Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 11, 2010 5:20 am at 5:20 am in reply to: Your thoughts on me and my background. Help! #700076growinggirlMember
FIRST OF ALL, I want to say thank you to everyone for answering, like I said before, it REALLY means a lot to me that everyone cares enough to be so helpful with their advice and help!
going wayy back, thanks well informed yid for being so honest. Forgot to mention that before.
btw i once asked in class how a goy can say shelo asani goy, and my teacher told me that in essence when a person converts they become totally new, so they are not that person who was a goy anymore. hashem creates them again, so really, their new self was never a goy. so they can say it.
and also it’s come up many times in class, over the years, that question about what happens if a baby was converted, and what they do then (i don’t even think any of the times the question was asked by me) and the teachers always said the same thing – that they just have to reaffirm it by their bar or bas mitzvah and theyre good. i can’t say that i know for certain that that is the actual halacha, but by the fact that i’ve heard many teachers say the same thing, i pretty much accepted that as the general rule.
October 8, 2010 8:51 pm at 8:51 pm in reply to: Your thoughts on me and my background. Help! #700046growinggirlMemberThanks to everyone for answering and for your good wishes, I really appreciate it.
growinggirlMemberi agree with the OP about non-jewish music in jewish places. the jews in mitzrayim were also living among the goyim for a long time, but i guarantee you the music in their stores would have only been jewish.
yes, there are some non-jewish songs that are nice and are pretty. but thats not the point. the point is that when you’re listening to their music, you have to in some way appreciate the singer and/or composer for producing such an awesome song. you think, “well this singer can’t be so bad, look their songs are so nice so clean. theyre cool.”
were not supposed to think goyim are cool. we’re supposed to think rebbeim are cool. and that’s why we listen to music that’s composed and sung by frum Jews, music can actually help get us closer to Hashem, vs listening stuff that we justify to ourselves by saying “well, it’s not actually BAD for me…”
-
AuthorPosts