Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Reb EliezerParticipant
It should be above the Magen Avraham says that.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מח,ב
When including someone in betching, there is a difference between the one mezuman betching and one just included. The one bentching must eat at least a kezayis grain whereas the one included only needs to eat or drink something.
There is an argument in SA O’CH 186,1 if women are obligated biblically or rabinically in bentching, see Tosfas above 20,2. The question will be if a man can be yotzei with their bentching. They did not inherit land on their own and whether they have an obligatiion to learn Torah and say bichas Hatorah. Since they must know theiir mitzvos, so they make the brocho, SA O’CH 47,1The MAsaysnthatn. Bris not having is like having it otherwise how was Tzipora able to cimcumcise her son.Reb EliezerParticipantWhat about, המעביר שנה ותנומה מעפעפי?
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מח,א
Tosfas says that holding a chumash is foolish and does not help but holding a sefer torah might, the RMA SA O’CH 55,4 is lenient with a chumash in case of need. Maybe, they wanted us to realize that we don’t include everyone so easily into a minyan even for the tenth.
When it comes to davenen only six must daven but by bentching seven is required a recognizable majority because bentching is biblical whereas davenen is rabinical.Reb EliezerParticipantcoffee addict, I don’t think it is worse than medicine where you make a brocho for the taste.SA O’CH 204,8.
Reb EliezerParticipantcoffee addict, you drink too much coffee to appreciate a joke.
Reb EliezerParticipantJoseph, more Democratic support will eliminate abortiions. No one said it is good but mistakes happen and they will abort if they cannot support them. We should encourage to give up children for adoption. Late abortiion should be outlawed. The poor endanger themselves when it is not legal and rich will go to a place where it is legal.
Reb EliezerParticipantcoffee addict, you want a separate brocho., so what brocho do you make on a flat tire? תצא רוחו ישב לאדמתו.
on a dollar? שכחו וגבורתו מלא עולם.Reb EliezerParticipantSee https://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/understanding-lag-baomer
reply # 1732466Reb EliezerParticipantcoffee addict, are you going to take a drink from a pitcher until you become drunk or are you going to drink glass by glass?
Reb EliezerParticipantYou are fooling yourself when it comes to abortion. No one does abortion for the sake of it. The rich will travel wherever it is allowed and the poor will endanger themselves.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מז,ב
When they sold Yosef, Hashem was included in the Beis Din. Rebbi Akiva, a descendent of gerim, was included in the ten martyrs in place of Him. In SA O’CH 55,4 questions whether a katan can be included with a chumash as a slave was included and one freed. The Rosh says that he was needed for Parshas Zachor leinen which is biblical. In Europe a katan was included with a chumash. The Taz says that one speaking in the middle of davening should not be included in a minyan.
The Chacham Tzvi 93, questiions if a golem can be included. He brings a proof from Maseches Sanhedrin 65
where Rava created a golem and brought in front of Rebbi Zeira who said he has no use for it and destroyed it. It cannot speak and has no soul to become part of a minyan even though someone asleep can be included.Reb EliezerParticipantHelping people survive is also part of morality. Some peoole don’t make enough money to be able to pay their mortgage, health care and tuition. The Republicans only care in helping the corporations by driving up the deficit and the national debt. For others sink or swim.
Reb EliezerParticipantAmen chatufeh according the SA above, not the answer Amen before the brocho is finished.
It says one who follows the stringencies of both the Beis Shamai and Beis Hilel on him it is writtenl כסיל בחשך הולך the fool walks in darkness. The Ostroptzer in Sefer Meir EIn Chachomim explains this in an interesting fashion.
According to the Beis Shama whoi holds shevisas kelim, the pots and candle holder have to rest on shabbos, asks the gemora, how can one light shabbos candles? TThe gemora in Maseches Shabbos answers that he is mafker it. However, if he folows the Beis Shabbai view of shevisas kelim and the Beis Hilel’s view that hefkar has to be complete, both for the poor and the rich, so when he lights candles he regains some ownership, so hafker will not work and therefore will stay in the dark.Reb EliezerParticipantIs it moral that if not for Jewish charities, Jews would starve and be unable to pay their mortgages or rent as the Republicans don’t care? They say sink or swim. They drive up the deficit and thereby the National Debt sky high.
Reb EliezerParticipantcoffee addict, good question. I think, you don’t get drunk at once, so meanwhile you are enjoying your wine. The RMA says 695,2 that you don’t have to become drunk. Just drink more than the usual and fall asleep. According to this, you don’t know ahead of time if you become drunk to not make a brocho on it.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מז,א
I think one is uncomfortable with dirty hands or being on a road so he wants to get out of there ASAP and not being concerned who should go first. Getting to a place where there can be a mezuzah, our normal behavior should resurface by giving respect to the more learned. Maybe, through the mezuzah, we realize that there is a higher authority who rules over the world and the talmidei chachomim whose strength emanates from Him must also be respected as we find by fear.
In SA O’CH 167,15 explains our gemora indicates that the others should not taste the chalah until the one making the brocho does but if they have their own lechem mishna, it does not apply. The MB s’k 81 that as long as they have their own bread, even if they are yotzei with his brocho, it does not apply.
The idea that we have to follow the way the rebbi taught us is very common. We find in Ediyos (1,3) where Hillel repeated the incorrect expression from his rebbies who were gerim Shmayoh and Avtalyon.
In SA O’CH 167,16 MB s’k 84 If the one making the brocho is making for others, they have to wait until Amen was said by the majority as it is also part of the brocho. They don’t have to wait for individuals who extend their Amen.
When it comes to Amen, we must be very careful how we say it. In SA O’CH 124,8 explains it in great detail. Not to say the aleph as chatof, fast. The Chatof represents a shvo naah on letters it cannot be pronounced, so it is shorter than the regular vowels. Pronounce the nun. Don’t say an Amen after the brocho is gone. Say the Amen by pronouncing every letter correctly but don’tr pull it.Reb EliezerParticipantcoffee addict, I have high blood pressure, so I only drink decaf. Coffee and salt they say to avoid. A little wine is good for you. The Jews don’t get drunk normally because they drink as a ritual, so they can control themselves.
Sleep is good for you. To drink to stay awake is also not good. Sleep Apnea is dangerous where a person periodically awakens and cannot fall fully asleep making it up in the daytime, so he wears a mask for sleeping.Reb EliezerParticipantcoffee addict, coffee that keeps you awake raises your blood preasure. so it is not good for you. You would make a shehakol for the taste.
Reb EliezerParticipantAn environment which has constant arguments is very bad for children. Some say it is a mitzva to teach your son how to swim. Swim in tbe sea of life. Pru Urvi does not mean after having them, throw them to the volwes.
Reb EliezerParticipantWhen it comes to mayim achronim, if there are five or less people bentching then the one bentching mezumen should wash first. SA O’CH 181,6 as our gemora. It says washing should be close to bentching. The above from MB when there are more than five people.
Reb EliezerParticipantThankx rational. They become the driver of a family by getting married with a licence as driving a car. You don’t want to drive your marriage of a cliff. You need to take a drivers ed class.
Reb EliezerParticipantAnother reason why the guest would bentch mezumen because it was a custom that the others would listen and not bentch themself, so the guest could not bless the host by himself.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מו,ב
There is an argument in SA O’CH 165,2 who should wash his hands first. The SA says the geatest but the Rosh says that smallest in order the greatest should not have to wait without being able to talk. By mayim achronim we start from the smallest in order of sitting. MB O’CH 181 s’k 13.
Reb EliezerParticipantTo include a third person iinto mezuman, he should preferably have some fruit or some cake SA O’CH 197,3
If there is a guest, it is better for him to bentch mezuman in order the one who bentches Hashem should also bentch the host. Sifsei Chachomim here. SA O’CH 201,1.February 18, 2020 11:27 am at 11:27 am in reply to: He who lives in glass houses shouldn’t throw roger stone #1832798Reb EliezerParticipantklugeryid, the Chasam Sofer says above that it does not say who sees the future but who sees the birth indicating past and future. We should learn from past experiences for the future.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מו,א
The Rabbenu Bechaye in Parshes Teruma Shmos (25,24) on וציפת אתו זהב טהור you should cover the table with pure gold the word זהב is זן, הארץ and בונה ירושלים. It could be that the three brochos of bentching is biblical but Moshe Rabbenu, Yehoshua and David Hamelech instituted the nusach of each. The Ramban explains the meaning of whoever lives in chutz laaretz is like worshiping a’z. There are seventy rulers above on each nation and Hashem kaveyochol rules over Eretz Yisroel, so these are intermidiaries but our provision comes thtough Eretz Yisroel. Maybe that is why the second brocho is the rememberance of the land and the third the redemption the rebuilding of malchus and the Beis Bamikdash.
My Rebbe the Mattersdorfer Rav, Rav Shmuel ztz’l said that we should always have ‘pure gold’ earned honestly.Reb EliezerParticipantHe forced out Gen. Mattis, Kelly. If someone is really healthy. they don’t have to call themselves Health as the Very Stable Genious.
Reb EliezerParticipantSay Tehilim 121
February 17, 2020 8:01 pm at 8:01 pm in reply to: He who lives in glass houses shouldn’t throw roger stone #1832596Reb EliezerParticipantklugeryid, it also says איזהו חכם הלומד מכל אדם a smart person learns from others. He does not need to learn from his own experiences but can learn from others experiences. You can argue that the Targum is not the Chasam Sofer but Rashi. He is able to see the consequences. Certainly the Chasam Sofer says what I said. It is hard to see the consequences, if someone did not experienced it and like this we resolve a contradiction on who is a chacham.
February 17, 2020 6:37 pm at 6:37 pm in reply to: He who lives in glass houses shouldn’t throw roger stone #1832574Reb EliezerParticipantThe Chasam Sofer is a Targum in Koheles:
עלי תמר סוטה פרק ח
החכם עיניו בראשו החכם עד שהוא בראשו של דבר הוא יודע מה בסופו. וכן אמרו בתמיד ל”ב איזהו חכם הרואה את הנולד. ובתרגום קהלת, חכימא מסתכל ברישא מה דעתיד למיעבד בסיפא.February 17, 2020 6:35 pm at 6:35 pm in reply to: He who lives in glass houses shouldn’t throw roger stone #1832571Reb EliezerParticipantklugeryid, see what the Chasam Sofer says:
חתם סופר מסכת נדרים דף ל עמוד ב
איזהו חכם הרואה את הנולד ולא אמר הרואה את שעתיד להיות, והיינו משום מי שמפחד מהעתידות ביותר עליו נאמר אמר עצל ארי בחוץ ברחובות ארצח, ואמרו מן הזהירות שלא תרבה להזהר, ואמנם איש חכם שוקל העתידות במה שכבר עבר וממה שכבר נעשה בעולם כיוצא בזה ומביא ראיה מהעבר על העתיד האפשרי והיינו שאחז”ל הרואה את הנולד שכולל העבר שכבר נולד עם העתיד להולד כבשמעתין וק”ל:Reb EliezerParticipantCurrently the workers can say the whole bentdhing as the boss expects them to do that. See SA O’CH 191,2.
Reb EliezerParticipantchicken fat not eaten by itself, so no brocho
Reb EliezerParticipantI suggested to have required shalom bayis classes before marriage.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מה,ב
SA O’CH 199,7 Women mezumen bentch for themselves being voluntary but bentching together with the men is required. They can answer quitely.
Maybe the answering Amen on ones own brocho except for separation might indicate that he is validating his brocho because he is not sure about it which is ugly.Reb EliezerParticipantאמן – א-ל מלך נאמן, אני מוסר נפשי My father told me a mashal on the value of Amen which I repeated at his eulogy forty years ago. There was a merchant who traveled overseas on a ship taking along merchandise to sell. There was a big storm wind which destroyed the ship and his merchandise and threw him out on a desert island. In his depression, he was playing around with the pebbles on the ground. Eventually, another ship arrived which took him home. When seeing his wife, he started to cry, telling her how he lost everything. Wanting to wipe his eyes, he took out his handkerchief and they noticed that something fell out of it. When they looked at it carefully, they realized that it was a diamond. So the wife asks him, do you have any more of this? He says, It must have fallen into my pocket on the desert island when I was waiting for another ship as I was playing around with the pebbles but I cannot go back there to collect more because I don’t know where the island is. When we come to the next world to account for our deeds, we start crying that we didn’t accomplish anything. We take out our handkerchief to wipe our eyes and an Amen falls out of it. So, they tell us. this is a diamond over here. Do you have any more of this? He says, if I would have known the value of this over here, how much more I could have collected but I cannot go back to collect more.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מה,א
Why at two we can make mezuman? The argument is if he is included in the plural expression or if he is separate. If he is included two is enough, else we need three, two besides him. The understanding of גדלו לה’ אתי telling two, so there is two besides him and three would be needed. Whereas the כי שם ה’ אקרא, means him and someone else therefore, two is enough.
The gemora says in Maseches Makus (22,2) that the Babylonians are fools that they stand up in front of a Sefer Torah but not in front of a talmid chacham. Ask the Baal Akedah, why are they fools when a Sefer Torah is learned out from a kal vechomer, if in front of the learners stand up than certainly in front of itself? He explains that we have a rule דיו לבא מן הדין להיות כנדון we cannot gain more information through a kal vechomer than what it is the source. The source is important and must be respected. Therefore the pasuk speaks about standing for a talmid chacham which must be respected. Similarly the one who makes the brocho is the source and therefore must be respected and not outdone by the one validating it, answering Amen.
Reb EliezerParticipantcoffee addict, is that somewhere in Iyov as there is only 150 perokim in Tehilim?
Reb EliezerParticipantSee SA O’CH 29. A good place to remove tefilin in ובא לציון after שנשמר חקיך, so we don’t make the brocho because there is no real limitation on wearing tefilin according to Rebbi Akiva but we are saying the content of the brocho.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מד,ב
In Eretz Yisroel they made a brocho when they removed the tefilin but we don’t do. There is an argument between Rebbi Yosei Haglili and Rebbi Akiva Mesaches Eruvin 96,1 if at night ,habbos and yom tov is forbidden to put on tefilin. Rebbi Yosei Haglili saya it is forbidden and Rebbi Akiva holds it is not. See Shagas Aryeh 41 in great detail. We pasken like Rebbi Akiva, so shabbos and yom tov is only assur because of a sign and and night because of releasing gas. So they made the brocho according to Rebbe Yosei Haglili but according to Rebbi Akiva we don’t make it.
Reb EliezerParticipantcoffee addict, where is the pasuk? Maybe שמות פרק טו) קָֽפְא֥וּ תְהֹמֹ֖ת בְּלֶב־יָֽם) ?
Reb EliezerParticipantMaybe Chanukah and Purim is not mentioned in Al Hamichya because there is no requirement on these days to eat foods that the brocho is said on. Purim when we drink is not for the sake of the wine but to be drunk. The praise on Chanukah does not have to be said on wine.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מד,א
We see over here how they enjoyed these sweet fruits from Genusar. The gemora says in Pesochim 8,2 that they don’t have these sweet fruits in Jerusalem in order they should go there to visit Hashem and not to go to enjoy the fruits. We see that there is a mitzva to be oleh regal and not just to be there because then in would not matter what his intentions are whereas by tzadakah, even if he gives tzadakah to live long, he is considered a pious person because the mitzva is not the giving but making sure the other person has. By shilach monos however, the RMA paskens in SA O’CH 695,4 that if he sends shilach monos and they refuse to accept it, he is yotzei the mitzva. The Chasam Sofer 196 explains in the name of the Monas Halevi that by shilach monos, the mitzva is the giving to show friendship and unity to the other, as Haman ym’s was complaining that the Jews are not united, which he has done.
Reb EliezerParticipantDovidBT, I don’t know if the two are the same. In SA O’CH 204,8 says that if medicine is enjoyed because of its taste like fruit flavored Tums, we make a shehakol on it. Similarly, coffee keeping you awake, but you enjoy its taste whereas water has no extra benefit but to quench the thirst.
February 16, 2020 12:49 am at 12:49 am in reply to: What programming language is better to start learning? #1832009Reb EliezerParticipantCTLAWYER, I am as old as you are, but I go back to the 407 tabulating machines and control panel wiring.
Reb EliezerParticipantThe Rav Abarbanel explains the meaning of לא תשא את שם ה’ אלקיך לשוא do not elevate Hashem your G-d’s name falsely. Don’t say Hashem is so great that he wants nothing to do with us and doesn’t care for us. A baa gaiva, who holds his head up high, pushes Hashem out of this world. He believes that Hashem belongs in the heavens and does not belong on earth because of His greatness.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מג,ב
The MB in SA O’CH 297 s’k 1 says that people cannot differentiate and we can make on all besomim a borei minei besomim for havdala.
Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מג,א
When it comes to reclining to be motzei others in kiddush or hamotzi, currently we don’t recline, so our sitting is like there reclining as indicated in SA O’CH 213,1. At the seder we do recline for wine SA O’CH 473,2 and for matzah 475,1 as we are commemoratiing our history when they reclined.
In says in SA O’CH 214,1 that every brocho requires the mention of malchus, the King of the Universe, otherwise it is considered no brocho as we learned above 40,2. The question is why the shmonei esrei does not include this?
Why tthe mentioning of malchus is so important? I explained above that we are organizing the praise of Hashem to show that He is the only One who can fulfill our wishes, so the Beis Yosef says in rhe name of the Rokeach that since we mentiioned it before shmonei esrei we don’t have to mention malchus again in the shmonei esrei.Reb EliezerParticipantברכות מב,א
In SA O’CH 168,6 says that fruit filled cake is borei minei mezonos. If you make it a meal. you have to eat 345 gram 12.17 ounces around 3/4 pound Pischei Teshuvas there.
In SA O’Ch 179,1 Once a person washed his hands with mayim achronim, he finished his meal and must bentch. The MB says there if he needs to do something before bentching, he should rewash his hands.
If he is a guest by someone, the end of the meal is decided by the host.ברכות מב,ב
In SA O’CH 174,1,4 wine in the middle of the meal requires a brocho but the wine of kiddush paters it..
-
AuthorPosts