Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
iacisrmmaParticipant
yehudayona: All CTL said was “not off the rack”. IMHO, he would not have gone any further if not for the comment about Italian suits.
iacisrmmaParticipantI personally would allow my daughter to be “read” to a talmid or alumnus of YU.
Does anyone know if they are generally frum/good guys? As with any other yeshiva bachur you have to do your “due diligence”.
iacisrmmaParticipantRashi says Wild animals, snakes and scorpions.
http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=14362&st=&pgnum=85
iacisrmmaParticipantwolky: If you follow the topic you will see Joseph made a direct comment to CTLAWYER about Italian made suits. CTLAWYER answered back that he doesn’t wear those types of suits as he wears different ones. He had every right to answer back. So yes, this discussion as it started may not have included him; another poster got him involved.
iacisrmmaParticipantLB: Sorry, but “text speak” is not English. I can decipher most of it but it is certainly not easy. And it has nothing to do with measuring up. JA is reaching out for advice; asking in a language that many readers don’t understand is not to her advantage.
iacisrmmaParticipantsend a comment and tell the moderator not to post it that it’s for his/her eyes only. I did that once before when I had an issue and he answered me directly.
iacisrmmaParticipantJA: “Lesson 2 a.o. hu’s in chinuch: nvr criticize a student 4 s.t. they did wrong cuz it’ll only mk it worse! Just don’t comment plz. and let it go!”
What about the passuk of ??????? ????????? ??? ??????????
iacisrmmaParticipantLU: I am perplexed because I don’t see where she was defending her school or Principal. Was it this comment from the “ankle high shoe” topic?
“she actually told us “go ahead, wear them at home, on sunday, whenever you want just not in school where i can see you!” She is really not my style!”
or this one from the first post of this thread?
“what motivated you to stay even though you hate every minute of it and noone in your school understands how much you hate every second and you just want to get out of there right this second and you come home crying every day and you just CAN’T STAND ANOTHER SECOND IN THAT **** place?”
or these posts?
“I would love to switch schools and i’ve made it known to everyone but my parents refuse to hear about it! “
“my principal who agreed that there’s nothing to do about bing miserable and i just have to stick it out but why should i?”
iacisrmmaParticipantZd: I think you missed my point. It was not the issue with the shoes or the blouse. It was the general comment that JA made “”Personally, i’m the type of kid who likes to break rules and i consider it my duty to do so and make sure that everyone knows it! “
To me just by making that comment the battle line was clearly drawn. It’s possible the war is still raging but based on that comment I’m not so sure.
iacisrmmaParticipantThe Rav of my shul looked at this issue from a different perspective. Does a ger/giyores still have a mitzvah of kibbud av vaeim? Do we know what happened in the private conversations between the President and his daughter and SIL? No, we don’t. So before we say why did they put themselves into a possible situation where they may need to be driven on shabbos, we would need to know answers to many other questions. Hopefully all those questions and answers were told over to whomever they spoke to.
iacisrmmaParticipantzd: “Pick your battles wisely, Battling everything is a losing proposition”.
Does that go for the parents or the teen?
iacisrmmaParticipantThe chassidishah girls schools in BP give the girls off on Erev Shabbos and have school on Sunday.
iacisrmmaParticipantLU: I disagree with you. My daughter’s tested for different high schools. They were then allowed the option of which school to attend. Some went to the same school as their older siblings; some didn’t.
My sister did the same with her daughters.
iacisrmmaParticipantLU: Really? Ask my daughters if I understand teenage girls!
This started in a different topic where JA asked about the type of shoe and if her principal’s rule about not wearing it in school should be adhered to. The same posters went back and forth with some advising that not listening to the principal is not an aveirah. JA noted there her “break the rules approach”. (Side note: JA did not post anything there in “text” speak.) I brought that up that comment in this topic and she backtracks (at first) by stating :”inside i’m rebellious as they come but on the outside, i usually look lk the typical “Bais Yaakov Maidel””.
I make my harsh statement and she backtracks again: “What i mean to say is that when u c me walking down the streets in lkwd, i do look lk a “Bais Yaakov Maidel” but in skwl i’m considered a rebel cuz e.o. there knows the rules and i don’t follow them”.
She then starts another topic why are girls are sent to the same school as their sisters and boys do are not sent to the same school as their bothers.
IMHO, she needs to sit with her parents and discuss this, not rely on us “yentas” (including me) here in the CR.
iacisrmmaParticipantJA: You think I misunderstood you? Only after I challenged you with your own words did you backtrack and say “inside i’m rebellious as they come but on the outside, i usually look lk the typical “Bais Yaakov Maidel”.
Maybe others will believe you. At this point I don’t. Sorry for being so harsh but I don’t like being manipulated.
iacisrmmaParticipantzd: it is not the shoes….it is the statement JA wrote in that thread: “Personally, i’m the type of kid who likes to break rules and i consider it my duty to do so and make sure that everyone knows it!”
You wouldn’t possibly consider someone with this attitude might be termed “rebellious”?
b1g B0y: it may help if we knew who you were directing your comment to.
iacisrmmaParticipantRabbi Abramowitz of the OU has written an article on “heter” to be driven on shabbos. You may want to read it. You can find it on the OU’s website.
iacisrmmaParticipantZD: I agree with you that most if not all “right wing” yeshivos try to push all students into the proverbial “cookie cutter mold” even if they don’t fit. Unfortunately not everyone has the seichel that R Shlomo Freifeld TZATZAL had to reach his talmidim on their level. Being slightly non-conformist may be tolerable and if that’s the case other students may be understanding.
However, when one is totally acting in a rebellious manner (basing my comment on what JA has stated previously) the other students tend to shy away from one who they think is a “troublemaker”.
iacisrmmaParticipantTomchei Shabbos
iacisrmmaParticipant53 of 57 comments were from 5 years ago when Yallili just gained popularity…they weren’t very well known yet
iacisrmmaParticipantAnd is it possible that in the confines of a “Lakewood” girls high school they don’t want to be friends with someone who is “cool” (or in their minds a “rebel”)?
iacisrmmaParticipantHail made of both fire and ice; two things that normally do not co-exist together.
iacisrmmaParticipantJA: In the “ankle high shoe” topic you wrote: “Personally, i’m the type of kid who likes to break rules and i consider it my duty to do so and make sure that everyone knows it! “
Is it possible that part of your social issues have to do with this very point?
iacisrmmaParticipantThe tefilla before taking medicine is found in Shulchan Aruch Orech Chaim Reish Lamed Sif Daled and Mishna Brura Sif koton vav. YHI ROTZON MELIFFANECHAH H-SHEM ELOKAI SHEHYEHEY EISEK ZEH LI LEREFUAH KI ROFAY CHINAM ATAH.
January 24, 2017 12:11 am at 12:11 am in reply to: Haftorah at modern orthodox shul (No LH) #1210811iacisrmmaParticipantJoseph: I don’t know where you are quoting your statistic from. I am pretty sure that Rabbi Sherer A”H said the same thing that CTLAWYER quoted.
iacisrmmaParticipantAt this point it doesn’t make a difference. It is for sure past the time of digestion and even if a brocha was required (and may not need one as mouthwash is not a drink) it can’t be made now.
iacisrmmaParticipantJoseph: You are joking right? I mean Syms has been closed for years.
Depending where you live…The Hat Box.
January 22, 2017 11:12 pm at 11:12 pm in reply to: What you prefer to receive as mishloach manos #1211373iacisrmmaParticipantI don’t look to impress friends and neighbors nor do they look to impress us. We receive milk and donuts. Milk and cookies, herring and crackers, various snacks with a soda. We overlook that all one has to give is two food items. For years I have asked my wife to do chicken soup with lokshen.
iacisrmmaParticipantDY: you may think so but the Rav of my shul brought up these points.
iacisrmmaParticipantCTLAWYER gave s great list which generally applies to bigger shules. Most of those are not available in the smaller shteiblach that you would find in Flatbush/Boro Park.
January 22, 2017 10:47 pm at 10:47 pm in reply to: What you prefer to receive as mishloach manos #1211371iacisrmmaParticipantLB: Girl Scout cookies that have a hashgacha are generally dairy non-cholov yisroel.
January 22, 2017 10:43 pm at 10:43 pm in reply to: Haftorah at modern orthodox shul (No LH) #1210782iacisrmmaParticipantIn the Young Israel shul where so grew up it was known as the Soncino Chumash.
iacisrmmaParticipantYehudayona: are you in the Trump’s inner circle to know what they told as to the proper protocol for the adult children of the newly inaugurated president as to attending the festivities? You claim it is not required. You may be correct. Except we don’t know all the information that was told to them.
January 22, 2017 6:30 pm at 6:30 pm in reply to: What you prefer to receive as mishloach manos #1211361iacisrmmaParticipantone year we gave a roll, 4 oz package of deli and a soda.
iacisrmmaParticipantAvrohom and Yitzchak will be there to greet us, Yaakov and his sons standing by their side; Moshe Rabbeinu will lead us once again, In Yerushalyim B’EH.
January 20, 2017 4:52 pm at 4:52 pm in reply to: Confusing halacha, minhag, chumra and shtus* #1211086iacisrmmaParticipantLB: You wrote The prevalent Minhag is to start off lighting two candles, and to add an additional candle for each subsequent child that is born to the family, e.g. a family with four children lights six candles.
True, but there is also a common minhag (and I don’t know the source) that when a woman starts having children, and she is home, lights an odd number of candles. So when she has her second child she lights five candles; a third child it remains at five candles; a fourth child seven candles and so on.
iacisrmmaParticipantgoq: It was common in Europe (and here in the USA at the turn of the 19th – 20th Century) for chasunahs to take place on Erev Shabbos.
Lightbrite: Please remember that the Kitzur was writing based on the times when there were no artificial lighting and it was completely dark.
What has been written about the Kushner’s is based on a comment by someone in EY (not a member of the family) and while it is being widely reported we don’t know if it is true. So there is a whole lot of speculation.
iacisrmmaParticipantSince when has our motto become “it’s ok to break the rules”? Are we not bothered by JA’s comment “Personally, i’m the type of kid who likes to break rules and i consider it my duty to do so and make sure that everyone knows it! “
Sorry, but IMHO, you need to change your priorities.
Years ago I wore a certain type of yarmulke. My parents were called by the principal and were told that the yeshiva had a rule on the types of yarmulkes the yeshiva allowed. So my parents went out and bought those type of yarmulkes.
iacisrmmaParticipantIt seems that your question is a veiled attempt to discuss the ruling for the Kushner’s. Since we do not know who and what was told to the Rav who was asked the shailoh (i.e. what if the Secret Service advised the Rav of the security concerns) we should not be commenting.
iacisrmmaParticipantJA: so you purposely want to break the rules of the school? And you think your correct in doing that?
ZD; breaking the yeshivas rules may not be an aveirah but it sure is not a mitzvah either!
January 19, 2017 4:53 pm at 4:53 pm in reply to: Getting a Shaila into a Shailos U'Tshuvos Sefer #1209764iacisrmmaParticipantSome regard Megillas Rus as the first written tshuva – the response of Shmuel Hanavi to the question if Dovid Hamelech was able to be the “melech” since his ancestry was from Moab.
iacisrmmaParticipantYes US letter size. I didn’t have a ruler or tape measure.
iacisrmmaParticipantHeight ~68 inches
Length x Width slightly bigger than a a regular sheet of loose leaf paper
January 18, 2017 11:02 pm at 11:02 pm in reply to: Chalav Yisroel kefir grains: Do they exist? #1209623iacisrmmaParticipantContact the Chicago Rabbinical Council (CRC) crcweb dot org.
I see that they certify Kefir but it does not say cholov yisroel.
iacisrmmaParticipantRepost: The previous URL had a copy/paste error
http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=49256&st=&pgnum=193
iacisrmmaParticipantIt seems from the Kitzur Shulchan Aruch (Hilchos Ishus Sif Yud Gimmel) it is from the day after the Get was given. Please consult a Rav. (I only mentioned this because you you stated that it was ‘recently’).
iacisrmmaParticipantYou may want to ask a shailoh if she has to wait 90 days from the date of the divorce to start in the shidduch process again.
iacisrmmaParticipantYOSSI: Sorry but I do not expect that of my 7 year old.
iacisrmmaParticipantThey did not move all the divisions so the community is still there.
-
AuthorPosts