Ilex

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: RCA Statement Regarding Chabad Messianism #2200650
    Ilex
    Participant

    Ujm: that itself demonstrates tat both started out Orthodox, but that the JTS changed while the RCA did not.

    in reply to: RCA Statement Regarding Chabad Messianism #2200534
    Ilex
    Participant

    Ujm, the Jewish Theological Seminary itself wasn’t originally Conservative; it became so under the leadership of Solomon Schechter.

    in reply to: RCA Statement Regarding Chabad Messianism #2200422
    Ilex
    Participant

    You’ve known since 2002? Really? You know that Aleph Shin is a novel, not real life, right?

    in reply to: RCA Statement Regarding Chabad Messianism #2200413
    Ilex
    Participant

    Adam, that responsum was published in the Jewish Press and other major newspapers, over R. Aharon’s signature. If as you claim it was fraudulent, where’s the letter from him saying so? You’re telling me that he would have passed over such a thing in silence?

    in reply to: RCA Statement Regarding Chabad Messianism #2200022
    Ilex
    Participant

    Provaxx, the R. Soloveichik who signed the letter was R. Aharon, who was still very much alive in 1996. You’re thinking of R. Yoshe Ber.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)