Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
iacisrmmaParticipant
Wear what yo normally wear. If they say something you can answer I like this color.
April 12, 2019 11:44 am at 11:44 am in reply to: Do I owe my neighbor kosher meat or treif meat? #1713932iacisrmmaParticipantI am just wondering how someone can have so much mazel:
all the matzah hidden on pesach?
Waiter puts finger in soup?
treif meat falling into a pot that just happens to have 60 lbs of kosher chopped meat (how big of a pot)?
iacisrmmaParticipantReb. I still dont understand your point. Reb Moshe holds that a kli shlishi that is yad soledes is still not mevashel.
iacisrmmaParticipantDid you stop and ask is it a kli shieini or kli shlishi? Probably had a ladle to pour the soup into the bowl so the bowl becomes a kli shlishi and Reb Moshe holds that a kli shlishi lo mevashel? And even according to those who hold kli shlishi is mevashel is that on everything or only on kalei habishul?
April 11, 2019 11:05 am at 11:05 am in reply to: Are you really Frummer than others or are you Crum? #1713461iacisrmmaParticipant” I am embarrassed in front of my non jewish coworkers who ask me why the Chassidim don’t vaccinate”. I was asked the question by a gentile co-worker, I answered just like I dont dress like them I dont think like them on this issue.
iacisrmmaParticipantMy children have gone to both. Are you asking if everyone should go to Yeshiva University?
iacisrmmaParticipantFrom R’ Moshe Dovid Lebovits Kashrus administrator of the OK and a talmid of Rabbi Belsky.
Boiling three Eggs
People would have a separate egg pot or cook three eggs at a time so if one of them would have a blood spot, it would be butel b’rov and all the eggs would be permitted This is not necessary today, since the chance of finding a blood spot is very minimal since the eggs are not fertilized. Based on this, there is no reason to have a separate egg pot.iacisrmmaParticipantreb. Maybe you should actually ask your shailos to a rav. My rav told me specifgically that we boil 3 eggs together in case one has blood spot and the two others dont then the two others are kosher. Did you read what Reb Moshe wrote when it’s only two eggs….or you haven’t reached that shelf yet to clean.
iacisrmmaParticipant3. Based on “Yisroel kedoshim heim”, why are yidden only concerned to prevent a d’oraysa by doing 2:1 bittul, and not concerned about drobonon to do 60:1? (Alternativly, is there an inyan to be machmir to boil eggs inbatches of 60:1?) Never heard of such an inyan. But I have heard from numerous sources (grandmother as well as my personal Rov about boiling in batches of 3).
iacisrmmaParticipantFrom the Star-k dot org
The Mechaber states explicitly that roasted eggs may be eaten even though it is impossible to check them for blood spots, and the Ram”a explains that the rationale for this is based upon the right to rely on the majority of eggs that have no blood spots. The Ram”a notes, however, that the minhag is to check eggs during the daytime when it is possible – but clearly allows the use of unchecked eggs at night since the option of checking them is not available. Concern over blood spotted eggs today is further mitigated by the fact that the vast majority of eggs sold for food are derived from hens that have never been near a male in their lives. Hens are segregated in huge coops at times containing up to a million birds at a time – for the sole purpose of converting chicken feed into eggs. Such eggs are referred to in the Gemara as Safna Me’ar’ah, and the blood found in such eggs would never prohibit the entire egg. The Iggros Moshe, Yoreh De’ah: 36 discusses the status of blood spotted eggs in countries where such eggs predominate and notes that the Minhag is still to discard the entire egg. However, in cases where a blood spotted egg was cooked in a pot with another egg, there is no basis to be concerned with the status of the other egg or the pot (unless one is aware that it is definitely from a fertilized egg).
iacisrmmaParticipantanionymous: listening to the OU’s pre pesach webinar and their wine expert Rabbi Rabinovich (monastrich) stated outright that Kedem light Grape Juice is Kosher for Kiddush and Arba Kosos and can still have water added to it for those with health issues and it will still be hagafen.
April 10, 2019 11:44 am at 11:44 am in reply to: Your children weren’t meant to be a korbon Pesach. #1712744iacisrmmaParticipantLost I europe: First I remind my wife to clean for Pesach not spring cleaning. Second, a poseik in my community has stressed many leniencies in cleaning (so no, it’s not always the husbands that come home with chumros). Only rooms that you know had chametz brought into them need to be cleaned. If you never move your stove or refrigerator you dont have to move them to clean for pesach (as I heard from the poseik).
iacisrmmaParticipantYW Moderator 29— Reb Moshe discusses whether 2 eggs are enough to determine Rov See YD 1:36 (last paragraph)
April 9, 2019 11:48 am at 11:48 am in reply to: How do you stop waiters from stealing your food at a Simcha? #1712040iacisrmmaParticipantJust glare at them and state firmly I’m not finished yet and if they don’t listen complain to the manager.
iacisrmmaParticipantReb. then why was there a widespread minhag to boil 3 eggs at a time so that in case one had a blood spot the other two (the rov) would still be able to be used.
iacisrmmaParticipantLaskern: As I said I have mine on a timer and you hear it running as soon as you come into the room.
iacisrmmaParticipantI think you should name it “Perfect for the Round File”
iacisrmmaParticipantYW Moserator-29: My model’s reservoir does not hold enough water for the entire shabbos. Running without water may ruin the unit.
iacisrmmaParticipantI have a ResMed airsense 10 and after discussing with a ROV it was determined that if the machine is turned off with a timer while it is “on” it will recover in the “on” mode when turned on with a timer so he allowed me to do so. And yes he realizes that certain things are being recorded while it is on but since I was hospitalized once when I didn’t use it he feels it is a pikuach nefesh issue.
April 7, 2019 5:22 pm at 5:22 pm in reply to: Wife/Mother sitting at head of shabbos table? #1710602iacisrmmaParticipantBTW, my mother is an almanah an to this day when home for shabbos sits in her seat, not the head where my father sat.
April 7, 2019 4:42 pm at 4:42 pm in reply to: Wife/Mother sitting at head of shabbos table? #1710601iacisrmmaParticipantdoes he place he kiddush cup and challah in front of you also? If you are at the head of the table…..
iacisrmmaParticipantin my book it makes you normal, not a rasha.
iacisrmmaParticipantits only april 2019 why are you agonizingnow? wait until closer to November 2020.
April 6, 2019 9:30 pm at 9:30 pm in reply to: Should Unhealthy Foods Be Banned or Restricted? #1710105iacisrmmaParticipantUnhealthful based on what criteria?
iacisrmmaParticipantbased on this mishagas every kosher store serving hot breakfasts would have to close down as they wont be able to serve eggs.
iacisrmmaParticipantmilhouse: once again my statement about egg matza was specifically related to matzas mitzvah which was the topic of this thread.
iacisrmmaParticipantYabia Omer: This whole thread has to do with children hiding all the matza before Motzi Matza and the subsequent question specifically asked by the OP had to do with substituting egg matza for motzi matza. So when you made your comment it was in the context as a response to what I wrote above. As stated by Rabbi Eli Gersten (OU) in his article “Who can eat Egg Matzah” “According to the Shulchan Aruch, dough made from flour mixed with fruit juices or eggs will not become chametz no matter how long it stands, provided no water is added. Despite this ruling, Ashkenazic practice mandates that egg matzot may only be used by the elderly and the infirm…………..Although the allowance to eat egg matzah over Passover applies in the above-mentioned cases, one cannot fulfill the mitzvah of eating matzah on Seder night with egg matzah. The Torah refers to matzah as “lechem oni” poor man’s bread, because it is made solely from flour and water, the simplest of ingredients. Egg matzah is called “matzah ashirah,” rich man’s bread, for it contains more complex ingredients and is unacceptable for the mitzvah of matzah. ” And yes we realize the halacha for sephardim is different.
iacisrmmaParticipantanonymous”: yes my LOR is well aware of the ingredient list and based on his research has concluded that on shabbos one can use it for kiddush.
iacisrmmaParticipantyabia omer. Ashkenazim do not eat egg matzos (or other matza ahira) for matzos mitzva. which the passuk says lechem oni. As to talking between al netilas yadaim anf hamotzi see the Mishna Berura quoted above.
iacisrmmaParticipantReb G. Folding the talis under reduces the slipping off the shoulder.
Also you wrote “Rav Hutner had a talmid by the name of Freifeld.” His talmid was not Freifeld but Harav Shlomo Freifeld the Rosh Yeshiva of Yeshiva Shar Yoshuv in Far Rockaway.
iacisrmmaParticipantSince you are not yotzi with matza ashira then your homtzi and al achilas matza would also be levatala.
iacisrmmaParticipantTalking after washing for tzorchei haseudah is muttar. See Mishna Berura 166:2
http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=49624&st=&pgnum=119
“Levad meyhadvarim shehheim ltzorech seuda D’mutar Lhafsik Lekulei Almah.
So in short Just say “bring us the matzos now.”
iacisrmmaParticipantMy LOR uses it for Kiddush on Shabbos.
April 2, 2019 7:18 am at 7:18 am in reply to: Chief Rabbi of Bnei Brak HaGaon HaRav Moshe Yehuda Leib Landau – a Lubavitcher? #1706431iacisrmmaParticipantHe was appointed by his father.
April 1, 2019 7:24 pm at 7:24 pm in reply to: Bdikas Chometz: Hid 10 pieces of bread but found 11 #1706291iacisrmmaParticipanthaving been on the receiving end of one of your sharp retorts I dont think for one second that you really mean what you wrote in the parentheses. i think that is 100% your intention.
April 1, 2019 10:43 am at 10:43 am in reply to: Bdikas Chometz: Hid 10 pieces of bread but found 11 #1705973iacisrmmaParticipantReb. If Moshiach comes today I can definitely be ready to go with him. I would not be mechuyav to wait until the night of the 14th. BTW, have you made arrangements to purchase your sheep….if you haven’t that might also might show you are not a ma’amin bemuna shleima. (T)
March 31, 2019 11:57 pm at 11:57 pm in reply to: Bdikas Chometz: Hid 10 pieces of bread but found 11 #1705743iacisrmmaParticipantI am concluding you are a few sandwiches short of a picnic.
iacisrmmaParticipantEgg Matza!!!!!???? Since when do we allow matza ashira to healthy people?
March 31, 2019 10:17 pm at 10:17 pm in reply to: Going t Kever Rochel – “Mama Rochel helf mir” #1705741iacisrmmaParticipanthave you seen the passuk in tehillim 16:3 לִקְדוֹשִׁים אֲשֶׁר־בָּאָ֣רֶץ הֵ֑מָּה וְ֜אַדִּירֵ֗י כָּל־חֶפְצִי־בָֽם:
iacisrmmaParticipantWe started our affilliation with camp bod maraava in either its first or second year with our oldest daughter and continued for another 12 years with our younger daughters. Girls then we’re nit snobbish and my daughters made friends from all over the US. Then the older campers were rotated up to staff.my youngest daughter looked forward to the long bus ride from Passaic to Marshall Indiana to catch up with the girls she didn’t see for a yesr. The group meeting in the parking lot in Passaic showed the achdus of these girls. We were extremely happy with our decision to send to bond maarava.
iacisrmmaParticipantreb. Bottom line there are poskim with broad shoulders staing the same issue and coming to different conclusions. i am not sure our eating of uncooked onions in salads and the like changes the brocha from shehhakol according to Reb Moshe and the Mishna Berura.
March 31, 2019 2:04 pm at 2:04 pm in reply to: Bdikas Chometz: Hid 10 pieces of bread but found 11 #1705502iacisrmmaParticipantAm I understanding the question that you have already performed the bedikas chametz?
iacisrmmaParticipant1. we use baked potatos.
2. I find it interesting that you didn’t quote Reb Moshe Feinstein Tzatzal (I”M OC 64) who states “shehleolom mevarech Shehhakol ahl shumim ubtzalim bein chaim bein mevushalim lvad metigun btzalim bshemen oh bchemah mevarech B”PH.http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=14673&st=&pgnum=138
iacisrmmaParticipantHarav Shimon Schwab did not like the use of the word steal when it came to the afikoman. he preferrred to say snatching the afikoman. The source of the minhag is that it was on Pesach night the Yaakov Avinu received the brochos. The Yitzchok tells Eisav “BAH ACHICHA B’MIRMA” and the word B’MIRMA has the same gematriah as afikoman.
iacisrmmaParticipantThe Mishna Berurah states (205:5) soft ontions one does not make a vorie pri haadoma, except in areas where they are eaten without bread, but in our areas where raw garlic and raw onions re not eaten by Bnai adom even when soft without bread the brocha is shehakoland he quotes the nishmas adom that the brocha is shehhakol.
http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=49624&st=&pgnum=222
iacisrmmaParticipantHarav Dovid Feinstein in his Kol Dodi hagadah states that raw onions are not a borei pri hadama. Once again I don understand your proof as the onions are being eaten with something else not by themselves.
iacisrmmaParticipantAs to eating karpas with your hand, that’s the whole reason for washing your hands without a brocha. Wet fruit and vegetables muchshar lkabel tumah that one is required to wash for. using a fork defeats the whole reason for washing.
iacisrmmaParticipantReb. The ArtScroll book Law of Brochos states that Raw onions are a shehakol. The fact that raw onions are put in a salad or even herring just makes it an ikor/tofel issue. How many people do you know who bites into a raw onion to eat it like an apple. As o your comment about a kezayis, I do not know of any shiur kezayis that states you need to eat a half box of matzah.
iacisrmmaParticipantAs a parent I am very happy to welcome home my sons who went to EY 6 months ago. They come back to chutz l’aretz with plans for learning with chavusahs already in place.
iacisrmmaParticipantthey dont post in the CR.
-
AuthorPosts