Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Sjs – Our MR or your MR?
Sac – pushing it off till later, i.e. Marriage, wont work. Then youll be pushing off stopping the movies till you have kids. Then youll push it off till theyre a little older. Itll never happen. Your future choson can be playing the same game as you now. Stop it NOW.
What’s the excuse when this happens at the 8 or 9 o’clock Shachris — and there are earlier minyanim?
And Rav Moshe responded strongly that it is assur m’doraysa.
BR: Whatever the intent, your comment is all too true, most unfortunately.
He did respond to your first post to him.
You gotta be consistent Aishes. You cant be upset at others who discriminate at BT’s, when you yourself discriminate against other BT’s.
That should’ve read Mitzvah Haba’ah B’Aveira.
The Police have no time for this. This happens a thousand times a day. Ignore it.
Charlie:
Japan has far less people on death row simply because they have far less murders in Japan. In fact, murder is almost unheard of in Japan. And that is the case, in very large part, due to Japan’s very strict death penalty.
rob: How can you say mitzvah bo baveira should not be a concern? That’s like saying a yeshiva shouldn’t turn away a donation made with stolen money! Of course a shul should make sure someone isn’t being mechallel Shabbos to come to shul.
charliehall: Considering that the reformers recruit and welcome bona fide gentiles as full fledged members, it is little wonder that their membership rolls have increased. Discount their so-called converts and children of non-Jewish mothers, and get back to us.
Terri Schiavo was judicially murdered.
cherrybim: Can you clarify that? I thought Lieberman was the head of the Conservative JTS.
People have also spent 30 years in prison for a rape they were exonerated 30 years later. Perhaps we should abolish prison sentences of 10 plus years, as that can be worse than death and they can NEVER get back those 30 years falsely in prison.
IIRC theprof1 has on previous indication indicated he is very much married.
The OP specifically said that. The question is, considering all the intermarriage and invalid conversions in the Reform and Conservative movements, what percent of their membership are halachicly gentiles.
It’s actually the grape juice that does all that.
Okay, I’ll make it easier for aries…
Theory of Relativity
Charlie – The Noachide laws do not require an eyewitness for conviction.
Cynical got stumped.
That was pretty quick I might add.
apy, who wears the pants in your house?
Make the death penalty MANDATORY, when it fits the legal circumstances, NOT at the discretion of a judge or jury.
The fact is, the Conservative movement is simply an offshoot of the Reform movement, begining with Zecharias Frankel and Sabato Morais, both Conservative founders originally from the Reform.
Theory of the Aether
In fairness to him, he does respond to comments questioning him. Sometimes that happens a week or two later (I’ve even seen longer – he isn’t around all that much in the first place ), but he doesn’t shirk when challanged. And he has insisted he means what he says, when challanged on his sincerity.
I think it is also worth pointing out, although some here doubt him, so far I saw Mod 80, WIY, BP Totty, Jose, ICOT, mw13, sof davar, and myself find him sincere even if we might disagree with him sometimes or even often.
The risk of Lashon Hora is great in this area. The consequences of mistakenly saying L”H in this area, can destroy someones life.
Homeowner use “strong” (without quotes) instead of “b” for bold, and use “em” for italiacs.
squeak – they are trusted by the Gedolim, who know them firsthand better than any of us. And as you yourself pointed out, they are needed to determine the facts.
squeak, – and to further your thought, when the gedolim DO use others for trusted judgements, let no one denegrate their utilizing their trusted advisors.
HaLevi — He only posts (usually) every second week or so, sometimes not being around for months at a time. He probably wont even see this thread for a while.
The latter, whilst absolutely terrible, is highly infrequent despite what what the blogosphere loudmouths (who are no friends of the Torah to say the least) would like you to believe.
apy – he is a relatively infrequent poster compared to many regulars.
Read what the Gedolim have to say regarding these two treif movements. They dismiss them both for the same apikorsus gamur. We are not even allowed to cooperate with either of them in any way that gives them the illusion of an iota of legitimacy.
mosherose is a sincere Yid who means what he says. The fact that he is so “extreme”, leads some to find this unbelievable.
RSRH:
Learning Torah all day, and doing nothing else at all, IS THE MOST productive way to serve society.
And no one should object to donors who WANT the zchus to pay the Kollel yungerleit, just like you don’t object to someone who wants to buy a baseball ticket paying those lowlife players.
Learning Torah is doing something, and not just something, but everything. AND they are keeping you and I safe, and keeping the world running. Just by sitting and learning Torah all day, and doing NOTHING ELSE.
…the ones that are Jewish, that is.
Party Pooper
Apy – Perhaps that’s a good idea. It would be beutiful to follow their wonderful ideas.
Yasher Koach!
Yes.
I believe their intermarriage rate may now exceed 50%. So it well may be that the younger generations in these movements are mostly non-Jewish.
Why not doc?
With women “rabbis”, toeiva, abortion, and practically everything else, there is little practical difference beetween the reform and conservatives.
Gerrer chasidim are makpid on tznius.
Form a line
If the Kollel guy pays the same as the parent who works as a low paid waiter, they are both in the same boat and you have no taainas to either.
If a book of apikorsus is written in Italian, only an Italian speakinggodol can ban it?
(I’m not alluding to any specific book.)
That most certainly is not the case.
He has a right to accept the interpertation of his trusted advisors. And who are you or I to question who a godol hador trusts. Especially since you dont know the advisor firsthand like the godol.
A godol is a godol b’yisroel; not “your” godol or “my” godol.
BTW, Rav Belsky has been the first to be moida that Rav Elyashev is his greater.
What about the posuk in the Torah?
Everyone’s situation is different. What was right for her husband 20 years ago is not necessarily right for her hypothetical so today. The Rov needs to evaluate their needs and situation based on their current situation now, as he did for them 20 years ago.
Wise Rov.