Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
January 25, 2015 10:53 pm at 10:53 pm in reply to: Why is everybody anti anti-vaccine theories, a dissertation #1100460Matan1Participant
Pardon my ignorance, but I think I missed something. Popa, what is the problem with the HPV vaccine?
January 25, 2015 4:03 pm at 4:03 pm in reply to: Why is everybody anti anti-vaccine theories, a dissertation #1100446Matan1ParticipantPopa,
Child abuse? Really? I can understand the reservation of some in the frum community about the HPV vaccine, but it does prevent several different kinds of cancers. It also has provides protection to males for some other diseases.
Matan1ParticipantI wan’t to pose a question. If the victim was Jewish, would we even be having this conversation?
I imagine that we’d all be running (rightfully so) to put the cop behind bars.
Just food for thought.
Matan1ParticipantCops can restrain suspects. They CAN’T put a suspect’s life at risk.
Garner was not resisting arrest, nor was he a threat to anyone. He was murdered by the cop, plain and simple.
Matan1ParticipantLet’s say he did resist arrest and pushed the cop (which the video clearly shows to be false). How does that give the cop the right to put him in a dangerous chokehold? It’s not like Garner was a threat. There were multiple officers around him, so I doubt that he could have hurt anyone.
Matan1ParticipantHe did deny wrongdoing, but I don’t see why that’s relevant. In America, everyone is entitled to a trial and is presumed innocent until proven otherwise.
Matan1ParticipantGarner did not physically resist arrest. I watched the video several times. He only starts to struggle when the cop puts his arm around his neck.
You can call me a liberal if that makes you feel better, but it does not change the facts. Eric Garner was killed by the police officer who put him in a chokehold.
Matan1ParticipantResisting arrest? Really? Garner said “don’t touch me” a few times. That’s it. How is that resisting arrest?
Matan1ParticipantExactly. Garner deserved a ticket. Nothing more than that.
Had he resisted arrest, Garner would be facing a potential felony. But fortunately, we have a tape of what occurred. It is clear from the film that Garner did not physically resist officers from arresting him. He was clearly upset at the situation, but did not in any way resist arrest.
Eric Garner did not resist arrest. Watch the video. He in no way physically opposed his arrest.
Garner was killed by the police officer on duty that night. No question about it.
We must protest his death and the outcome of the grand jury.
Matan1ParticipantHealth, pardon my ignorance, but what was he supposed to do? My understanding of police responsibility is that cops should our streets safe. Garner wasn’t a threat to anyone. Sure he was breaking the law, but in America we have a legal process where everyone is entitled to a trial. And last
I checked the penalty for selling loose cigarettes is not death.
November 9, 2014 5:43 am at 5:43 am in reply to: Modern Orthodox people (and sometimes Popa) are stupid #1041214Matan1ParticipantThe Ralbag went great lengths to explain how many of the miracles in Tanach were just natural occurrences. They way it was explained to me, God prefers to work within the system of rules that he created. God doesn’t like breaking the rules of physics. At least not too much.
Matan1Participantno?
October 13, 2014 5:25 am at 5:25 am in reply to: Why can't we write (and type) on Chol Hamoed.??? #1035062Matan1ParticipantSam,
What else do you think the Sanhedrin might change?
September 21, 2014 1:57 am at 1:57 am in reply to: If you think the R word is offensive you are retarded #1199685Matan1ParticipantPopa, if you’ve ever met someone who is so depressed that they can’t get out of bed, or so manic they won’t sleep for days, you wouldn’t throw the words bipolar around so lightly.
Or maybe you have met someone who is bipolar. In that case, I believe you are a highly insensitive individual.
Matan1ParticipantFrumnotyeshivish, I look forward to your response.
Matan1Participant1) I never said that the mind and spirit aren’t connected. I said that they aren’t connected in regards to mental illness. We can’t treat mental illness via the spirit. It just won’t work.
We know that depression is physical. Just look at a fMRI of a healthy brain and a depressed brain. We can see the physical difference. And when we treat depression with a physical cure, we see the brain return to its healthy state.
I’m not denying the relationship between the spiritual and physical. But psychology has developed so many physical cures, I can confidently say that mental illness is physical.
2) Euthanasia isn’t the same as suicide.
3) There is no way you can correlate incarceration rates with a failure in psychology. Do you have any evidence?
4) Really? You’ve seen patients killed off from psychotropic drugs? Examples please.
5) I believe in my spirit. I just don’t believe that it has anything to do with mental illness.
Matan1Participant1) I can easily prove the cause of an illness. Take a group of people with depression. Randomly divide them into two groups. Give on group a treatment and the other a placebo. If the experimental group shows more improvement, we can confidently say that the treatment had a direct effect on the illness. If the treatment is something physical (and not spiritual), we can say that the illness is physical in nature.
Of course, this wouldn’t tell you what about the treatment helped, but that the illness is physical.
2) You are right, I should have been more precise. Clinical psychology is about helping people with mental illnesses, just like an oncologist would help someone with cancer, or an accountant would help someone with their taxes. There is no heresy in a clinical psychology. It’s all about a professional in a specific field helping people who suffer from mental illnesses.
Matan1ParticipantSpiritual Doctor-
1) The existence of the soul has nothing to do with clinical psychology. Someone with a mental illness is not lacking in their soul. The two are not linked. Mental illness can be caused by a variety of things, none of which are in any way connected with something spiritual. To believe this is not only wrong, but also very harmful for people with such ailments.
2) Freud didn’t commit suicide. He was euthanized after a bout of terminal cancer. Not suicide. And not relevant.
3) What on earth do psychologists have to do with criminals. People who commit crimes usually are not seeing a therapist. And by law, a therapist must contact the police if their patent is a harm to themselves or others.
4) There is no such thing as “chemical control”. Many doctors try to use antidepressants to help patients. Of course there are side effects. All drugs have side effects.
5) There is no heresy in clinical psychology. It’s all about helping people. It that’s apikorsus, then I give up.
Matan1ParticipantI think you are blurring the lines between mental health and spiritual pursuits. If someone if suffering from depression, anxiety, OCD or any other mental illness, it is completely and entirely irresponsible and dangerous to think that the root of the problem is spiritual.
You go to a rav for halachic and hashkafic advise. You see a doctor when you are sick. Don’t confuse the two.
Matan1ParticipantFrumnotyeshivish, why do you think clinical psychologists have anything to say about the soul? Most scientists who discuss the soul are neurobiologists. And most of the topic is theoretical in nature.
Matan1ParticipantThe inherent meaning of the word isn’t, but they way it’s used and its derogatory nature makes it offense.
Matan1ParticipantPlease don’t use the R word. It is very insulting and derogatory.
Matan1ParticipantWhat about SSRIs?
Matan1ParticipantWhat exactly are you guys talking about?
Matan1ParticipantFor all those who hate on CBT, why do you feel this way? Did you have a negative experience in CBT?
Matan1ParticipantI recently started my training. What’s the question?
Matan1ParticipantAlright, why do you feel that it is a better therapy than CBT?
Matan1ParticipantPopa, what kind of therapy do you think is good?
Matan1ParticipantSyag, I’m not saying that is the view of the Jewish community, or that I believe it. I’m glad to see that many believe in the efficacy of psychology and medication.
Matan1ParticipantPopa, I hate to sound rude but you are flat out wrong about CBT. There is a tremendous amount of evidence on its efficacy. It has been shown in countless studies that it works to treat cases of depression, anxiety disorders, ptsd, and other mental illnesses.
By expressing the view that CBT does’t work, you are steering people away from a treatment that can really help them. It is more than being wrong. It’s actually causing harm.
Matan1ParticipantSyag, I meant no offense. It was just a feeling I had. I hope that I am wrong about it.
Matan1ParticipantPopa, why are you so critical of CBT?
Matan1ParticipantAdvice from anonymous posters is overrated. Speak to a professional for health advice.
Matan1ParticipantSee a qualified psychologist
Matan1ParticipantYou may have an anxiety disorder. It has nothing to do with bitachon. Our body’s are supposed to feel anxious from time to time. Without any any anxiety, we couldn’t live productive lives.
What happens to many people is that their brain has some chemical malfunction which causes them to feel unnecessary and irrational anxiety. This is not uncommon, and can be treated in several ways (benzodaizepines, SSRIs, talk therapy).
September 12, 2014 2:52 am at 2:52 am in reply to: Im Going to Uman.I will pray for you there. #1038454Matan1ParticipantPopa, I was looking for an answer, not a sarcastic on liner.
September 11, 2014 11:29 pm at 11:29 pm in reply to: Im Going to Uman.I will pray for you there. #1038452Matan1ParticipantCan someone explain this whole Uman thing? Why do you have to shlep to Ukraine to daven? There are plenty of good minyanim around the world.
September 11, 2014 12:51 pm at 12:51 pm in reply to: Im Going to Uman.I will pray for you there. #1038436Matan1ParticipantRebbe Nachman is dead. How can you “be by Rebbe Nachman for Rosh Hashanah”?
Matan1ParticipantHow much bad as Obama done to label his as Gog?
Matan1ParticipantSam, you mention yoga as avoda zara. Why do you say this?
Matan1ParticipantWhat does he say about democrats?
Matan1ParticipantPBA,
If you work such long hours, how do you have time to post in the coffee room?
June 2, 2014 9:03 pm at 9:03 pm in reply to: Shmuly Yanklowitz, Novominsker and OO theology #1095034Matan1ParticipantInteresting. Where did he say that? (i’m not trying to be antagonistic, i’m just curious)
June 2, 2014 7:46 pm at 7:46 pm in reply to: Shmuly Yanklowitz, Novominsker and OO theology #1095032Matan1ParticipantWhat has he said or done that makes his an apikores?
Matan1ParticipantHakatan, why must everything be about zionism with you?
Matan1ParticipantExactly what DaMoshe said. If chardeidim in Israel don’t want to work, thats fine. It’s their own decision to make. But they should not expect the state (which they hold to be traif) to support them.
Matan1ParticipantHakatan,
How exactly is Israel trying to change our people from a Torah-based nation to a goy based nation?
By supporting the most Talmud Torah in the world today? By asking them to share in the mitzva of securing the state of israel?
Or maybe by providing an all male unite of soldiers.
Matan1ParticipantGetzel,
The state of Israel owes chariedim nothing. Absolutely nothing. Every cent that they have given to the chreidim has been a gift.
It’s like if I give a poor man 20 dollars every week. One week, I only give him ten. He has absolutely no right to complain that he only received 10 dollars. Every penny I gave him was a gift. He didn’t earn it or deserve it.
Chareidim in Israel are upset that the money that they receive as gifts are being cut. What chutzta!!!
Matan1ParticipantLike Sam2 said, Israel provides money to every family in the country.
If you don’t celebrate Yom Haatzmaut, thats fine. But please show some hakas hatov towards the state for supporting the most Torah study in the world.
Matan1ParticipantHaKatan,
The zionists, both of yesteryear and now, were the single most supporter of Torah study in the world. Period. No question about it. So please stop your vitriolic comments about the state of Israel. If anything, you should be thanking them.
-
AuthorPosts