily accept something for nothing.
November 9, 2020 7:03 pm at 7:03 pm in reply to: Do American Jews care about Eretz Yisroel? #1918307motchah11Participant@youngrechnitz, Why do you point only to the Second Amendment? Democrats are pretty rough against the First Amendment too. They have fought against religious expression & free speech in many cases — as longs as it’s Jews and conservatives.
motchah11ParticipantI’d like to know about food distributions in Rockland County.
motchah11ParticipantCharlieHall: That is a stupid argument. They are chayiv misah for each and every of the 7 Noahide Laws. No one said that theft is murder. I’m sorry you don’t accept the Talmud’s rulings, but I’m fed up with apikorsus.
motchah11ParticipantThe relevance is to voting. Do we have to vote to stop goyim from performing abortions or not?
motchah11ParticipantAccording to the gamara in sanhedrin, In a scenario that the unborn endangers the mothers life, a goy wouldn’t be allowed to kill the baby and yid would be allowed
motchah11ParticipantI have my answer. The gemara in Sanhedrin says they are chayiv misah for abortion.
motchah11ParticipantSam Klein, the 7 Mitzvos Bnai Noach are general rules. They include at least 77 detailed Laws in their purview. It’s not just the 7 Mitzvos themselves. Each one has codicils (if that’s the right word) and so forth.
motchah11ParticipantWelcome back! I promise that here you will not be judged. There are too many of us who have wavered from time to time to judge anyone else. What can we do to help you in your situation? If you need something, please tell us. If you live anywhere I can reach I will be glad to help you, bring you something. I would invite you to my house but with the Coronavirus going on I don’t know what to do. But if that’s what you need, I will ask my wife.
motchah11ParticipantVery nice!
motchah11ParticipantOkay, not in the Serengeti, but in Borough Park, late Thursday night; someone is coming home from mishmar, and he turns a corner and walks right into a trap — five scary looking individuals armed with knives. He’s feeling pretty vulnerable right then.
But he whips out his bag of favorite hamentashen — raspberry filled, of course — and shares it with the scary-looking gentlemen, and everyone parts friends.motchah11ParticipantI have heard that the Yaavetz paskens that we should not use Loshon Hakodesh as a speaking language until Moshiach comes. But I just heard it; I have not seen it inside, nor do I know where it can be found, if it indeed exists.
January 23, 2020 3:12 pm at 3:12 pm in reply to: Why do many people in Lakewood drive way to fast? #1825454motchah11ParticipantThis is new? In Monroe almost everyone drives like an entitled lord in a hurry. I hate driving in Monroe. And in Monsey every goyisher car service drives like they’re on a Sunday drive, slow as molasses, without blinking before turns.
motchah11ParticipantWelcome to the family.
motchah11ParticipantTwo things guarantee happiness: gratitude and חסד. Be grateful to Hakodos Boruch Hu, and do חסד to other people. Both will fill you with happiness, I promise you.
motchah11ParticipantHuman nature being what it is, is it surprising it’s so difficult to match two people? The Ribbono Shel Oilam sits and is mizaveg zivugim all day. People keep changing, and theor matches keep changing.
motchah11ParticipantFirst he blocked me as I was trying to walk on the sidewalk. Then I turned around and saw how he was parked. His car blocked three parking spots.
motchah11ParticipantOh please, I’m just predicting.
motchah11ParticipantI can guarantee that we will not be zoicheh to nissim giluyim or achishenah. I look around, and the only way I see that the entire Klal Yisrael will all be zoicheh is if it chas v’sholom happens like in Mitzrayim, if most Yiddin are niftar min ha’olam, chas v’sholom. Otherwise, I don’t see it happening. I think Hashem will be mirachem on Klal Yisrael, and bring the geulah slowly, being mikarev everyone to the Emes.
motchah11ParticipantNo, he parked sideways, right in the middle of one spot. so he stuck out onto one spot behind him and another spot in front of him.
September 25, 2019 6:34 pm at 6:34 pm in reply to: Why do people comment without actually reading the o p? #1789716motchah11ParticipantA roundabout is a traffic circle.
September 25, 2019 8:20 am at 8:20 am in reply to: Why do people comment without actually reading the o p? #1789499motchah11ParticipantWell, at the roundabout near my home there are never any police cops, because where would they stand?
motchah11ParticipantI was once blocked on the sidewalk by someone who managed to take up all three spaces. I couldn’t understand him until I saw that he had parked crossways and blocked three parking spaces on a busy erev Pesach. My mind was boggled and I am still taken aback.
motchah11Participantmunkatch: That is only one of the two ways that the posuk says it can happen. Again, Chazal say clearly that it can happen with nissim giluyim, if it happens “achishenah.” But if it happens “b’ito,” that posuk in Michah will not happen.
motchah11ParticipantReb Eliezer: I know. But why is the assumption that it will happen “achishena?”
motchah11ParticipantHamakom: That being the case, the only possible way is for it to be b’ito. And that is a process that will happen slowly.
motchah11Participantcoffee addict: Of course I want to be considered zoiche! But it must be all of Klal Yisrael who are zoiche in order for it to be achishena, and wanting doesn’t make it happen.
motchah11ParticipantI posted four responses here, yet none of them showed up.
July 26, 2019 5:33 pm at 5:33 pm in reply to: Can a husband bring down his wife (take her farther from Hashem)? #1765864motchah11ParticipantSomeone, almost forty years ago, told me there is a gemara that says that a man married a woman tzadekes, and she turned him into a tzaddik. Some time later he lost his wife and remarried, and married a rashanta, who turned him evil.
But I have never seen it inside, and I don’t know where this alleged gemara is.
July 23, 2019 2:31 pm at 2:31 pm in reply to: Why are those behind this site over on ona’at devarim? #1764358motchah11ParticipantWhat snide comment do you mean?
motchah11ParticipantAnil: When I was single, I used to resent the women who opined that a man should wait until he’s, say, 24, before getting married. I was suffering as a single. Furthermore, Chazal say “ben sheminag esray lichupah.” Are we going to push up the year for a bar mitzvah too, because “today’s boys are less mature?”
July 21, 2019 11:12 am at 11:12 am in reply to: What are any issues with serving a role in Conservative Shule? #1762089motchah11ParticipantDaasYochid:
What are you talking about he HAS to shave and drink cholov stam? What nonsense! Rav Koshe zt”l was mattir these things under certain situations, but spoke and wrote against doing them. Just because he follows Rav Moshe’s psak against entering Conservative and Reform temples means he HAS to shave and drink cholov stam? What in the world are you talking about?
motchah11ParticipantThe Sefer Chassidim siman resh vav (206) says that if a man is misnave about Moshiach, you know with certainty that he was fooling around with the Shem Hamiforash or other forbidden things , and bothrring either molochim or shaidim, and they got angry at him for it and so they told him this nonsense in order to embarrass him and those who believe in him.
Look it up yourself.motchah11ParticipantNimnu vigumru: The world is a mess.
motchah11ParticipantIt’s more complicated than that. My sister is Satmar, and lives in Williamsburg. She has a Satmar neighbor who told my brother-in-law that the only reason he makes a Sukkah is because of his wife. He, personally, eats at MacDonalds from time to time.
Sadly, there are many frum-looking people who are not really frum at all. Who can say how many frum people there are when we don’t always know the truth?
motchah11ParticipantThe Shamir will make its reappearance when Moshiach comes, right? And the gemara is Maseches Shabbos says that everything Chazal promised will happen when moshiach comes (trees growing suits, women giving birth every day) has its counterpart here and now (sikk growing in tree bark, chickens laying eggs daily, etc.). So perhaps this is a semblance of the Shamir. May it come back soon!
June 11, 2019 11:37 am at 11:37 am in reply to: Who is Rav Shlomo Kanievsky? Is he being groomed to be the next Godol HaDor? #1740419motchah11ParticipantHow do I turn off notifications to my email?
motchah11ParticipantI keep getting notices in my email whenever anyone posts something here. How do I turn it off?
motchah11ParticipantThere is also a Kabbalistic reason for calling it Sholosh Seudos. Friday night the Yidden are in a state of kabbalah — accepting the kedushah from Shabbos. It is for that reason we say “Viyanuchu bah” — loshon nikaivah, during Friday night maariv, because loshon nikaivah is used in Kabbalah to indicate reception.
Shabbos by day we are in bichinas mashpiah — the state of influencing, that is, we bring kedushah into the world. This is why we say during davening by day on Shabbos, “Viyanuchu bo” — loshon zachor, because loshon zachor is used in Kabbalah to indicate giving, emitting.
During the time of “Sholoh Shudos” (Sholosh Seudos), we are in a third state: that of both receiving and giving at the same time. Therefore we say “Viyanuchu bom,” loshon rabim during minchah on Shabbos.
Therefore, “Sholo Shudos” is a time where all three seudos Shabbos come together and act as one, which is why we call it Sholosh Seudos” instead of Seudat Shlishis.
May 30, 2019 5:06 pm at 5:06 pm in reply to: Who is Rav Shlomo Kanievsky? Is he being groomed to be the next Godol HaDor? #1736027motchah11Participant@yabia: As I posted above, there have been gedolai hador ever since Moshe Rabbainu. The Rambam lists the leaders of each generation from Moshe Rabbainu to Rav Ashi. There’s nothing contemporary about it. It is a fact, and a pivotal fact in Yiddishkeit. It was here in every generation.
May 29, 2019 10:49 am at 10:49 am in reply to: Who is Rav Shlomo Kanievsky? Is he being groomed to be the next Godol HaDor? #1734926motchah11ParticipantYussel, what you’re saying is ridiculous. In every generation the Yidden have looked to their leaders, the gedolai hador, the poskim. The Rambam lists the gedolai hador from Moshe Rabbainu until iirc Rav Ashi.
motchah11ParticipantWell, in my family the girls also asked the Mah Nishtana.
April 16, 2019 3:10 pm at 3:10 pm in reply to: Did YWN cave to pressure and remove a news item? #1715569motchah11ParticipantI don’t see a chillul Hashem about the Notre Dame story. Perhaps in the comments, you mean?
March 17, 2019 9:26 pm at 9:26 pm in reply to: Confessing to your Spanish speaking friend that you are actually cheese #1697392motchah11ParticipantHmm, what kind of cheese?
March 15, 2019 8:58 am at 8:58 am in reply to: Confessing to your Spanish speaking friend that you are actually cheese #1696482motchah11ParticipantReb Yidd, I resent that remark! Who says that we need to cascade memos about our functional relative alignment? The truth is that I can make a window to discuss your four-dimensional monitored paradigm shifts. On the day after Shushan Purim.
motchah11ParticipantI googled “tzion menachem” and turned up nothing bad about the man. Where do I find this “bad information” people say about him?
January 2, 2019 4:42 pm at 4:42 pm in reply to: Can the “right” of modern Orthodoxy be saved while the “left” has left? #1656382motchah11ParticipantI hate to admit this, but from the “far right” of Chareidim there are many who no longer believe in Hakodosh Boruch Hu or His mitzvos. What can we do about them?
-
AuthorPosts