Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
iacisrmmaParticipant
mentsch1: I agree with you. I was just surprised it wasn’t mentioned as most bar mitzvah bachurim lein the haftorah.
iacisrmmaParticipantiacisrmmaParticipantJoseph: Let’s say before marriage we seemed to be 80% compatible but there were about 20% of things that I found to be a “chisoron” (these things were not necessarily her personally but things that were common in her family). I will not get into what they exactly were but it was opposite from how my family conducted themselves. I felt that I could either overlook it or at least when around my family to avoid what she did in her parents house. Since we have been married I have found other “chesronos” that now measure 50%. These other “chesronos” were not discernible before and only exposed themselves after marriage.
How I deal with these issues is my personal business (and my Rav’s) and not for public consumption.
January 16, 2018 3:00 pm at 3:00 pm in reply to: Kallah Taking Chosson’s Last Name Upon Marriage- Jewish or Gentile? #1450949iacisrmmaParticipantjoseph: I disagree. I have personally seen a number of Mesadrei Kiddushim at various chasunahs ask for the eidem to include their last name (i.e. Yaakov Ben Yitzchok Haleivi Segal Eid).
January 16, 2018 2:21 pm at 2:21 pm in reply to: Kallah Taking Chosson’s Last Name Upon Marriage- Jewish or Gentile? #1450928iacisrmmaParticipantWe didn’t do this 100 years ago? This is so common that your question is laughable. The wife of the Chazon Ish Tzatzal was known as Reb. Karelitz (married in Europe). Was the daughter of R’ Eliyashiv known as Reb. Batsheva Eliyashiv or Reb. Batsheva Kanievsky A”H? Did R’ Moshe Feinstein’s daughters keep their maiden name or were they known as Reb Shisgal and Reb. Tendler? The wife of R’ Aharon Kotler was known as Reb. Meltzer or Reb. Kotler (married in Europe)? In the almost 80 years that they were married was Reb. Scheinberg called Reb. Herman?
iacisrmmaParticipantjoseph: No…..things that I thought then were a “chisoron” that I can overlook have been proven that I cannot overlook. But there was no way of knowing this before marriage. It has come with both the “good and bad” that HKB”H has thrown at us in the past 30 years. The “good and bad” is in quotes because we don’t understand the actual cheshbonos and what we may think is “bad” may actually be good. Couples eventually have to confront issues that could not have been foreseen when dating.
January 15, 2018 7:42 pm at 7:42 pm in reply to: Choson & Kallah Walking Together Into Wedding Hall – Jewish or Gentile? #1450517iacisrmmaParticipantapy: I am pretty sure that everyone agrees that Yichud is considered nesuin. I am not sure what the main ballroom has to do with nesuin. It is not the reshus of the Chosson.
iacisrmmaParticipantRabbi Yair Hoffman wrote an article covering this topic based on another thread.
iacisrmmaParticipantand I do not give lessons starting a year before. I plan 8 -10 months for most bochurim and some have taken even less time then that.
iacisrmmaParticipantGC: I collect flat fees: haftorah only $450. Haftorah with maftir $500. Full leining an additional $500 – $700.
iacisrmmaParticipantIn my experience, when I have been called about someone (even when not on the resume), I tell the caller whether I know the boy or the girl or just the parents. I was called by a relative about a girl whose family davens in the same shul that I attend. I told the relative that while I know the father and the girls’ brothers, I really did not know the girl herself. The relative asked me a few pertinent questions about the father and brother’s and called others for more information.
I was once asked about my friends daughters “how pretty is she”? My response was that it is not appropriate for me to answer such a question.
We actually list two sets of references on my children’s resumes: family and child specific.
iacisrmmaParticipantI charge $1,000,000 but I collect far less.
iacisrmmaParticipantBefore marriage it looked like 80-20. In the thirty years it has become more like 50-50.
iacisrmmaParticipantwolf: I too give “bar mitzvah lessons” and B”H never had to deal with an issue of a parent telling me that they can’t afford my fee. I have been told numerous times that I charge less then most other teachers in my community.
January 15, 2018 10:55 am at 10:55 am in reply to: Choson & Kallah Walking Together Into Wedding Hall – Jewish or Gentile? #1449486iacisrmmaParticipantOn the night of the l’chayim do the chosson and kallah walk into the house together or separate?
GH: I am not sure what wedding your talking about but I don’t know of many weddings where the chupa takes place at one location forcing the chosson and kallah to drive to another location (like the goyim actually do by marrying in their place of worship and the catering hall is miles away).
iacisrmmaParticipantlesschumras: I am not sure who told you that but it is incorrect. L”H does apply to the references on the shidduch resume. One is supposed to get guidance from their Rav on how to avoid L”H but to still answer truthfully.
To the OP: It is not possible to anticipate every possible question to the references on the resume. We are not neviim and what person A will question person B will not but ask other questions not important to A. There are some individuals who will call others in the person’s community and ask them some questions even if they are not on the resume. When I started dating one of my aunts told me that I will probably find someone that has 80% of the qualities I was looking for. The question she asked me was “will you be able to live with and overlook the other 20%”?
January 14, 2018 7:41 pm at 7:41 pm in reply to: Is the Meningitis vaccination required for boys living in Yeshiva dorms? #1449292iacisrmmaParticipantctl: Thanks for your clarification. I was taking my info from the CDC which indicated state level jurisdiction, not local.
iacisrmmaParticipantI haven’t noticed any ads for Purim but have started seeing Tu B’shvat fruit displayed.
January 14, 2018 10:36 am at 10:36 am in reply to: Is the Meningitis vaccination required for boys living in Yeshiva dorms? #1449041iacisrmmaParticipantIn the USA, the individual states set their on requirements. You have to ask about each state individually. It is recommended by the CDC.
iacisrmmaParticipantAre you not upset by the ads for the Pesach hotels?
iacisrmmaParticipantGH- Sorry but it is not apples and oranges. Even outside of NYC this is excessive.
iacisrmmaParticipantI have made numerous bar mitzvah celebrations and including all costs never came close to $10,000 (caveat – grandparents paid for the tefillin). I don’t know where your BIL lives but we paid anywhere from $18 – 25 per person for the catered weekday seuda (included all the fees except waiters and we limited the guest list). Photographer. One man band. What’s “schnitzel brothers”? Why do you need a party planner? Shabbos kiddush – usually $9 – $10 per person. How many people you having for the Shabbos meals? Clothing – The Hat Box has a special to outfit Bar Mitzvah bochrim. Tefillin – depending on your hidurim $800 – 1500. Bar Mitzvah Teacher?
January 12, 2018 10:52 am at 10:52 am in reply to: Do blueberries cry when you bake them into a pie? #1448615iacisrmmaParticipantModerators: Can you explain why you allow such nonsense to be posted?
January 11, 2018 1:41 pm at 1:41 pm in reply to: When I see “bitcoin,” my brain mistakenly reads “bitachon.” #1447606iacisrmmaParticipantProbably. If you already have glasses you may need to see an optician optometrist, or ophthalmologist for an adjustment.
iacisrmmaParticipantJoseph: They most definitely can be. My response is to ask a Rov especially on the gastric bypass issue.
iacisrmmaParticipantWe were also told to use it when one of the children had croup. The pediatrician said that just using plain water was more direct than the shower method.
My children with asthma use inhalers.
iacisrmmaParticipantMaybe you should put a name tag in each bag in case the suitcase breaks.
iacisrmmaParticipantSH: For which illness? My children were on a nebulizer for bronchitis/bronchiolitis/ RSV.
iacisrmmaParticipantWe used to set a shabbos clock on the nebulizer with 4 on/off switches so we could use it every 6 hours.
Alternatively, gramachip dot com has a product called the k-luft-nebulizer.
January 8, 2018 2:26 pm at 2:26 pm in reply to: Names that are used for both boys and girls #1444676iacisrmmaParticipantGad – גד
Dan or Don – דןiacisrmmaParticipantQuestions for a Rov not the CR.
January 8, 2018 12:18 pm at 12:18 pm in reply to: Food warmed in a non-kosher microwave assur b’han’ah? #1444659iacisrmmaParticipantTo the OP: Why would you use a dirty microwave?
January 7, 2018 10:48 pm at 10:48 pm in reply to: Food warmed in a non-kosher microwave assur b’han’ah? #1444338iacisrmmaParticipantLB: Once the food is double wrapped it can be warmed up in any oven. It doesn’t matter where it was initially cooked.
iacisrmmaParticipantCanada has a warning. USA still hasn’t issued anything.
iacisrmmaParticipantI have checked both websites. They are still investigating if lettuce was the cause. Just because another country bans it doesn’t mean it will be banned here in the USA. Therefore they don’t have to pull it from the shelves. However, I am not buying it at the moment.
iacisrmmaParticipantThis is the way Rashi in chumash has been interpreted for years. That it is different then then his pshat in the gemora is a kasha on Rashi. The simple pshat of matiz is to spit which indicates the mouth. Also, the gemora does not mention that the mitzriim hit the frog which is mentioned in the medrash.
iacisrmmaParticipantCall the Star-K. They have on their “No Hechsher Required” page — ‘Plastic wraps, bags do not need a hechsher even for hot”
iacisrmmaParticipantAnd it is quoted by Rashi on the passuk….the term used is UMATIZ which means to spray or splatter
http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=33588&st=&pgnum=81
iacisrmmaParticipantSorry but it is not an “American Meshugas”. It’s in the Misrash Agada.
http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=33177&st=&pgnum=148
iacisrmmaParticipanttakamamash: To me you have the best role model. Ask your shver his secret to getting you to feel this way about him. You will be one giant step closer to you goal.
Mazal tov and may the chuppa take place b’shah tovah u’mitzlachas and all your other children be zocheh to find their zivugim in the proper time.
January 4, 2018 2:22 pm at 2:22 pm in reply to: Must a Shul Select Only Someone Who Is Married To Be Chazan? #1442934iacisrmmaParticipantI actually called the number yesterday and asked the question. The person responded with a number of reasons. First, they have only had married chazonim in the past and don’t want to change. Two, most of the members are married couples with families and they expect the chazan to be part of the “social fabric” which would include having other couples over for various seudos. They feel this is not entirely in the realm for someone who is single. Three, they recently had someone who is divorced in a position of authority and it didn’t work out well, and they are leery of having a repeat of the situation by having someone who is not married.
iacisrmmaParticipantI have been thinking this over since my earlier response and was wondering…do you have any married sisters? What is your father’s relationship with them? If they have told you that your father is a good shver, then you have someone to model yourself after.
On the other hand, what is your father-in-laws relationship with you? If you feel he is a good shver, then you have someone to model yourself after.
Did you ever say to yourself, “I wish my shver didn’t treat me that way”? If the answer is yes then don’t treat your SIL in that manner.
iacisrmmaParticipantIt is not an easy answer as my definition of a “good” shver is different from what my sister’s definition is. Try not to be critical of him. Just like you have to treat each of your children as individuals, so too your SIL and (future) DIL/SIL. I had a hard time adjusting to my shver A”H as he expected me to do things that he did not require of his own son (in kibbud av issues).
While it may not be the case yet for you, make sure you treat all your SIL’s the same way. My in-laws did not and it caused ill feelings. For example, they always paid for the other SIL’s lulav and esrog but never paid for mine or even offer to.iacisrmmaParticipantIt’s funny since a number of years ago they wanted to be called “West Lawrence”.
iacisrmmaParticipantWhat new light are you talking about?
iacisrmmaParticipantLB: and do you live in Iceland?
iacisrmmaParticipantRockaway resident: Take a valium. Anyone can make a mistake.
January 3, 2018 6:33 am at 6:33 am in reply to: Must a Shul Select Only Someone Who Is Married To Be Chazan? #1441474iacisrmmaParticipantGH: Or the opposite. Being single, he may have to travel for shidduch purposes leaving less time to devote to the shul. IMHO, you are reading to much into this. They state clearly the person must be married. Unless you personally are an unmarried chazan why is it bothering you? In addition, where does it say that the chazzan would also be the baal koreh? Maybe the shul already has one and he already deals with the bar mitzvah bochurim. I commend the shul for being up front in the ad by stating the marriage requirement.
January 2, 2018 5:05 pm at 5:05 pm in reply to: Must a Shul Select Only Someone Who Is Married To Be Chazan? #1441251iacisrmmaParticipantGH: It may be a psak of a former Rav of that shul (or town). We don’t know the shul so stating “so no reason to exclude them other then the preferences of the particular shul” is very unfair.
iacisrmmaParticipantEasiest recipe: go to your local supermarket and buy the ready made.
-
AuthorPosts