midwesterner

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 151 through 200 (of 948 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Hashkafah on watching the Super Bowl #1828793
    midwesterner
    Participant

    I had a grandson’s bris in Yerushalayim on Monday morning. BH I did not even have the nisayon of watching any of it, as it started at 1:30 AM.

    in reply to: A rebbe iz Atzmus uMahus vos hot zich areingeshtelt in a guf #1823861
    midwesterner
    Participant

    The world was created from Tohu vavohu. Everything since has context.

    He was not defining people. He was writing about a rebbe. If benignuman is correct, it would apply to every yid in klal Yisroel. The rebbe was answering an age old question as to how one is allowed to ask a rebbe to daven for him when it is established that we don’t go through a middleman. His answer was that by going to a rebbe, you are going directly to Hashem because he is an atzmus ein sof etc. He said he had no sources, and it was just a feeling. If it was so elementary, he wouldn’t have gone out of his way to apologize for it.

    in reply to: A rebbe iz Atzmus uMahus vos hot zich areingeshtelt in a guf #1823203
    midwesterner
    Participant

    This has been discussed at length ad nauseum here. Not going to respond to the hashkafah here, there’s plenty of other talk on this matter, if you care enough to find it. Couple of quick facts though that are not debatable.

    This was originally published in a sicha titled Basi Legani, (1951) when he became rebbe. It was not some bochurishe hava amina. He was defining the relationship between a rebbe and his chassidim mostly in terms of his father in law, but at the point where he was assuming that very mantle of leadership. I’ve heard that in versions published since the ’80s, this line has been edited out.

    To knaidlach: If you want to prove that any questionable thesis or philosophy is consistent with normative Torah thought, one must prove it from outside that philosophy’s writings. Proving the Chabad hashkafah is normative Torah by telling someone to look in Chassidus Chabad puts you in an endless loop.

    in reply to: President Trump Declares War Against Iran #1820964
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Impeachment has been going on for months. It has more or less died down until Rebbetzin Nancy decides to forward the articles to the Senate. To say they are connected on some kind of timeline, like when Clinton bombed an aspirin factory the very day he was impeached, is ludicrous.

    in reply to: Siyum Hashas: The Daf Yomi Cycle didn’t End on 1/1 #1819086
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Saturdays and Sundays are potential playoff dates. The stadium wouldn’t have been available M”S anyway.

    in reply to: Siyum Hashas: The Daf Yomi Cycle didn’t End on 1/1 #1819068
    midwesterner
    Participant

    01/01 wasn’t the last day? Oh c’mon!! Fake News!!

    in reply to: Seder to Mefarshim in Gemara? #1812937
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Wow! The level of familiarity with what goes on in a gemara.

    in reply to: Should bochurim in mesivta date/go into shidduchim? #1809538
    midwesterner
    Participant

    No.

    in reply to: A pre-siyum siyum? #1808093
    midwesterner
    Participant

    The Giants and the Jets aren’t playing. But they didn’t know that back then when they had to sign the deal. The stadium is contractually obligated to not rent out the facility on any day that might be a playoff game for either of the home teams.
    In general, when the siyum had to be moved because the actual day doesn’t work, the Aguda has always moved it up rather than back. Their stated philosophy was (in the past; I didn’t hear anything about it this specific cycle) that such an inspiring event would cause many more people to want to join. They therefore give them a few extra days for people to arrange chavrusos and/or find shiurim. If they would make it afterwards, and then it takes someone a couple of days to work out a plan, they’d already be holding a few days into Brachos, and people would be discouraging by starting off already in arrears.
    [In 1982, the date of the actual siyum fell out during the Aguda convention, Thanksgiving weekend, They made their big bash in the Felt Forum a week and a half before on Sunday. The public explanation was as explained above. They may have also not wanted the event to go head to head with their convention, but they did not say that publicly. My rebbi, Rav Avrohom Chaim Levin zt”l, was honored to say Brachos daf 2 on the day that it actually fell out during the convention. He took that as a siman and a motivation, and he committed to learning daf yomi and stuck with it until his very last day, almost 5 cycles later.]

    in reply to: What do you think of converts? #1803430
    midwesterner
    Participant

    If you are only planning to do it soon, perhaps you should post on Shabbos to avoid risking becoming an akum sheshavas? Make sure your monitor screen is on so those who hold that typing without lighting is muttar will also approve.

    in reply to: After millions spent on promotion why are 30% of seats unsold? #1801507
    midwesterner
    Participant

    That was the once in a lifetime event known as the 12th siyum hashas. This will be the once in a lifetime event of the 13th siyum hashas.

    in reply to: After millions spent on promotion why are 30% of seats unsold? #1801176
    midwesterner
    Participant

    GH: Don’t project your own inadequacies on the large tzibbur which accomplishes way more in Torah than you give them credit for.

    in reply to: After millions spent on promotion why are 30% of seats unsold? #1800312
    midwesterner
    Participant

    The 68.5% ad was created and publicized at least two months ago. Did you think they haven’t sold anything since? Of course they have! They just haven’t updated the ad.

    in reply to: Frolicking Selichos Concert #1788975
    midwesterner
    Participant

    For thousands of years they didn’t have penicillin and chemotherapy. (Or maybe they did before Chizkiyahu Hamelech was gonez Sefer Harefuos.) But for thousands of years they did have musical instruments. And the poskim still said they don’t belong in shul. Maybe because they foresaw that people would be so small minded as to be able to see the videos of the frolicking that goes on at these Selichos events, and think that there is some similarity between that and shira in the Bais Hamikdash (or even a Chazzan with a background choir.)

    in reply to: Internet: The biggest source of brocha in the last generations. #1787236
    midwesterner
    Participant

    A comment to TFT and the others about the quick change from bad to good.

    I have been blessed by Hashem with six wonderful daughters. In the 11 year span from when my eldest went to seminary to when my youngest went, we watched the cellphone policies go from:
    1. Assur, no one had
    2. frowned on- just a few had
    3. neutral, get one if your parents are nervous
    4. good idea, you should probably get
    5. Everyone should get one
    6. The seminary will actually supply them so they can send group messages about a host of issues.

    in reply to: jewish song search on musipedia failed #1777787
    midwesterner
    Participant

    For the first one, try searching for the title Hishbati eschem. For the second one, try Higaleh na

    in reply to: 8 days: Be 🙂 or 😫? #1771031
    midwesterner
    Participant

    DY: Also some fair chunks of Breslov

    in reply to: Siyum Hashas – Inclement Weather – What Happens? #1745421
    midwesterner
    Participant

    APY: You don’t think that Aguda has already been on to that for a long time? You won’t be pitching anything to them that’s not already being pushed (except for the beer part maybe).

    in reply to: What would it take for you to move “OOT” ?? #1745326
    midwesterner
    Participant

    There is also a very wide range in the OOT world. Cities like LA, Chicago, Cleveland, Toronto, Detroit, Baltimore etc. have all the amenities that you have in NY, smaller volume, without a lot of the negativity described above. Other smaller communities, like perhaps South Bend, Omaha, Memphis, have some nisyonos when it comes to shopping, chalav Yisroel, etc. Then there are places in the middle, eg. Minneapolis, St. Louis, Denver, that have some things and are lacking others. There is no monolithic OOT.

    in reply to: Siyum Hashas – Inclement Weather – What Happens? #1745323
    midwesterner
    Participant

    The last one was in early August and it rained all day. It only began to dry as the program got underway, which was late due to the rain. You have to do what you can do, and leave the rest to Hashem.

    in reply to: Yiddish at Siyum hashas #1744514
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Probably more than 80% of the program is in English. Try to be sovel one or two chassidishe rebbe or similar types speaking in Yiddish, so that all the Yiddish speaking public (and they are a fairly large portion) can enjoy as well.

    in reply to: Unacceptable Grammar #1738440
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Ubiquitin: The name Yated Neeman was given by the Steipler zt”l, based on a posuk in Yeshaya 22:23

    in reply to: Understanding Lag Baomer #1732411
    midwesterner
    Participant

    How can the above be reconciled with Yochanan Kohen Gadol?

    midwesterner
    Participant

    When will this lehach’isdik troll who constantly subtly, and sometimes not so subtly twists divrei chachamim to be mal’ig on them be banned? And I’m actually not referring to Joseph!

    midwesterner
    Participant

    Methinks that some on this site have reached the madreiga of lomed al menas lekanter.

    in reply to: Hallel with Bracha on YH? #1724621
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Wow!! I think I agree with RG for maybe the first time! It bugs me when people call things apikursus, when they are just wrong, stupid or ignorant. Not every megaleh panim batorah even shelo kehalacha is automatically apikursos. No reason to fire off a nuclear weapon when a fly swatter will do the trick.

    to PY: Any rabbi who says you can suspend hilchos aveilus for YH is probably not a trusted enough source for most people on this forum. For sure not the ones you’re trying to market your ideas to.

    in reply to: Do women need to stay up all night of Shavuos? #1724610
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Women don’t need a kapara for sleeping in. They do it every day when their husbands are out at the 5:30 shiur or the 6:00 shacharis. Ever been in a Jewish bakery before 7:00 AM? Only male customers!

    (HT: PBA)

    in reply to: Hallel with Bracha on YH? #1724073
    midwesterner
    Participant

    LW: Mi she’achal shum v’reicho nodef, yachzor v’yochal shum v’reicho nodef?

    in reply to: I don’t understand outcome of Mueller report #1718259
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Participant: Excellent question. I suggest you ask Martha Stewart her opinion on the matter.

    in reply to: Why do we seclude ourselves from the world around us? #1713705
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Check out the Rambam in HIlchos Deios beginning of Perek 6

    midwesterner
    Participant

    “when english is optionary things become rampid.”
    One of the best posts in a long time!!

    in reply to: How to become a Gadol (not the bar mitzva kind)? #1699190
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Would assume the REC is Rav Elya Chazan?

    There is no specific seat for any specific yeshiva. Never was. Mir did not have anyone on the Moetzes after Rav Avrohom Kalmanovitz was nifter until Rav Elya Brudny. Not R Shmuel B, and not R SM Kalmanovitz. Philly had both R Elya and R Shmuel for a decent period of time. Was R Yisroel Belsky ever on the Moetzes? Don’t think so. Telz always had someone, but not since R Chaim Stein was nifter, unless you count R AC Levin in Chicago. But he was on together with R Chaim for many years, so that would shlug up the sevara anyway. And now he’s gone, so how many slots does Telz get, and who gets them?

    in reply to: Hebrew Publishing Company #1692935
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Working for Artscroll prohibits one from using a siddur published by another company?

    in reply to: A Solution: Finding Shidduchim (aka “Shidduch Crisis”) #1684970
    midwesterner
    Participant

    If this is not totally a troll attempt, it has got to be the number 1 all time dumbest post masquerading as a well thought out one.

    in reply to: shokling during davening #1678729
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Another source is Kol atzmosai tomarna . . .

    in reply to: Mishenichnas adar marbin besimcha📆🎉 #1674695
    midwesterner
    Participant

    There are those who say the Mishenichnas Adar we increase the simcha. And we continue to increase until Rosh Chodesh Av, when we are mema’et just a little bit. Let’s see what he looks like on 29 Tammuz!!

    in reply to: In Town versus Out of Town #1664382
    midwesterner
    Participant

    There are national brands of flour available all over that are Yoshon year round. No need to stock up like that.

    Good old Joe went on a rant in which he describes the greater quantity of yiddishkeit on the East Coast. Not sure he proved anything about the quality. Where I live there are also places with 3 shuls on a block. Not so many such places, but they are there. We fill our shuls, we fill our yeshivos. Brooklyn has more, because they have more people. But that is quantity, not quality.

    We have Hatzala, Chaveirim, Bikur Cholim, a Chessed Fund Warehouse that is unmatched anywhere in the world including Lakewood. And we don’t antagonize the police when they try to give a parking ticket, so they like us, and respond when we need, so there’s no need for Shomrim. And a Chevra Kadisha that does much of what misaskim does.

    We don’t have hundreds of gemachs, but we probably have dozens.

    I’m not finding children of local people moving to Brooklyn any more that are moving from there to here. Lakewood is different, because they go there to learn.

    in reply to: Please recommend me a good business start up book #1663508
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Psalms by Kind David et al

    in reply to: The world is in a state of Geula- and don’t misunderstand us! #1660489
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Happy to be in the Gan Eden Club. Not so excited about the pre-boarding though.

    in reply to: OPEN LETTER To My Fellow NY Hatzolah Members About Billing Insurance #1652395
    midwesterner
    Participant

    It’s not free money. It is money well earned. And the money will need to come in anyway, just a question of further taxing community resources, or finding some other untapped source that wont deplete pockets of baalei batim. Will relieve some fundraising stress on the community and free up some funds to be used for other charitable needs.

    in reply to: The world is in a state of Geula- and don’t misunderstand us! #1649123
    midwesterner
    Participant

    First night chiyuv to eat even in the rain but not sleep is due to the gezeira shava of Chamisha Asar to Pesach where it says Ba’erev Tochlu Matzos. Nothing to do with mitztaer and its relationship to the concept of teishvu k’ein taduru.

    in reply to: So who composed it first? #1647784
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Pretty safe to assume that any song by Carlebach and anyone else, was composed by Carlebach first. Exceptions that come to mind being the obvious Kumbaya on Shifchi Kamayim, and Volt Ich Gehat Koach on Songs of Shabbos.

    in reply to: The world is in a state of Geula- and don’t misunderstand us! #1632381
    midwesterner
    Participant

    B’crach echad is not a raya to anything. If so, you wouldn’t be allowed to but BIrkas Hatorah or anything like that before Beraishis.

    in reply to: The world is in a state of Geula- and don’t misunderstand us! #1632243
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Wow! The Tanya must really be heilig!! Not only a chumash, but they won’t even put Likutei Sichos or maamarim on top of it!

    in reply to: The world is in a state of Geula- and don’t misunderstand us! #1630855
    midwesterner
    Participant

    laskern: That is irrelevant. They are not saying sequence doesn’t matter. They acknowledge that it does. But if you’d really know what’s going on in the Tanya, your heart would tell you that it is equal to a chumash.

    in reply to: The world is in a state of Geula- and don’t misunderstand us! #1630786
    midwesterner
    Participant

    That Rav Moshe Feinstein “got along well” with the Lubavitcher Rebbe can in no way be construed that he held him to be his rebbe, the Gadol Hador, the Nasi Hador, or anything like that.
    I find it interesting that someone like CS, who proudly (and condescendingly) claims that Chabad (intellectual) is a higher madreiga than Chagas (emotional) has decided to accept the likelihood of the rebbe as Moshiach – a cornerstone of her philosophy in life – as coming from a feeling.

    in reply to: THREAD: Not for Anti-vaxxers #1623446
    midwesterner
    Participant

    I think that anyone who is bothered by profits made by pharmaceutical companies is extremely shortsighted. I am thrilled when they make money, and lots of it. You know why? Because that means that they will keep trying to come up with more and more new drugs to improve and extend our lives. Profit incentive has proven to be the best motivator to produce anything.
    All those people that complain about the drug companies making money need to look in the mirror. Are they, or anyone of their loved ones, taking drugs for anything? They should know that is only available in today’s world without those companies. (Obviously it all comes from Shomayim, but Hashgacha has arranged that these companies are the primary shluchim in our world for this benefit.)
    Does anyone know how much they spend on research and development of new drugs? And in how many drugs are tens of millions if not hundreds of millions invested in R&D, yet never make it to market? As long as they can make money, they will continue to invest.

    in reply to: Why should we not harrass the anti vaxers #1623448
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Very, very few of anti-vaxxers are parents of children who were harmed by vaccines. I know many people who are anti vaxxers. Not a single one has a child harmed. (One has a spouse that had allergies to some related issues, and was helped by changing away from conventional medicine. But children? None.)
    As is well known, the original research that proved the link between vaccines and autism, that kick-started the entire movement, has been more than debunked. It has been proven fraudulent.

    in reply to: THREAD: Not for Anti-vaxxers #1623403
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Herd Immunity may or may not be proven. But with these diseases making a comeback, and ground zero being Rockland County, Ocean County, and Brooklyn; I would suggest that ‘herd non-immunity’ is being proven before our very eyes!!

    in reply to: The world is in a state of Geula- and don’t misunderstand us! #1623272
    midwesterner
    Participant

    Time for Truth: TT has already acknowledged that OOT’s surmise was correct.

Viewing 50 posts - 151 through 200 (of 948 total)