Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
LightbriteParticipant
Little Froggie: Who used elephants in war?
LightbriteParticipantI saw a dozen donuts yesterday. About three dozen the day before.
I’ve taken pictures of hundreds in the past week+.
These were all store bought donuts held hostage until a redeemer bailed them out. Soon they will all be consumed.
If they are homemade, they’re born free.
LightbriteParticipantIf so it’s a good Ness 🙂
…A miracle I recently experienced was tikkun-related.
My birthday is coming up and I wanted to let go of baggage, move forward, and upward in my relationship with Hashem and life.
Despite wanting to take it with me so so much, I decided to leave the booklet that I was holding in EY.
It is better to leave it safely on a bookshelf here until I was able to look at it more objectively.
At this point I was holding it until I made space.
The bookshelf was crowded, so I had to push books to the side. It was still crowded so I relocated a couple books to another shelf.
Finally I had space to slide in the booklet. With my hands I parted the way and slide the booklet beside the other books.
In went the booklet.
Out popped something that fell on the floor.
I picked it up.
A bracha card related to my upcoming birthday!
Ness gadol Baruch Hashem 🙂 🙂 🙂
LightbriteParticipantIt’s a cool way to storytell and teach us about how much we had to go through to remain committed to Yiddishkeit.
Apology & Update please:
Apology: I watched the 2014 YWN video and wrote a couple of critical responses that weren’t approved.
I’m sorry because my comments were ignorant, judgmental, and harsh.
Ignorance et al: I hadn’t read the article at the time but posted in height of feeling disturbed by the video.
After learning more, it reminds me of eating maror on Pesach to symbolize the bitterness that we bore in Egypt.
Here is an excerpt from YWN:
“…it is a genuine Minhag that dates back hundreds of years. In a nutshell, this is what is done:
In Chassidish communities of Poland and Hungary, it has been the custom when the Shamash is ready to light the Chanukah candles in shul, for children and others to throw hand towels and other items at him both before and during the lighting.
The custom is still practiced today in numerous Chassidish minyanim.
[Vishnitz] page 31).
What is the reason for this custom and where does it come from?
The custom is cited in the name of the Sanzer Rav, but quite feasibly could have dated before this as well. The Halichos Chaim, written by Rabbi Aharon Kluger cites the minhagim of the Klausenberger Rebbe Rav Yekusiel Halbershtam (Chanukah p.18) and explains that the purpose of this custom was to vividly demonstrate how things were during the time of the Greeks and the Hellenists when a Jew wished to perform a Mitzvah. He was laughed and jeered at, unless the Mitzvah was performed in their specific Hellenizing way.
Yet another given for this custom by the Klausenberger Rebbe is that on the chance that the Shamash feels a sense of empowerment and haughtiness in fulfilling this Mitzvah so publicly. The clothing and towels are thrown at him to demonstrate that he has accomplished nothing (See Yehi Ohr 5733 p.67).
The custom to light in shul only dates to the times of the late Rishonim. It is interesting to note that neither the Rambam, the Rif, the Rosh, the Ohr Zaruah, the Eshkol, Rashi, nor the Machzor Vitri mentions the custom of lighting in shul. The earliest authority to mention the custom is the Baal HaIttur. Indeed, the first to mention that a blessing is recited is Rav Yitzchok Perfet, the Rivash (1326-1408). The Maharam Shick (YD) stated that the Chasam Sofer actually did not recite a blessing when lighting in shul.” (YWN 2014)
December 26, 2016 11:06 pm at 11:06 pm in reply to: Politics thread for those who can't bear politics threads #1206221LightbriteParticipantCTLAWYER +1
LightbriteParticipantPeople make it sound like going to Israel is the ultimate solution to shidduchim.
I’m in Israel at this moment so I’m enjoying believing in this solution.
Maybe since I live in the US, I don’t hear the other side where maybe Israelis are pressured to look elsewhere for shidduchim too. For them that may be the US.
LightbriteParticipantwritersoul: lol… That’s very thoughtful of you ?
LightbriteParticipantFrom *Shiddchim and Shadchanus – Yismach*
“Hilchos Shidduchim”
“According to R’ Elyashic zt”l one is allowed to slightly lie about their age. However, according to R’ Shlomo Zalman Orbach zt”l one is absolutely forbidden to lie about their age, even to a slight degree. Only in very specific cases does one attain a heter to lie about their age.* This heter requires a specific psak.
*Simcha Leish 1:8 see mokoros”
Citation:
Yismach
LightbriteParticipant“The only one I’m unsure of is lying about age for shidduchim. There may be different opinions, so you have to ask a sheilah. Personally, I think it’s a bad idea even if someone is told it’s permissible” (LU)
LU: Agreed on the lying about age for myself at least. I wouldn’t feel right about starting off a marriage with a lie (assuming that all went well).
Maybe if the two have a good sense of humor and can laugh about it.
Still I wouldn’t want to lie and don’t know if I would want to continue seeing someone who lied to me about his age.
Here’s a related thread:
http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/shidduchim-why-is-everybody-lying-and-is-it-ok
LightbriteParticipantWouldn’t it be sweet if families sent out family-photo Chanukah cards every year?
LightbriteParticipantAvi K’s reference has better examples.
LightbriteParticipantWTP: I’ve never heard of that and have heard/read plenty of stories where people go to Israel for shidduchim.
Thank you
December 26, 2016 2:49 pm at 2:49 pm in reply to: Switching from/to Sephardi, Ashkenazi, Mizrachi #1205176LightbriteParticipantThanks LU. Would an Ashkenazi rabbi give someone Sephardi advice and vice versa?
Or would he refer me to another rabbi?
I’ve only known/met/spoken to Ashkenazi rabbis.
Years ago a Chabad rabbi who knows my dad is Sephardic told me that I was okay eating kitniyot on Pesach.
Afaik all my shailot were answered based on Chabad teachings. Which I guess is a type of Ashkenazi.
I feel like I have so much spiritual religious homework.
Wow it’s such a relief about the bedtime shema!
And I’ve only done Havdalah I think twice. I used both the Tehilas Hashem and Artscroll Siddurs (one has an extra prayer and one had directions that I found easier to follow). That was too massive a leap to jump into for the long run. I am still working on keeping Shabbat for now.
I mentioned Havdalah because they had those prayer cards with the yummy built-in incense at the bookstore too.
LightbriteParticipantOkay here is one example of lying that I learned how to do.
With one person in particular who really bothered me persistently and put me down, saying that he was “just teasing”, I learned to avoid him and respond to his “Where’ve you been?” with “I’ve been busy.” If he asks more I repeat the same thing over again.
He also asks me an invasive question that there is no good answer to. Even saying that I don’t have time to talk gets me into a draining situation. Even writing about it is triggering me so I will stop and close the point here.
My answers feel like lies. Yes I’ve been busy but in his mind me being busy is not the same as my definition. Telling him the truth is a sakana for me. My therapist taught me that “broken record technique” of deflecting energies and people for pikuach nefesh.
I wonder what the rav would say here.
I’ve heard that some rabbonim recommend lying about details like age for shidduchim, like saying someone who is 40 is 39.
Was it midrash where Aaron lied to two people (brothers?) who were fighting, saying that each one told him that they felt remorse and/or wanted to make up with the other one (when in fact neither told him that), and that helped warm each up to go to talk to the other and they made up. It was happily ever after.
December 26, 2016 1:51 pm at 1:51 pm in reply to: Politics thread for those who can't bear politics threads #1206218LightbriteParticipantEveryone has good middos and sparks of Hashem
December 26, 2016 1:51 pm at 1:51 pm in reply to: Politics thread for those who can't bear politics threads #1206217LightbriteParticipantNetanyahu lit Chanukah candles at the Kotel last night 🙂
LightbriteParticipantLol touche LU.
Yes I wanted to give a real life example but it was too personal.
So then I thought of another and maybe better real life example but the details are so specific that someone could easily figure out the person by Googling. The story wouldn’t make sense if I was vague on the details.
Without anything close to compare, I made up this example which I agree isn’t a strong or accurate mashal.
… On another note, how common is it to find halacha books on how and when to be dishonest? Lying under certain circumstances is a really hard halacha for me.
I don’t want to say specifically why I’m bringing this up now but it’s important. I have mixed feelings about lying. I don’t want to do it. Yet I see how when someone else lies to spare another person’s present feelings, it may give the person hope that one day freedom will come.
In that book about the Chabad Rebbe by Joseph Telushkin, Telushkin talks about how the Rebbe never told his mother that his brother died. For the rest of her life the Rebbe reportedly fabricated letters and even had someone call her long-distance to keep up the story that the brother was still living.
That is such a touchy situation.
Way too specific to advise individuals whose sibling, G-d forbid, passes away, on whether or not to tell one’s mother/father.
LightbriteParticipantWTP +1
Omgosh I didn’t even think about the long white beard!
When was the razor [man’s clean shaved face] invented?
Maybe every old man back in the day had a beard?
And he was clearly of a higher social status that he could afford enough to plump up. That was back then. Today it’s often the opposite.
LightbriteParticipantActually… I know that I am in Israel and am rarely here, but maybe I can give myself permission to just have a couple of simple days.
I feel like I should pack in more activities in the next two days.
However in real life it is exhausting to do do do. When I come back there is a lot to do.
Thank you. Putting this out there helped me see that I am putting pressure on myself to do more when I can use this time in another also meaningfull way.
LightbriteParticipantHave you read Miriam Adahan’s *Awareness* book?
LightbriteParticipantLU: Wisdom in a bottle you have!
Good point. Good teachers teach others to avoid mistakes by having them emphasize with their teacher’s life experiences.
One of my teachers-in-life always tells us not to go upside down near the mirrors. He stresses this in every group class. I avoid the mirrors because I’ve learned to trust him and his experience.
When I took his training, he told us how someone fell into the wall and two approx 10×6′ mirrors came shattering down. Taking the risk by the mirrors isn’t worth it. The indirect awareness of what could happen is enough.
So thank you. By sharing your experiences you are helping others.
Hopefully you are also conscious of all the right things that you did back then and do do now 🙂
December 25, 2016 8:43 pm at 8:43 pm in reply to: Why does lakewood need so many hat stores #1205994LightbriteParticipantTrue dat.
LightbriteParticipantThank you thank you!!!!
Great ideas.
Been to Jerusalem, Bnei Brak, Haifa, and Tel Aviv.
I’m central now.
Ein Gedi is such a cool idea. I don’t think I have ever been there.
Downside is the 3hr each way bus ride.
Maybe something closer in the middle?
December 25, 2016 8:17 pm at 8:17 pm in reply to: Why does lakewood need so many hat stores #1205992LightbriteParticipantSupply and demand yes.
Yet is it really that simple?
Even when all the merchants have the same hat costs, inventory, and demand, hat prices vary.
Why wouldn’t a store with more baseline expenses, such as higher rent and employee salaries (and employees), not charge more per hat to account for their greater profit needs?
Then again what about other motivators for pricing? Some people, regardless of the cost to maintain their business, may need more profits to support their families.
Or sometimes stores add more to their prices to account for expected losses due to various factors, including damaged hats.
LightbriteParticipantDo you know anyone who made Aliya and then moved back the US for a shidduch?
LightbriteParticipantMitzvah time please: Anyone want to summarize the OP’s OP?
LightbriteParticipant“Sometimes you say things that make it sound like you aren’t really Frum yet, but other times, you are asking detailed questions about specific halachos that make it sound like you are very Frum and concerned about keeping every detail of halacha.”
LU: I agree and it’s the weirdest thing.
Did I already share this story? Last week I went with a friend to a clothing store in Jerusalem. It was the Israeli version of freezing outside and she needed to upgrade her resources. My friend found a winter coat [resource] and read the label: Wool and polyester.
After seeing “wool” I said to the extent of, “What if it has linen?!”
The sales person then went on to say that the company is 100% Israeli, adheres to halacha, and they serve all the datiyim here.
It was the weirdest thing. I was dressed dati. [Oh yes I did share this story I think in another thread?] But the sales lady had no clue that I just happened to be dressed dati that day to go to the Kotel. The day before I looked like a chiloni.
However that question came from me. I meant it. I really don’t want to buy shatnez. I really don’t want to encourage my friend to buy something with shatnez.
All I can say is that if and when I do something, I like to do it for real. I’m still figuring it out.
Thank you LU 🙂
LightbriteParticipantHope. I have hope.
LU there’s a prayer for you at the Kotel… b’karov you’ll see that what’s past is past and it was there to help you get to your zivug ?
LightbriteParticipantCan one really say that he or she absolutely knows why he or she is single?
Does that mean one went against G-d’s Will with Hashem’s help (because Hashem will lead us where we want to go?)
LightbriteParticipantDunno what other people say but it can def be argued that the Rebbe bore children through his brachot. At least dozens of children, and maybe more like hundreds and thousands of children were born after their mothers’ came for brachot.
Maybe that histadulus on their part going for the Rebbe’s bracha counts to some?
Another idea, all his shluchim are said to be his children.
Also isn’t there something in halacha that says teaching a child Torah is like having your own child?
LightbriteParticipantreuventree555: What DY and LU said.
The rabbi is still being authentic.
Think about a professor who passes out a syllabus on the first day of classes.
It says that:
-There is no leniency on tardiness and u excused absences.
-Five tardies equals one unexcused absence.
-Five unexcused absences is an automatic fail.
Surely there have been some exceptional circumstances where a student broke these rules by coming late to class. However the student still passed the class.
Whether it was arranging something with the teacher before the semester or explaining emergency circumstances, and making up the time and classwork in another way, the professor found a way to accommodate the student’s needs.
The professor also still implemented these rules as stated with the general student body.
… It’s just so weird that I never thought of these books in such a way until now. Maybe that means that I am starting to be more critical of the information and recognize that there are variations that make living Torah a personal relationship with Hashem.
Thank you
LightbriteParticipantLU +123
LightbriteParticipantWhat is secular? Or chiloni?
When I looked up the definition of secular, it’s defined as someone who only believes in nature and what is measurable by the senses, what we see. Secular doesn’t believe in G-d or the Divine.
So is it wrong when I say that I am secular?
What would you call someone is not Charedi but totally believes and practices Ain Od Milvado, and observes some mitzvot that a solely secular person wouldn’t keep?
Is there a point where someone says I am no longer labeling myself as BT and am now charedi?
Or is it better to move to another community once you’ve grown enough and say that you’re charedi?
LightbriteParticipantWhat’s the miracle? That our one argument for Chanukah keeps going and lighting us up even hours after consuming sufganiyot and latkes?
LightbriteParticipantRitualistic practice for Xmas cookies:
How about leaving them out for the S-man with a cup of milk.
But then would we have to ban leaving out a glass of wine on Pesach for Eliyahu?
LightbriteParticipantNC: Source, see below. Forgot the pg #, but I think it’s provided in the index.
“Rebbe: The Life and Teachings of Menachem M. Schneerson, the Most Influential Rabbi in Modern History”
By Joseph Telushkin
December 23, 2016 11:07 am at 11:07 am in reply to: Why does lakewood need so many hat stores #1205988LightbriteParticipantPrices also depend on the store’s costs to remain open and profitable.
In theory yes but that is not always reasonable for the store to stay afloat.
Perhaps they offer a warranty or superior customer service. Or a good deal on two or more.
Do they hat stores ever have holiday sales or inventory clearances?
December 23, 2016 10:54 am at 10:54 am in reply to: Why does lakewood need so many hat stores #1205987LightbriteParticipantMaybe it’s good inventory since their hats may always be in style.
Every Jewish man and married woman cover their heads outside, so there is a greater demand.
Maybe some people are loyal to the hat store owners that they knew.
Maybe before moving to Lakewood, the hat store owners owned a hat store business in a more remote area. Despite more stores in the area, they figured that Hashem is in charge of parnassah anyway and they had faith that Hashem wanted them to continue their business.
Maybe selling hats is a good way to get to know *big heads* in the community. As in, selling hats to the leading rabbi or mayor helped make strong connections.
Hat stores may appeal to any generation and age. Even little kids can get fun kippot or headbands^
^Dunno what they sell at Lakewood hat stores besides hats but I assume that they at least cater to children and make additional sales for the small stuff too, maybe. Maybe not. Please correct me if my hypothesis is incorrect.
….and the Winner is… because Hat Stores were the next step to open up for new immigrants.
Jewish immigrants came to NY in waves.
In time they moved out into other neighborhoods and NJ. As trains made traveling outside of NY practical.
American Jewish Immigration:
After spending their money for the boat ship across the ocean, many Jewish immigrants often took factory jobs in the garment industry.
Sometimes they got to work up to become tailors. All they needed to carry was their needle. Many Jews already had a keen eye for studying Torah and reading. Jobs that focused on the details were fitting.
Of course there were also Jews that had bigger sights. They came to America and wanted a piece of the dream. So they started their own businesses.
Typically these enterprising Jewish men started by carrying their wares on their back. One-man shows. They had a sack of common necessities. Maybe scarves and hats too. They traveled around the streets and markets selling what they could.
From there, they could get a cart. A horse with cart. And the few who made it, like really made it, opened up their own stores. A retail location.
They sold what people needed. People traveling through the area and new residents often needed hats. Sometimes hats needed to be replaced. Or they were gifts. Every child comes B”H with a head. Every Jewish head in time b’esrat Hashem would need to be covered.
I am guessing that the hat shops of today may have been inherited as well. The children who grew up in and out of his or her parent’s shop is now running the show.
Hopefully this explains some of the history of today’s roots. I don’t know of Lakewood’s hat store owners personally. I do know that there is more to a story than our personal experience. We are another link in a chain. Maybe at least one shop’s story fits in here.
Have you thought to ask the hat store owner?
LightbriteParticipantIs Chareidi closest to Yeshivish?
December 23, 2016 10:23 am at 10:23 am in reply to: The Sephardim's Relationship to Ashkenazim in Israel? #1205865LightbriteParticipantOh Yeshivish or Chassidish aren’t sll or nothing, right?
There is a spectrum.
December 23, 2016 10:22 am at 10:22 am in reply to: The Sephardim's Relationship to Ashkenazim in Israel? #1205864LightbriteParticipantUmmm hello to self… I guess I am talking about Yeshivish. Vs. Chassidish.
There must be Yeshivish Sepharadim and Chassidish Sepharadim.
Thanks
LightbriteParticipantCPR manikin is $97 online
LightbriteParticipantTwisted: Today took two hours. B”H
Just to be safe because one hour the other morning wasn’t enough.
This house was built circa 1930. This house was one of the first in this city. The newer features here like electrically heated water are still old technology in contemporary comparison.
LightbriteParticipantWhat is the hat wearing occasion? Daily? Shabbos? Simchas?
LightbriteParticipantSo tipping them may be permissible
LightbriteParticipantUnless you’re Health!
LightbriteParticipantLA +1
December 22, 2016 9:08 pm at 9:08 pm in reply to: The Environment and Our World- I Care About it #1204814LightbriteParticipantWEIRD Nations = Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, And Democratic
December 22, 2016 9:01 pm at 9:01 pm in reply to: The Environment and Our World- I Care About it #1204813LightbriteParticipantMA: Alas. I noticed that about disposable utensils and dinnerware.
Disposables makes life and keeping Kashrut esp. more manageable for frum families.
Otherwise some families need two dishwashers. If they’re lucky to afford them and the space and costs of running them.
Also, one side of a double sink is tiny and dishes can pile up quickly.
And think about babies today … disposable diapers.
Imagine how much work it was to wash cloth diapers. Some people still use them. That is intense labor. Today diapers pile up in landfills. Yet disposable diapers are conducive to life in WEIRD nations.
Going old school may be a great setback in the longrun for families and individuals.
LightbriteParticipantCutting already baked chocolate chip cookies?
How? They break into pieces. Unless you make super gooey soft ones with kosher gelatin and cut them while still warm?
-
AuthorPosts