☕️coffee addict

“As for the gedolim who never lived here, they have a different cheshbon. because of their communal duties.“

Avi,

So they’re making themselves lose out for a bunch of רשעים that don’t want to move? Better yet have them pasken to their community that they should move

And your reply to uknow implies that everyone in chutz l’arertz is rich, and can make it in Israel

You’re delusional (I guess that’s why all the meshulachim go there, right?)

Uknow,

Gut voch,

I’ll answer your last part first

“Also, can you explain your בלעם line?
Not sure I was זוכה to understand”

Billam said he was יודע דעת עליון (he knew what Hashem was thinking) so I don’t know what is correct

And this is how I’m answering your first question

All I know is what my rebbe tells me and both my Rosh hayeshiva and the Rav of my shul left eretz yisrael and live in the states so it doesn’t seem like there’s a חיוב to move to Israel, and just like there are countless gedolim that live in the states

“However, I do believe that ה׳ wants us to be in א״י.”

Some people might feel that Hashem wants us to live outside of Eretz Yisrael until משיח comes

Personally though my name isn’t בלעם and I don’t think your name is either

Uknow,

What you’re saying makes sense, however my main beef is when people make it sound like Israel is a utopian place where there is no שנאה which isn’t true

Therefore moving to Israel might not help save oneself from persecution

“1) The Shamir is described as a unique supernatural organism created bein hashmashot of the Friday of creation, and kept hidden, not an ordinary natural species of worm that eats rock instead of wood.“

Why would Hashem need to create both of this worm could do it?

“I think everyone understands that the split of the 10 Tribes happened waaaay before Jews were categorized as A or S. I think the OP is just trying rile me up.”

That’s right I was doing it to rile you up because of all your stupid “sfardim are better than ashkenazim” posts and it did the desired effect

I really don’t understand why people have to find a need to differentiate between different segments of yiddishkeit it brings to mind the marvelous middos machine’s “ahavas chinam” song

Thanks to all who replied

“Coffee Addict, what passuk”

Milhouse

“Yehuda won’t oppress Ephraim, and Ephraim won’t be jealous of Yehuda”

Joe

Hook line and sinker

I don’t think the passuk is talking about jealousy due to food Charlie

It’s talking about important things

Neville,

Come again?

Joe,

Some claim yoshke is Hashem

Joe,

The עשרת שבטים in English is 10 shevatim for (the ones that split off from yehuda)

“According to religious Zionists, galus is definitely not over, even for those living in Israel. We believe that the State of Israel is part of the geulah, but it’s not complete.“

So if that’s true that brings me back to my original question

“This is what golis is all about. You made your השתדלות now hashem wants you to leave.
Pack your bags and leave while you still can. בטל רצונך מפני רצונו”

Maybe I should say that about the people who don’t want to be a part of the draft

Manitou,

So if I immigrated to Israel I experienced geulah without moshiach? Why are we davening for moshiach just daven that we should win the lottery so we could move to israel