Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Orthodoxrabbi,
So you’re using the source that he can come from the dead by a person that says his father is moshiach but you’re arguing that his father is moshiach?
He would say the rebbe isn’t moshiach because it’s his father
“i think every chabadsker loves rav shach“
Well you’re mistaken
I’m sorry
I know a Lubavitcher that put up his middle finger when Rav shach’s name was mentioned
If you loved misnagdim you wouldn’t call them snags it’s like a person that’s calls Jews the k word and says he loves all jews
“i hope one day soon chabad’s love for every jew“
Except for Rav Shach and every snag
Food and board for starters
Ctlawyer,
I have had the same experience with chabad at my city of birth
Yechi,
Did any Lubavitcher believe that before the rebbe passed away?
Orthodoxrabbi,
“And yet he also says bar kochba was a melech and rabbi Akiva thought he was moshiach. How strange! The Rambam pashut says a king and ur gonna tell me bar kochba was a king without fitting how the Rambam says a king is established?!”
He minted his own currency, something which kings do
Is the Lubavitcher rebbe the only person that fits the criteria
What about bar kochba, or even other gedolim?
Menachem
The answer is, is that chabad is a great sect in yiddishkeit and it would be even better if it cut out “the rebbe is moshiach” naarishkeitin so the frum non chabadniks that you meet are trying to make chabad (and in essence the whole religion) better
Commonsaychel,
To answer you, if you don’t feed the trolls the CR becomes dead
Avirah,
Sinas chinam is looking how each of us is different and accentuating it
So Lubavitchers believe their rebbe is moshiach and can come from the dead, so what? It isn’t an aveirah (maybe a shtus) and they won’t listen to you and you won’t listen to them
You’ll think they’re crazy and they’ll think you’re crazy
I don’t see a point to multiple “rebbe being moshiach” threads and why now?
We need another anti lubavitch thread? You couldn’t just piggy back on a different thread?
Anyways is this a pre three weeks thread so we can get ready for sinas chinam?
As I’ve stated in another thread
I have two goldfish
Night mashgiach
Commonsaychel,
It wasn’t but I guess the guy talked a lot on the titanic
The definition of drone (before drones were invented) is to speak tediously in a low monotonic sound
Maybe we can revive this thread with those stories!
“If they clean the bugs off their lettuce it’s the same as any other lettuce.
It’s not like even the frummest kitchens are guaranteed to know how to be bug free.”
N0mesorah,
Not sure where you live but the frummest kitchens are somech on a vaad hakashrus and don’t check their own vegetables
Aaq,
What are you talking about?
Rightwriter,
Where is he in the Gemara? Spelled ישו?
“@coffee-addict I’m not sure what to take from that story. Obviously you viewed things one way, but I don’t know the precise circumstances, nor the people involved, to say that it’s an indictment of MO Yiddishkeit.“
I was saying a compliment to MO (at least to that MO kid) not sure where you got that I was bashing MO
“You can eat salads from most Barely Orthodox homes.“
Where do you get that from? You know there are bugs in lettuce that three washes can’t take out
Joe,
I figured you would nitpick
A pessimist always sees the glass half full and the Mishnah in pirkei avos calls this an Ayin Rah
Btw lobster is a sheretz so it’s six lavin that makes it worse than chazir
I’m not dealing with the older generation they might be a lost cause
And in my case the salad is also sheratzim however it seems like MO has gone away from the shittah that lettuce is a miyoot hamatzoi
I’m sorry to hijack this thread, not really interested in starting a new one and not interested in looking for one that it will fit into better
The shul that I daven shachris in (because it’s near my job) is MO. Today in between the first and second minyan I eavesdropped a little on a conversation that the rabbi of the shul was having with a father and his teenage son, it seems like there is going to be an engagement in the family and the other side might want to do it in a restaurant that’s not so kosher so the son wanted to know what he should do if that is the case. The rabbi said obviously you can’t eat the meat, but the cold food shouldn’t be a problem and that includes the salads
The boy wasn’t comfortable with it
End of story one
A few nights ago I was at a simcha of the Rav of my shul where I live and one of the attendees (who is a big part of the shul) was asking who’s the caterer and found out that it was a well known caterer, so he tells this story that he was at a different simcha a while ago and asked about the meat to the mashgichim over there and they didn’t know, so he goes around to the rabbanim at the simcha and tells them the mashgichim don’t know who gives hashgacha on the meat and everyone just kept on eating
I’m sorry if the point of my stories aren’t clear, but what I’m saying is, is that everyone is judged on his level, the MO kid that will be going to a not so kosher restaurant is giving more nachas to Hashem than the rabbanim that was ok with the meat
I don’t understand
I haven’t heard what you’re talking about and I don’t follow what you’re saying
Mentsch,
But if your “chumrah” is preventing you from doing it…..
Why can’t the “machmirim” just shop their chametz in a goyish store (ShopRite) and everything else in the Jewish store
It’s bein hazmanim already?
Seriously you’ve only posted three times and it was all OP never a reply to someone
Amil,
Never thought of that, I don’t even know where my local Audubon society is!
Aaq,
I work in an MO neighborhood and live in a mixed neighborhood so not sure what you’re getting at
Wow,
Never thought this thread would get political 🙄
N0mesorah,
Where are you located? I see a lot of birds flying around
This is probably the best place to put my question (not interested in starting a new one)
I’ve heard that exposure to this smoke (air quality) for 24 hours is like smoking either 6 or 12 cigarettes
If so why aren’t birds and outdoor animals dying left and right?
My phone has a weather app and it gives air quality
“The chamets sold before Pesach should be batel in the chametz bought after Pesach.“
כל קבוע כמחצה על מחצה דמי
😂😂😂😂
Thought my comment went through
Get off the $!?&@? beach
“CA: Actually, I didn’t intend to trigger a debate on the rebbe. I read enough of those to the point where some breaking news on the shidduch crisis would seem more relevant.“
And a lot of political threads don’t intend to trigger something about Trump
I like akuperma’s reply
“Yes its call the troller supermarket“
One way to spot a troll is if they haven’t posted anything from n the CR since they opened their account (3 years and 11 months ago) and they start by posting a new thread that could be inflammatory
My point was that when it comes to the midrash, you look in mefarshim to understand what it meant.
When it comes to a sicha, you refuse to even open up the sicha itself and see what it says, let alone ask someone learned in these subjects to explain it properly (excluding those in the CR. Online discussions just go in circles.)I’m going to bring up Rav Shach זצ״ל again
Do Lubavitchers know the context of what he said regarding the rebbe, you don’t
Nowhere in the Torah or Halacha does it say that we have to view אחרונים as תנאים
“I did not intend for the OP to morph into a debate on the Rebbe, Z’L.“
That’s the funniest line I’ve seen you write
That’s like saying someone didn’t intend for the OP to morph into something about Trump 😂😂😂
(Now we can’t start about trump just for the fun of it)
If you mean the living Torah museum then yes
Lol at commonsaychel’s mod, I like the comment!
Re the OP I think it’s bittul Torah mixed with pritzus on college campuses both which women don’t have a problem with
“I would never disrespect Rav Soloveitchik the way the Rebbe was disparaged on this forum shame on you.“
Lostspark
What about Rav Shach
I’ve seen Lubavitchers stick their middle finger when his name was said
You will never find an Avi Ezri in any Lubavitcher homeI wonder why
“The whole inyan of cheesecake is only to remind us of the Bikurum which is brought from the 7 species of the Land, flowing with Milk and Honey“
Do you have a source for that?
There are numerous reasons why having dairy is a minuag for shavuos
To the OP
Why is that different than food in general that numerous stores and people make in excess that gets thrown out daily
🥱
Another chabad moshiach thread?
ישראל ואורייתא וקודשא בריך הוא חד הוא
When klal yisrael is באחדות then we can be called ישראל
That’s why ויחן שם ״ישראל״ נגד ההר
I want to make an observation though
It seems like klal yisrael’s problem by קבלת התורה was the ג עבירות חמורות (we see that by the חטא העיגל) as such the first beis hamikdash was destroyed for those things
The next”קבלת התורה” was Purim (קימו וקיבלו) but they didn’t have אחדות (they were מפוזר ומפורד בין העמים) which is why the second beis hamikdash was destroyed because of שנאת חינם
Makes sense?