Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
GrandmasterMember
Ask tomorrow by the mikva. They know everything.
March 25, 2011 4:00 am at 4:00 am in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759882GrandmasterMemberThere is no commandment in the Torah to deface anothers’ property. In fact, it is asur.
It is like when Avrohom Avinu smashed Terach’s avoda zora. Should Avrohom have paid Terach for the damage? Was Avrohom in the wrong? He was put in the oven to burn for his crime.
March 25, 2011 3:30 am at 3:30 am in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759878GrandmasterMemberSo you can’t make the assumption that their rav is okay with it, just as your disputants cannot make the claim that their rav disapproved.
And my point was? Exactly that. I was being rhetorical.
That being said, as Jews (even putting aside all the logical reasons demonstrating these tzadikim were correct in their actions) we have an obligation of being dan lkaf zchus. So if we don’t know otherwise, we ought to presume they did so with the haskama of their rav.
March 25, 2011 3:18 am at 3:18 am in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759876GrandmasterMemberAnywhere in the article about these bachurim, is there a quote that their rebbe or rav holds otherwise? Any claim that they didn’t ask for guidance from a rebbe or rav? Has anyone seen or heard even a single authoritative claim that their rebbe or rav has stated their actions were anything but appropriate?
GrandmasterMemberWelcome to Brooklyn! The best place in chutz laaretz for a Jew to live in!
March 25, 2011 12:31 am at 12:31 am in reply to: Who Would You Elect as Mayor of Coffeetown #1111031GrandmasterMember“Mod-80, Mod-42, The Goq, popa_bar_abba, eclipse, Fellow Coffeeites, I want to express my thanks to The Goq for his generous and heart-warming introduction. I am delighted to have his support and his counsel and his advice in the coming months ahead.
With a deep sense of duty and high resolve, I accept your nomination.
I accept it with a full and grateful heart–without reservation– and with only one obligation–the obligation to devote every effort of body, mind and spirit to lead our Party back to victory and our Coffee Room back to greatness.
I am grateful, too, that you have provided me with such an eloquent statement of our CR’s platform. Pledges which are made so eloquently are made to be kept. “Our Duty to Klal Yisroel”–the civil and economic duties essential to the human dignity of all Yidden–are indeed our goal and our first principles. This is a Platform on which I can run with enthusiasm and conviction.
And I am grateful, finally, that I can rely in the coming months on so many others. On a distinguished running-mate who brings unity to our ticket and strength to our Platform, The Wolf. On one of the most articulate statesmen of our time, Eclipse. On a great spokesman for our needs as Coffee Addicts and a people, popa_bar_abba. And on that fighting campaigner whose support I welcome, Mod-80. On my traveling companion in many threads, Daas Yochid. On Derech HaMelech, our devoted and courageous Chairman.
March 25, 2011 12:09 am at 12:09 am in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759872GrandmasterMemberThey followed Torah law (which takes precedence over dina dmalchusa), which prohibits such imagery, and by thus alone made a massive Kiddush Shem Shamayim.
If I even got one one hundredth of the schar they earned for this mitzvah, I would be eternally grateful for it.
March 24, 2011 9:30 pm at 9:30 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759868GrandmasterMemberThe Pidyon Shvuyim would defend them with the secular authorities and other costs.
As far as the schar they will get for this mitzvah, I can only envy them for it.
March 24, 2011 8:39 pm at 8:39 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759864GrandmasterMemberI’ll give quadruple. Plus I’ll raise friends from everyone I know.
But I wont pay a cent to those who put the pritzus up.
March 24, 2011 8:35 pm at 8:35 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759862GrandmasterMemberThen I’ll give double what I was planning.
March 24, 2011 8:23 pm at 8:23 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759860GrandmasterMemberIn a heartbeat.
March 24, 2011 8:15 pm at 8:15 pm in reply to: Married Lakewood kids want a down payment now! #753602GrandmasterMemberSigning up for HUD at age 16-18. That way when the 10 year waiting period is over, you will be ready to buy.
That sounds like a great idea.
GrandmasterMemberYou are expounding your own views while I am talking about the views of the Torah community
March 24, 2011 7:32 pm at 7:32 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759856GrandmasterMemberLet’s bring this case specificly. If the Bochrim in question were arrested & thrown in jail for vandalism, would they still feel they did the right thing?
Absolutely. They would then catapult into Jewish Heroes who were moser nefesh for the Torah. They ought to proudly and prominently wear a big yarmulka and black hat as they are led into the police precinct (and court if necessary) joyfully singing “Moshe Emes V’Torahsai Emes”, lhavidl like politicians and activists arrested at political protests smilingly pose for the cameras with their handcuffs after being arrested for civil disobedience. Then Klal Yisroel will lovingly initiate a massive Pidyon Shvuyim campaign to defend our heroes.
March 24, 2011 7:28 pm at 7:28 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759854GrandmasterMemberHalachicly gezel akum is not the aveira of gezeila, and one does not have to repay for gezel akum.
GrandmasterMemberI have seen photographs of women in just about every frum person’s home that I’ve been in — and that goes from the most “modern” to the right-wing yeshivish and chassidish.
The discussion was regarding publishing her photo on the internet, not her home. You are incorrect as it pertains to publishing it online or even in mass circulation newspaper in the Torah community.
GrandmasterMemberSuffice it to say that I (and most people) don’t agree with you that having a picture of a woman visible is wrong.
If you count the entire decadent society towards your “most” then you are correct. If you limit yourself to Torah Yidden, then you are wrong.
GrandmasterMemberDo you *really* believe that posting a picture of a woman is the worst thing you can do?
Let’s not get into sementics about it being the worst or second worst or third. I’m sure you can think of worse things. (i.e. having communications on FB with an opposite gender.) But it’s bad enough to figuratively call it the worst thing.
GrandmasterMembersmartcookie:
But since I, or anyone else for that matter, wasn’t witness to the abuse, we may not make conclusions.
So true.
I NEVER totally believe things that I hear.
Thank you for standing up for the Emes under attack. This is too rare a phenomenon in today’s society.
Why am I the only person on this forum who finds that talking against an ex on a public website is wrong?
You are not.
What is going on?
Some people unfortunately wrongly feel they have a right to attack their ex and everyone must believe their side of the story. They don’t even want anyone to think their is another side to the story.
March 24, 2011 12:04 pm at 12:04 pm in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759822GrandmasterMemberaries: My point was if even after every entreaty and heartfelt plea the space owner and the advertiser still absolutely refuse to remove a salacious ad in the heart of a Jewish neighborhood with little children seeing it constantly (not to downplay the tragedy of Jewish adults seeing it too), who could oppose taking matters into our own hands?
Let us not allow society’s decadent values to desensitize us to the horror of having this trash in the midst of our neighborhoods.
March 24, 2011 5:19 am at 5:19 am in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759813GrandmasterMemberIf the ad displayed a far worse (yet technically legal) image and was put up on 13th Avenue across from Shomer Shabbos, and the advertiser refused to change it, would anyone still be opposed to it being removed by “other means” so your children shouldn’t have to see it daily?
(Mod – Hopefully this language will pass.)
fine, despite the obvious reference to Boro Park.
GrandmasterMemberBecause of her gender.
GrandmasterMemberWould you forgive him if he did tshuva?
GrandmasterMemberbut that too!
What didn’t he buy you that you considered abuse?
GrandmasterMemberthen the psak can be ignored.
charlie: You’re overruling Rav Moshe?
March 24, 2011 3:38 am at 3:38 am in reply to: Bochrim Spray-Paint Over �Not Tzniyus� Advertisement #759804GrandmasterMemberBravo for these bochorim.
GrandmasterMember95: In the OP, kapusta said that a) the comment was on the main page (not the CR) and b) it was primarily someone’s comment that disturbed her, not a comment of hers that was deleted that was her main concern.
GrandmasterMemberItch: If you have an issue with the Am Hanivchar, it is something you ought to work on.
GrandmasterMemberDo teshuva.
GrandmasterMembers2021: Why? Everyone on “your side” has to hate him now? No one is allowed to emphasize with him?
GrandmasterMembertryinghard: Good point. There is no comparison to our holy tinokos shel bais rabban in Yeshiva to the vilda chayos in the PS. There is no comparison to our youth who shteig in Torah HaKedosha most of their school day to (l’havdil elef havdolos) those teaching and learning of how they descend from apes and share the same zaida as the gorillas after they finish distributing their c…..’s since abstinence is out of style.
yichusdik: After painting with a broad brush against our tzadikim in the Yeshivos, based on some isolated examples from your alleged personal anecdotal evidence, you finally realize about “tarring all with the same brush” and “problems that apply to a small fraction of the schools” — but apply it only to PS and not Yiddishe kinder and rebbeim in our holy Yeshivos?
Yes, yichusdik, being a member of the Am Hanivchar is a mark of aristocracy.
GrandmasterMemberThe OP made a follow up post stating her daughter didn’t actually sit on the ladies lap, but rather: “And she sat in the corner of the seat,not actually on her.”
Just pointing it out, since it seems to have been missed by most.
GrandmasterMemberyitay: “one or two ‘bad words'” is no big deal?
GrandmasterMemberWould coveting it not involve the issur of jealousy?
GrandmasterMemberoomis: They shouldn’t be talking to the girls on the street altogether.
GrandmasterMemberBeing frum is never “too” expensive.
As far as tuition, move to Brooklyn and pay about $4,000 a year, if not less.
GrandmasterMemberyichusdik: You will not cause anyone to become unconvinced that the Am Hanivchar, even whilst in golus, are far superior in all regards over others. Even if you bring more sheker and loshon hora against Yeshiva bochorim and rebbeim.
GrandmasterMemberpopa, How was she being purposely manipulative and using her rank, as opposed to simply being mean or insensitive?
GrandmasterMemberStrawmen? Murders in public schools is a yearly reality. Violence in public schools is a daily reality. Drugs can be purchased at will in public school. None of this is a reality in Yeshiva. You talk about respect in Yeshivos? In public school respect is for their favored gang. Not for their parents and certainly not for their teachers. Their fellow students? That’s who they bring their guns to “protect” themselves from. Yes, yichusdik, the Am Hanivchor is superior across the board, in all regards, on all levels.
GrandmasterMemberGoq: You do the graveyard shift, ending at midnight, in the yeshiva office?
GrandmasterMemberyichusdik: Which Yeshiva has had shootings? Any Columbine incidents in any Yeshiva you know of? Do any yeshiva’s have metal detectors for the students as they come in each morning, as the NYC P.S. system does?
GrandmasterMembersuperiority complex
The Am Hanivchar is superior.
GrandmasterMember“Maybe there was”
apy: When? And if there wasn’t, why was it discarded in recent times?
GrandmasterMembercharlie: Which is a far far far lower percentage of the prison population than the percentage of the overall population the frum represent.
GrandmasterMemberPublic school kids behave better than yeshiva students? In lala land. I never heard of guns being found in yeshivas, something plentiful been found in PS. Violence? In PS, not yeshivas. Stop maligning our better behaved children than any other demographic group.
And more secular studies is going to help them behave better? That’s a good one.
GrandmasterMemberOh, I missed his apology. Sorry.
GrandmasterMemberobservanteen: What was stolen?
GrandmasterMemberonegoal: When you wrote “It is a bit more quiet this way, in a good way though.” it sounds like you think its good that ZK isn’t posting so you can enjoy the quiet from his/her absence. That’s why everyone is asking how could you say such a thing. I am saying you didn’t mean what you said. Am I correct?
GrandmasterMemberI dunno? Birds of a feather flock together?
GrandmasterMemberCan Sender Av and myself get a subtitle change from its current iteration? (Sender Av asked for a change above.)
-
AuthorPosts