Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
If the country would crack down on crime more, then the thugs would be a bit less willing to do violent crime, v’hameivin yavin the resulting therefores. Meaning, specifically, someone who is found guilty of killing with intent, first degree, whose conviction is upheld by a court of appeals shoul be put to death. When you crack down hard, it sends a message and produces results – people won’t kill if they know that if they’re caught and provan guilty they will be put to death. This is a shita of a gadol of the previous generation – i heard it from one of his closest talmidim.
“It was quite a controversy amongst the mispalelim.”
Is there a rabbi? and even if not, who established the 15-min?
“There is nothing wrong with texting”
So why then do so many gedolim decry it? and what about those who get addicted and text even on shabbos, which is not a lo shchiach? And there is no such thing in physical existence that does not have a single downside whatsoever, R’ Simcha Zissel says this b’feirush, and it is also brought down by mekubalim by the eitz hadaas. Furthermore, what exactly are your inspiring credentials that entitle you to a cogent, relevant and meaningful opinion?! If anything, to issue such a blanket statement indicates tremendous ignorance of the inyan.
:mochoh timche – are you talking about my hachnosas orchim comment? because if you are, that is a rude comment. it was not anti halachik. i hope you weren’t talking about this (although i doubt it).:
I was saying only in a general sense.
“1)Am I not entitled to my own opinion?”
No one is not entitled to an opinion, for the same reason that random people do not have a relevant opinion on nuclear physics or quantum mechanics. Torah is no different. There is no room in Torah or Halachah for people to have their own “opinions”. The question posed by the OP is “what does Bitachon mean to you” – that is perfectly valid, as one can associate whatever meaning in something as he pleases, as that is toluy on the individual; to have an opinion what something is, on the other hand, is invalid and one who does not have the requisite daas Torah has no right so an opinion whatsoever. What the OP brought down is simply real tzedadim of a machlokes as spelled out by valid Torah authorities of previous generations.
“2)Read the title – does it not say “what does bitachon mean to YOU”?”
See previous paragraph – you didn’t confine your opinion to answering that question alone.
“3)Are you popa bar abba with a different name?”
No
who coined the term “troll”?
“beware of idiots.”
Very interesting that the number one thing you take out of the CR is the presence of myriad idiots at every turn corner and post just waiting to ensnare you in their webs of trickery to convert you to the worst apikorsus ever. . . . . . . . . .
“In my opinion, Bitachon is definition number two.”
Where did you receive your Rabbinic Ordination from exactly that entitles you to your very own opinion on what is obviously not a simple matter, as seen by the many many seforim written to explain this very question.
“Thank you for all the very helpful tips!!! Btw giggle girl thanks for clearing things up for me, I was getting a little worried there!
And thank you everyone for the very warm welcomes!! I’ll be sure to enjoy myself here!!!”
Realize that some take great pleasure in espousing blatantly anti-halchic views in sharp contrast to the rich heritage of rishonim, acharonim and gedolim of today, and this forum is a shining beacon of light to those of this ilk.
“And surely those who raise their voices and sing along with the chazzan which is like arrogance and they should be rebuked because it is like kalus rosh.”
Claiming that such a practice is not in any way halachically problematic, let alone praiseworthy, would seem to also fit into this category of arrogance.
unfortunately what the mishna berurah says is no longer paramount in the eyes of the masses (not that it ever really was but still).
“beware of idiots”
does that apply to oneself?
My rosh Hayeshiva told me about it he never told me who it is or where to find it.
There is an extreme deah that kol isha is even stam talking.
is czar a marriage counselor
quietly comes from chanah who davened her tefilah to HKB”H quietly which Eili, the reining Kohen Gadol at the time interpreted as a sign of gross intoxication.