jphone

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 101 through 150 (of 901 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Unbeliveable Reaction to the Grossman verdict #674262
    jphone
    Member

    Dear moderator 80. Does Pidyon Shevuyim apply ONLY to death row inmates? The prison in Otisville is filled with many potential cases of Pidyon Shevuyim if it extends to anyone incarcerated. Will YWN lead the letter writing campaign on their behalf? Is it your belief that the state of Florida illegally and wrongfully held Mr. Grossman necessitating the mass campaigns? Does it stop with this case? If it does, why? If it doesnt, where are the calls for more Pidyon Shevuyim campaigns?

    in reply to: Unbeliveable Reaction to the Grossman verdict #674260
    jphone
    Member

    Aries, unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on your point of view), as long as you do not commit a federal crime, like real estate, location is very important. You can bludgeon someone to death in one state and do 10 years with good behavior and get the death penalty in another.

    jphone
    Member

    Yes, he didn’t follow the rules. Did the parents?

    in reply to: Unbeliveable Reaction to the Grossman verdict #674256
    jphone
    Member

    This will sound calloused to some, terrible to others and may come as a shock to even more. How many of these http://crime.about.com/od/deathrow/Death_Row_Inmates_Past_and_Current.htm people on death row will we now start a campaign for clemency? There are over FIVE HUNDRED death row inmates in Florida and North Carolina alone! Will we scour the lists for names like Grossman, Feldman, Cohen and Goldstein before we sign a petition or start email campaigns? Have we as a community suddenly become anti death penalty? Personally, I sent emails made phone calls as requested by the various Frum organizations. In truth, I feel like a lemming. Where are those organizations for the other 375 inmates on Floridas Death Row? Are they actively researching their cases? Why not? Will we all become major contributors to the Aleph Institute? This is not intended to question Martin Grossman, A”H, case on its merits under Fla law. I am not familiar with the specifics of the case, or Florida law. I AM familiar with the fact that until 3 weeks I never heard of Martin Grossman a”h, thought nothing about death row inmates or the death penalty. And if I dont get another email about death row inmates from R’ Chaim David Zweibel, on behalf of the Agudah, I will likely go back to the way it was 3+ weeks ago. I feel like a lemming and a hypocrite. How about you?

    in reply to: Hangover Remedies #674241
    jphone
    Member

    “Hangover Remedies”

    Dont drink. You wont need a remedy!

    in reply to: Dressing up as a Nun, Munk,or Santa Claus for Purim #927308
    jphone
    Member

    How would you feel if on St. Patricks Day you saw people dressed like a Rabbonim drinking straight out of a keg of beer? Would you think it was funny if at the next “rainbow coalition” parade people dressed up like chassidim? You might think it is funny, they dont.

    I remember, when I was in high school, there were some fellow who liked heckling one of the english teachers, a devout catholic. One day, to get under his skin they asked if they could “go to the pope” (the previous popes name was john). everyone thought this was so clever and witty, until the next day the teacher announced that he had to make a quick stop at the rabbi. Suddenly everyone was insulted and annoyed (he actually DID go to the office, but thats a separate story).

    in reply to: Walking in the Street – Stay Safe #674168
    jphone
    Member

    One of the scariest parts of my Purim is navigating the streets of Boro Park driving my children to their Rabbeim and Moros. Seemingly from everywhere, people, in groups or individually appear on all sides collecting tzedaka. I have no problem with collecting tzedaka, however, playing chicken with cars is really nerve wracking for us drivers.

    in reply to: Decorating Your House For Purim #674283
    jphone
    Member

    My in-laws decorate their house with plastic table cloths covering all furniture and carpet, so when the inevitable happens, the furniture and carpet doesnt get ruined.

    in reply to: Learning VS Working #674163
    jphone
    Member

    Work. The other 4 letter word 🙂

    in reply to: Learning VS Working #674161
    jphone
    Member

    What was Moshe Rabbeinus bracha to Zevullun? Be happy earning a livelihood, just grin and bear it, you guys drew the short straw and have to bear the brunt of the curse and go work and support Yissachar? Is the bracha of Viasafta Digancha a klala in disguise? Is hishtadlus a klalla?

    in reply to: Learning VS Working #674156
    jphone
    Member

    “If you do not like my explanantion, there are 69 others out there!”

    This is your pshat or the “chashuva rabbis”?

    in reply to: Learning VS Working #674148
    jphone
    Member

    “this was a curse and the more someone works, the more “curse” they are bringing on themselves.”

    Did anyone tell this to Shevet Zevullun?

    in reply to: Shloime Gertner’s New Album- Say Asay #681840
    jphone
    Member

    The first time I heard a song from this CD a fellow listener (car pool mate) wondered if we were listening to the right radio station.

    in reply to: Shidduch, I want ….They want …. #674071
    jphone
    Member

    “For all those who are Makpid in every word, I will rephrase.”

    As a shadchan, you better be makpid on every word.

    The one and only shadchan (professional) I ever spoke with, apparently was not. When I told him I had a degree from Touro and the girl he wanted to set me up with specifically told him that she did NOT want to consider someone in college, he decided I was a perfect candidate, after all, since I already had my degree, I was no longer in college. He didnt care what she meant, only what she said. As a shadchan, thats a waste of everyones time. I was so annoyed at him, I threatened him with a din torah for reimbursement of every cent I spent on the date including all travel expenses (gas and tolls) and “entertainment” (ok drinks at a lounge) if he wouldn’t do so on his own.

    in reply to: Shidduch, I want ….They want …. #674068
    jphone
    Member

    Wolf:

    Would someone who learned half a day and attended college half a day be called, a “goy”?

    in reply to: Shidduch, I want ….They want …. #674064
    jphone
    Member

    “I want a learning guy … My parents want a college boy… or I want a college boy… and they want a learning guy.”

    Is it just me, or do others also see the use of the word “guy” when associated with someone learning in yeshiva, but when he is working he is suddenly only a “boy”.

    Boy implies young and immature while guy implies someone older and more mature.

    in reply to: Learning VS Working #674138
    jphone
    Member

    Why are the 2 mutually exclusive? Why cant someone work, to earn a parnassha and spend the rest of the time learning? For some, this may mean going to the office 8 hours a day, for others, 4 others less and others more. The balance can be spent in the beis medrash.

    Also, there are many who simply have no hatzlacha sitting in the beis medrash 19 hours a day and lose their ability to sit after an hr, others more.

    There is no “right way” or “wrong way”. There is no cookie cutter mold for every person. Your Rav/Rebbe/Madricha can/should/will advise you what is best for you.

    in reply to: Which Yeshiva? #674027
    jphone
    Member

    Hopefully, everyone is learning in the best yeshiva, that suits their own needs.

    Chofetz Chaim may be great for me, and terrible for you while Ponovezh is great for you and terrible for me. The derech halimud, hashkafas hachaim, the way the rabbeim interact with the talmidim (if at all). Are you self motivated, or do you need a rebbe on top of you all day?

    in reply to: Internet Lockdown #673670
    jphone
    Member

    There is an option, when logged in as administrator (the default when you buy a computer) who to make an application available to. The default setting is “all users”. It is easily changed.

    in reply to: Shidduchim – Meshugas or Acceptable #673753
    jphone
    Member

    Oomis, Speaktruth. Your both missing the point, she doesn’t know the boy in any way, just heard about him and has determined he is not for her. She refuses to meet him and see for herself if he is or is not for her. At 33 years old, if this girls has some hang up about some family member or some other stupidity she SHOULD seek counseling. Personally, I think she is afraid that at 33 she will hear “after all this time, HE is who you are marrying?”. He is not, the best guy in the yeshiva, the sharpest dressed, the one with the handsomest face, the super high IQ or faubulously wealthy. He is just your average guy, who learns a few hrs a day, has a masters degree, goes to work, dresses like everyone else. Isn’t distinguished in any way, just, your average guy. I think that after all these years of waiting the girls is simply afraid to end up with just your average guy, she probably passed on that guy many times over the years. Now, she is fopolishly holding out for “super guy” so she can justify to her small mind, the waiting was well worth it. Hence. My advise to seek help.

    in reply to: Shidduchim – Meshugas or Acceptable #673747
    jphone
    Member

    An older girl (approx 33) recently turned down a guy (approx 39) because “I kind of know of him from the neighborhood and I dont think he is for me. Someone just like him, is what I am looking for” she said. Mishugas or Acceptable?

    No, they never dated.

    No, they were never formally introduced to each other in any setting.

    No, they do not daven in the same shul or have siblings who are friendly with each other.

    However, HE is not for her, but someone JUST LIKE HIM is.

    I suggested she go for counseling. Was that proper or unacceptable?

    in reply to: Texting For a Bachur #673451
    jphone
    Member

    The rt uv spllng haz gottin lawst as ppl txt echothr and hav stpd spkng.

    I’m stil trying to figure out lol,ppl, sos, txt, u2, too many acronyms.

    in reply to: Texting For a Bachur #673434
    jphone
    Member

    What, you dont follow your Rebbe on Twitter or Facebook? How do you get the newest Mareh Mekomos and updated time for shiur? These tools are critical.

    in reply to: Internet Lockdown #673667
    jphone
    Member

    Another approach I’ve seen. Internet Explorer/AIM/MSN etc… is only available on the parents log in, it is not available via any other log in. Setting the parents as the administrators of the computer also means that kids logged into their own directory on computer can not install anything on the hard drive (such as a copy if IE they can get off a CD that has juno or Netzero) and the only available tools to them are Word, Excel and the things needed for schoolwork. If they DO need to be online for schoolwork or other legitimate reason as determined by parents, then one of the parents must make the application available to the kids by logging in on their own. It sounds cumbersome, but it really isnt. It makes the computer avaialable to the kids whenever they want to use it it legitimately (Word, Excel, PowerPoint or an allowed game – installed by the parents and made available to all “users” – for example) and the parents dont have to worry about “where” the kids are.

    in reply to: Free Blackberry Apps #760331
    jphone
    Member

    not that much easier.

    in reply to: Texting For a Bachur #673429
    jphone
    Member

    If a child MUST have a phone AND Text, make sure to get a plan where you pay per text and make sure your son understands he obligated to pay for any text that is not an emergency. In most situations, this is enough to curb texting when not really necessary.

    in reply to: Free Blackberry Apps #760329
    jphone
    Member

    Torah Mom. Any cell phone can do what you describe. You dont need a smartphone.

    in reply to: Binah-Shidduch Issue #682763
    jphone
    Member

    Youdontknow me:

    “I don’t think it helps anyone to keep girls 18-21 from trying to get married”, I personally agree with this statement of yours. However, all indications from the back to back full page ads taken out by Nasi and those who published the declaration of 60+ rosheo Yeshivos about “close in age marriages” is that someone somewhere seems to be saying just that.

    in reply to: Binah-Shidduch Issue #682759
    jphone
    Member

    Youdontknowme:

    No I don’t. I don’t believe you understand me, either. I don’t disagree with anything you write in your latest post. All I’m saying (or trying to anyway) is that there are legitimate reasons why people may go to college. All I was adding, is that if there is a serious effort to encourage the dating of “older girls” say 21+ then girls younger than 21 will have to find other ways to occupy their time since getting married and starting a family is not what we apparantly want them doing. I suspect that girls who otherwise may not have, may now go to college simply to fill their time, and if there will be a stigma against such girls, then nobody will date than at 21 anyway, so we are no better off than we are now. Probably worse off.

    in reply to: Binah-Shidduch Issue #682757
    jphone
    Member

    Those who have a family business to go into, are lucky and may not need college to earn a parnassah others do not, and need an education to adequately suppport a family. Not all family businesses can support an entire family either. What’s important is that the person has the ability to support a family and more importantly, there is not a negative attitude towards those whose hishtadlus means going to college. Boys and girls. Especially girls who now that “we” don’t want them dating for several years will have to find something to occupy their time.

    in reply to: Free Blackberry Apps #760323
    jphone
    Member
    in reply to: Kosher Exercise Video/DVD? #1070776
    jphone
    Member

    He may be a nut job, but a number of Richard Simmons’s videos don’t have women in them, and are pretty good excercise videos.

    in reply to: Shidduchim and Outside People “Helping” #673333
    jphone
    Member

    “It is a mitzvah for a man to be mepharnes his own family, it is stated in maseches Kesubos”

    The husband obligates himself to do so in the kesubah too. Unless his wife is mochel this obligation (I dont know the halacha, but I suppose she can be) she can probably take him to beis din to make him fulfill this obligation.

    in reply to: Shidduchim and Outside People “Helping” #673332
    jphone
    Member

    “The boys are getting marrried “despite” whatever outside “help that you don’t approve of.”

    I didnt start this thread with the word help in quotation marks. Clearly the person who started this thread feels that outside interference is a big problem.

    in reply to: Binah-Shidduch Issue #682740
    jphone
    Member

    “It seems to me that every single girl is taking some type of college courses”

    Sure. They are all in some sort of excellerated program that will give them a piece of paper that allows them to teach, do some sort of special ed (most try in a yeshiva) or therapy. How many morahs, therapists and special ed jobs can the frum community support? I am referring to a professional degree that may take 3-4 years to complete in a college or university (not raizel wright and the like), which girls should have plenty of time to complete prior to marriage given that our leadership suddenly doesnt want them dating until 22 anyway.

    “I don’t think the stigma of girls going to college exists anymore.”

    Tell that to most girls who go to NYU, Parsons, Baruch and many other schools not named Touro, or some fly by night accelerated program.

    “Even if I’m wrong about that won’t sending the girls to more school only increase the maturity gap between boys and girls?”

    Not sure about maturity, but will certainly widen the educational gap 🙂

    in reply to: Ideas for Midwinter Vacation #673812
    jphone
    Member

    The bais medrash?

    in reply to: Shidduchim and Outside People “Helping” #673322
    jphone
    Member

    AZ. By definition, “ideas” are suggestions for everyone to implement, including everyone else. If each person would do their own thing then nothing will be done to alleviate this suppsed major problem.

    To get back on topic of the name of this thread. “Help” as it is writen is clearly an indication that these people are doing more damage than anything else. Don’t involve “outsiders” and when they mix in tell them to mind their own business. I think this “outside help” is a bigger problem than any “age gap”.

    in reply to: “Paroah in Pajamas in the Middle of the Night” #673058
    jphone
    Member

    Its on the pesach with r’ alter tape. When we take out the pesach stuff will give a listen and tell you the words 🙂

    If you can’t wait till then, I’m sure this tape is available at any seforim store.

    I’m also pretty sure most kindergarten morahs will be teaching the song this week, ask one for the words.

    in reply to: Shidduchim and Outside People “Helping” #673315
    jphone
    Member

    “and within reason don’t spend all your time trying to come up with ideas for the 19 20 years old girls.”

    If our “leadership” doesnt want 19-20 year old girls dating they should suggest a few things for them to occupy their time. College? Another year of seminary memorizing more Rambans in sefer Iyov? ? New chessed projects? Perhaps a whole new batch of moderators for the proliferation of blogs? Perhaps they can all become teachers assistants resulting in a teacher/student ration of 1:3? Anyone?

    in reply to: Binah-Shidduch Issue #682724
    jphone
    Member

    Here are some idea:

    . Take away the stigma that is placed on those who go to college and more girls might pursue a degree instead of running to get married before they hit 20. Only so many teaching and therapist positions exist. The degree will only help them earn a parnassah so that their husbands can sit and learn even longer.

    . Another year of schooling for girls? Yes, it is another year of tuition, but does it cost any more than the monthly support they would fork over to a son in law if their daughter got married at 19?

    in reply to: Binah-Shidduch Issue #682717
    jphone
    Member

    “Therefore, unless we figure out a way to change this equation we will not be able to significantly alleviate the crisis?”

    The answer is not for “younger” boys to date “older” girls. The answer is for the “younger” boys really be younger.

    in reply to: Binah-Shidduch Issue #682710
    jphone
    Member

    I can read english. “Primary cause” is written in larger font and in bold. It is clear what the intention of the ad is.

    No, I did not misunderstand what my r”y told me. I wrote what he told me and I did not misunderstand what he wrote. Perhaps you won’t acknowledge that I understand as does my R”Y, that what his signature is signed on to is not what he was led to believe he would be signing.

    The primary casue is the system currently in place. The system that encourages boys not to think about the rest of their life until they are 23 and encourages girls to get on with the rest of their life before the ink is dried on their high school diploma.

    in reply to: Binah-Shidduch Issue #682708
    jphone
    Member

    Maturity is definitely is not. A signifigant contributor to a “shidduich crisis”, very likely.

    in reply to: Binah-Shidduch Issue #682706
    jphone
    Member

    Why bother with the boys at 17 now? Seems its been decided that they should still get married at 22-23 only to girls 21+. The bigger question is, what to do with all the 19-21 year olds we don’t want dating , or will we encourage them all to run after the small minority of 19-21 year old boys who are dating?

    in reply to: Another Shidduch Related Question #675527
    jphone
    Member

    If someone asks for handwriting sample to submit for analysis, ask them for a urine and blood sample, you want to make sure they don’t carry any disease.

    in reply to: Is it Private Info or Not? #673128
    jphone
    Member

    The child was in school prior to this interview. If this principle has questions, he SHOULD ask them, however, there are adults he could ask (this kid WAS in school until this point and had teachers and a principle) he should not be asking other kids.

    in reply to: Shidduchim and Outside People “Helping” #673290
    jphone
    Member

    I counter propose that the shadchan reimburse all dating expenses prior to the 3rd date, this way all can be reasonably sure the shadchan isn’t witholding or embelleshing info given to the other side.

    in reply to: Binah-Shidduch Issue #682702
    jphone
    Member

    AZ. Since boys ages 19-22, for the most part are not dating and girls 19-22 for the most part, are dating, there is a natural age gap. The full page ads with the signatures of 60 or so Roshei Yeshiva and Rabbonim urging “close in age shidduchim” is saying 1 of 2 things (it isn’t clear what)

    1) Boys should start dating at a younger age or

    2) Girls should start dating at an older age

    If not, the age gap will continue. the “primary cause” of older singles is not the “age gap” as it is thrown around but the age gap that is a result of the current chinuch system. If it is not changed and all 23 year old boys who start dating will be dating girls 22+, the girls 19-22 will by and large have to find something to do. Will these Rabbonim allow them to go to college, get a job in corporate america? Will the mindset of yeshiva boys towards these girls change? If not, we will have even more single at an even younger age along with many more single boys.

    This “marry close in age” is half an answer, at best, and half answers are worse than no answers.

    As an aside, my Rosh Yeshiva is a signatory to the full page ad. When I asked him what he signed onto, he replied “the concept that close in age shidduchim is not a bad thing” and that “shadchanim should give priority to older girls, whenever possible”. He trusted, that is what would be “advertised”. He did not expect, and quite frankly does not agree with the premise that the “primary cause” of the “singles crisis” is the dating age. What can he do now? He advises his bachurim when to date and if asked, offers advise on a particular shidduch, he will NOT say, “not for you, your 23 and she is 19”.

    in reply to: Understanding The Haiti Tragedy #672893
    jphone
    Member

    Perhaps your opinion regarding religion and these questions is wrong? Where is it stated that the purpose of religion, judaism specifically, exists to answer these 2 questions?

    This does not mean that what happened is not horrible or that we should feel for and attempt to help in whatever way we can.

    If you knew why it happened, would you understand why it happened?

    in reply to: Screen Names #1176001
    jphone
    Member

    YW Moderator 1-10,000 was already taken.

Viewing 50 posts - 101 through 150 (of 901 total)