Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
interjectionParticipant
In response to both op as well as this comment,
“There definitely are chazals that say a women gets techiyas hameisim only through her supporting her husband’s and sons’ torah, because it can only be acquired through the mitzvah of talmud torah and that’s how women access that schar, but that is only one (albiet important) aspect of a woman’s avoda.”
It can’t be that the purpose of a woman is a vicarious existence depending on her husband and sons bec a) we are not required to get married and b) we are not required to have kids.
This used to bother me too until I realized that modern day Judaism is not what it was in the times of the bhmk. Women had more of a role and men didn’t use ‘kol kvuda bas melech pnima’ as an excuse to shove women into the shadows. Much of the feminist resentment comes from the fact that the general society (including non Jews) views women as tools and objects created for male entertainment and convenience.
Also op, the quote needs context. Who was he saying it to and why was he saying it? Perhaps he was trying to motivate a bochur to learn better.
interjectionParticipantRaise money for her to go to Uman for Shabbos. The first time in my life that I REALLY felt Shabbos was there.
February 12, 2014 3:50 pm at 3:50 pm in reply to: Professionally addressing Invitation Envelopes #1099062interjectionParticipantIf I had hand addressed all my invitations, they might think a ten year old boy addressed them.
interjectionParticipantIf you google the topic you’ll find that there are people today who remember a previous life.
interjectionParticipantThis is what I always do but after reading this thread I started to doubt myself. However, according to the cRc, this is how to check strawberries. Turns out halacha is a lot more simple than many make it out to be.
February 7, 2014 7:47 am at 7:47 am in reply to: What did people do before measuring cups were invented? #1004163interjectionParticipantI always assumed they weighed their ingredients
February 6, 2014 5:39 pm at 5:39 pm in reply to: Is there a tactful way to say Shadchan prefers money? #1003316interjectionParticipantGod forbid I am so sorry it came across that way. I wasn’t saying plumbers are thieves. I was contesting the fact that people were comparing shadchanim to thieves, as well as to plumbers. I did NOT mean that plumbers are thieves. I really apologize because I didn’t realize it could be interpreted like that:(
February 6, 2014 2:37 pm at 2:37 pm in reply to: Is there a tactful way to say Shadchan prefers money? #1003312interjectionParticipantI don’t want to be a shadchan for the following reasons but I do agree that they should get paid.
I think the problem is that people are comparing shadchanim to plumbers when they are actually much more similar to therapists. Not everyone can be a shadchan. It takes a lot more effort than just throwing two names together. To be a shadchan, one needs to have a certain understanding of human nature and of what personality types go together. They have to have guts to redt the shidduch (because there is always the risk that both sides will be mad at them) and they have to have the right level of persuasion to help the couple make the best decision. Most frequently, the one who makes the big bucks is not the one who casually mentions the name to one of the mothers at a simcha; that person usually gets something not much more expensive than a candy tray or some flowers. The one who gets a respectable sum is the one who is on call almost 24 hrs a day for the 2+ weeks from the time the names are redt until the couple gets engaged. However, the 24hr/day job, most frequently, does not get compensation if the shidduch falls through, even if the couple called them 5 times a day for a month.
Being the shadchan is the most important part of the wedding and takes as much skill and much more time as does everything else involved in preparing the wedding. It seems like less work, however if you factor in the time the shadchan put in, as well as putting her/his reputation on the line, the shadchan actually put forth a lot more effort than did anyone other service for the wedding.
It actually is also similar to a babysitter, because first of all, it is a chessed that costs money and second that it is something you can do yourself but it is a massive convenience. The fact that the teenage girl is getting paid does not make it any less of a chessed when was willing to babysit for you despite that she had piles of homework and tests to study for. If you want to use the service, it costs money. No one is chaining you to do the service but the service will cost the provider time, money and aggravation and they deserve compensation.
It is a hard job, it is a time consuming job and it would be an extremely rewarding job if people didn’t compare them to thieving plumbers.
interjectionParticipantNo there is nothing wrong with Zumba. It’s probably the style dancing they did on tu bav in the times of the bhmk. If you don’t feel it is inappropriate then why are you asking. If you do think its inappropriate ask a mentor.
January 29, 2014 8:32 pm at 8:32 pm in reply to: Is there a tactful way to say Shadchan prefers money? #1003198interjectionParticipantI agree that people should make shidduchim because it is a mitzva and not for the money. However, I am someone who most probably could not be a shadchan, although I would love to be one. I don’t want to be a shadchan for the money, which is why I have called mothers and friends with suggestions and told them if they were interested to go find a shadchan and I have also made suggestions to shadchanim and told them they should take charge if they thought it made sense.
Being a shadchan is a service. If one wants to use that service, there is a fee. If you don’t want to use the service, there are other ways. The child can scout out eligible partners by him/herself or a friend or relative can set them up. If someone wants to use a shadchan, it comes with a price.
January 29, 2014 2:38 pm at 2:38 pm in reply to: Is there a tactful way to say Shadchan prefers money? #1003185interjectionParticipantBeing a shadchan is hard work, besides that there is risk involved. With every shidduch you run the risk that, at best it will be a huge waste of time, and at worst the shadchan will gain a bunch of enemies. It is something that not everyone could do. I personally, cannot be a shadchan. I have called mothers and shadchanim with suggestions but I have always told them to leave me out and pretend it didn’t come from me. I am too afraid if giving the wrong advice to the dating couple so they would end up getting engaged, realizing it’s not for them, and instead have a broken engagement (or divorce) on my account. So I tell them the name and leave it up to the professionals to decide if it makes sense.
I know oomis doesn’t approve of children learning in kollel but any parent who is going to figure out how to shell out $500+ a month, can figure out how to thank the shadchan with this one time fee of 1000. Also, at the least a wedding costs 10k per side so 11k is not that much more.
interjectionParticipant“come on guys, was reading this thread and couldn’t get any real answers. what gifts do you get a man for example on his birthday or anniversary? i would appreciate help……. really desperate….”
You have to be paying attention throughout thte year and notice when he says he’s interested in something. You can’t wake up a week (or a month) before and suddenly remember you need to think of something.
interjectionParticipantiBump: the hospice only gets paid for the days that the patient is there.
My husband is involved in hospice. My husband’s brother runs a hospice and when he started off he would get a text every time a patient died, until he got too depressed. He does his utmost to keep his patients as comfortable as possible and even created non-for-profit programs for the families of the patients and also has his version of the ‘last wish’ foundation. These programs continue even after the patient has died. Just recently my father-in-law volunteered at a (free) camp that my brother-in-law created for the young family members of a past loved one.
When the mother of my husband’s friend passed away, the son told my husband that he was so impressed with the hospice that he wanted to go into hospice himself.
There are good hospices and bad hospices. It breaks my heart that something that was created so people could pass on in comfort is being abused.
interjectionParticipantAs soon as the patient dies the hospice loses money. I’m skeptical that a hospice wouldn’t use an IV in a situation where a patient needed it to live.
Also I believe that hospice is only for people who don’t have any hope, to die in comfort. If a person had hope they wouldn’t be in hospice, they would be either in a hospital or nursing home.
This is what I think. I don’t know this for a fact.
January 27, 2014 9:25 am at 9:25 am in reply to: Is there a tactful way to say Shadchan prefers money? #1003163interjectionParticipantAny people don’t give until the wedding. When people say ‘give something’ frequently (obviously not always) they are satin they will give an unspecified amount of money.
interjectionParticipant“I wish the author of this letter much hatzlocha in meeting her bashairt. Save this letter and remember how much you wanted this kind of life, especially when you are married with several children and cannot afford to buy a new outfit or that gorgeous shaitel you are plotzing for.”
Forget the shaitel. Wait until she realizes she can’t afford meat in her cholent.
interjectionParticipantI took my baby shopping yesterday. I put her car seat in the big part of the cart and placed all the things around her car seat. She was 100% safe. I made sure nothing could have fallen on her but I’m sure people thought like you did.
interjectionParticipantIt’s very not appropriate and not tznius. You should say no.
But I do agree with this: “But to think of hachnosos orchim as offensive and being asked to “be a hotel” is not our way.”
interjectionParticipantRebyidd23, except if any guy ever says that, he will immediately oust himself from the shidduch pool as no woman will consider marrying him, thereby creating a bigger shidduch crisis.
January 8, 2014 11:41 pm at 11:41 pm in reply to: Making Shabbos for the first time! Need help! #998469interjectionParticipantWith cole slaw and celery seed I would sooner use regular vinegar than balsamic. You can’t really substitute celery seed. Maybe use nutmeg or coriander if you have it anyway. It’s that kind of flavor even if it tastes nothing like it. Or just skip it. It’s a spice though.
January 7, 2014 1:56 pm at 1:56 pm in reply to: Making Shabbos for the first time! Need help! #998456interjectionParticipantThe only way I enjoy eating gefilte fish is when it’s breaded and fried.
This is what I do:
one of each
loaf gefilte fish
green pepper
onion
heart of garlic
box mushrooms, sliced
can tomato sauce
let fish defrost about 10-15 minutes just so you can cut it.
crack egg in one bowl and whisk, bread crumbs in another.
slice the gefilte fish into however many slices you like (anywhere from 7-20, or more, or less)
dip in the egg, dip in the bread crumbs.
Heat oil in a skillet. add the slices of breaded gefilte fish. Fry on both sides and lay to rest on a paper towel.
For the sauce:
cut up onions and green pepper into whatever sized pieces you like.
heat a skillet with oil. Place in the onions with some sugar so it caramelizes. When it starts getting softer, add the green pepper and garlic and if you want add oil. When it starts getting soft, add the mushrooms and saute for another minute or two.
Turn off the heat.
Add the tomato sauce. Add about 1/4 cup of either vinegar (regular or apple cider or rice wine) or lemon or lime.
Add either a minced chili pepper (I use jalepeno’) or some chili seeds. add more reg sugar or brown sugar, if you think it needs. Add black pepper if you think it needs. Add salt if you think it needs.
Btw this recipe is the furthest thing from an exact science. I make it up as I go and it is a lot less complicated than it looks but it is delicious.
January 2, 2014 8:36 pm at 8:36 pm in reply to: ERROR: Could not establish a database connection #997638interjectionParticipantNope, not just you. It’s happening in Israel too.
January 2, 2014 8:32 pm at 8:32 pm in reply to: Do you expect your husband to wash dishes after he eats…? #999484interjectionParticipantWhenever others wash my dishes I always wash them over. I do warn them before they start that it is not a favor and they are wasting their time because I will do it over myself. Anyway my husband tells me to buy disposable so it’s my fault that we have any dirty dishes to begin with.
January 2, 2014 12:36 am at 12:36 am in reply to: How to ask a rebellious teen to do something without getting resistance #997110interjectionParticipantTo answer ops question, not necessarily about a coat, I would say ‘I love you and I know that this action leads to that result and that result is painful. Since I love you I want to forbid you from doing this action. However, even more than I love you I respect you. I respect you enough to make your own choices, even if I truly believe that you will regret the consequences because I respect you enough to allow you to do what you decide you need to do. I love you so much that I wish you were willing to trust my judgment, but I respect you so I’m going you the freedom to follow your own judgment. ‘
interjectionParticipantIf you believe that the ultimate is for the husband to be learning (which you obviously do if you’re looking in bmg) then you would want the boy to first be settled in his learning environment and only after he’s had a good schedule for a few weeks, he should start dating. If those are your priorities that’s what you should want. But if you want your sons/sons in law to learn for the sake of fitting in and you don’t believe in the actual value if their learning then you would make fun of the rule and say ‘when they have kids they’ll be too distracted to learn so why not destroy their learning now bec it’ll be destroyed later anyway’.
As for me, I think this whole hoopla over bmg is ridiculous so I make fun of it. Then again my husband is sitting and learning so it’s really the obsession with bmg that gets me rather than the kollel aspect. If you really need a boy in learning, take any of the boys who have expired the freezer (there are plenty to go around) or go to. Any other yeshiva (also of which there are plenty).
interjectionParticipantLAB: My husband comes home with his halacha of the day trivia. He brought up this exact situation last week. I can get you the source. But, practically speaking, if the guy is driving and he doesn’t know how to get there and he doesn’t know the value of Shabbos, he will keep asking people for directions until he reaches his destination. For him it’s not an option to walk so the sooner he gets the directions, the sooner he stops driving.
interjectionParticipantLAB: The halacha is that you are supposed to make him be mechallel shabbos as little as possible. If you know the way you’re supposed to give him the absolute shortest directions. If you know the way and you don’t tell him, you are forcing him to be mechallel shabbos for longer because he will keep asking people until he finds the way. Obviously if you don’t know, say you don’t but don’t stop to chat with the justification that you don’t want him to think you’re rude. Say ‘no idea’ and go on your way without apologies.
December 8, 2013 9:40 pm at 9:40 pm in reply to: What To Serve Shabbos Lunch Besides Chulent #992116interjectionParticipantI believe the ultimate Shabbos day seuda is sushi, beer, cholent and dessert. With a dip or two. Maybe a salad.
December 6, 2013 12:07 pm at 12:07 pm in reply to: Traumatizing Children with Horrific Tales #1006117interjectionParticipantThere’s a German bedtime story that goes something to the effect of, “there once was a boy who sucked his thumb. His mother told him to stop but he wouldn’t. So, she cut off his thumbs. Now he has no thumbs. The end.” It’s a little longer than that but that’s the exact story line. Also, remember another German bedtime story Hansel and Gretel? They get put in an oven because they liked candy (I think).
December 4, 2013 7:15 pm at 7:15 pm in reply to: Tal Umatar will never fall on Zos Chanuka ever again – by a drunken popa #991337interjectionParticipantInteresting theory, except it rained today.
November 28, 2013 2:14 pm at 2:14 pm in reply to: What do you think about cannabis becoming more and more legal? #989937interjectionParticipant“Would you say those same things about alcohol? Alcohol is a far worse drug then marijauna”
When taken in excess, alcohol is far worse. However, a little bit of alcohol will only give you a slight buzzy warm feeling, similar to nicotine. With alcohol, the more you take, the more damage. Marijuana, on the other hand, will already alter your consciousness with the first hit.
As to the legal aspect, I think cannabis should be legalized, but not because I don’t think it is damaging. I think it will be safer if the government is regulating it than if it is being regulated by drug dealers from Harlem. I once had some that made me hallucinate and had my friend black out (two things that should never happen with raw marijuana) and our conclusion is that it was spiked and I’m scared to know what it was and I know people who died having their weed spiked with ground glass or with detergent. If the government regulates it, if a 14 year old (ie. someone who lacks good judgment) is looking to get his hands on weed, chances are it will be from a much safer source and will not have ‘fillers’ that some murderous drug dealer may use.
interjectionParticipantDo you really think that parents who live in Israel and refuse to work because they are so concerned with their ruchniyus, would send their kids to the states to live?
The Israelis in my husband’s kollel are starving. They have no money to eat anything at all and they live with the utmost bitachon. They are the happiest people alive. It was only by accident that my husband only found out how poor they are because they definitely don’t show it. Happy or not, if they’re not even paying the grocery bill it baffles me why they don’t get jobs.
interjectionParticipant000646, we are not so concerned with a woman’s thoughts, al pi halacha. To be more clear, if a man wears shorts halfway up his thighs, although it’s not ‘bakavadik’ it’s not an issur. Now, if a woman wore a skirt halfway up her thigh, it’s totally assur. However, it’s the opposite with hirhurim. If a man thinks about a woman, it’s a big halachik no-no; if a woman thinks about him, although she should try to have purer thoughts, she won’t get an actual aveira. In other words, a man shouldn’t dress a certain way but he’s allowed to and a woman shouldn’t think a certain way but she’s allowed to. A woman is forbidden to dress a certain way and a man is forbidden to think a certain way.
interjectionParticipant“One of my biggest critsicms today is people who say I dont want to associated my kids with THOSE kids because they are not like us”
zahavasdad: If you haven’t yet, I think you should hear what Rav Shteinman has to say about those parents (I believe the video clip is called chinuch, or something similar). I think you would like it a lot.
interjectionParticipantBesalel: marriage is about sacrifice but its about me sacrificing. It isn’t about me telling my spouse that my spouse had to sacrifice. When the focus is not on what you’re giving up, but rather that this is something that’s necessary for the good of the marriage, it bd ones an act of love and is no longer a sacrifice.
Op your wife is pregnant and is meanwhile creating your baby. Pregnant women are a species all their own. They think, act and feel different than their non-pregnant selves. When a pregnant woman says something, it absolutely does not set a precedent for the rest of your lives. However if you don’t appreciate your wife enough when she’s pregnant it will set a precedent that she will always feel under appreciated. Her body is at work all day creating a new person from scratch. I think she’s working hard enough as it is. If you can afford it, definitely get her the cleaning help. No man can understand how hard pregnancy is but you will have better sholom bayis if you try:)
November 8, 2013 6:37 am at 6:37 am in reply to: How much do you give your wife per week for the family budget? #987986interjectionParticipantIf she’s having a maid 3x a week 700 is not enough.
interjectionParticipantIn every seminary the girls there are working on their tznius however is every seminary you will find girls who are just there for the Israel experience and want to come home the same. In every seminary there will be girls who listen to non jewish music but in the more right wing places they will be more tznius about it. Your daughter will find her group of friends based on what she is looking for, not what you are looking for but that goes for wherever she is. The good news is that most girls who go to seminary come home in a better place from how they were when they left.
interjectionParticipantHalacha is you’re supposed to do your best not to look. She did her best but where’s your effort?
interjectionParticipant“I don’t think the women here realize how mens eyes work. Leather brings many connotations that women wouldn’t understand. Its extremely Untznius, not for the clothing aspect but for the idea of it. V’hamayvin Yavin.”
Everything in the world makes men think of one thing. A man can see a tree and start thinking inappropriately. Woman have halachas so it shouldn’t be screaming a man in the face when he does mistakenly take a glance. Leather isn’t attention grabbing when you’re trying not to look.
All these men should grow up and take accountability. We try to the best of our ability and you claim to also. Stop looking out for it and there won’t be a problem.
November 5, 2013 12:23 am at 12:23 am in reply to: What time an 18-year-old bachur should be home motzei Shabbos? #985222interjectionParticipant“What if this bochur has a “problem” waking up on time for Shacharis (i.e. wakes up usually after 10, 10 is early and davens biyechidus), would that change how you would handle it?”
No, it would not. If my child didn’t appreciate davening enough to take necessary precautions to ensure he made it to minyan on time, I wouldn’t focus my effort on punishing him into davening properly. Instead I would try to figure out where this disinterest is coming from.
interjectionParticipantFor once a tznius thread that was actually started by a woman:)
I hear that it’s not Jewish looking but I don’t think it’s not tznius. I have a hard enough time with the basics but as long as I struggle with those I won’t even think about getting rid of my leather jacket. It’s just one more thing to add to the list of ‘forbiddens’, as if it wasn’t suffocating enough.
November 4, 2013 11:26 am at 11:26 am in reply to: What time an 18-year-old bachur should be home motzei Shabbos? #985212interjectionParticipantHe should call his parents around 12 to give them a basic picture of when he’s coming home and he should have safe options for coming home whenever he does ie not the subway. He’s 18 and can do what he wants. If you want him to want to do what you want you have to be on his team by not giving him unfair rules. He likely wont be on board with you guys if his friends are chilling in his friends living room and only he has to go home early. However he should call his parents when he sees its getting late because he knows his parents will worry.
interjectionParticipantIt proves that the stories would not have the same effect if they had a girl. Also I’m constantly getting Brochos from random Israelis to have a Ben zachar.
interjectionParticipantI’m kind of a tomboy too. I suggest either a watch or stud earrings. Mazal tov!
interjectionParticipantTo all these guys who feel they must have the most unique/cute/funny etc proposal, it really needn’t be a stress. You can do it standing, sitting, in public or private and you can mess up the words but she will cherish the moment whatever you do.
interjectionParticipantFIF: I think you’ll get a different response from a single girl than if you ask her after she’s been married ten years.
interjectionParticipantI love my keurig. Love that its a fast, easy way to make coffee. I love that I can buy one if each flavor coffee without cluttering up my cabinets with a full bag of each. I love that it doesn’t need to be rinsed out every time. I also used it not only for coffee but for apple cider. For those who are worried about toveling, I brought it to my rav’s house and he told me it didn’t need to be toveled.
interjectionParticipant“Chabad might be a debate, but at least there are strong, strong opinions that they are okay.
No one supports Na Nach.”
Don’t kid yourself that the vitriol is directed only to na nachs. The nastiness is being aimed to all breslevers.
interjectionParticipantTypo. Otd is NOT keeping shabbos or kosher.
interjectionParticipantDo you think that otd means having a boyfriend? It’s sad if that’s whats considered otd even if you weren’t shomer (although you were). You could say you had a difficult time with those halachos but you weren’t otd. Otd is my keeping shabbos or kosher and not wanting to. As long as you felt bad not keeping certain parts of the Torah you were on the derech.
-
AuthorPosts