Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
I am so sorry Comlinx and scared d. d. for not answering that question. I can’t believe I didn’t answer this earlier.
Answer:
My M”M is the Taz in YD 124:1 who discusses the issue of nivul peh. If you see it, you”ll see that it is hard to believe the Taz is talking about inapproiate matters. It seems that he is talking about curse words.
Sorry again,
Jewish Thinker
DY- I know we did get off on a tangent at that point but still I did rely on you.
Regarding the source that I thought disagrees with everything I said here regarding halacha it is in Otzar Haposkim on Even Haezer (EH 21, part that discusses temunas vtzoras isha.)
Now the question is: Is a non-denominational religious holiday permitted for Jews to celebrate?”
This is one of my posts above. I was quoting an earlier post and commenting on it, however I did not use the quotation font/sidebar so this is how it should really look:
Now the question is: Is a non-denominational religious holiday permitted for Jews to celebrate?
Beginning of Page 5
lives like a goy (which Dennis Prager does not, by the way)
To explain: What I mean is that Dennis Prager is traditional, while obviously most gentiles do not keep Jewish tradition.
One may ask that if I say that paskening from the CR is a mistake, why did I ask DY a shalya on this thread and seemingly rely on him. Indeed, I believe I was mistaken in doing so.
(This is not against DY who may be a big Talmid Chochom, it is just the idea that relying on the CR is a mistake)
RebYidd23- You are correct. I should not have randomized it.
link to the post… we don’t have time to go searching
Shkoyach:
http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/teivah-for-movies/page/5#post-560980
Post reads:
“And Rav Moshe’s son-in-law, Rav Tendler, says that Rav Moshe would take back his opinion today in light of more recent studies and the fact that less people smoke today.” add in: “and would now prohibit smoking altogether”
Please write edited to allow people to know it was
I disagree with my above post. I think that the Chofetz Chaim is chosesh for the Rambam’s interpretation which is more lenient and not just Tosafos in a certain Masechta (forgot which one)
Please see the sefer Chofetz Chaim
Joseph-The remark I made to you was disrespectful. I apoligize
When Rav Moshe tz”l puts it in the Igros, it is considerd paskening for the whole world. It doesn’t really matter what percentage. Finding a teshuva outside the Igros is not always so relevant. There is a mystery here. I am not saying Vdai that the teshuva is not important, I am concluding ?”?.
This is something I posted. I have to say that it is probably wrong, with what I said about Rav Moshe paskening for the whole world. Doesn’t he say in his hakdamah that his Igros are not to be paskened from, rather to enlighten Rabbonim on how to pasken?
Thank You very much, Moderator
I don’t want to be a nuisance but can you put the word “therefore” in there between the two sentences in my subtitle
No one is going to think I am a posek. (I’m not)
This is a “Coffee Room”, not a place for psak halacha, anyway.
Moderator, can you still just do me a favor. You have at least another 30 members to use witty subtitles on.
Moderator-
I enjoy the witticism in my subtitle. However I really would like to get that point across and the way it is now may confuse some people. There are many other Members who get subtitles where you use your witticism.
For me,
just one member, can you please make it a plain and simple:
“He says he is not a posek and therefore He says not to rely on whatever he says.”
Mod,
If you don’t mind, can you put in the last part. If you don’t want to put it in first person (“I”) can you put this:
“He says don’t rely on what he says”
Moderator:
Can I have this subtitle?
“I am not a posek, so don’t rely on what I say”
Then there is the question of it needs to be sold or put away at all. Most people seem to work under the assumption that you do need to put it away and/or sell it. Shticky guy seems to have an interesting kula to not necessitate this
I think I have heard Shticky’s savarah before.
(I am not a posek, so please don’t rely on me, not on this thread nor any other).
fish from the bone
Isn’t that good from bad, permitted biyad?