JustThink

I am shocked at what your suggesting that the frum world follows “the modern day interpretation of the Rabbanim” rather than the literal torah.
if by literal torah you mean only torah shebichsav your an apikores like the tzedokim (rambam 13 ikrim). If you mean something else I’m not sure what that is, but we obv arent mekayeim mechiyas amalek for more than one VALID reason (as apposed to “avoiding by claiming”).
1 we’re in golus and it not possible to be mekayme that mitzva realistically
2 what you yourself say, that we dont know who amalek is, but if you learnt any gemara it would be poshut to you that thats not an excuse its an actual reason a) the gemara says that ashur mixed all the nations so theres always on every goy a roiv that he’s not amalek (same reason that we can accept geirim even tho theres certain nation which cant marry into klall yisroel)
b) even w/o that, mehaiche taisi that your mechuyav to raise money to do genetic testing to figure out whos amalek (if its even possible)