Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 251 through 300 (of 937 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Listening To Non-Live Music On Sefira #1151852
    Josh31
    Participant

    “were moiser nefesh themselves for Yiddishkeit”

    There is a time and place for mesiras nefesh.

    For the needs of someone sick and not in danger, categories of Rabbinic enactments are permitted. And these are Rabbinic enactments associated with the Biblical Shabbos.

    In the laws of mourning there is generally more of a basis to be lenient.

    If you push people to always be moser nefesh, they will be “burnt out” when the real need to avoid the “Big 3” arises.

    If I were a Rabbi and anyone came to me with a question about music, my first question would be, “Do you have mood swings, or have you ever been diagnosed with Depression?”

    in reply to: Are you a Ka'eylah Jew? #1203230
    Josh31
    Participant

    “pipe up with ka’eleh several words before I read it”

    You are going too slow, and they cannot use a buggy whip on Shabbos or Yom Tov. 🙂

    in reply to: Johhny Lingo's 8 cow wife #866934
    Josh31
    Participant

    The American equivalent is:

    1 cow: You can only afford to travel once a year out of town and it is on a bus.

    8 cows: The private jet is always ready.

    7 cows: You have time share on a PJ for about 10 round trips a year.

    6 cows: You have to use the scheduled airlines, but you always fly in first or business class.

    Bottom line: If you want a true American 8 cow wife, you better actually have the cows (a PJ fueled up and ready to fly).

    in reply to: Are you a Ka'eylah Jew? #1203225
    Josh31
    Participant

    Perhaps nowadays some chazzanim appreciate knowing that at least some of the congregation is following him?

    Some also appreciate the short break it gives him.

    We sing “v-ne-e-mar” several times during the long Rosh HaShanah Mussaf for that purpose.

    in reply to: WHAT?!!?? No Shalom Zachor??? #867683
    Josh31
    Participant

    It is a K’nas (penalty) aginst the boy for interrupting his mother’s pesach preparations with his birth:)

    in reply to: Tachnun Calendar #861327
    Josh31
    Participant

    I am coming up with about 76 times in a 12 month year and about 80 times in a 13 month year the long Tachanun (Monday & Thursday) is said if no bris or Chasan. After Thursday we get a long break.

    in reply to: Sports teams and Hashem #1028355
    Josh31
    Participant

    The reason the Yankees are historically so good is because they always have a stronger Koach HaMammon than any other team.

    Tzom = Kol = Mammon = 136.

    With the Yankees it is Mammon and not the other two.

    in reply to: Colored Shirts #985630
    Josh31
    Participant

    Perhaps it is best to reserve wearing white shirts during the week for real Klei Kodesh?

    in reply to: syium costs #859138
    Josh31
    Participant

    Separate and large shipping fees are such a turn off to me that I would rather pay $28 for an item with shipping included than $18 plus $8 for shipping.

    in reply to: Neteuri Karta Purim celebrations…. #858760
    Josh31
    Participant

    A shul with NK or “fellow travelers” in it can never finish reading the Megilah. When the reading reaches the word “Medinah” the graggers go off and cannot be stopped.

    in reply to: Collecting Tzedaka during Davening..your opinion? #859107
    Josh31
    Participant

    Cherrybim, has your Rav given guidelines about the Tzedakah obligations of those $150,000 in debt?

    in reply to: Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us #869073
    Josh31
    Participant

    For all our disputes with ZeesKite, I am convinced that she has been thru Shas at least once, and probably twice. Her knowledge is not based upon tidbits that can be picked up on the internet. And based upon another posting in YWN, her knowledge is not just in the area of “Fire & Brimstone”.

    in reply to: Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us #869069
    Josh31
    Participant

    ZeesKite, your husband needs to put his Gemaras and Shulchan Aruch under lock and key. You know more “Fire & Brimstone” concepts from the Gemara / poskim than those who have been learning in Yeshiva for a decade. If you were a guy, you would sail thru the Smicha exam when it comes to the laws of Neidui, Mumrim and Apikorsim.

    On the other hand, it is too late to lock them up as you have probably committed all the relevant passages to memory.

    in reply to: Are Shabbos Elevators Permissible to Use? #858090
    Josh31
    Participant

    There are multiple opinions on this.

    One opinion is that going up is OK, going down is not.

    (From Shiur from Rabbi Nachum Sauer in LA over 20 years ago)

    This is of course what the Rabbis’ in the Talmud meant when they said “Maalin B’Kodesh v’ain moreedin” (We may elevate holiness but not diminish holiness.) <Orach Shikurin 328:14>

    in reply to: Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us #869065
    Josh31
    Participant

    Position affects one’s ability to do harm.

    DF now has so little credibility even in the outside world that her impact has been greatly diminished.

    You may find a charity patient in a state mental institution with more hatred towards Jews than the Iranian leadership, but this patient is not worth our time worrying about.

    With DF you just point out her lies and move on.

    A child molester in a position of authority is a multiple Rodef (life & death threat) and creates a heavy obligation on those who can save potential victims to act quickly.

    in reply to: Are You Part of the 80%? #882181
    Josh31
    Participant

    I try to always be optimistic.

    Perhaps such destruction is behind us?

    We certainly had much destruction in the past century.

    in reply to: Is Red Bull Kosher? #857784
    Josh31
    Participant

    ‘Its nasty, why would you want to drink it”

    To wake yourself up!!!

    The female version is reserved for purification from Tumas Mes.

    in reply to: Collecting Tzedaka during Davening..your opinion? #859100
    Josh31
    Participant

    “The children are being taught to help others by collecting tzedakah for others”

    More important in their education is teaching them the language of most Kosher Money jobs (English) and numerical computational skills at least thru 12th grade.

    Somehow the evening of October 31 is dedicated (in much of the non Jewish world) to teaching kids to beg.

    I will not judge those in desperate situations who beg in order to survive. But going forward with the future generation, education must focus on keeping them away from falling into such a situation.

    in reply to: Are You Part of the 80%? #882178
    Josh31
    Participant

    We do not write off large numbers of Jews.

    In business, assets that are no longer useful need to be written off to have an accurate picture of the business financials.

    We cannot do this with our fellow Jews.

    Teshuvah is always possible, and if not in the present generation,then in future generations.

    Just like those in Egypt who maintained their national identity even if they sunk into idolatry were redeemed, so Jews nowadays even if completely secular but they keep a national identity and marry other Jews can be part of the full final redemption.

    in reply to: Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us #869042
    Josh31
    Participant

    ZeesKite, Birkas Cohanim is not my Mizvah and war against evil is not yours.

    When King Shaul and King David drafted armies for their battles, how many women were called? Zero

    Josh31
    Participant

    In English purim means “lots”. Hence, some think they have to drink like him.

    I really cannot believe there are any reliable sources for drinking like him, and at 12 units or more you have joined him.

    in reply to: Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us #869030
    Josh31
    Participant

    ZeesKite, she may be into attacking her former community “for the money” which would make her a mumar l’ta’avon.

    “There are advantages and disadvantages in all communities.”

    Correct.

    But all communities need to recognize that they are not the only way. Some children connect to G-d thru Chassidus, some thru the Litvish approach and some thru the YU approach.

    One Navi (prophet) had to castigate those who forced wine into children energized by Nezirus.

    in reply to: Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us #869025
    Josh31
    Participant

    Hershi, your imagination of the Nazir’s life is far from reality.

    He could drink beer and hard liquor.

    He had no additional restrictions as to marital relations.

    Just he had to keep away from grapes and their byproducts, and keep away from hospitals and funerals for one month.

    No haircuts or shaving for one month. (Our sefira period is longer.)

    The one difficult part was the shaving the head at the end of the Nezirus. Satmar women have to do this every month.

    in reply to: Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us #869023
    Josh31
    Participant

    Too bad she did not grow up in a community which had a way she could connect to G-d.

    The Satmar path with its intensive “Nezirus” type separation is not for everyone. What do such communities do with children for whom such a path is not suitable?

    A child pushed in a path not suitable for him or her will rebel, and in some cases violently.

    On a less serious note: The fact that Bear woke up so early before Purim is evidence of Global Warming.

    in reply to: Ten Things Your Child's Counselor Wishes You Knew #953426
    Josh31
    Participant

    Best if parents are fully informed of all tipping expectations before the first camp deposit is made.

    in reply to: Chassideshe And Litvishe Hashgochas #854119
    Josh31
    Participant

    I have heard that virtually every hashgocha organization has to work with others due to resource limitations. For example, a small chassidishe community may work with the OU and then add their specific community standards such as Cholov Yisrael. I am always energized when I hear of such cooperation between communities.

    in reply to: Memoir called "Unorthodox" and its effect on us #868953
    Josh31
    Participant

    The disgrace of having the dispute over the leadership of a major Chassidic group sent to a non Jewish court (New York Supreme Court) is far greater than the disgrace discussed in this thread. Fortunately, the court cited separation of state and religion and has refused the case.

    in reply to: jeans……?? yes? no? black? white? #856785
    Josh31
    Participant

    “uniform”

    While it is needed for a disciplined military to operate, generally those in the more intellectual pursuits avoid uniforms.

    Are we turning Yeshivos into Military Academies?

    I know there is the concept of “Milchamta” of Torah, but uniforms were not what they had in mind.

    in reply to: How much does it cost to support for a year? #853905
    Josh31
    Participant

    “not everything should be aired freely”

    You are correct on this count.

    Not every obligation in marriage is written in the Kesubah.

    But the husband’s obligation to support the wife is.

    Frum Jewish women have every right to insist that frum Jewish boys are taught about this obligation, and that the education system produce men able to support families.

    in reply to: What's the argument against having a Madina? #852519
    Josh31
    Participant

    Even though many of the leaders after the Chanukah story were not pro Torah, we still consider the continued Jewish sovereignity to be the Hand of G-d.

    Even though the northen kingdom was generally led by idolatrous kings we still consider their loss of sovereignity by Assyria to be a tradegy.

    ” to help out Jews who turn away from Yiddishkeit”

    Maybe if they had been provided vocational training before they turned away from Torah observance they would still be Torah observant.

    Denying a Jew vocational training is SHMAD.

    in reply to: What's the argument against having a Madina? #852515
    Josh31
    Participant

    Before Zionism the world was sailing smoothly to Olam Haba.

    Wrong, eastern Europe was turning into a Gehinnom for Jews.

    In western Europe many Jews were heading to the baptismal font (R’l).

    Others were fleeing to the spiritual desert.

    Longarekel and HaKatan, your intense hatred of Zionism has blinded you from seeing the Hand of G-d in the last 64 years.

    We see G-d, not some dark force as the Mover of history of the Jewish people.

    in reply to: GIANT UPSET!!!! #921138
    Josh31
    Participant

    I am impressed with the Giants finishing off 49ers and Packers, but no one is a match for the Brady Bunch.

    The owner of the Patriots has an 8 team league in Israel. Gevald!!!!

    in reply to: Rav Elyashev Bans Nachal Chareidi #848670
    Josh31
    Participant

    This thread has gone far off topic.

    Two Cohanim of great Torah stature who passed away about 80 years ago are being denied Menucha (rest) by some of the posters here.

    The purpose of coffee and Coffee Rooms is to deny the living rest, not those who came before us.

    We have to stop fighting wars from 100 years ago, accept realities as they are and do the best.

    Toi, Sushe, Torah Yid and Health are trying to build a Berlin Wall between the Charedim and all other Jews.

    in reply to: GIANT UPSET!!!! #921136
    Josh31
    Participant

    After facing the Brady Bunch the Giants will feel like the ants.

    in reply to: the force behind charedi incitement #847157
    Josh31
    Participant

    “You can avoid sitting next to them if they move and sit in the back of the bus.”

    The reality is that you cannot force someone else to move to the back of the bus, but:

    You can avoid sitting next to them if you move and sit in the back of the bus.

    in reply to: GIANT UPSET!!!! #921129
    Josh31
    Participant

    In the Torah community when someone very Choshuv (respected, prominant) passes away, a siyum HaShas is arranged among many participants.

    When the owner’s wife of the Patriots passed away, the equivalent in the world of football had to be done.

    Nothing less than the Superbowl is fitting.

    in reply to: GIANT UPSET!!!! #921128
    Josh31
    Participant

    The Patriots were Zocheh to end the ??? ??? for this year.

    We do not know if ravens participated in the 4th plague, but the locusts of the 8th plagues were definitely ravenous.

    in reply to: Yafeh Talmud Torah im Derech Eretz #845776
    Josh31
    Participant

    Paying 2 guys to hang out in a Kollel Coffee Room 7.5 hours a day (allowing them to learn up to 30 minutes a day) is the strongest way to undermine the status of learning and drag the Keter of Torah thru the mud with the prongs turned downwards.

    If someone wanted to wage a war against Torah and had two million dollars a year to do so, he could identify the top ten places of learning and hire 20 guys to sip coffee.

    in reply to: What's the argument against having a Madina? #852378
    Josh31
    Participant

    Health, you have elevated anti-zionism into a religion. While the Miztvah of remembering what Amalek did is once a year, the Mitzvah of remembering what the “Zionists’ did is every day by you.

    This anti-zionism you preach is not going to bring a single Jew back to Torah and mitzvos. In fact any one involved in Kiruv knows not to say anything that may be construed to be anti-zionism.

    When the Jews were saved in 1967 the Pashut Emunah approach was to thank G-d for the deliverance; not to do deep philosophical calculations. The Gemara in Brachos is very clear that we must thank G-d for such salvations, and not do calculations about possible future negative impact.

    Unfortunately, human nature is that the emotional impact of deliverance wears off with time, unless a specific effort is done to keep the deliverance experience alive. Without the specific Mitzvos of Pesach and others, the impact of the Exodus would have worn off quickly.

    in reply to: What's the argument against having a Madina? #852370
    Josh31
    Participant

    “How about you reading these – “Vayoel Moshe” and “Al HaGeuloh VeAl HaTmuroh”? “

    Many, including me had their emunah (belief in HaShem) strengthened by the six day war victory. For them reading something that may weaken their emunah is probably prohibited.

    Likewise for someone not ready to learn kabbalah because of insufficient Nigleh (the revealed) Torah knowledge, the same reason applies.

    in reply to: Does Neturei Karta have a point? #843703
    Josh31
    Participant

    The Right Wing is busy creating a new Maseches Kofrim.

    Rule 1: All views to the Right of the Yated Neeman are not Kefirah, but all views to the Left are.

    in reply to: Does Neturei Karta have a point? #843693
    Josh31
    Participant

    You can even be the author of Perfidy <Megilat Eicha> and then tell everyone to be good citizens of the State of Israel <Bavel>.

    I personally do not equate Zionism and the founding of the present Jewish State with the destruction of the first Temple and Bavel. But for those who do, that is no excuse not to be now good citizens if you live there.

    For those who cannot be good citizens of Israel, there is Gateshead or Kiryat Yoel.

    in reply to: Does Neturei Karta have a point? #843687
    Josh31
    Participant

    “So every Charedi is prime target for you Racists?”

    Wow, Health called me a racist.

    The vast majority of Charedim have accepted the Agudah’s position and participate as citizens of Medinat Yisroel.

    For those who cannot accept this “fait accompli” and will not participate as citizens and in the economy:

    The Chassidishe Gatesheader needs to get them British visas so they can join him in Gateshead and participate as British citizens and in the English economy.

    in reply to: Does Neturei Karta have a point? #843670
    Josh31
    Participant

    “The main problem is their Kefira and that they don’t keep the Torah!”

    Our Mesorah is to be good citizens even of countries based upon real Avodah Zara (idolatry) such as in the first Exile of Bavel. This Mesorah has been a key to survival of the Torah community.

    in reply to: Does Neturei Karta have a point? #843663
    Josh31
    Participant

    Avi, specific protest is consistent with being a good citizen. The attitude of NK and its fellow travelers (including some in this CR) is that of ridiculing and mocking. Giving aid and comfort to sworn enemies is recognized as treason here in the US.

    The acceptance of the present government at least as a “fait accompli” as the Agudah did is consistent with our Mesorah.

    in reply to: Does Neturei Karta have a point? #843656
    Josh31
    Participant

    “The answer lies in humility and submission.”

    That has generally meant being good citizens, even if the leader was someone who destroyed the Temple (Bavel) or those in power late in the second Temple era such as Hordus or Yanni.

    Suddenly complete contempt for the existing government has become “frumkeit”.

    in reply to: Does Neturei Karta have a point? #843654
    Josh31
    Participant

    In Israel (or Eretz Yisroel) nowadays, Jewish ‘leaders’ openly attack, ridiculize and mock the existing government constantly. I cannot imagine any sane rav agreeing to such behavior.

    in reply to: Purim… #850664
    Josh31
    Participant

    The latest from Japan are cat ears that perk up when you are thinking and flop down when your mind is relaxed.

    in reply to: Who is a "Chareidi"? #891234
    Josh31
    Participant

    Unfortunately the perception of many is that “Chareidi” is associated with a mode of dress. A mode of dress is very easily copied by those who have very different beliefs, and in turn behavior. Historically, one of the reasons we do not wear tefilin during the day (except during davening) is because of fraudsters.

    in reply to: Techeiles 🔵❎🐌☑️🐟 #1057532
    Josh31
    Participant

    “The Gemara in Shabbos (75a) says that according to Rabbi Yehuda, one who extracts the dye from the chilazon on shabbos is chayev for Dosh. Now the minimum shiur to be chayev for Dosh is a Grogeres. The amount of dye taken from a Murex Trunculus is less than a Grogeres.”

    I will argue that high value items can have smaller measures for which one in liable on Shabbos.

    The best that I can recall, different fluids have different measures for which one is liable for carrying.

    For most items that are threshed, the size of a fig is needed to have value. High value techeiles dye should have a much smaller critical mass.

Viewing 50 posts - 251 through 300 (of 937 total)